10 Worst Ideas That Actual WRESTLERS Came Up With

CM Punk believes veteran advice is valuable. Maybe not, on the following evidence...

Jeff Hardy
WWE

Last year, CM Punk made a massive deal about veteran advice and how it was beyond disrespectful not to take it.

This was one of his many problems with the Elite. Who were they not to listen to those who paved the way? The counter-argument was this: the Elite paved their own way by defying industry norms and ultimately playing a significant role in the formation of a company that allowed Punk to walk into it as a major, well-paid story with the artistic freedom he always coveted.

The Elite didn't believe that veteran advice was necessarily beneficial to their careers, particularly since doing the exact opposite - and defying Jim Cornette, Harley Race and the "minds" in developmental - saw them prosper.

It's a recurring theme in The Discourse: should wrestlers take advice from veterans, and also, do people need to have been involved in the business in order to have an insightful/accurate opinion on it?

This idea is rather undermined by the idea that so many veterans demean themselves on the podcast grift and trot out some of the worst takes you will ever hear, purely to remain relevant.

It is also undermined by this list...

10. Saraya Books The Worst AEW Match Ever

Saraya AEW
AEW

AEW wrestlers enjoy a degree of creative control.

Most are allowed to cut promos in their own voice, and a select few have input into their storylines; the Elite, MJF, Chris Jericho and Jon Moxley all have a signature approach to storytelling that sets their work in the promotion apart. This is a good thing - AEW is the destination for great promos - but nobody outright books their own arc. Everything is filtered through Tony Khan.

Mercifully so, in the case of the following pitch.

Saraya has recovered from a dismal start, in which she appeared entitled to ride in and "save" a division with her revolutionary presence. The fans were put out by this TNA-adjacent development, and Khan pivoted by turning Saraya heel and incorporating this attitude into her onscreen character. That's just as well, since, left to her own devices, Saraya's ideas are...not good.

At least, one idea, pitched to DJ Whoo Kid (h/t 411Mania), was not good. At all.

"Ronnie [Radke, Saraya's notoriously divisive partner] even wanted to become part of it. A storyline, do something against Chris Jericho. He's such a good bad guy. He plays a very good bad guy, and people love to hate him. I feel they [Ronnie and Jericho] would have a good storyline. I would love to wrestle one of the guys. If I have to beat up Chris Jericho, Jericho would be up for it."

This would situate Radke as the babyface in this scenario, and to those unfamiliar with him, that wouldn't be a good or successful idea. He can't wrestle, for starters, and is loathed by many within the alternative rock scene. Since Jericho himself is alienating some fans with his perception as a clout vampire, you're looking at the highest ratio of unlikeable people in one ring since NXT UK folded.

"It writes itself," Saraya argued - which is correct, provided you ask ChatGPT to book the worst AEW storyline since December 2019.


9. Jeff Hardy's Insane Gimmick Match Idea

Jeff Hardy AEW
AEW

Jeff Hardy is an unconventional thinker, which, at least with the following pitch, is a euphemism for "a bit thick at times".

Wrestling has a problem with gimmick matches in general. The old standards have succumbed to excess. The ladder match is no longer thrilling. WWE has bastardised the cage match beyond logical recognition. The WarGames revival never asked fans to invest in the core idea; it was literally littered with pointless extra weapons from the first WWE reboot.

Moreover, there are few new gimmick matches that have taken their place. After Money In The Bank, not a single promotion has created a drawing attraction that combines excitement and violence without a desperate, grabby and convoluted "update" (see: AEW's Casino versions of the battle royal and multi-person ladder matches).

Leave it to Jeff to save the day with his 'Upward Spiral' match. Speaking to Alex McCarthy (h/t CagesideSeats), Hardy pitched the following:

"I have this weird idea for this Upward Spiral match...what if there was a match to where you wrestled for five minutes but then...the ring starts spinning, and then it spins at a certain speed for a certain amount of time...Naturally, you'd get dizzy, but then another two minutes or whatever it starts to spin again, but it's a little faster. I'm just curious as if you can run spots as the ring's spinning and be safe about it."

The exorbitant cost involved in creating a spinning ring, just to watch a match worked like the first few weeks of WWE Performance Center training, probably isn't worth it!

Then again, Jeff Hardy has actually taken a bump, so perhaps it might be the most lucrative idea since the Royal Rumble. Nobody else is qualified to determine this one way or the other.


8. Tommy Dreamer's Sniper Pitch

Tommy Dreamer 16:9
WWE

Tommy Dreamer was desperate for you to know that he was hardcore.

He'd take Singapore cane shot after Singapore cane shot in order to gain acceptance from the ECW faithful. He'd lose and lose and take a battering each time, just so the fans would want him to win in the end. It was a bit desperate, in that he begged for the reaction that somebody like the Sandman simply got, but it worked out for him. He never was the Sandman, in truth, and more than one ECW fan deemed him a bit corny, but he just about secured his legacy, even if it wasn't quite show-don't-tell.

He wanted to take his crusade even further in ECW's heyday, but was talked out of it - "it" being a hit on his life.

Inspired by the "Whodunnit?" craze of the '80s and '90s, he wanted to get shot in the middle of the ring. With a gun. He actually had a clever touch on a very stupid idea, playing with the lights out trope to reveal the sniper's laser when the arena went dark. He was to feud with the person who was revealed to have shot him, but booker Paul Heyman refused to go ahead with the angle. He feared that a fan might get killed, were the sniper's aim not accurate. Dreamer himself could have died.

It was left to Terry Funk to talk Dreamer out of it, but, amusingly, he didn't have safety in mind. He told Dreamer that it wouldn’t draw; his dad got shot in an angle, and the fans stopped caring about him because he didn't kill the guy who tried to kill him.


7. The Ghost Of Eric Bischoff

Eric Bischoff
WWE

Eric Bischoff was not unlike Tony Khan as a booker, in that he surveyed what was hot in the underground or missing from the wider wrestling landscape, and then integrated it in his WCW product.

NJPW Vs. UWF-i on top, ECW underneath, "real" characters antithetical to the WWF's occupational gimmicks across the roster: at its peak, the Nitro formula was incredible. Bischoff differs from Khan in that he only had one truly original idea - that being his bold and patient approach to the Sting character - and once he f*cked that up, WCW tumbled into self-parody, regurgitating somebody else's ideas until the audience stopped caring.

Bischoff did have one unique idea, but Harvey Schiller, then President of Turner Sports, said it wasn't happening. Which is just as well.

Bischoff per 83 Weeks wanted to fake his own death in a worked helicopter crash in Mexico, reasoning that it may take up to six months to verify that he had actually perished there. He would tell only his immediate family (and Warner higher-ups) of the plan. It was sure to work, too, because of the six months thing.

Except his plan was to turn up at Halloween Havoc as a ghost and haunt the babyfaces, which might have concluded the investigation Jesus Christ.

The brains behind "I can't fake die in America, people will know I'm not actually a ghost" thinks he's an expert storyteller.


6. Jim Cornette Fantasy Books The Invasion

Chris Benoit William Regal No Mercy 2006
WWE.com

You should know Jim Cornette's deal at this point: he values legitimacy and logic above all else, and cannot abide what he perceives to be weak offence and a lack of commitment to selling.

You might know him as the guy who grifts his hatred of the Elite; if you're a little older, you'll know him as the man who hates Vince Russo so much that he once threatened to kill him, or at least said "If I could figure out a way to murder him without going to prison, I would consider it the greatest accomplishment of my life".

Cornette despised Russo for "exposing" the business with his stupid lowbrow television and relentless worked shoot philosophy - which is very odd, since his fantasy booking of the Invasion, as told to Kayfabe Commentaries in 2009, called for precisely that. Tensions were to escalate between the WWF and WCW when Chris Benoit jumped back down south in this redux, Vince McMahon sent William Regal to WCW to teach him a lesson, and the "shots" in their match would "land" to make it clear that the hatred between the promotions was actually real.

Doesn't that negate everything else on the shows as "fake", which is what Cornette has despised about pro wrestling since it went all meta in the 1990s and beyond?

And wasn't that idea redundant, since the hatred between the WWF and WCW in the mid-to-late 1990s was so real that it was the most compelling rivalry of the decade?

Why would you break kayfabe to put over the one thing that the fans actually bought?


5. Jim Cornette Books FTR Vs. The Young Bucks

FTR Young Bucks
AEW

The FTR vs. Young Bucks programme was better before the dream match came into focus.

FTR manipulating Hangman Page, by first pretending to be friendly with the Elite out of respect for elevating the tag team form, was a strong idea. It put over both the Kenny Omega and Hangman Page team and the value of the AEW World Tag Team titles they held. FTR had to orchestrate a masterplan in order to unsettle the dominant champions. FTR had to cut the team in half before they could even think of cutting the ring in half.

Then, with the gold secured at All Out 2020, the FTR Vs. Bucks rivalry deepened, and the results were not great, even if they delivered a classic at Full Gear. The Bucks started behaving like their old, transgressive selves by beating up members of the broadcast team backstage. If the idea was to make it feel like the 2016 Bucks were feuding with the 2016 Revival, as many fans had idly dreamed about at the time, it didn't work; the Bucks came off as petulant whiners. It all worked out, but the feud itself underwhelmed.

Khan's idea was still better than Jim Cornette's.

Cornette thought FTR should have stiffed and sandbagged the Bucks in a nine minute match - "not going along with their sh*t" - leaving the fans to question whether what they had just witnessed was legitimate. He justified this worked shoot by saying the AEW base would get what he was going for with a "double cross".

The AEW base wanted a Bucks Vs. FTR dream match. They wanted it for four years. That's what they got after being made to wait for it.

What's with Cornette's booking when he isn't actually getting paid to do it?

He makes Vince Russo look like Bill Watts.


4. Bob Holly Beats EVERYBODY

Hardcore Holly Billy Gunn
WWE.com

The man was probably being glib, but it's funnier (and not that unrealistic) to suggest that he meant what he said.

In and around the mid-2000s, WWE - probably because they lacked many of their own - made the unusual step of reaching out to the roster for creative ideas. As infamously recounted on Something To Wrestle, Bruce Prichard recalled Bob 'Hardcore' Holly saying the following:

"Hey, I got an idea: why don't you give me the belt."

"And then what, Bob?"

"And then I beat everybody."

Splendid.

Bon Holly, career midcarder, doing the Roman Reigns run, except he don't need no damn Usos to get 'er done. Bob Holly, solid and snug and that's about it, tasking himself with drawing atop WWE for...well, as long as his body can hack it. The man said "everybody" and did he stutter, ya little sh*thead?

No, he didn't stutter, asswipe, so he beats everybody. Cena. Batista. 'Taker. Michaels. Everybody.

Then, when they get beat, the next round of developmental guys get beat. Drew McIntyre is chosen...to get his ass broken in half. The Shield get beat. All those indie thigh-slappers; they get their asses kicked and they might even get terrorised backstage if they act up.

It's 2023. Holly just beat Cody. One slap to the face, just like old times.

People on Twitter deem it "cinema" and justify the decision by saying that Cody needs to face more adversity before the fans can get behind him beating the 6,574 day reign of Bob Holly.


3. Paul Heyman Works Out Mark Henry...Or Does He?

Mark Henry
WWE.com

This isn't a terrible idea...on paper.

There's some logic to it. The idea is to go back to basics and maximise the value of a performer who WWE really only got right for about 18 months. The thing is, it's very Paul Heyman.

Paul Heyman's modern booking philosophy is simple but effective, provided the star power can elevate it. He likes to do the same thing over and over and over (and over and over and over) again to reinforce its effectiveness. A Brock Lesnsar German suplex is the most powerful weapon in wrestling. Roman Reigns always wins LOL, even if WWE could have "finished the story" three times over at this point. It's easier to finish Infinite Jest in one sitting than it is for WWE to book a babyface World title run.

Heyman's formula can grow tiresome - the Brock Lesnar finisher spam match died at WrestleMania 38, and this Roman Reigns push is entering nWo 1999 levels of diminished returns - and his big idea to get Mark Henry over was the Chris Masters story. Speaking to SomethingAwful (h/t 411Mania), Heyman in 2016 said he could make the headlock the most exciting move in wrestling by having Mark Henry apply it for 32 consecutive weeks before somebody broke it.

The idea makes sense, yes, but Brock Lesnar Vs. CM Punk from SummerSlam 2013 was better than anything Lesnar has done since.

Bobby Fish
IMPACT Wrestling

2. Bobby Lashley Tries To Get Fat

Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

Bobby Lashley probably couldn't get fat if he tried; the man somehow turns 47 years old in July of this year and still looks as if he has been chiselled out of marble.

He did however wish to try, as he revealed to Not Sam Wrestling (h/t Metro) in 2022.

"If I get beat one time, I want to go into this severe depression and put on like 40, 50, 60, or 70 pounds and just be fat and be a completely different character. And then have like somebody like an MVP, or somebody that’s on my side, kind of like, pull me back and then have the crowd watch this transition back to me."

In addition to being mildly offensive - the idea that being overweight automatically makes one sad is a bit much, even for WWE - it wouldn't have worked because people simply enjoy watching an ultra-shredded monster f*ck people up.

Why, in general, is that so hard to grasp?

Why does WWE have to make Bron Breakker sell for so long in his matches? Why can't they book a fun babyface World title reign?

Why does Lashley feel like he has to rip off a story beat from the MCU?


1. Surgically Enhanced Goldust

Goldust Debut
WWE.com

Goldust is a strange character to unpack.

It's often stated that it was ahead of its time and uniquely compelling, and that is true, but it was gay panic masquerading as something only slightly less on-the-nose. The matches were terrible, and ultimately, the babyfaces you were meant to like acted revolted at his presence. The striking look, enchanting entrance and total commitment to the bit cannot detract from the fact that, ultimately, Vince McMahon wanted to gross you out with the idea that a man fancied other men, even if that man insisted otherwise.

Frankly, it was remarkable that the WWF talked around it as much as they did. Years later, top babyface John Cena seemed to hate gay people as much as Austin Theory and the nation of Taiwan.

As the initial bait of the Goldust character wore off, he "developed" into a bizarre weekly sideshow bit as 'The Artist Formerly Known As Goldust', which saw him mimic various wrestlers and celebrities. During this time, Goldust unsuccessfully pitched to legitimately surgically enhance himself with breast implants.

This terrible and problematic idea was mercifully shot down.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!