10 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Revolution

In which Omega, Page, and The Young Bucks star in a tag team all-timer.

Jon Moxley
AEW

There may never be another All In or Double Or Nothing.

The special feeling those nights captured is nigh impossible to replicate when your promotion becomes a routine part of the weekly pro-wrestling calendar. Yes, AEW's quarterly pay-per-view cycles make these shows feel bigger than if they were going down every month, but the magic of those landmark nights was because they were landmark nights. Revolution, essentially, was a standard supercard on a standard schedule.

It was also the best pay-per-view AEW has ever produced.

Revolution's tremendous build was paid off through four hours of rich, engrossing storytelling, cutting-edge action, and varied themes, motifs, and payoffs. The triple main events of Cody vs. MJF, Hangman Page and Kenny Omega vs. The Young Bucks and Jon Moxley vs. Chris Jericho all delivered in different ways, with one emerging as an easy early Match of the Year candidate. They were propped up by an undercard permeated by shots of adrenaline and dramatic heft and of course, Chicago being Chicago, the crowd were tremendous.

That not everything on Revolution landed is almost scary. As great as this show was, there's still room for improvement from a promotion in the midst of a major creative upswing in 2020. Double Or Nothing II, at this rate, could be an all-timer.

Let's light the fuse...


Downs...

2. The Wrong Opener?

Dustin Rhodes Jake Hager
AEW

Jake Hager vs. Dustin Rhodes had its warts, the biggest of which was the faulty face/heel dynamic. You may not have been able to discern who was supposed to be the good guy if you went into this cold and with no knowledge of the story. The constant cuts to Hager's worrying wife painted him as an oddly sympathetic figure when Rhodes was in control and as well as being grossly outdated in 2020, Dustin's forced kiss spot amplified this flaw. Less of that going forward, please.

'The Natural' brought his customary fire and the live crowd were totally into cheering him and hating on Jake, though this wasn't the bruising, impactful performance we perhaps needed from 'The Big Hurt.' His heat spots were plodding. Hager has some sharp offense (his Vader Bomb is tremendous), but the pace was stuck in treacle at several points during his control sequences. This is partly down to the layout, as he would've benefitted from a more dominant showing and a shorter runtime, though there were (admittedly understandable) holes in his work in his first big match in years. A lack of rotation on Dustin's Code Red near-fall made the move look overly cooperative.

Not a bad match, but not the right choice to open the pay-per-view either. Revolution should've started with a shot of adrenaline. Instead, it commenced with an opener that was only intermittently exciting, despite the tremendous job these guys did on the Countdown special earlier in the week.


1. Statlander & Rose Struggle In A Tight Spot

Nyla Rose Kris Statlander
AEW

A brief list of things that Kris Statlander and Nyla Rose had going against them last night:-

1. They had to follow the Tag Team Championship match. Any bout put in that spot was going to struggle for crowd reactions.

2. The lack of build.

3. The debilitating flu that forced Statlander to pull out of an indie date earlier this week and clearly hindered her work last night.

It's because of the above and the high effort levels that we won't go too hard on this bout. Statlander and Rose worked hard to try and win the crowd over after the blitzkrieg tag encounter and had pockets of the arena behind them by the end, but only pockets. This didn't connect. A shame, as better circumstances would've led to a better response, though the work had its flaws too. A sloppy undercurrent undermined many a big sequence here.

Nyla retained the AEW Women's World Championship, as she should have. A long reign is on the cards for 'The Native Beast.' Her and Statlander definitely have a better match in them and will likely deliver it later down the line, but this one fell short - and it isn't entirely their fault.


Ups...

10. The Dark Order Trump SCU

The Dark Order once again performed above their gimmick in a fun a little opener with SoCal Uncensored on the Buy In pre-show, with Evil Uno and Grayson picking up the victory.

It's a gimmick that misses more than it hits married to a couple of wrestlers that hit more than they miss. Here, Grayson and Uno were as crisp and fluid as ever, working snappy, effective sequences with two of the savviest veterans in the game. Everyone looked fired up and ready to go for a Chicago crowd that received the match well, dissing the Order with "spooky perverts" chants. Scorpio Sky's hot tag got the expected big pop after Grayson and Uno worked the heat on Frankie Kazarian. The match connected, it popped, and it was all it needed to be.

Grayson scored the pinfall, taking The Dark Order to 5-0 in 2020. A shot at the Tag Team Championships now surely beckons for the evildoers.


9. Real Sport Feel

AEW Tale of the Tape
AEW

AEW's decision to throw up UFC-style Tale of the Tape screens before each match was a small touch but an effective one, making Revolution feel like a more legitimate across the board.

The company's purported "real sport feel" has taken a pounding from earnest, fair critics and bad faith actors alike. This was a great example of it working. Not only did the graphics feature all the relevant info but these brief windows allowed the announcers to analyse the upcoming bouts and give their takes on what was about to go down, adding another layer of believability. Good, solid stuff, and the kind of neat enhancement that helps frame these bouts as sporting encounters.

Let's hope AEW keeps doing this for all pay-per-views going forward.


8. Those Aesthetics

AEW Revolution set
Twitter, @AllEliteTiffany

Wrestling is an aesthetic business as much as anything else and AEW nailed this department last night, with Revolution looking beautiful.

The set was tremendous. Yes, there was a touch of the WWE about the massive video screens on the stage and ramp but that's fine, because WWE's sets absolutely rule. The promotion's willingness to make their big shows look and feel different from their rank-and-file weeklies is a big plus point and while simple, Revolution's set looked lovely.

We were also treated to a great introduction video bringing us through an "alternative reality" before running through the key matches and stories, and fans were given light-up wristbands that changed colour depending on what was going on. When Nyla Rose came out, they were red; during the show's intro, theY flashed green. Piercing the darkness, this looked awesome.


7. Oh Hey, Colt

Colt Cabana
AEW

Colt Cabana got a great pop in his Chicago hometown last night. He came out to save SoCal Uncensored as The Dark Order beat them down on the Buy In, then stood tall with the babyface group at the end. This must have been a great moment for him and it got over, because of course it did: Colt is beloved.

The former Ring of Honor man was initially undone by the numbers game before The Dark Order's own theme hit with them in the ascendency. A robed figure emerged from the back - was it the fabled Exalted One? No, sadly. It was Christopher Daniels, the Order's latest big recruitment target, who evened the odds, helped his boys overcome, and ensured they won the exchange.

A supplemental Down for the abrupt music hits, particularly when they blasted SCU's track while Daniels was delivering Angels Wings, but this was an effective, well-executed segment to introduce Cabana as a full-timer. His singing was confirmed by Tony Khan after the show.


6. LOL

Blood & Guts
AEW/Fite TV

First of all, a hearty lol at AEW titling this special episode of Dynamite "Blood and Guts." This was the derogatory term Vince McMahon flung at the upstart promotion shortly after Double or Nothing and he deserves this clap back. As petty as it may seem to some, it popped AEW's fanbase, rallied their base, and grabbed attention online.

Secondly, they're probably doing a War Games match on this show.

A War Games match. On an episode of Dynamite.

Jesus.

The announcement vignette featured shots of a steel cage and the phrase "this means war," and we already know that AEW has trademarked "the match beyond." That they're going to throw this on free weekly television is equal parts nuts and great. Almost certainly born from Cody's love of all things old-school WCW, it continues AEW's theme of filling the gap between pay-per-views with special supercard-style Dynamites (a la Bash at the Beach) and provides another logical spot to blow feuds and storylines off. Kudos.


5. MJF Takes Chapter One

Wardlow MJF
AEW

Throw Cody vs. MJF somewhere between the Shawn Spears and Wardlow bouts when ranking 'The American Nightmare's' old-school, territory-style epics. This wasn't the melodramatic instant classic many would have expected. Indeed, it was a minor letdown that suffered from notable pacing issues after a red hot start, though it was still very, very good, and an appropriate first in-ring instalment in a rivalry that is far from over.

Downstait's live performance was almost comically bad. Cody and MJF banished this straight away, with 'The Nightmare' practically frothing as the prospect of getting his hands on his former protégé and young Maxwell taking a powder almost immediately. 'The Salt of the Earth' sought refuge in the crowd, threw beer over a fan, and shot for ultimate frustration. It was an effective first act that had the audience baying for his blood even more than they were before the bell.

Cody was full of fire, taking a page from The Great Muta's playbook by taking a massive run-up from the ramp to clothesline MJF over the top rope. His opponent was all about the shortcuts. It was clear he'd have to take every single one to best his old mentor here, and he did, whether he was talking smack, targeting Cody's broken toe, or nailing low blows. This theme continued with the seconds on the outside. Brandi Rhodes, Arn Anderson, and Wardlow all came into play, with the most notable spot seeing Anderson downed by a wayward Cody kick, as Wardlow threatened to F5 Brandi. Overbooked? A tad, perhaps, but effective nonetheless.

MJF took the win by blasting Cody with the previously-concealed Dynamite Diamond Ring. He was a rightful winner. Revolution wasn't the right time to pay this thing off with a babyface win and now, in victory, MJF is a made man. Here's to the next chapter.


4. Skate Or Die

Sammy Guevara Darby Allin
AEW

Though the match itself barely hit five minutes from bell-to-bell, Sammy Guevara vs. Darby Allin, as a complete package, was absolutely f*cking outstanding.

This was two livewire lunatics engaging in an early battle for AEW's future at the end of a bitterly personal rivalry. The scrapping began with Allin diving through the ropes onto Sammy and it was pure propulsion from there on out, with 4-5 minutes of big bombing on the outside preventing the bout from officially starting. Sammy and Darby thrashed each other around like madmen. Allin's missed dive was covered extremely well by an announce team that expertly put over that Darby had gotten too carried away. Seconds later, the former EVOLVE ace had his skateboard lobbed in his face before 'The Spanish God' hit a goddamn 630 splash off the top, to the outside, and through a table.

Fans barely had a chance to pick their jaws from their laps, though this was far from a mere spotfest. This was a foot-to-the-floor, hateful war of escalating violence, great character work from both, and incredible pacing. Allin showcased his versatility through an expertly-worked submission sequence in which he twisted and contorted Guevara as if he'd been possessed by Zack Sabre Jr., with added biting! The man's got range.

Chicago standing up in unison for the match-ending Coffin Drop was a heartening sight. Darby is over. He and Sammy are the future of this company and though Allin took the win, this was but the first banger over what should be a multi-year rivalry.


3. He Tried!

Orange Cassidy PAC
AEW

"This time, he's gonna try!" was Chuck Taylor's promise after PAC vs. Orange Cassidy was confirmed on this week's Dynamite. He was right. Against 'The Bastard,' Cassidy not only drove a stake through the heart of the idea that his style can't work in the context of big-time scripted combat, as he proved what anyone who's ever watched his awesome Beyond Wrestling encounter with David Starr already knew: 'Freshly Squeezed' is a master of balancing shtick and workrate.

From the sh*tty pyro and Justin Roberts announcing his location and weight as "wherever" and "whatever" to the perfectly-timed comebacks, Cassidy's presentation was immaculate. Yes, he got his comedy stuff in. PAC mockingly responded to 'The King of Sloth Style's' slo-mo shin kicks with some of his own, but got caught playing games and taken out of his game by OC's explosiveness. 'Freshly Squeezed' almost had him with several nearfalls. The first came after a prolonged, brutal heat segment highlighted by Cassidy literally bouncing head-first off the ring post. Later, PAC looked like he murdered Orange with an impossibly snappy Liger Bomb, and Cassidy sold everything brilliantly. This is another of his big strengths: he's legitimately a top ten bumper and seller in the world. Everything his opponents do looks so effective thanks to his willingness to ragdoll.

Mad flurries and comebacks brought Cassidy to the verge of victory. There was a palpable urgency to his work as he dived on PAC and nailed Superman Punches and Stundog Millionaires, though he was inevitably caught in the Brutaliser when the Lucha Brothers appeared to brawl Best Friends away from the ring, continuing that rivalry. The audience responded as if someone had just put a bullet to a beloved family pet.

A brilliant triumph of drama and yes, storytelling, PAC vs. Cassidy ruled, and the best part? It existed well within the realms of accepted pro-wrestling psychology.


2. Brawl Out War

Chris Jericho Jon Moxley
AEW

With PAC vs. Cassidy all about the explosive comebacks, Cody vs. MJF going full '80s NWA, and Cody/Page vs. The Young Bucks so cutting-edge, Jon Moxley and Chris Jericho were almost forced to work an all-out brawl in Revolution's main event. Fortunately, it's a style that both men work incredibly well.

Jericho's Inner Circle Choir serenaded his arrival with a beautiful rendition of "Judas." Like MJF before him, 'Le Champion' was looking for a way out as soon as the bell rang. His methods were different, though: rather than trying to frustrate Moxley, Jericho looked to get himself disqualified. Plunder was employed liberally as they fought through the crowd but AEW's smartest referee, Aubrey Edwards, was wise to this, using her discretion to nullify Jericho's dastardly gameplan. A neat way of justifying the weaponry.

Filling the space between moves with a panache few others can master, Jericho's performance was what we've come to expect from him in AEW. Peacocking, vicious, and devious, he was a total piece of sh*t, and Moxley responded in kind, biting the seven stitches between the champ's eyes early on. This was a fight. It was ugly and attritional in all the right ways. Everything it needed to be, basically.

AEW rewarded intense investment by paying off the Randy Couture training footage from this week's Countdown show as Moxley reversed a Liontamer into an Ankle Lock. A welcome moment of superior technique and strategising, though Mox was almost undone by a Sammy Guevara belt shot once the rest of the Inner Circle had been banished. The 'Purveyor of Violence' had an ace up his sleeve, though. His injured eye, so often Jericho's target, had healed. He revealed this by yanking his own patch off, nailing a second Paradigm Shift, and walking out as AEW Champion.

Time will tell whether or not taking the belt off Jericho was the right move, though Moxley's "hey, what the f*ck?!" post-match promo was a hoot and every great babyface reign begins by vanquishing the ultimate bad guy.


1. Masters Of The Craft

Kenny Omega Hangman Page
AEW

Many pinpointed Kenny Omega and Hangman Page vs. The Young Bucks as the most obvious Match of the Night candidate leading into the event, though few could've predicted just how brilliant it would turn out.

"Instant classic" is an overused term. It has been trotted out to the point of exhaustion and no longer holds the heft it should, but it feels like an appropriate descriptor here. This was a near-perfect clash the calibre of Furnas and Kroffat vs. Kobashi and Kikuchi, any DIY vs. The Revival match, or the Bucks vs. Golden Lovers. It was a phenomenal fusion of state-of-the-art action and rich, nuanced, pro-wrestling storytelling delivered by four of the best in the game, and a complete success across the board.

The balance between sporting encounter and getting too personal was on a razor's edge. Omega, at one point, stopped Hangman from powerbombing Matt Jackson through a table, and Nick had to talking his older brother down from going too far in the first act. All illusions of friendliness were shattered when Page slapped the p*ss out of the younger Buck, though. From there, it was the Bucks working to wind Page up by exploiting his hair trigger as they reverted to prime d*ckhead form the likes of which we haven't seen since they were PWG mainstays. Their heel work was exemplary throughout, and essential: the job AEW has done in building Page up as the hot man-of-the-people babyface has been remarkable.

Perhaps the biggest success here was the wrestlers' ability to work their kind of match without sacrificing storytelling. The narrative mirrored the build in that it was deep, engrossing, and full of details like Matt's hand quivering as he tore Kenny's Kinesio tape away. These guys presented an evolution of the classic tag team formula. They're taking tried and tested things that have always worked and pushing them forward with creativity and precision, with this clash a huge feather in their caps.

Omega looked doomed as the Jacksons isolated him after killing Page with an Indetaker on the ramp, but the bout still had gears to get through. Hangman rallied. He hit his own One Winged Angel, him and Kenny found their cohesion, and the combination V-Trigger/Buckshot Lariat sealed the deal.

Props to AEW for not going with the obvious turn, either. A post-match tease saw Page seemingly grapple with the idea of blasting his partner, before pulling out and hugging. This thing is far too good to sacrifice this early.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.