10 Times WWE Ruined Something They Didn't Create

Hey, remember when the nWo were the coolest group in wrestling?

Broken Matt Hardy
WWE.com

Wouldn't it be sweet to see The Hardy Boyz move on from their nostalgia act on Raw and start using the 'Broken' gimmick that gave them so much notoriety in TNA? Matt already uses elements of the character on TV anyway, and it'd give the brothers something fresh to do in WWE, right?

But there's also a chance that Vince McMahon wouldn't get it.

If history has taught us anything, it's that McMahon doesn't enjoy pushing ideas he didn't come up with to the forefront of his programming. Who's to say with 100% confidence that the 'Broken' universe would be any different? This could be something The Hardyz do for a few months before it fizzles out.

Of course, it could also be a success, but to disregard the poor treatment of other non-WWE creations in the company would be foolish. Funnily enough, WWE should follow a popular phrase when it comes to such things, perhaps even putting a little topical twist in there:

If it ain't 'Broken', don't try to fix it...


10. The Club

Luke Gallows Karl Anderson
WWE.com

As part of Bullet Club, both Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson gave off a menacing aura that made them one of NJPW's finest tag-teams. This was a long way from the nutty Festus gimmick Gallows had previously played in WWE, but that brand of McMahon-led comedy would become part of his career once again.

When WWE announced that they'd signed the team, fans familiar with their work in Japan started licking their lips. Surely the company would realise just how hard Gallows and Anderson had worked to build a reputation, and capitalise on that by booking them as one of WWE's premier tag-teams.

Nope, they carried around testicles in a jar instead.

Awkwardly declaring themselves doctors for a while, the once-bad ass duo looked like non-threatening dorks straight out of the WWF 'New Generation'. Now, post-comedy, Gallows and Anderson are reduced to whipping boy status on Raw, a position which defies their wonderful chemistry in-ring.


9. Raven

Raven Pose
WWE.com

When not even WCW could mess up (and ultimately misunderstand) the Raven character as badly as WWE did, you know there's a problem. Scott Levy must have rightly said '...but what about Raven?' out loud several times during his second stint with the company, because he was woefully overlooked in favour of others despite his deep character.

Created for an ECW audience who enjoyed such multi-layered backstories, the Raven guise also worked in WCW for a spell. Sure, Raven was never going to crack a main event scene packed with guys like Hogan, Flair, and Nash, but he did have a place on the card. In WWE, that place appeared to be at the bottom of the pile.

As if casting the guy as some kind of jobber to the stars wasn't bad enough, WWE seemed to think the best way to exhibit Raven's psychologically damaged, borderline nihilistic personality was by putting him in a Hardcore division more accustomed to delivering comedy.

Aside from that, Raven was never given a fair shake to show what he could do.


8. Goldberg

Goldberg WWE Highlight Reel
WWE.com

Goldberg would be much closer to the top of this list had his second WWE run not been a success. Returning in 2016, the ex-WCW star was booked much more like he had been during those halcyon days in Atlanta, rather than undermined and treated poorly like he was in 2003.

If Goldust wasn't putting his wig on Bill, the WCW hard man was working lengthy matches that didn't play to his strengths at all. There's a reason Goldberg's recent WWE matches only lasted a few minutes; never one of the most technical stars in-ring, Goldberg's attraction relied on him blasting through opponents in quick, intense squashes. WWE didn't give him that the first time around.

On the evidence of Goldberg's run between 2003-04, it's a good thing he decided to sit out his AOL/Time Warner contract for a few years and wasn't part of the 'Invasion' angle. Thank God for that second stint too, because WWE threatened to completely ruin Goldberg's aura when they did finally get their mitts on him.


7. Sting

sting triple h
WWE.com

Sting was the man in WCW throughout much of the '90s. When that company bit the dust in 2001, the clamour to see Sting in the WWF/WWE was huge, but it seemed less and less likely with each passing year. Then, Sting finally came to WWE in 2014. Long time WCW fans probably wish he hadn't.

We didn't get the dream match against The Undertaker people had salivated over for years. Instead, Sting lost both his WWE, matches against Triple H and Seth Rollins, before sadly being forced from the ring due to injuries. That was it, the big WWE run that once seemed so elusive.

When WWE should have embraced the uniqueness of Sting (a huge star who had never been in the promotion before), they instead decided to tag the tired notion of 'Us vs. Them' onto his first feud and make it all about a WCW invader who wanted to ruin WWE.

How did WWE ruin Sting? They tarred him with the 'Invasion' brush 14 years too late, neglected the one match everybody wanted to see and treated him like a legend from elsewhere who was in above his head


6. Zack Ryder's Buzz

Zack Ryder
WWE

Zack Ryder's biggest push came in spite of WWE, which is really a crazy thing to say considering he was already on the talent roster when he caught fire. There's no other way to view it: WWE's top brass didn't want fans to pay attention to Ryder. So, rather than roll with a success story that had landed on their lap, they squashed it.

Racking up views on YouTube and gaining quite the following on social media (do you know any other mid-carders in WWE with 2.19 million followers on Twitter?), Zack's 'Z! True Long Island Story' videos became a phenomenon, going viral and turning the then-Superstars regular into one of the most over guys in the locker room.

The YouTube stuff was Ryder's own work and had little to do with WWE's creative team. That's likely why the company didn't get behind it. Barring a brief push in late-2011, Zack never reached the level his popularity merited. Even endorsements from The Rock and John Cena couldn't save Ryder from being slowly pushed back down the pecking order.


5. The Great American Bash

WWE The Bash
WWE.com

WWE had the pick of any WCW pay-per-view name they wanted. Events like Starrcade and Halloween Havoc seemed logical, as did the chance to finally promote War Games under the WWE banner (even if Fall Brawl always was a lame duck title). None of those interested Vince McMahon, because he wanted The Great American Bash instead.

This was fine, if WWE were prepared to treat the event with respect. Loyal fans who remembered the show from the NWA's glory days were glad to see it back on the calendar, but 2004 would change that. Sadly, so would each subsequent event (barring a few enjoyable matches) until WWE themselves did away with it completely.

In 2009, WWE even retitled the event as 'The Bash'. A terrible name without the historic 'Great American' prefix, the show was yet another example of the promotion's bizarre need to stomp all over anything WCW had created. After all, it couldn't be WWE's fault that The Great American Bash wasn't clicking with their audience, could it?


4. Vader

Vader Michael Cole
WWE Network

The addition of Vader to the WWF roster at the beginning of 1996 seemed massive at the time. One of WCW's biggest stars for years, the heavyweight heel would surely provide excellent foil for Shawn Michaels as WWF Champion and also work wonders against the likes of The Undertaker, Bret Hart, and others.

Arguably the only classic match Vader worked in the WWF was a Fatal-4-Way at an In Your House event in February 1997. Aside from that, he rarely looked like the same behemoth he had when wrestling Sting, Ric Flair, and many more in WCW. By 1998, the WWF had shed Vader of his trademark mask and he was calling himself a "big fat piece of sh*t" on pay-per-view.

Two years into a run that had promised so much, Vader looked tired and ready to walk away. He didn't manage a single title in the WWF and retreated to Japan after being reduced to glorified jobber status, losing to Mark Henry and Bradshaw on the way out.

One of the '90s biggest heels was spoiled by the one company that should have known how to use him effectively.


3. The NWO

Shawn Michaels Kevin Nash Big Show X Pac NWo
WWE.com

Ok, so WCW's creative team didn't do a great job with the New World Order from 1998 onwards themselves, but at least the group had been created in that company. Besides, they were always the renegades who did whatever they wanted and answered to no-one. In WWE though, even the mighty nWo did the bidding of Vince McMahon.

Re-introduced (in their original form) in 2002, Scott Hall, Kevin Nash, and Hollywood Hogan were cast as a "cancer" brought in to destroy the WWF at McMahon's behest. Later, Hogan would turn babyface and the likes of Big Show, X-Pac, and Booker T became members. Even adding D-Generation X figurehead Shawn Michaels to the faction did little to stop the rot, despite the notable mix of two super-cool stables.

Abandoned by July, the once-proud nWo gimmick had been neutered under WWE's watch. Making things worse, McMahon had a genuine opportunity on his hands to reinvigorate the concept and make it worthwhile, but it was just another pawn in the never-ending quest to make everything WCW-related look second rate.


2. Diamond Dallas Page

DDP WWE
WWE.com

Working his butt off and successfully transitioning from loudmouth manager to main event wrestler, a motivated DDP achieved his dream and became one of WCW's best-loved stars in the late-90s. In the spring of 1999, he delighted fans by bagging his first World Title. A few years later, he was dead in the water upon finally reaching the WWF.

Agreeing to take a financial hit and tear up his guaranteed contract with AOL/Time Warner, Page accepted less money so he could be part of the 'Invasion' angle in the WWF. He'd come to regret that decision though, because the former 'People's Champion' was turned into a weird stalker who wanted The Undertaker to 'make him famous'.

Gone was the super-cool connection with fans DDP had worked hard to create, replaced by a character neither WCW or WWF fans wanted to see him play. The Diamond Dallas Page brand which had been so key to WCW's rise was flushed down the toilet when the man accepted such an awful gimmick.

Just watch his WCW run instead, and avoid the WWF years as best you can.


1. ECW

Ezekiel Jackson ECW Champion
WWE.com

That first ECW One Night Stand show in 2005 was great, wasn't it? WWE's love letter to the hardcore promotion's rabid fan base, the event was a nostalgia blast that just worked. It's just a shame then that things were ruined when WWE tried to milk the ECW cash cow dry and (worse, much worse) watered it down.

Between 2008-10, the weekly ECW show resembled Sunday Night Heat more than a tribute to Paul Heyman's original vision. Things had been shaky before then, but at least ex-ECW stars like The Sandman, Sabu, and Rob Van Dam were part of things.

By 2010, Tiffany was the brand's GM and Ezekiel Jackson was champion. How things reached this point is anyone's guess, but it was clear to see the atmosphere that had made those One Night Stand shows in 2005 and 2006 so successful was replaced by WWE's own idea of what ECW should be. The result was an agonising four-year run of TV that spat on the Extreme Championship Wrestling name.

-

What other non-WWE creations do you think they ended up ruining? Let us know down in the comments section below!


Watch Next


In this post: 
NWO
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.