10 Worst Worked Wrestling Shoots Of All Time

Exploring wrestling's uneasy relationship with the fourth wall.

Worked-shoots are an incredibly risky concept. Occasionally, if handled with care, they can inject a genuine sense of believability and tension into an otherwise bog-standard angle. Jerry Lawler's legendary feud with Andy Kaufman blurred the lines between reality and kayfabe by convincingly involving a mainstream celebrity, while the 'Summer of Punk' storyline built upon real backstage grievances and proved that worked shoots could still work in the internet age. However, with wrestling scrutinised and criticised in the same manner as any other scripted television show these days, worked shoots tend to fail more often than they succeed - often with horrendous consequences. Fans and reporters are now quick to doubt the legitimacy of a supposed shoot, meaning that even incidents such as Jeff Hardy's infamously drugged-up showing at Victory Road 2011 are treated with great suspicion. The reason for such mistrust is simple: most wrestling promotions have never quite let go of the fact that the industry secret is out, and are determined to inject some sense of authenticity back into a business which doesn't really need it anymore. Angles with realistic themes and emotions are lauded, of course, but only to a point. Once a storyline goes out of its way to break the fourth wall, the overall product can be damaged. In short, the ends of a worked shoot rarely justify the means, as we're about to find out. Here are the ten worst worked shoots in wrestling history.


10. Jeff Hardy's Car Crash

In 2009, Jeff Hardy became embroiled in an ultimately disappointing feud with brother Matt. The real-life relationship between the pair was used by the WWE to create a sense of realism, which saw heel Matt attempt to wreck Jeff's life outside of the squared circle. He rigged his brother's entrance pyro to blow up in his face, and was rumoured to be responsible for the burning down of his house. The most clumsy incident, by far, was one which came before the actual start of the feud, and was never officially tied to Matt (due to the haste with which the WWE scrapped it). Jeff and his girlfriend were reportedly involved in a hit-and-run incident in North Carolina, a news story which included fake police footage, and was quickly outed as false. The WWE failed to take into account the fact that Smackdown tapings had already aired in other timezones, meaning that the incident was announced before it was even supposed to have occurred. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rqGCgBYfDKc

9. "I Respect You, Booker-Man"

At WCW's SuperBrawl '96 Pay Per View, Brian Pillman supposedly cut a shoot interview on Kevin Sullivan before walking out of their scheduled match. The pair were supposed to square off in a "respect" match, after which the loser would be forced to admit they respected the winner. Instead, Pillman grabbed a mic and yelled "I respect you, booker-man", outing Sullivan as the promotion's real-life head booker, and was subsequently released from his contract. This was later revealed to be a complete work. Pillman then went to ECW, where WCW higher-ups hoped he would be able to sharpen his anarchic "loose cannon" gimmick before returning. The only problem was, WCW legitimately did release Brian from his contract. He went to ECW, garnered a lot of attention as a result, and was courted by the WWF. He snapped their hand off, screwing his former employees in the process.

8. John Cena Gets Stabbed

Back in 2004, John Cena was rapidly gaining popularity thanks to a well-timed babyface turn, one which would eventually see him become the all-conquering superstar we know today. One of his first feuds was against the debuting Carlito, a heel backed up by his muscular bodyguard, Jesus. With Cena set to film 'The Marine', the WWE needed an excuse to write him off television while maintaining the feud's momentum. They chose perhaps the most heavy-handed course of action possible. Cena was reportedly stabbed by Jesus in a Boston nightclub, crossing a line the wrestling business rarely treads. Wanting to cause your opponent great physical harm is fine, but actual attempted murder (especially in such a gruesome, realistic manner) is understandably frowned upon. For the record, Cena returned after a month and quickly beat Carlito for the US Championship.

7. Donald Trump Buys Raw

The planned WWE angle of summer 2009 was to have Vince McMahon "sell" Monday Night Raw to Donald Trump, a man with whom he'd feuded in the past. In this instance, the angle was convincingly made a shoot by the television network, rather than the promotion themselves. It worked out too well. One day after the announcement, the USA Network released official statements which implied that the whole storyline was legitimate. The WWE's stock dropped overnight, as investors baulked at the idea of a man with such little wrestling expertise running the show. Wisely, the angle was nixed the following week, which saw Vince simply buy back the show. Issues over the plausibility of buying a television show were conveniently ignored.

6. Mick Foley Visits The TNA Writers

The only thing worse than an overly-elaborate worked shoot is a lazy one done for the sake of it. Mick Foley's stint in TNA fortunately had little lasting damage upon his legacy, and he is still firmly regarded as an all-time WWE great, but this incident must rank as one of the lowest moments of his career. A segment written by Vince Russo (who else?) saw Foley meet the show's writers backstage. Through understandably gritted teeth, the Hardcore Legend congratulated the team on writing such a great show, and jokingly asked if they could write a segment where owner Dixie Carter returns his phone calls. Rarely has wrestling's sacred fourth wall been broken for such a pointless pay-off.

5. The Set Collapses On Vince

In an attempt to create a shocking, sympathy-inducing moment for Vince McMahon, the WWE aired a 2008 segment where part of the Monday Night Raw set fell onto the owner. Faces and heels alike rushed to free the boss from the wreckage, and EMTs were eventually on the scene to carry him away on a stretcher. Rarely has such an overly-serious segment been so mercilessly mocked by the wrestling community. The unconvincing nature of the stunt - and Vince's pained use of Triple H's real name - were the target of much derision, and many a wrestling fan will still be reduced to laughter from the phrase "Paul, I can't feel my legs".

4. Matt Hardy vs Edge

This feud could have been electric. The real-life love triangle between Matt Hardy, Lita and Edge led to Matt's release from the company, inadvertently turning him into a huge babyface. Fans clamoured for his return for weeks, chanting his name at live events and protesting endlessly on internet messageboards. Hardy's inevitable return, and the subsequent feud between the pair, was an incredibly disappointing one. Equal blame must lay at the feet of the wrestlers and the bookers. Rather than grant Hardy a big feel-good victory over his foe, the booking team tipped the balance in the heel's favour (despite the fact that fans were desperate to see Edge gain his comeuppance). Matt's handling of the situation was similarly clumsy. He cut a strangely heelish promo upon his return, stating that he wished Edge would die in a car crash, before claiming that the whole thing was a shoot on his blog. The entire feud immediately lost its credibility and, as a result, momentum.

3. Kevin Sullivan's Wife Leaves Him For Chris Benoit

While the feud between Edge and Matt Hardy was a shoot that became a limp worked angle, a similar incident between WCW's Kevin Sullivan and Chris Benoit began as a fictional storyline, but quickly spilled over into real life. The previously mentioned Kevin Sullivan booked an angle where his real-life (and onscreen) wife, Nancy "Woman" Sullivan, was found to be sleeping with Benoit. The old-school Sullivan made sure that the storyline remained believable between shows. Benoit and Nancy travelled together and made ostentatious public appearances, fuelling theories that the whole thing was actually a shoot. However, the whole thing backfired on Sullivan in a big way when Nancy and Chris actually did fall in love, ruining his marriage in the process. Every wrestling fan knows the eventual, tragic fate of Nancy in 2007, but that incident aside, the whole angle was a strange example of a worked-shoot becoming all too real. To Sullivan's credit, he continued to wrestle Benoit in a thoroughly professional manner, demonstrating almost unbelievable restraint given the circumstances surrounding their rivalry.

2. New Blood Rising

WCW's dying days were a mess of convoluted attempts to work the crowd, culminating in the pair of incidents which top this list. The slightly later incident occurred at New Blood Rising, a 2000 Pay Per View which was set to feature a "real fight" between Goldberg, Kevin Nash and Scott Steiner. Goldberg, presumably annoyed at backstage booking decisions, walked out of the match. The announcers immediately began criticising his unprofessionalism, while Nash and Steiner stood around acting confused. They then "improvised" a finish (which had, of course, all been planned beforehand), while Goldberg was later lambasted for not "following the script". Needless to say, the whole incident was received very poorly by WCW's fans - especially those in attendance, who paid to see something at least resembling a professional wrestling show. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x48phv_new-blood-rising-2000-steiner-vs-na_sport

1. Jarrett Lays Down For Hogan

New Blood Rising was unquestionably bad, but it had nothing on a worked-shoot carried out at the previous Pay Per View. Bash At The Beach 2000 saw a title match between Jeff Jarrett and Hulk Hogan descend into absolute farce, a result of head booker Vince Russo's attempts to address genuine backstage politics via the dubious medium of a worked shoot. Unlike many incidents on this list, Jarrett vs Hogan did legitimately confuse fans with regards to its legitimacy. Rather than making this a more effective example of a worked shoot, however, it merely rendered it even less decipherable than before. Jarrett, acting under the instructions of Russo, lay down and surrendered the World Heavyweight Championship to Hogan as soon as the match started. Russo then came out and lambasted Hogan for his backstage politicking, while the Hulkster blamed Russo for the state of the company. The whole thing was pre-planned, but only Hogan and Russo knew this. The announcers repeatedly insisted that the incident "wasn't part of the script", and were just as confused as everybody watching at home. Ironically, Hogan actually did take offence at Russo's promo, and later attempted to sue the head booker for defamation of character. He refused to work for WCW despite still being under contract, and the whole incident is often rightfully regarded as the prime example of a worked-shoot gone wrong - both in theory and execution. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xfotjg_hulk-hogan-vs-jeff-jarrett-bash-at-the-beach-2000_sport

Content Producer
Content Producer

Highly overrated 23 year old from the North East of England. Hanging off of your gangster car.