10 Worst Case Booking Scenarios For WrestleMania 35
KofiMania keeps running wild, but will it last until New York?
As strong as this year's WrestleMania card looks, getting too fired up for a WWE pay-per-view can be a dangerous game, particularly for those with high levels of personal investment.
Everyone should try to get excited for the show, but many are setting themselves up for a fall. Creative will never calibrate a show purely to pop their picky audience. This point is especially relevant to 'Mania 35, as organic fan movements effectively led to two of the top three programmes (KofiMania and the main event) being booked in the first place, and undesired outcomes could spark another futile #CancelWWENetwork movement.
Last year's main event proves that nothing is certain anymore. Big babyfaces will lose on this show, and fans will feel let down. String a few of these together (unlikely, admittedly), and what looked like a promising show goes to hell thanks to heightened expectations and, of course, oddball booking decisions.
Note that this piece is not an endorsement of the scenarios within. Your writer doesn't want a single one to go down, in fact, but they might, so treat this as a warning.
Let's hope Vince McMahon and his merry men don't lose their minds before 7 April...
10. Nia Jax & Tamina Win A Ladder Match
The path WWE have taken to WrestleMania 35's Women's Tag Team Title match hasn't been particularly inspiring. It's this year's "throw as many people in the ring as possible" bout, with the teased Divas of Doom versus Nia Jax and Tamina two-on-two feud expanded to include Sasha Banks and Bayley. Then came The IIconics, who defeated the champs on their maiden SmackDown voyage, and we've got ourselves a four-way.
Some have called for this bout to be turned into a ladder match.
They are insane.
Jax's track record of hurting people speaks for itself, and her partner doesn't exactly work with finesse either. Throw the green (but improving) IIconics, Sasha Banks' occasional recklessness, and a rusty Beth Phoenix into the mix, and you have a recipe for complete and utter disaster. Ladders are fun and all, but throwing them into this match sends the odds of someone getting injured through the roof.
Having the unpopular Jax and Tamina go over sentimental fan favourites Bayley and Banks would turn this into a true nightmare scenario, burying the new belts six feet deep. Imagine the reaction...
9. The SNL Goobers Eliminate Braun Strowman
Here's the thing about Braun Strowman: Braun Strowman isn't even a thing anymore.
WWE stopped caring about 'The Monster Among Men' a while ago. He's no longer a potential World Champion, but a comedic novelty act. While this could change again, his demotion should be apparent to anyone paying attention, and he once again finds himself without an important WrestleMania match.
Optimists have him down to win the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, and in all likelihood, he will. There isn't a particularly strong case for anyone else this year. It's an unimportant bout that never yields tangible rewards for the victory, but who the hell else is going to do it? Viktor? Tyler Breeze?
... or how about Michael Che/Colin Jost?
The two Saturday Night Live hosts are confirmed participants, and have spent the past few weeks fannying around with Strowman on Raw. The two parties don't like each other. Now, there's every possibility that these sneaky little scamps will find a way to send the big man tumbling over the top rope and out of the match, concluding their feud with one of the most head-scratching 'Mania celebrity moments.
8. Dominick Destroys Joe Vs. Mysterio
Dominick's involvement in the Rey Mysterio vs. Samoa Joe programme doesn't make a drop of narrative sense.
Rey brought his son onto television, not Joe. He involved him in the angle by announcing he'd be ringside at WrestleMania. Why, then, is the lucha legend prattling on about "defending his family's honour" on 'The Grandest Stage Of Them All?'. You brought your son here, man. Joe didn't so much as lift a finger. Fair enough, the bruiser was super creepy around AJ Styles' family, but if anything happens to Dominick, it's nobody but Rey's fault.
Besides, didn't Mysterio Sr. see what happened when Miz's dad was at Fastlane? This is stupid.
Dominick will be involved in some shape or form. His ringside presence wouldn't be advertised if he wasn't going to do something, whether it be getting slapped by Joe or even turning on his father. Either way, WWE would do well to keep it low-key. Joe vs. Rey doesn't look like a potential show-stealer, but it's a fun match for sure, and the last thing fans of certain preferences will want is for it to get buried in some wacky Mysterio family drama.
7. The Demon Falls
Finn Balor's Demon character was first spotted on WWE's WrestleMania 35 poster weeks ago. Him showing up in New York as his alter ego isn't guaranteed, but it's a safe bet, particularly as he's tasked with defeating a powerhouse in Bobby Lashley who put him away at the last time of asking.
The Irishman needs to get the job done, so why not call on the guaranteed victory?
WWE have done a good job of preserving the Demon thus far. Though his initial call-up spawned understandable oversaturation concerns, Finn only dons his facepaint sparingly. Its last outing saw him crush Baron Corbin in hilariously quick fashion. Doing the same to a supposed monster like Lashley probably isn't on the cards, but he should put Big Bad Bobby away with less trouble than usual.
But what if he doesn't? What if the company decide, for some hare-brained reason, that Lashley should be the one to hand the Demon his first main roster loss? It's a moment that should be saved for later down the line, once Finn has notched a few notable victories under the guise, and burning it at 'Mania 35 would be dumb as hell. WWE gonna WWE, though.
6. Your Workrate Fave On The Kickoff Show
The WrestleMania 35 card is huge.
13 matches have been confirmed so far, but that number could hit 16 or 17 by the time next week's Raw and SmackDown are done with. This is going to be a monster show, and potentially the longest in history in terms of match count and runtime, with some outlets predicting the event could go for 8 hours in total.
Sacrifices are inevitable. Potential bangers will be relegated to the Kickoff Show, and while WWE don't deserve the heat for making these moves, they're definitely going to upset someone when they have to shunt Buddy Murphy vs. Tony Nese onto the pre-show. It's inevitable.
WWE always catch flak for shunting the Cruiserweights in the death slot, but they'll catch even more if they throw Bayley and Sasha Banks down there as well. Samoa Joe vs. Rey Mysterio is another possibility. On top of this, any Tag Team Title matches that go down will almost certainly get the Kickoff treatment, and this year's heavy focus on women's wrestling means that the battle royal will probably get put on the main card, leaving another pre-show spot to fill.
The outrage won't be worth it, but people will be salty when their workrate fave gets dunted.
5. Baron Corbin Vs. Kurt Angle Actually Goes Ahead
This Baron Corbin vs. Kurt Angle match is weird. So weird, in fact, that fans were quick to call it a ruse, with chants of "WE WANT CENA!" filling the arena as soon as it was announced, while social media buzzed with all kinds of conspiracy theories.
The Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer and Mike Johnson of PW Insider tried to kill these rumours, with both reporting that WWE actually wanted Corbin to be Angle's opponent for this 'Farewell Match.' They claimed that this wasn't a troll job, but an earnest piece of booking, and that there will be no last-minute replacements on the road to New York.
The bout does make a shred of narrative sense, as Corbin and Angle have butted heads multiple times over the past months, with Baron beating Kurt earlier this year. Still, we can't take the reports as gospel, particularly with Cena currently trolling the hell out of Corbin on Instagram, and talk that 'Big Match John' will be in town for WrestleMania 35.
Cena vs. Angle remains the bout most people want. Corbin, for all his qualities as a stooge heel, is the dullest retirement opponent imaginable.
4. Triple H Gets Epic
The Triple H vs. Batista programme started with incredible promise.
'The Animal's' return angle was one of the year's most effective, with the Guardians Of The Galaxy star literally dragging a cameraman to Ric Flair's locker-room, then doing the same with the legend's battered, broken body. The quality has diminished as the weeks have progressed, but it's still a hot programme, and while these guys have a combined age of 99, they can have a successful WrestleMania match.
12-15 minutes, a smart layout, brawling, weapon spots, and all kinds of smoke and mirrors. That's the formula. Unfortunately, Triple H's 'Mania track record suggests this won't be the route 'The Game' takes.
Hunter loves his big, bloated, methodical WrestleMania epics. He can't help himself, and while Batista's inactivity should make him think twice in 2019, the possibility can't be ruled out. There's every chance that he's going to try to drag a gassed Big Dave through 30-35 of tedium. This could render the match borderline unwatchable, though it'd take a Herculean effort for Triple H to stoop any lower than Super Show-Down's horror show versus The Undertaker.
3. KofiMania Ends In Failure
There isn't a hotter male babyface in WWE than Kofi Kingston, whose ascent to World Title level came totally out of nowhere, and may never have happened had Ali not been struck down by injury before Elimination Chamber.
That's not to say the former 205 Live man would be facing Daniel Bryan had he stayed healthy. Far from it, in fact: Kingston is here because the fans demanded it. The popular midcarder's workhorse performances in both singles gauntlet matches and the Chamber made him the people's choice to face Bryan at 'Mania, and this well-spun story of a veteran underdog grinding his way to the top the old-fashioned way should conclude next weekend, where general booking logic would dictate he becomes WWE Champion.
Those who've become invested in his programme (IE: 90% of the audience) aren't going to be happy if he doesn't, and there's a strong chance he won't. Perhaps Vince McMahon truly thinks Kingston is a B+ player. Perhaps he still sees him as a successful tag team guy rather than a successful singles guy. Neither is beyond the realms of possibility, and it could get heated if Kofi falls.
2. Brock Lesnar Destroys Seth Rollins
Seth Rollins fans will be hoping their guy doesn't become 2019's Roman Reigns when he steps in the ring to battle Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 35.
'The Kingslayer' should slay 'The Beast' at 'Mania. Should. He's a hard worker who has earned another run with a top title, and the audience is fully behind him. Besides, Brock's second Universal Title run has already gone on for too long. It's time to revive that belt with a new champion who'll bring it back to the forefront by actually taking it to television every week, and while Rollins doesn't necessarily need a long reign, it'd be a shame to see him lose to Lesnar on 7 April.
At this stage, the outcome is a coin flip. Even if it wasn't, there's every chance Vince McMahon could change his mind, even on 'Mania night itself, when he looks across to both competitors in guerrilla, sh*t himself at the prospect of a smaller workrate guy beating his monster, and goes back to Brock.
Worse still would be Lesnar flattening Rollins a la Braun Strowman at Crown Jewel or No Mercy 2017, though this is unlikely.
1. Charlotte Flair Wins... By Tapping Becky Lynch Out
It looks like WWE are heading towards a big photo finish with their Four Horsewomen at WrestleMania 35, and that sounds awesome.
This would mean Bayley and Sasha Banks retaining their Woman's Tag Team Titles earlier in the evening. Charlotte Flair would then escape the Triple Threat with her SmackDown belt, while Becky Lynch would presumably become Raw Champion by pinning or submitting Ronda Rousey. Then, finally, we'd get the Women's Revolution's foremost architects in the ring, together, belts raised aloft, with admiration pouring down from every corner of the arena.
WWE will never have the opportunity to pull off this specific WrestleMania moment (after the first women's main event) again. If they don't do it, it'll be a big missed opportunity, though not everyone is sold on the idea.
One thing most people are sold on, however, is Becky Lynch's triumph. She has been WWE's biggest babyface for months. Her work since becoming 'The Man' has been stellar, so surely her walking away with Ronda Rousey's big red prize is the only thing that makes sense on 7 April, right?
Imagine the reaction if she doesn't, and Charlotte Flair, the kayfabe company golden girl, makes the folk here submit in match seemingly calibrated for a cathartic babyface victory...