10 Weirdest WCW PPV Main Events Ever

The promotion tried all sorts of things during their war with the World Wrestling Federation.

Black Scorpion Thumb
WWE

Throughout its long and colourful history, World Championship Wrestling always made great use of pay-per-views. 

Jim Crockett Promotions (JCP), the company that would become WCW, was the first to make use of closed-circuit broadcasts - and also beat WWE to the idea of a monthly pay-per-view schedule. 

Many of their original concepts - War Games, Halloween Havoc, The Great American Bash etc. - have been continued by their former competitors, proving the lasting impact they've had over two decades since they went bust. 

They might have been pioneers when it came to the format, but that doesn't mean they always got it right. The company put on some utterly awful shows with some truly bizarre matches in the final spot, the best of which are detailed here. If you can believe it, the year 2000 only appears twice. Who'd have thunk? 

This list is only covering shows post-1988, which is when JCP was purchased by Turner and rebranded as WCW. Equally, a "main event" here is classed as the final match on a given card, so none of this "multiple main events" nonsense that wrestling companies love to trot out. 

10. Hollywood Hulk Hogan vs Roddy Piper - Starrcade 1996

hulk hogan roddy piper starrcade

During the 1980s, you couldn't have asked for a better main event match than Hulk Hogan versus "Rowdy" Roddy Piper. 

This was the feud that had closed out the very first WrestleMania and had helped turn WWE into the biggest promotion in America. However, by the time 1996 rolled around, a lot had changed. 

Hogan and Piper closed out Starrcade '96 when they were both in their mid-forties, which meant something very different back then than it does today. But that's not why this match is so odd. 

After years of failing to defeat The Hulkster as a heel, gallant babyface Piper made the NWO leader pass out in a sleeper hold, winning him the match and the WCW title. At least, that's what everyone thought at the time. 

Despite Hogan being the champion and this being the main event of the biggest show of the year, Piper apparently "forgot" to make this match for the belt, rendering his victory ultimately useless. 

Hollywood Hulk would hold onto the gold until August the following year, and Piper would never once get his mitts on the top prize. 


9. Goldberg vs Scott Hall - Souled Out 1999

Goldberg Scott Hall Souled Out 1999 Ladder Match
WWE.com

At Starrcade 1998, Kevin Nash defeated Goldberg to win the WCW title and end Bill's undefeated streak in one of the most controversial booking decisions in wrestling history. 

Nash got a huge assist in this match from his buddy Scott Hall, who used a cattle prod to weaken Goldberg so Big Sexy could hit him with a powerbomb. This led to the main event of the next pay-per-view, Souled Out 1999, which saw Hall and Goldberg go one-on-one in a Stun Gun Ladder Match. 

Just one question - what the hell is a Stun Gun Ladder Match? 

The objective of this bizarre bout was to retrieve the titular weapon, which was hanging above the ring, and then use it on your opponent. Presumably this was only a ladder match because Vince Russo hadn't signed with the promotion yet, otherwise you know that sucker would have been on a pole. 

Having these two fight over a stun gun somewhat lessened the severity of their feud, which probably did deserve a main event match. Goldberg won, by the way, avenging his loss in one of the strangest ways possible. 


8. Golberg vs KroniK - Halloween Havoc 2000

goldberg kronik
WWE.com

The idea of one wrestler fighting two or more opponents is a weird one at the best of times, but the story behind this handicap match makes it even more odd. 

Goldberg was booked to face the tag team of KroniK - Bryan Clark and Brian Adams - at Halloween Havoc 2000 in a match where, if he lost, he would be kicked out of WCW for good. The match was supposed to take place earlier in the night, but after the former Atlanta Falcon was laid out in a mysterious attack, it was pushed back to give him more time to heal up. 

Wow, they must have something special planned to go to all this trouble. Spoiler alert - they did not. 

Instead, Goldberg came out and handily defeated both men in a match that lasted under four minutes. That was it. 

This might have been fine if it hadn't been the focal point of the show, but the fact that it had displaced Booker T versus Scott Stener for the World title from the main event made this ridiculous decision even harder to swallow. 


7. Hulk Hogan vs The Butcher - Starrcade 1994

The Butcher Vs Hulk Hogan
WWE

Everybody's relied on a favour from a friend at some point in their lives, but few people have ever mooched off someone so successfully for so long as Ed Leslie. 

The man best known as Brutus "The Barber" Beefcake  made the most of his real-life friendship with Hulk Hogan during the height of his career. This favouritism was on full display at Starrcade 1994, which ended with Hogan defending the WCW Championship against The Butcher, AKA one of Beefer's six thousand career gimmicks. 

The Butcher had turned on Hogan earlier in the year, aligning with The Three Faces of Fear in an effort to take his bestie's title. Unfortunately for everyone watching, this meant sitting through 12 minutes of bland, uninspired wrestling from a man who had absolutely no business headlining WCW's version of WrestleMania.

Mercifully, this was the one and only time Leslie was ever put in this sort of position by a major company. Even WWE at the height of Hulkamania knew this was a bad idea, but WCW clearly didn't have the same level of clarity when it came to standing up against their biggest star. 


6. Sting vs The Black Scorpion - Starrcade 1990

sting black scorpion starrcade 1990
WWE

During Sting's first NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship reign in 1990, he needed a credible heel challenger that wasn't Ric Flair. Sadly, there weren't many of those around, so head booker Ole Anderson came up with an idea. 

Anderson introduced The Black Scorpion, a masked man from Sting's past who tormented him for months. This led to a title match between the two at Starrcade where, if The Scorpion lost, he would unveil his true identity. 

The Stinger beat the different kind of Stinger with a diving crossbody and then, after a struggle, pulled off his mask to reveal... Ric Flair! 

Wait, what?

As it turns out, Anderson had no idea who he wanted the Scorpion to be when he started running the gimmick. After a number of options fell through, Flair was begged to return to the main event scene, which he did so under the proviso that he would get to beat Sting later down the line. 

A complete and utter booking mess that led to one of the most disappointing un-maskings in wrestling history - not exactly the way you want to end your flagship pay-per-view.


5. Jeff Jarrett vs Diamond Dallas Page vs David Arquette - Slamboree 2000

WCW Slamboree 2000
WWE.com

At least when David Arquette won the WCW World Heavyweight Championship, the company had the decency to do it on TV and not on pay-per-view. 

The Scream Actor did get to headline a major show however, as he technically defended the gold against Jeff Jarrett and Diamond Dallas Page at the 2000 edition of Slamboree. 

This was a Triple Cage match, inspired by the multi-Academy Award-winning movie Ready to Rumble, and each part of the cage contained a new variety of weapon. The third and final stage was the guitar room, Jarrett's signature weapon, but it was Arquette who used one to turn on his friend DDP and hand Double J the belt... his belt... that he'd just won. 

Ok then. 

Things got even crazier when, after the bell, Kanyon ran down to help Page, only to get intercepted by Mike Awesome. 

The former ECW man lobbed Kanyon off the top of the cage to sending plummeting down to Earth, which would have been a cool spot had this show not taken place almost one year to the day (and in the same building) as Owen Hart's tragic death from a similar stunt gone wrong. 


4. Hulk Hogan & Dennis Rodman vs Lex Luger & The Giant - Bash At The Beach 1997

hulk hogan dennis rodman bash at the beach
WWE

Some wrestlers work their butts off for decades without ever coming close to a pay-per-view main event for a major company. Dennis Rodman go to do it twice just by being pals with Hulk Hogan. 

The legendary NBA player first appeared on WCW pay-per-view at Bash at the Beach 1997 as an honorary member of the NWO. Alongside The Hulkster, he took part in a tag team match against Lex Luger and The Giant. You might expect a match like this to only go a little while, just to let Rodman look good and give the fans something to talk about. 

Nope. This dragged on for 22 entire minutes. 

To make things even stranger, Rodzilla wasn't even the one who took the fall. Instead, Luger beat Hogan by submission to end the match in a huge feelgood moment that eventually led to The Total Package winning the WCW title on Nitro.

It turns out that Rodman not only main evented a WCW show, but he also played a small part in one of Nitro's biggest ever moments. And he wasn't done there...


3. Hollywood Hulk Hogan & Dennis Rodman vs Diamond Dallas Page & Karl Malone - Bash At The Beach 1998

wcw nwo bash at the beach 1998
WWE.com

One year on from his first Bash at the Beach main event, Rodman stepped back into the ring to close the show once again, only this time he wasn't the only basketball star involved. 

To counter Madonna's ex-boyfriend, Diamond Dallas Page recruited another top player, Karl Malone, to be his partner for this tag match against Rodzilla and Hogan. As luck would have it, Malone's Utah Jazz and Rodman's Chicago Bulls had just faced each other in the NBA Finals, making this a huge coup for WCW. 

Once again, the company could have put on a ten-or-so-minute match to give the fans what they wanted and not let the non-wrestlers embarrass themselves. Instead, they booked this match to go even longer than one from the year before. 

Viewers didn't even get the satisfaction of watching Hogan submit this year, as The Disciple (yet another of Ed Leslie's gimmicks) interfered to allow his best buddy to pin DDP for the win. This was an utterly horrible match that no amount of publicity could have justified - a massive open goal that WCW put way over the crossbar.


2. The Mega Powers vs The Alliance To End Hulkamania - Uncensored 1996

uncensored 1996
WWE.com

In a desperate attempt to get him over as a babyface in 1996, WCW put Hogan back together with his old Mega Powers partner Randy Savage and pitted the two against a bunch of people who had all beefed with The Hulkster over the years. 

Ric Flair and Arn Anderson were there from The Four Horsemen, whilst Hogan's recent scuffles with The Dungeon of Doom were represented by Meng, The Barbarian, Kevin Sullivan, and Lex Luger. Zeus, the villain from Hogan's 1989 movie No Holds Barred, was given the new name Z-Gangsta, and Robert "Jeep" Swanson was put under a mask as The Ultimate Solution. 

That's a lot of people. 

Hogan and Savage fought all eight of their foes in a Doomsday Cage match, where they had to work their way down from the top of the structure to the floor. This was some of the most cartoonish stuff WCW ever did. The babyfaces were hitting people with frying pans at one point! 

This was an absolutely mad match, especially when you realise that Hogan forming the NWO was just three months away at this point.


1. Diamond Dallas Page & Jay Leno vs Hollywood Hulk Hogan & Eric Bischoff - Road Wild 1998

Jay Leno WCW Road Wild 1998.jpg
WWE

Rodman and Malone may not have been wrestlers, but at least they were athletes. Someone who is very much not an athlete is chat show legend Jay Leno, but that didn't stop him from main eventing WCW's Road Wild pay-per-view in 1998. 

The comedian became involved with wrestling after Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff invaded The Tonight Show, challenging him to a match at the upcoming show. Leno found an ally in Diamond Dallas Page, who always seemed to get stuck babysitting celebrities, and it was on. 

Instead of putting Goldberg in the main event, who had beaten Hogan for the WCW title just two months earlier, WCW booked the NWO guys against Page and Leno for the final match. 

This sideshow battle came to an end with Kevin Eubanks, Leno's bandleader on his show, hit Bischoff with a Diamond Cutter, allowing his boss to pin Easy E... with his shoulders about six inches off the mat. 

Oh Jay. 

A completely insane idea that resulted in rock bottom buyrates for the company, Jay Leno's involvement in Road Wild 1998 has gone down as one of the most infamous decisions WCW ever made. And that's saying something.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.