10 Ways WWE Can Finally Get Their Audience Back

WWE already has the next John Cena on the books.

Big E
WWE

The complexion of the WWE audience has changed considerably over the last several years.

Reductively, they used to give a sh*t. They used to tell decision-makers that they didn't give a sh*t about the wrestlers that WWE attempted to push at the expense of the wrestlers they wanted to see pushed.

Those fans wanted to see CM Punk disrupt the tedious monotony at WWE's rotting core. Alberto pinned CM Punk at Hell In A Cell 2011 to further ice the Summer of Punk.

Those fans wanted to see Daniel Bryan get the big push as his stupendous work and joyous ring entrance got over big in 2012. He was defeated in 18 seconds at WrestleMania XXVIII.

Those fans wanted to see Becky Lynch as a charming, witty ass-kicker who cut through the verbose bullsh*t in 2018. WWE, before once more realising that going with Charlotte Flair was untenable, went with Charlotte Flair.

Those fans - or at least a significant number of them - have since stopped watching. What's left of the audience just sits there, happy to react only and with polite enthusiasm to the key spots agented by the apparent storytelling company. There's a rabid, quite possibly mentally unwell base on Twitter, but that's as hardcore as it gets. They are brainwashed cultists unable to even grasp what they like about their chosen hobby without criticising AEW. There's only about 200 of them, loud as they are.

What happened to the millions and millions?

10. Rediscover What WWE Actually Is

Vince McMahon NXT
WWE

Vince McMahon once more became the panto villain as he - cruelly or hilariously, depending upon your perspective - gutted NXT of much of its talent and, as will become clear, its identity.

Is this a bad thing, necessarily?

NXT is done as a cool alternative and as a talent development pipeline. It exists now as a polished, purpose-defeating echo of a super-indie scene that Vince was never going to embrace. Realistically, he is far more in tune with his public than his isolated overlord stigma would suggest. Look at the NXT numbers. Look at John Cena's quarter hours and house show gates. Astonishingly, the fans of the promotion that buried indie wrestling for years have not connected with WWE's half-hearted emulation of it.

WWE, at its core, was never a promotion that spotlighted superb bell-to-bell pro wrestling. It was only vaguely competitive in that arena when Vince was no longer allowed to pump his contractors to the gills. Beyond the glory of Bret Hart's peak - and this isn't to say that WWE's in-ring output was always terrible, but rather incidental - WWE excelled at broad, soapy episodic drama told by gigantic men.

Vince has approached this back-to-basics vision in a stunningly petulant way, but it's not a terrible idea. WWE fans want sports entertainment. Just not a super-sh*tty version of it.

On the subject of which...


9. End The Spooky B*llocks

Alexa Bliss Lilly
WWE.com

Watch a typical episode of RAW, and Alexa Bliss in particular, and you will both see and hear a resounding answer to heavily-debated topic of wrestling discourse: does spooky bullsh*t belong in pro wrestling in 2021?

The answer is no.

The Fiend and latterly Alexa Bliss have their fans, but then, so do niche realms of internet pornography. They don't belong on a pro wrestling show any more than a winking evil doll does, at least in the world WWE has built. It's not merely an execution issue, not that the execution is good. The Fiend got booed out of every arena he ever worked that didn't have Daniel Bryan stood in the opposite corner. He was the Freddie Blassie of X-Pac heat. The idea of a wrestler with supernatural abilities is world-breaking bullsh*t that wreaks havoc on logic.

Why doesn't Alexa hypnotise everybody all of the time?

Bliss gets a reaction when she performs wrestling moves. You can clearly tell that fans recognise her strengths as a performer while also realising that she is drastically miscast. This entry is not counterintuitive to the previous entry. People don't want to see Alexa Bliss work 35 minute matches, but they don't want her to act as n*nce-lube, either.

Either create a world in which anything goes, or fix the world that is broken because anything goes.


8. Embrace Literally The Easiest Thing Imaginable

Apollo Crews Big E
WWE.com

WWE's creative problems run deep. You can't fix rust with a lick of paint, but it's rather easy to remove an old piece of sh*t from your shoe.

Either scrub it off, or, better yet, simply don't step in it.

The television and advertising industry, until the recent paradigm shift, was always reluctant to host pro wrestling because of its reputation as this weird niche interest. If some of your friends think you're a man-child weirdo for liking it, that belief is certainly shared in network corridors. Moreover, because wrestling to them is so stupid, you are stupid - and thus poor - for enjoying it. This is why, until recently, wrestling was so limited in the TV arena. Advertisers think you are too poor to buy the stuff that they hawk, rendering the act of paying for ads entirely pointless.

Nonetheless, wrestling survived in just the one form because there is no off-season, no re-runs, and it is cheaper to produce than most shows. The TV industry sanctions it on that USP.

In 2021, WWE has undermined its singular appeal by presenting re-runs on a weekly basis. This also pisses fans off because it's a literal, careless display of the "same old sh*t".

There are a million ways to avoid this. Create stables to build matches on a wrestler versus rival's stablemate premise. Track wins to make a wrestler's next match build on what they have just recently done. Book squashes. Place a blindfold over one's eyes and throw a dart at the tens of wrestlers in catering on any given night.

Pick one.

One.


7. Add Stakes To The Action

Drew McIntyre sword
WWE.com

Do you give a sh*t about an inanimate object? One that does not impact your own life in any meaningful way?

No?

Then you likely don't give a sh*t about much of WWE's recent output which, yes, is based around inanimate objects.

The lore of Drew McIntyre's mam's sword has relegated the former top guy into the jobber realm, and if the sword is meant to symbolise his nice connection to his (genuinely admirable) mother, it's not getting over. Because it's a sword.

It's a sword that Drew McIntyre first started carrying around to make him jump off the screen a bit more and sell a few more action figures. In reality, it's so clichéd that it just makes him look like a parody of a scotsman. The man couldn't look more Scottish if they deep-fried Scotland's early exit from an international football tournament.

Over on SmackDown, Baron Corbin has plunged into a pit of despair upon losing his little crown. The Miz and John Morrison use water gun-like devices as foreign objects.

Perhaps things like "real-feeling animosity" and "the career-changing heft of winning and losing" are more important than "things" in generating intense emotional investment.


6. Keep It Simple, Stupid

Seth Rollins Cesaro
WWE.com

Emphasis on the f*cking stupid.

WWE appeals to a broad audience. This isn't trademark authorial snark but rather the fact of the matter.

WWE wants the most people possible to watch its product. This is why the matches are worked at the pace they are worked, why the recaps are so numbingly frequent, why the storylines are told through long, repetitive promos and not shown through detailed in-ring craft.

But for years and years now, WWE has failed to trust its audience in what has become a damaging symbiotic relationship. They don't so much do the simple things they're after as pummel them with repetitive thwacks of ring style and info dumps.

When WWE does the simple things without patronising its audience, that audience laps it up. The WrestleMania build was putrid, largely, but Cesaro's promise of swinging Rollins around the place was purchased with glee by the crowd at Raymond James. The "ref tosses the baddie out of the ring" bit went down like a right treat on an otherwise lifeless SmackDown last week.

These people just want a payoff that is threatened for dramatic effect and delivered to make them feel something called "happiness".


5. Target The Children's Audience

Nikki A.S.H.
WWE.com

WWE is close.

WWE is so close to grasping its future. There's one small detail to iron out. At present, by presenting Alexa Bliss as a sexualised child who plays on swings and also dry humps Randy Orton, WWE is targeting people that like children. By slightly tweaking its storytelling to appeal to the children themselves, they might yet future-proof the company after the TV rights fees era dries up.

WWE is not aiming for 56 year-olds. They draw them, but they're not aiming for them. They do well in cable rankings to retain the 18-49 set, but those numbers have been on the decline for several years.

WWE is controlled by a toddler and made its name appealing to youngsters in the 1980s. They already write a cod-inspirational product with a near-total lack of sophistication that is spurned by grown adults. Why not go all in?

Why not go full hog on just doing kid's wrestling?

Most people think of it as children's TV anyway, only, not that many children are watching. They're not watching because Nikki ASH isn't an inspirational child-friendly character because she's a deluded loser. She doesn't face and overcome great struggles. She just ekes out victories and sells them as if they're great moments in the history of human perseverance.

Scary giants, superheroes, silly slapstick comedy: RAW is in effect a children's TV show as it is. Get rid of the n*nce-bait and the 40 consecutive chair shots, and parents might allow their kids to stay up late and actually watch it.


4. Strap Up Big E

Big E Apollo Crews Fastlane 2021
WWE.com

Big E rules and is almost universally beloved.

A hyper-entertaining and credible power guy who can veer across earnest fire and charisma-drenched patter seamlessly, he's also a tremendous human being. He should have been WWE's number one babyface years ago plural. At last, it appears that it's finally happening for him.

The idea that Vince McMahon doesn't want a top star is a generous nonsense: he's simply incapable of building one. He is at least incapable of marketing a babyface, anyway, because he's an increasingly befuddled and disconnected figure with grotesque values. He can promote a top heel accordingly, in Roman Reigns, but Roman Reigns desperately requires a long-term babyface to inspire hope that this storyline is going anywhere.

Already, the indications are that the title of this list is in vain. On last week's SmackDown, Baron Corbin stole Big E's Money In The Bank contract, as if Big E's name isn't on the f*cker. Either it's that easy or Baron Corbin is that dumb. Big E can only transcend WWE's trappings so much. All roads lead to Corbin or something like it eventually.

But.

Big E is a fearless - he once buried the dross writing with his burial of the Shining Stars pun - and he has earned Vince's trust.

If there's a remote chance that he has a degree of freedom, à la Daniel Bryan, there's a not insignificant chance that this actually works.


3. Bring Back Vignettes

toni storm
WWE.com

What's heavily ironic is that the WWE stans who bury AEW for not expanding on the events of Dark (which is free-to-air) watched on with no complaints as Vince McMahon for years debuted NXT acts with no vignettes on the RAW after WrestleMania.

What would the casual fans think?!

If Vince McMahon has lost all faith in NXT as a star-making mechanism, he would do well to recognise that simply debuting NXT stars devoid of context was always a piss-poor display of laziness. Debuting an act in front of a hardcore flown-in audience was an attempt to get them over through inference. It never worked because, if they were lucky enough to get booked beyond two weeks, they were handed the same sh*tty material as everybody else. This is another, far more significant issue, but as it stands, these people have no chance of even getting over to a degree that might allow them to transcend the b*llocks imposed upon them.

Everybody loves a vignette. Vignettes were commonplace when WWE was good; they tease a game-changer and shape their characters. In the interests of balance, AEW should experiment with vignettes because their incessant love of the shocking debut!1 has yielded decidedly mixed results.

A vignette in itself, irrespective of the content almost, acts as evidence that WWE actually gives a sh*t. Of course, the next time WWE screens one, the Dark Father will be invoked as counter. They actually don't give a sh*t, on that evidence.

This brings us to...


2. Try Not To Be Incredibly Stupid

Charlotte Flair Nikki Cross
WWE.com

This one is difficult because stupid people, being stupid, don't realise that they are stupid - and there are a lot of stupid people in the halls of WWE, from the dusty autocrat at the helm to the hack TV writers sh*t-scared of him.

A lot of times, when a show becomes stupid - when characters make dumb decisions for the convenience of the plot, when canonical events are retconned because they are no longer convenient etc. - fans say "That's stupid" and simply stop watching.

In the case of WWE, it's a wonder this viewership decline only really became pronounced in 2015.

Booking grown adult woman Charlotte Flair to have an inability to tell the time was incredibly stupid. This is a multi-time World Champion who, in canon, is effectively the third-best singles performer they've ever had. In canon. You know how much importance they place upon multiple title wins.

And she can't tell the time.

Imagine Steve Austin, Hulk Hogan, Mitsuharu Misawa, Shinya Hashimoto - any tippy-top wrestler a promotion wanted its fans to take seriously - losing a Beat The Clock challenge match because "Eeeeh I didn't notice the bloody time, where has today gone?!"

Try not to be this dumb for at least...


1. Be Good, Consistently, For A Calendar Year

Vince McMahon
WWE

This is the main crux of the issue.

A significant portion of fans that might be inclined to still enjoy WWE for what WWE is - a soapy, verbose and contrived interpretation of pro wrestling - simply can't trust it to be good for any worthwhile length of time.

WWE is not uniformly, irredeemably abysmal. Well, RAW is, which isn't ideal, but they're not pumping out Heroes Of Wrestling-tier junk on every single broadcast. Certain developments betray the prevailing take that WWE is in the mud. The RK-Bro storyline is over with crowds and, gauging by the rare, real sound in arenas, fans have been effectively manipulated into sympathising with Riddle. The Head of the Table stuff isn't as over as his biggest defenders think it is, but the individual performance is legitimately superb. Put an over babyface on a winding long-term collision course with Roman Reigns, and the promise of the act might yet reveal itself.

Night one of WrestleMania was excellent - a quintessentially WWE show that proved, across its giant breakouts, dumb-fun Shane McMahon bumps and glorious spectacle, that the old magic still glows.

Say WWE strips itself of the reluctant, loveless embrace of the old indie scene and somehow distills night one of 'Mania and applies it to cohesive, functional TV. Say Vince McMahon's recent HHH-baiting impulses are proven correct.

The chronic lack of trust is such that it will still take at least a year of healing for it to matter.


In this post: 
Big E
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!