10 Ways WWE Can Turn Around Its Ratings Woes

With ratings at an all-time low, how can WWE turn things around?

Liv Morgan
WWE.com

WWE ratings are on the decline. Over the past four years, RAW's numbers have dropped by over 40% and despite the odd bright spot here and there (usually for special reunion shows featuring Superstars from the Attitude Era), it doesn't appear as if they're going to rebound any time soon.

SmackDown's numbers aren't much better as they've declined significantly since the show first debuted on FOX and the blue brand doesn't pull in ratings much higher than RAW despite being on network TV rather than cable. NXT, meanwhile, is back to being beaten by All Elite Wrestling: Dynamite on a weekly basis after that boost from Survivor Series last year.

As if that's not all bad enough, WWE struggles in the key 18 - 49 demographic and has a relatively old audience, something which doesn't bode well for the future. With all that in mind, something obviously needs to change.

It's not too late for WWE to turn things around and while it's going to take a while, there are ways for ratings to increase and potentially return to where they were just a few short years ago. Here, we delve into 10 ways the sports entertainment giant can recover from its current ratings woes and significantly improve the product in the process.

10. Cliffhanger Endings

Lana Raw Arrest
WWE.com

RAW ratings frequently fluctuate by hundreds of thousands of viewers from week to week and it's clear that there are a lot of people out there who don't consider the show appointment viewing. One sure-fire way to change that would be to increase the number of cliffhanger endings so that fans actually have a compelling reason to come back.

Remember when CM Punk turned heel and attacked The Rock? How about Seth Rollins turning on The Shield or Shane McMahon buying WCW? Of course you do because those left a lasting impact and saw wrestling fans talking for an entire week about what comes next. These days, social media is key and if lapsed viewers see people speculating about major cliffhangers like those, even they will be curious about watching the follow-up.

Too often, RAW and SmackDown end the same way; the heels or babyfaces gain the upper hand, end the show standing tall, and then the cycle repeats itself the following week. Increasing the frequency of shocking cliffhangers makes the shows vastly more exciting, creates buzz online, and generates headlines.

WWE's creative team just need to up their game to make it work.


9. Make Triple H The Man In Charge

Triple H raw
WWE.com

Vince McMahon deserves a lot of credit for what he's done with WWE over the years but he's blatantly out of touch and no longer fit to be in charge of RAW and SmackDown. Reports of him tearing up the show's scripts hours before they go on the air are frequent and the worst creative decisions and storylines are more often than not credited to him.

To an extent, he may be used as a scapegoat but it's clear that the company's flagship shows need new leadership (and we're not talking about Eric freakin' Bischoff).

Even at two hours, NXT remains vastly better than RAW and SmackDown and that's because Triple H is in charge. It's clear from interviews with The Game that he has very different ideas about how things should be run and it's no coincidence that mysterious creatures in cages and people being covered in dog food are the "highlights" of Vince's shows, while NXT continues to deliver actual character development and solid in-ring action.

Sorry, Vince...it's time to let someone else play the game.


8. Bring Back An Authority Figure (Really)

William Regal
WWE.com

When they're done right, authority figures in WWE do work. Seeing Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon bring the heels in line on SmackDown Live was always good fun, while seeing Vince get his comeuppance always helped make these shows a must-see. Don't forget, it was his rivalry with Stone Cold Steve Austin that helped WWE overcome WCW all those years ago because it was something viewers could relate to.

Currently, wrestlers seemingly book themselves in matches and there are never really any serious consequences for anyone's actions. Bringing in a fresh authority figure of some sort could shake things up in a big way and involving them in key storylines and taking a slow build approach to their eventual downfall is definitely a way to get fans hooked again.

Admittedly, this is a concept WWE pretty much killed by putting Baron Corbin and Shane McMahon in charge as heels (the former can arguably be blamed for RAW's shocking decline in viewership). However, with the right talent and stories, viewers would have the opportunity to watch their favourite wrestlers overcome new challenges, see the bad guys get what they deserve, and know that there's a reason for what happens each week.


7. Up The Sex Factor

Scarlett Bordeaux IMPACT Wrestling
Impact

Fans and critics alike have panned the Rusev/Lana/Bobby Lashley/Liv Morgan storyline but it's done great numbers for WWE both in terms of TV ratings and YouTube views. Content like that is trashy but people want to see where it goes and while we may be living in a politically correct time, a lot of viewers still want to see segments like Lana and Rusev in bed even if it's just for a glimpse of...well, not much at all really!

It may sound juvenile but, ultimately, sex sells and WWE embracing that might not be a bad thing at this stage. Women do tune into RAW and SmackDown each week but it's a predominantly male audience and while female talent should absolutely still be treated with respect, imagine the quarter-hour numbers if Scarlett Bordeaux (who has been vocal about wanting to bring sexiness back to women's wrestling) was out there each week and involved in a risqué storyline?

No one is suggesting getting rid of the stellar women's division and going back to "Divas" but utilising some female AND male Superstars in this way could bring back teenage boys - which WWE needs - and fans who miss the antics of the Attitude Era.


6. Increase The Number Of Gimmick Matches

Rollins Fiend dark steel cage match
Twitter, @UseYourIllusion

WWE's shows have a habit of blurring together and that's because a lot of what we see isn't much different to what happened the week before. A couple of weeks ago, though, RAW had its first Ladder match in years and there's no way anyone is going to forget that thrilling battle between Andrade and Rey Mysterio any time soon.

These shows are too often dominated by No-DQ matches and glorified Street Fights with the same old weapons but marquee stipulations like a Cage match or a Submission match should be used more frequently. That's not to say that every episode of SmackDown should end with one but WWE no longer needs to save these for Pay Per Views because the WWE Network has made the concept of fans "buying" a PPV irrelevant.

If Roman Reigns finally wants to get his hands on King Corbin with no outside interference, why not make it a Cage match? Aleister Black and Buddy Murphy are fighting again? Well, it's time to make it an Iron Man match! WWE's TV shows need to feel like a big deal and gimmick matches like these, not to mention an increased number of title bouts where the belt actually changes hands, are a must.


5. Make Wrestling Mainstream Again

stone cold mike tyson
WWE.com

RAW and NXT air on the USA Network, while SmackDown is on FOX. Those are two major stations so what's up with the lack of crossovers? We saw some of that when the blue brand moved to network television but it feels like the days of wrestlers showing up in TV shows is a thing of the past and that's gone a long way in isolating wrestling.

WWE does its best to be considered mainstream but the company needs to let talent take more acting gigs because that will open the door to viewers being intrigued enough to follow these larger than life personalities back to where they hail from. The company also needs to be more open to outside opportunities because All Elite Wrestling did a great job of bridging the gap between genres after taking advantage of Time Warner's links to franchises like Batman and Rick and Morty last year.

WWE can tout articles in publications like Rolling Stone and Sports Illustrated as much as they like but they're still missing the "cool" factor and that means coming up with ways to connect with youthful brands and grabbing the attention of non-wrestling fans in the process.


4. Money In The Bank Needs To Matter

Brock Lesnar Money In The Bank
WWE

The importance of Money in the Bank has declined in recent years and Superstars failing to cash in (thereby wasting their opportunity) or cashing in the same night they win the briefcase is a well the company has now visited too many times. Making the gimmick matter again would be massively beneficial to WWE over the summer, particularly as it's a period where ratings tend to fall after the excitement of WrestleMania.

WWE took this to extremes last year by having Brock Lesnar constantly promise to cash in and while it benefited ratings in the short term, being lied to on a weekly basis also massively pissed fans off and likely drove off a lot of already exasperated viewers.

Using the Money in the Bank briefcase effectively can keep people tuning in for an entire year and if it's built up with a strong storyline behind it, the moment that cash in happens then becomes a moment fans talk about for years to come. It can also be used to freshen up the main event scene when things start to grow stagnant and introducing a tag team version - which was rumoured to be the plan last year - could also be a smart move.


3. Secondary Titles That Are More Than Just Props

Sami Zayn Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Outside of the WWE, Universal, and Women's Championships, WWE has a lot of titles. Can you remember the last time one of them got a legitimately well-thought-out and compelling storyline, though? Sometimes, the Superstars holding them can make a difference and we do get the occasional great match such as that aforementioned showdown between Andrade and Rey Mysterio.

Shinsuke Nakamura, however, has held the Intercontinental title for months and only now has a viable challenger in Braun Strowman. Other than that, it's been used like a prop and it really shouldn't be that difficult for WWE to keep things competitive with these different title divisions, especially with such a deep roster.

Every championship needs to mean something and we should be seeing Superstars fighting to get their hands on them at every opportunity. Instead, WWE gives the impression that none of the titles outside the world heavyweight picture matter and that means the people at home are thinking the same thing. As a result, how can you expect viewers to want to tune in when most of what they're watching is borderline pointless?

By strengthening these secondary championships, WWE would make its programming stronger and once again help increase interest in the product.


2. Stop Giving Content Away For Free

Edge WWE Return
WWE.com

WWE is a billion dollar company and while its YouTube views are massive, they also account for a tiny fraction of the company's income. While their videos do numbers that 99.9% of YouTubers dream about, the only thing WWE really gets out of them is bragging rights. With that said, there's really no need to put highlights from both RAW and SmackDown on the site so quickly.

We live in a world of short attention spans so your average teenager is almost certainly going to choose YouTube clips over a three hour show. WWE even makes a point of only including the really important moments in these videos so why bother watching on TV on when you can see what you need to there? Even Edge's entrance was on YouTube less than 24 hours after his return meaning that subscribing to the WWE Network for that historic moment was far from a necessity.

From a pure business standpoint, WWE stands a greater chance of increasing viewership by forcing people to actually watch their shows three times a week rather than giving it away for free. Randy Orton's attack on Edge currently has 2.7 million views; RAW, meanwhile, received 2.4 million viewers this week and even if half of those were people just watching that again after seeing it on TV, imagine how much better ratings would be if the other half had tuned in live?


1. Make NXT Superstars Free Agents

Rhea Ripley NXT Champion
WWE.com

When NXT got involved with Survivor Series, ratings increased, WWE finally closed the gap between that show and All Elite Wrestling, and the brand eventually took the lead. Now, it's back to being beaten on a weekly basis and the best possible way to change that is for WWE to make good use of RAW and SmackDown in order to help bring fresh eyes to the "developmental" brand.

There's not a wrestling fan on the planet who wants to see NXT become RAW-Lite but let the likes of Daniel Bryan or Seth Rollins appear on Wednesday nights and bring the occasional NXT Superstar to the other shows for brief rivalries, and you'll be on to a winner.

NXT talent had no meaningful involvement with this year's Royal Rumble and that makes it feel like they weren't worthy of fighting for a shot at the main event of WrestleMania. Upping the level of interconnectivity would potentially upset some fans but it might also entice a lot of casual viewers to tune in and see what's happening every Wednesday. There are ways to do this without hurting NXT and if WWE ever wants to truly defeat AEW, it could be a necessary evil.


In this post: 
Liv Morgan
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Josh Wilding hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.