10 Underrated WWE Attitude Era Matches

The hidden gems.

test shane mcmahon
WWE.com

The Attitude Era only encompasses three (or four, depending on who you talk to) years of WWE history, yet many of the company's all-time best and most memorable moments can be found therein.

This can primarily be attributed to the strength of the roster, which was not only liberally sprinkled with some of the industry's biggest ever stars, but also a healthy under-card filled with top-tier talents like Chris Jericho, Ken Shamrock, Chris Benoit, X-Pac, Jeff Jarrett and Eddie Guerrero.

Since they were very seldom afforded the requisite time to produce a five-star, for-the-ages classic, their matches were sometimes over-shadowed by the main events that followed them, destined to be remembered as mere starters in a three-course meal.

In our efforts to celebrate the very best matches the Attitude Era had to offer, these ones are often forgotten about - and the same can even be said of some of those that actually headlined shows, such was the frequency with which great, era-defining matches came about.

And that just won't do - so here are 10 that deserve a second viewing.

(Incidentally, if you do enjoy a nostalgic retrospective on WWE's hey-day, or else just need to brush up on your wrestling knowledge to impress - and, perhaps, annoy - your friends, why not consider buying What Culture's Wrestling With Attitude? It's 100% unofficial, after all).

10. Chainsaw Charlie Vs. Cactus Jack (Raw, February 1998)

There was only one way that Terry Funk and Mick Foley could prepare for their Dumpster Match with The New Age Outlaws at WrestleMania XIV: by tearing lumps out of each other on Raw two months prior.

If you are looking at the names of its competitors and blindly assuming that this was just a spot-heavy brawl without any sort of structure or regard for long-term health, then you'd be absolutely right.

Funk and Foley spent the majority of this match outside the ring, trading brutal-looking weapon shots before the latter tossed his opponent in a dumpster and catapulted himself on top of him from high up on the Raw scaffolding.

Oh, and then the Outlaws came out and launched it off the stage for the hell of it.


9. Eddie Guerrero Vs. Dean Malenko Vs. Perry Saturn (Judgement Day 2000)

Perhaps it's the fact that this match was a Chris Benoit short of a full Radicalz reunion that has seen it largely forgotten from history - or perhaps merely its tantalisingly short length.

With a full 15 or 20 minutes (as opposed to the meager seven it was given, a consequence of The Rock and Triple H's hour-long Iron Man match in the night's headline slot), this - a triple threat for Guerrero's Intercontinental Title - really could have been a genuine multi-man classic.

The finish, abrupt and screwy on paper - an interfering Chyna took Saturn out whilst Guerrero went for the cover on Malenko - was actually clever in this context, because it ensured that all three men retained a semblance of credibility, despite the match being so short.


8. Test Vs. Shane McMahon (SummerSlam 1999)

Test Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Many of Shane McMahon's in-ring excursions come as a result of a member of his family being attacked or assaulted by a wrestler with whom he's now looking to get even.

This was the exact opposite: Test was getting a little too friendly with Stephanie, and Shane - concerned that he wasn't the right man for her (either that or he was... jealous?) - challenged him to a "Love Her Or Leave Her" Greenwich Street Fight at SummerSlam.

Despite pulling out all the usual Shane O'Mac stops, including the use of one or two weapons we haven't seen in a WWE ring before or since, it was Test who emerged victorious, winning the right to date Shane's sister (who, needless to say, lacked any autonomy of her own).


7. X-Pac Vs. Jeff Jarrett (SummerSlam 1998)

xpac jeff jarrett summerslam 1998
WWE.com

Neither X-Pac nor Jeff Jarrett made it to the Attitude Era main event - the former because he started getting that famously awful heat, and the latter because he jumped ship to WCW before it really took off (and, to be fair, didn't exactly live to regret it).

In the mid-card, though, these guys were kings in mid-1998, fighting a criminally underrated hair versus hair bout at SummerSlam, which for a short while catapulted Sean Waltman to perhaps the best run of his career.

With out-of-ring high-jinks from Howard Finkel, D-Generation X and Jarrett's "Southern Justice" cronies, this was basically just 10 minutes of pure Attitude Era, the only complaint at which you can throw is the fact that, with the loser high-tailing out, the hair-cutting stipulation wasn't fully adhered to.


6. Mankind Vs. Ken Shamrock (Judgement Day 1998)

Mankind Ken Shamrock Judgement Day 1998.jpg
WWE.com

Seldom has there been a match between two wrestlers with styles as contrasting as Mankind and Shamrock, one of them a brawler who favours weapon shots and the other a former MMA fighter with more holds than Chris Jericho.

That's what made this match such a hoot though: Shamrock, the defending Intercontinental Champion, kept trying to blunt his opponent's offence by working the limbs, but Mankind - one of wrestling's best ever sellers - fought through the pain barrier to keep the fight at a pace that suited him.

In fact, Shamrock, despite his best efforts, couldn't get his never-say-die adversary to tap out, instead relying on a dubious referee call - after Foley gave himself the mandible claw - to keep the title around his waist.


5. Chris Jericho Vs. X-Pac (No Mercy 2000)

The WWE mid-card in the year 2000 was just about as good as it's ever been, and two of the big reasons for that were Chris Jericho and X-Pac, two stars who were just a hair's breadth away from breaking through the main event's glass ceiling.

In fact, it was only a few months prior that Jericho's WWE Title reign was cruelly annulled by Earl Hebner after he scored a win over Triple H on Raw - and yet Y2J was still putting on matches like this at the bottom of the show.

This grudge match, which took place inside four sides of unforgiving steel, is perhaps best known for its closing sequence, which saw Jericho trap his opponent in the Walls of Jericho whilst they were both halfway to escaping the cage.


4. The Rock Vs. Ken Shamrock (Raw, November 1998)

The Rock Ken Shamrock 1998 Survivor Series
WWE.com

This match must surely be one of the best main events in Raw history.

Not only did it have nail-biting drama, thanks to the stipulation that The Rock would lose his opportunity at the WWE Championship unless he emerged from this bout with Shamrock's IC belt.

It also had each and every fan in the crowd cheering in unison, willing The Rock - who was at the foot of his magical ascent to the top of the card in late-1998 - to overcome the odds Vince McMahon had placed in front of him.

The finish - Shamrock retaining by disqualification after the ref caught him using a steel chair - is perhaps the only real complaint you can level at it, but this, at least, made sense in the long run.


3. Kurt Angle Vs. The Rock (No Way Out 2001)

The Rock vs. Kurt Angle - No Way Out 2001
WWE.com

It seems odd to suggest that any match featuring two of wrestling's biggest ever stars is underrated, but this one has suffered from its placement on the No Way Out 2001 card - after the epic Three Stages of Hell clash between Triple H and Stone Cold.

In its own right, this match may also lose one or two wrestling points for the fact that Big Show interfered relatively early into the bout (although, having attacked both competitors - along with the referee - it can hardly be said that the outcome wasn't a just one).

Short on time, the bout came to an abrupt ending around the 15-minute mark, but its pulsating conclusion had the sort of drama that is not traditionally associated with February pay-per-views (of which this show was arguably the all-time best).


2. Hardy Boyz Vs. Edge & Christian (No Mercy 1999)

Hardy Boys Edge and Christian No Mercy
WWE

Think of car crash ladder matches involving the Hardy Boyz and Edge & Christian and you probably (and quite understandably) gravitate towards the first ever TLC at SummerSlam 2000, or the insanely good sequel months later at WrestleMania X-Seven.

But this one, a straight two-on-two Ladder Match at No Mercy in October 1999, was to some every bit as good, functioning as a sort of experimental match for some of the balls-to-the-wall mental spots we went onto see in those classic TLCs to come.

Matt and Jeff, then under the "New Brood" banner, won the bout - in the process earning not only $100,000 in cash but also the management services of Terri Runnels


1. Six-Pack Challenge (Unforgiven 1999)

Bulldog Austin Six Pack Challenge
WWE.com

A match of this kind would perhaps be even more appreciated in today's era, where WWE continue to recycle the same four or five match-types to the point of saturation.

Despite every man being for himself, the six competitors - Triple H, The Rock, Mankind, Kane, Big Show, and The British Bulldog - were allowed to tag each other into the match as and when, creating a dynamic whereby it became impossible for any one of them to emerge as the favourite to take the title.

Throw in Stone Cold Steve Austin - who served as the match's take-no-prisoners special guest enforcer - along with the common-garden referees who were on strike - and you had all the ingredients for an absolute Attitude Era classic (and one of that is conspicuous by its absent from most top 10 lists).


Contributor