10 Worst WWE Booking Decisions Of 2017 (So Far)
Burials, pointless title changes, and good old James Ellsworth...
WWE is full of great wrestling at the moment. Raw and SmackDown usually deliver at least one or two quality matches every week, NXT is on the resurgence, and 205 Live is much improved from its early form. Exciting action is inevitable from such a huge, talented roster, and in-ring standards have rarely been so high.
Despite this, it's hard to shake the feeling that the company could be doing so much better. It often feels like WWE's wrestlers are performing well in spite of the bookers, not because of them, and while the promotion's top workers are among the world's most exciting, their good work is often overshadowed by shoddy decision making.
WWE's booking mechanism has rarely been as faulty as it is today. The company have created an environment with little suspense, surprise or drama, in which nobody ever gets over, and storylines rarely reach satisfying conclusions. Their work regularly leaves fans pulling their hair out, and things are as bad as ever in 2017.
The company have given us much to get excited about this year, but many more reasons to feel frustrated by their direction. Let's take a look at the decisions that have had us changing the channel...
10. Dolph Ziggler Defeats AJ Styles
Once a consensus pick for WWE’s most under-pushed worker, Dolph Ziggler’s interest levels have never been lower than they are today. ‘The Show-Off’ has been abandoned by all but his most ardent supporters, and while this is primarily down to years of bad booking, he is one of WWE’s most pointless wrestlers in 2017.
That hasn’t stopped the company persisting with him as a moderately well pushed wrestler, and Dolph has been the focus of a couple of confusing booking decisions this year. At Backlash, Ziggler was granted way too much offense in a match that was supposed to put Shinsuke Nakamura over as a star. He lost, but it was him, not Nakamura, who felt like the most important wrestler coming out of the bout, thus defeating its purpose.
Then, nine days later, Ziggler inexplicably defeated AJ Styles on an episode of SmackDown. Putting him over the brand’s franchise player made zero sense on paper or in practice, given their contrasting positions within the hierarchy, and to make matters worse, Ziggler didn’t even benefit from the win. AJ avenged his loss the following week, making it even more confounding that he was booked to lose to such lowly opposition in the first place.
9. Baron Corbin Wins Money In The Bank
Most fans suspected that Baron Corbin would walk out of Money In The Bank 2017 with the briefcase in his clutches. ‘The Lone Wolf’ was identified as a heavy favourite months in advance, and the betting odds never wavered. As a result, few were surprised when he scaled the ladder and scored the prize on 18 June, which sapped some excitement from what had been an outstanding match.
Corbin shouldn’t be a horrendous Mr. Money In The Bank. Holding the briefcase works for his opportunistic heel character, and he’s nowhere near as skill deficient as his detractors would have you believe. Still, his victory was a deeply uninspiring choice, and his presence will do little to energise SmackDown’s ailing main event picture.
Jinder Mahal and Randy Orton have shrouded the WWE Championship scene with crippling boredom. Having somebody the fans are legitimately invested in (a Sami Zayn or Shinsuke Nakamura) enter the frame could’ve at least shaken some of that away, but alas, not for the first time this year, WWE went with the least interesting option, missing the opportunity to revive SD’s main event in the process.
8. Bayley's Moment Comes Too Soon
Bayley has had a miserable time on WWE’s main roster. Her run has seen one misstep after another, and while she’s not beyond saving, her stock has never been lower than it is today.
The Alexa Bliss feud was the most damaging stage of her downward spiral, but the process started long before that. On the 13 February episode of Raw, Bayley became Women’s Champion for the first time. Her winning the gold isn’t a problem in itself, as she was once a white-hot babyface commodity with all the qualities needed to lead the division, but the circumstances were all wrong.
Bayley’s rise through NXT was a perfect story, and her eventual developmental Women’s Title victory came following a multi-year underdog struggle. WWE tried something similar on Raw, but crammed it into too short a timescale. Her big moment felt artificial as a result, and to make matters worse, her win came thanks to an assist from Sasha Banks, suggesting she couldn’t have got the job done alone.
WWE jumped the gun with Bayley’s title reign. Waiting until WrestleMania 33 and coupling it with breaking Charlotte’s long-standing PPV undefeated streak in Orlando rather than at Fastlane may not have prevented her slide, but it would’ve had a lot more impact.
7. Randy Orton Becomes WWE Champion
Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt have been at the heart of some of WWE’s worst material this year. Their union was actually relatively well booked, and gave both men a much needed sense of purpose, but things nosedived when Orton turned on his false master. The ensuing weeks presented Bray at his hokiest, and brought out some of Randy’s most insipid babyface work.
The rivalry produced two of the worst matches WWE have put on in years, with the first coming at WrestleMania 33. Bray’s WWE Championship was on the line, and as a means of striking fear into ‘The Viper’s’ cold, black heart, ‘The Eater Of Worlds’ projected roaches and maggots onto the ring apron. It didn't work: Orton was unperturbed, and defeated Wyatt shortly after.
The match was a catastrophe, and the outcome deeply unsatisfying. Bray threw everything he had at Orton, including his supernatural powers, but he was comprehensively defeated. The message coming out of it was that Wyatt was no match for Orton, even when he pulled out the biggest guns in his arsenal, and the outcome not only crushed his momentum, but doomed viewers to one of Randy’s least inspiring title runs.
6. John Cena's 16th World Title
The WWE Championship has taken an absolute pounding this year. Pointless title switches, lowly champions, and poorly written feuds have damaged its credibility to the point where it no longer feels like SmackDown’s most prestigious title. Kevin Owens’ United States Championship has overtaken it, and given the state of that belt's prestige a few months ago, that’s quite remarkable.
The slide started at the 2017 Royal Rumble, when John Cena needlessly ended AJ Styles’ tremendous title reign. The match was outstanding, and probably the main roster’s best of 2017 thus far, but while Cena’s double Attitude Adjustment finish was exciting, the outcome existed only to write his name alongside Ric Flair’s in the history books.
The win saw Cena equal ‘The Nature Boy’s’ record of 16 world titles, and John lost the belt just 14 days later, having failed to make a single successful defence. This was one of the most egregious recent examples of WWE sacrificing storytelling and their top title’s credibility for the sake of "creating a moment", and we can probably look forward to a similar situation when Cena returns, as making the record his own feels inevitable at this point.
5. Randy Orton Wins The Royal Rumble
While WWE would have you believe that anything can happen in the Royal Rumble, this is rarely the case anymore. It has been a long time since the company used the match to mint a new main eventer, and the past few years have been dogged by predictable winners and a lack of major surprises.
The Rumble remains one of the year’s most anticipated events, but it has lost much of its lustre. Still, this year’s presented one of the most star-studded lineups in years, and plenty of potentially exciting outcomes. Despite this, WWE went with the least inspiring option in the world by giving Randy Orton his second Rumble victory, and closing the pay-per-view on a bum note.
Perhaps it's wrong to expect excitement from the event after years of predictability, but ‘The Viper’s’ triumph still felt like an anticlimax. His 2016 return generated little buzz, and while he eventually faced Bray Wyatt at WrestleMania, the Rumble’s conclusion made it seem like we were heading towards a match we’ve seen dozens of time before in Orton vs. Cena.
Randy’s Rumble win wasn’t terrible, but it was extremely boring, and ultimately doomed us to the horrendous Wyatt feud.
4. Goldberg Defeats Kevin Owens
There was absolutely no need for Goldberg to become WWE Universal Champion this year. As successful as his return was, introducing gold to his feud with Brock Lesnar did nothing to enhance either man’s position in the company (as both were already among WWE’s biggest stars), and while Goldberg was drawing huge crowd reactions throughout his comeback’s first two acts, this noticeably dwindled when he became champion.
His match with Kevin Owens at Fastlane lasted just 22 seconds. KO was distracted by the arrival of his former best friend, Chris Jericho, and that allowed Bill to run right through him and secure the gold. It kept Owens protected, and brought his miserable title reign to an overdue end, but those were the only two positives to come from the situation.
Goldberg didn’t make a single title defence before taking it to WrestleMania 33, where he was defeated by Lesnar in under five minutes. His worthless reign had a detrimental effect on what had been WWE’s hottest feud up to that point, and ultimately doomed us to over a year with a part-time champion, as Brock looks set to keep hold of the Universal Title until ‘Mania 34.
3. Alexa Bliss Crushes Bayley
Alexa Bliss and Bayley should be thanking the heavens for Bray Wyatt vs. Randy Orton, because if it wasn’t for those two, their Raw Women’s Title feud would rank as the year’s worst. By the time this one-sided rivalry expired, Bliss had battered her babyface opponent into the ground on more than one occasion, and WWE now face a huge task on their hands if they’re to rebuild her.
Alexa and Bayley’s darkest hour came at Extreme Rules. They met in a Vince Russo-esque Kendo Stick On A Pole Match for Bliss’ title, with the narrative focusing on whether or not naive, timid Bayley could step up and compete in such an environment. The answer was a resounding "no", as the challenger was flattened in just over five minutes.
Bayley was humiliated that night. She tried to beat her opponent at her own game, but fell definitively short. Alexa’s pre-match assertions that Bayley couldn’t compete with her were proven correct. It was one of the year’s most deflating match results thus far, and from the company's standpoint, the only way in which it could be deemed a success is if WWE’s goal was to leave the former NXT Women’s Champion broken and humiliated.
2. Jinder Mahal Wins The WWE Championship
SmackDown’s confusing booking has been the source of much discussion this year, with Jinder Mahal’s WWE Championship win often central to the debate. ‘The Modern Day Maharaja’ went from career-long enhancement talent to WWE Champion with unparalleled quickness, and the consequences have been entirely negative.
Mahal isn’t terrible; he’s just deeply mediocre. He’s an unengaging talker with a derivative anti-USA, pro-India gimmick, and while he worked with increased aggression and intensity at Money In The Bank, he offers little excitement between the ropes. He’s a fine guy to have around in a preliminary role, but he’s not cut out to hold WWE’s supposed "top prize", regardless of the incremental improvements he has made in recent weeks.
The complete lack of build is the biggest issue. Jinder’s ascension came completely out of nowhere. One week, he was losing to Mojo Rawley in three minutes, and the next, he was number one contender. Had his coronation come at the end of a well booked journey to the top, perhaps it wouldn’t have been so heavily rejected, but the form it took resulted in the worst kind of surprising. It felt jarring rather and exciting, and SD is still reeling from it.
1. James Ellsworth Steals The Womens' Moment
Money In The Bank 2017 was supposed to be all about SmackDown’s women making history with their first ever ladder match. This message was at the heart of the show’s build, and while their bout opened the event, WWE invested a great deal of time and effort into putting it over as a huge, monumental occasion, only to tear it all down at the match’s conclusion.
A man, not a woman, was the deciding factor. James Ellsworth bundled Becky Lynch from the ladder, then scaled it himself. He retrieved the briefcase and tossed it down to Carmella, who, after some deliberation from the officials, was declared the victor.
It was one of the most harebrained things WWE have done all year. In snatching this “historic moment” away from the women, they only put heat on themselves, not Carmella and Ellsworth. SmackDown General Manager Daniel Bryan reversed the decision two nights later, but the rematch can’t possibly undo the damage done.
This booking decision sent all the wrong messages on what should’ve been a landmark night for women’s wrestling, and for a company whose entire storytelling mechanism is based around creating memorable moments, WWE did a great job of running away from one at MITB.