10 Worst Survivor Series Elimination Matches EVER - According To Dave Meltzer
Star-Burns
Vince McMahon may blow hot and cold on the elimination format he devised in 1987 to topple NWA pay-per-view stalwart Starrcade, but the multi-man contests remain the easiest of annual selling points for an event that would otherwise feel out of place amongst the traditional 'Big Four'.
Attempts to wipe out the show thankfully failed, with the format gaining something of a resurgence in recent years. Blockbuster Raw/SmackDown quintets from the male and female divisions will lock horns for the second consecutive year, and whilst 'Brand Supremacy' isn't exactly the neatest narrative thread, the company's propensity for booking matches such as these in the modern era virtually guarantees quality on the night.
Unfortunately, WWE's handle on the gimmick wasn't always so robust. The Thanksgiving tradition has provided its fair share of feasts, but hasn't shied away from dishing out an overcooked turkey or two. Wrestling Observer overlord Dave Meltzer has devoured single last one of them, and knows a pumpkin pie from a sh*t sandwich.
Post-1996 Curtain Call, Vince McMahon once infamously told Triple H he'd have to eat a lot of the brown stuff. Loyal viewers shouldn't have had to endure similar torture.
(NOTE: In the event of a tied rating, the most recent match gets preferential treatment. Wrestling evolves at a breakneck pace, and any older contest outperforming a contemporary equivalent is deserving of the elevated status)
10. Team Paige Vs Team Fox (2014, *)
The tenth worst match in Survivor Series history.
Alicia Fox leads a team to the tenth worst match in Survivor Series history. The times, they're a not-changin'.
Yes, as it turns out, the screeching lunatic inexplicably running the rule on Raw actually has form in the role, steering her team to a whitewash victory over 'The Anti-Diva's miscreant crew.
Meltzer's rating isn't far off the mark, in all honestly. The division was still a barren, botch-laden battleground. Though live crowds had long bored of bras, panties and puppies, the company hadn't done near enough to promote them as serious competitors.
Furthermore, for a match only three years old, it's genuinely sad to look back on 2014's contest and consider the fate of the eight combatants.
As of press time, Paige has yet to return to WWE TV since the commencement of a lengthy layoff in mid-2016. Cameron, Layla and Summer Rae are now all gone. So too is Emma, here cast as a bubble-popping babyface long after WWE bungled her main roster arrival.
Natalya, Naomi and Fox deserve credit just for clinging on, but carry stigmas from contests such as these that will take more time and effort to shift.
9. Jim Duggan's Team Vs The Berzerker's Team (1991, 3/4*)
Filling the time on a pay-per-view that deemed it necessary to abruptly end a match featuring teams captained by Ric Flair and Rowdy Roddy Piper, this bizarre assortment of heels and faces were thrown together in order to address Sgt Slaughter's change of heart with all the subtlety of an enflamed American flag.
Alongside captain Jim Duggan, El Matador and the Texas Tornado, Slaughter set about righting his pretty horrific wrongs by toppling ex-partner Colonel Mustafa and his confused gang of villains made up of lowercard losers The Berzerker, Hercules and Skinner.
A match useless mostly for the overall lack of ability on offer from the eight men, Tito Santana and Kerry Von Eric aren't employed to do nearly as much as they could with the luggage on offer as Duggan and Slaughter gobble up the (old) glory for the good of 'Murica in another Survivor Series shutout.
If nothing else, the match curiously foreshadows the in-between days WWE would embark upon in 1992. Ditching both star power and steroids as the company crumbled under its most scandalous annum, the company would look an entirely different place just one year later, leaving nearly all eight men in this match surplus to requirements or seeking employment elsewhere.
8. Team Raw Divas Vs Team SmackDown Divas (2008, 1/2*)
WWE has already won the battle of brand supremacy in 2017, regardless of how well the Raw and SmackDown Live! teams do at the Survivor Series. '#UnderSiege' somehow received its own chant as Shane McMahon laid down the law for his blue team a week removed from his Monday Night Raw invasion. Incredibly, the company have somehow found a way to condense a lengthy beatdown into t-shirt fodder. It would be commendable if it wasn't so sad.
What's less tough to stomach is how the company have at least generated actual separation between the rosters since the relaunched split. Raw and SmackDown stars turning up on the other side has become a rarity again at least. And while the pay-per-view schedule is more clogged than ever, the bottleneck of events come from the need to make intra-show conflicts feel important within their own 'Universe'.
This was decidedly not the case in 2008. Monthly supercards were made up of mixed roster matches with increasing regularity, whilst women on both brands were reduced to menial slots or eye candy hotshots whilst fighting over one irreversibly damaged title. Every entrant in this p*ss poor perversion push-back entered in Raw and SmackDown t-shirts, but tore them off before even making it to the ring. It was a distinct lack of care inadvertently synergistic with the audience.
7. Gangrel, Mark Henry, Steve Blackman & Val Venis Vs British Bulldog & Mean Street Posse (1999, 1/4*)
If merely reading that line-up doesn't exhaust you into submission, the match itself absolutely will despite its placement slap bang in the middle of the company's hottest ever period.
Survivor Series 1999 is a grim outlier amongst months of spectacular matches, moments and memories ingrained in audiences by the virtue of endless in-house love letters to the Attitude Era. Weighted by a main event the company knew a fortnight earlier wouldn't even be happening, the roster were haphazardly shoved into elimination matches such as this whilst the organisation figured out the best use of them all in a post-Vince Russo world.
Bulldog and The Posse were at least heels, but their mismatched mishmash of opponents straddled either side of the divide, and were all around a year past their sell by date ahead of millennium reinventions during WWE's absolute peak in 2000.
The entire elimination format was originally based on a series of individual feuds dovetailing for the spectacular visual of seeing heels and babyface collaborate on their collective conflicts. After watching sh*tshows like this, it's no wonder Vince McMahon began to grow tired of the entire concept.
6. Four Doinks Vs Bam Bam Bigelow, Bastion Booger & The Headshrinkers (1993, DUD)
Bam Bam Bigelow was the right man at the wrong time in both his major WWE tenures. In 1987, the company simply didn't need a giant babyface as long as everybody basked in the afterglow of Hulk Hogan's red and yellow glare. Virtually everybody over 300lbs worked a leg drop loop with 'The Hulkster'. Bam Bam must have been devastated to not see one of those paydays.
The heel he should have been back then emerged in late-1992 right as Vince McMahon was desperate for naturally larger athletes, but outside of a passable rivalry with Tatanka in mid-1993, Bigelow was confined to comedy far beyond the logical range of the character.
Ignoring the fact that the poor schmuck had to contend with the woeful Men On A Mission and Bushwhackers wearing Doink masks, his own team succumbed to the lunacy that seemed to envelope the entire battle.
Frenemy Bastion Booger was distracted from the match by food, whilst one of the ordinarily awesome Headshrinkers literally slipped on a banana peel for a finish.
The newly repurposed Doink p*ssed himself at Bam Bam's plight as the tattooed bruiser left the ring defeated and dejected. He was the only one laughing.
5. The Godwinns, Billy Gunn & The Road Dogg Vs The Headbangers & The New Blackjacks (1997, DUD)
The real life and kayfabe controversy that bookended Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels' emotionally charged Survivor Series 1997 main event helped mask an utterly pathetic undercard made up of uniformly dreadful four-on-four elimination scraps.
Team USA vs Team Canada was a woefully booked affair and some staple-of-the-time faction action will appear later in the list, but a listles brawl early on the show between two clumsy quartets highlighted exactly why the makeshift pairing of Billy Gunn and The Road Dogg were able to break so far away from a barely chasing pack.
Devoid of heat with six performers either unable or unwilling to generate it, Dogg and Gunn were a riot in their red hot new personas as absolute pr*cks, almost immediately looking the right choice to dethrone the dinosauric Legion Of Doom whenever a tag title shot came their way. Winning this match through chicanery as they had every other one since forming, the duo dodged any form of comeuppance from the babyfaces they'd spent weeks abusing, and even dodged repercussions from a Godwinn duo they'd manipulated into siding with them in the first place.
The New Age Outlaws weren't perfect all-rounders, but their wanton disregard for a division on life support was the last gasp the league desperately needed. This contest couldn't have made it clearer.
4. True Divas Vs Total Divas (2013, DUD)
Total Divas exists today on an island from the Women's Division on both brands. Though performers and their partners from both shows take part in the scripted reality vehicle for E!, there exists virtually no correlation between the tales on that show and the action between the ropes on Monday and Tuesday night. Understanding the importance of differentiating the narrative of each, WWE occasionally let their storylines filter into Total Divas drama, but not the other way around.
Still in an experimental phase with the show (and women's wrestling in general), the company attempted to awkwardly marry both sides in a Survivor Series battle destined for failure.
A lack of talent, training and tenure on both sides hugely hampered the battle, whilst AJ Lee's game leadership of the 'True Divas' squad was logical but uncomfortably forced. She'd carved out a niche on the show as a convincing champion, grappling still for credibility on a roster still without much of an eye for equality. But she did it alone - the 'norm' for most women on the main roster was still to hope for a spot on the show rather than a place on WrestleMania.
With no single talent capable of carrying the match or the storyline, the 14-women battle failed to get a coherent message across. Worse still, Total Divas actually won. The division had never looked more lost at sea.
3. The Big Show Vs The Big Boss Man, Mideon, Prince Albert & Viscera (1999, -*)
When WWE elected to make the Survivor Series battle between The Big Show and The Big Boss Man's a hurdle rather than the finish line, a similar level of farce was apparently required between the ropes as it was at the funeral home.
Just days removed from bodyboarding on a coffin carrying his father's corpse, Show was on a fairly justifiable path of rage that blew through his own makeshift team before the match itself. Kai En Tai and The Blue Meanie were subject to an unprovoked dressing room hammering, as were the scrubs backing a bailing Boss Man in the match itself.
This was all to keep Show hot ahead of a pretty significant appearance fans weren't aware he'd be making in the main event later that evening.
WWE had heavily promoted the Austin/Rock/Triple H title topliner as the biggest match in company history, safe in the knowledge at least a fortnight earlier than 'The Rattlesnake' wouldn't be fit for purpose.
Selecting Big Show as a replacement and eventual winner, the decision was made to airlift him from the crew of losers he'd been booked next to in violent fashion. It was just a shame it failed so hard at actually being entertaining.
2. The Truth Commission Vs The Disciples Of Apocalypse (1997, -*1/2)
Elsewhere on this list, makeshift quartets from the Survivor Series 1997 undercard contested a desperately boring battle unbecoming of a supercard with a reputation as infamous as any wrestling show in history.
This one is even worse.
Disciples Of Apocalypse matches had passed their sell-by date approximately three weeks after the group debuted. The infinite three team punching loop between the bikers, the Nation Of Domination and Los Boricuas quickly looked like a video on repeat. The decline in quality was stark and apparent, but cards needed filling and faction guys were perfect for fleshing out house show after Stone Cold Steve Austin went on the shelf in mid-1997.
The Truth Commission were in a tier below the warring groups, but made up the numbers in similar fashion for this four-on-four affair. There was no overt malice between the groups. Quite the opposite in fact - the tacit tones of racism underpinning both groups brought them closer together than any other faction, though bigotry and nationalism were only implied rather than outwardly discussed whenever the groups appeared on television.
As he'd do in most roles, Don Callis stole the show as the ill-fitting leader of the group, but The Jackyl's early elimination forced fans to endure the horrors of another ten minutes before the soon-to-be-pushed Interrogator (Kurgan) saw out the battle for his separatist brethren.
1. The Royal Family Vs Clowns 'R Us (1994, -**1/2)
Jerry Lawler's Survivor Series 1994 ended with a custard pie dripping from his face. He was humiliated, embarrassed and alone. A victim not just of a sneak attack, but one of WWE's worst ever comedic backfires.
Often, these ideas begin with a wealth of good intentions, but even those looked hard to parse when assessing this absolute disaster. Doink's character had gone off a cliff following a late-1993 babyface turn, with Dink's arrival confining the gimmick to permanent residence amongst wrestling punchlines. And Vince McMahon's propensity for finding comedy in little peopled reared its ugly ahead almost a year later when he armed the clown with two more miniature avatars to take on Jerry Lawler and his own bullied gang.
A chicken fight sight gag that culminated in 'The King' falling flat on his face was as highbrow as the humour got. As the first man eliminated though, Doink was forced to the back whilst Lawler schemed his way to victory via abuse of the rules and other team members. The laughs beyond that point were ironically in short supply.
The mini kings and clowns conspiring to topple Jerry at the conclusion supposedly paid off his misdemeanours. WWE booked a WWE Title match to follow this atrocity to atone for their own.