10 Worst WWE Gimmicks Of 2017
Sons of Apathy.
2016 was difficult to beat in the brainless gimmicks department.
It was the year in which WWE attempted to make the never-great Darren Young 'Great Again' with the assistance of demented life coach Bob Backlund, some mystifying, wooden vignettes, and a massively halfhearted push. Those vignettes were incredibly weird; Backlund raged against smart phone technology, for some reason, and note-taking. Backlund also instructed Young to "cut way down on the shopping" and to "walk briskly," instead of running, unless maybe he missed a bus. This was avant garde Adult Swim anti-comedy of the weirdest order, though unintentionally so. The whole thing was probably designed to make fun of Backlund's latter-day insanity, a joke that wore thin during the Attitude Era.
2016 also heralded the arrival of the Shining Stars - Puerto Rican time share salesmen! - who tried to sell time shares backstage in thoroughly baffling segments. David Lynch at his most insane was more comprehensible than this.
This was sh*t-thrown-at-walls stuff for the deadest of undercard acts.
2017, somehow, was worse - in that performers with genuine star potential were subjected to stuff as bad...
10. "Face Of America" Kevin Owens
The newly shaven, suited-and-booted Kevin Owens, having wrested the United States Championship from Chris Jericho, fancied himself as 'The New Face of America' in the springtime. The Hart Foundation circa 1997, it was not. Well, it might have been. It was quickly shelved in early summer when it became apparent how needless it was.
The idea - if you can stretch to that descriptor, given that it was hardly inventive - wasn't just derivative of wrestling's passé past. It was also derivative of its present; Owens was one of three anti-American heels on the one SmackDown brand, alongside Jinder Mahal and Rusev. Astonishingly, given Rusev's used toy status and Mahal's general being, Owens was the one ordered to drop the act.
It wasn't terrible - it was just completely beneath a performer of his creativity. His discomforting passive aggressive behaviour towards Michael Cole was far more effective in conveying him as complete a*sehole. The subversion of John Cena's U.S. Open Challenge was a neat touch, given how well-remembered the original was - but alas, we never bore witness to the conclusion of the arc.
He was probably pencilled in to job to Cena, actually, so every cloud.
9. "Wily Old Veteran" Dolph Ziggler
Yet another retread over on the SmackDown brand, which stuttered badly this year, Dolph Ziggler's arc as the main roster gatekeeper proved woefully ineffective - and borrowed wholesale from John Cena's latter-day "You need to go through me!" bit.
A victory over John Cena means something, at least. Kevin Owens arrived as a major player by virtue of beating John Cena precisely because Cena was majorly credible. Dolph Ziggler, serial loser and disappointment, possessed nothing in the way of credibility - in storylines, nor among the wrestling fandom, a huge portion of which felt he had been surpassed by the next generation of talent.
His series with Shinsuke Nakamura did little for the rechristened 'Artist', whose weird, conflated Prince update on his Michael Jackson bit warrants a dishonourable mention. The matches suffered because Ziggler's over-the-top domination was as hard to believe as it was hard to muster much enthusiasm for. WWE, presumably, didn't go the exciting back-and-forth route for fear of telegraphing the outcome. It was already telegraphed. As a result of the layout, it was also boring.
Blue brand creative didn't even bother to have Ziggler go over the one man who gets over by narrowly losing - Tye Dillinger - before returning to the dry well upon Bobby Roode's inglorious promotion.
8. "Christ, Not Him Again" Kane
Kane, over the span of his 20 year career, has alienated all but the rose-tinted Attitude Era apologists through acting as the Authority's primary inducer of blue balls, devolving into an often unfunny comedy act, and generally receiving pitiful, grim and repetitive booking treatment from creative.
And yet, in 2017, we are expected to buy him as a threat after the most transparent, antagonising mini-push seen since, well, Jinder Mahal. And look how that worked out. Dispatched to bury Finn Bálor all the way to hell a mere 24 hours after he contested a WWE Match Of The Year candidate opposite AJ Styles, the decision made not a lick of sense in both storylines, reality, and the long-term future of the company WWE seems to give not a toss about.
He'd just defeated the consensus best wrestler in the company at TLC, finally appearing as a threat to Brock Lesnar after months of foreshadowing the Royal Rumble match - in parallel with months of brutally bad Bray Wyatt business. Enter Kane: with one birdbrained burial, Bálor might as well have joined Bo Dallas on the lowest rung of the ladder.
The irony is that all of this was ultimately designed to build Braun Strowman back up as a threat, following his loss to Brock Lesnar at No Mercy - and the Monster Among Men has cooled down considerably.
7. "The Opposite Of Good" Bludgeon Brothers
How do you solve a problem like Luke Harper and Erick Rowan? Just throw them in any old bloody tag team.
WWE almost messed up the most rhetorical question in its recent history.
We first bore witness to the Bludgeon Brothers in a pre-filmed vignette, in which their backs were turned to the audience. They almost bumped into each other turning around, which was the first of several troubling omens. The second was the gigantic toy mallets draped over their shoulders. The third was the Ascension-level lexicon. Severed spines! Annihilation! Moral decay! Suffering! Misery! Anguish! Pain! Thesauruses!
No cage could contain them. What were they: Alex Riley?
The fourth was the setting of the next crop of vignettes; they were filmed in the woods, as if this was all B-roll footage from the Wyatt Family vids of 2013. It was opposite day in dem old woods; down was up, up was down. Dark was light, light was dark. They weren't over; they were filed under "laughable".
The Brothers Bludgeon have translated well enough to television thus far - probably because it's hard to botch a powerhouse tag act featuring a talent as well-received as Harper - but they didn't half try.
6. "Mirror Man" Shane McMahon
Shane McMahon is a superhero with the ability of power absorption.
He can trade blows with the Undertaker, the marketed "best pure striker in WWE history". He can go toe to toe against the best pure wrestler in the company, AJ Styles, trapping him in sudden submissions like he's f*cking KUSHIDA. He can take Kevin Owens to the limit in a battleground befitting his opponent's barbarism.
"Mirror Man" Shane McMahon is hard to buy, and even harder to stomach. The former no-guts-no-glory underdog of old is unrecognisable; his role as SmackDown sole survivor illustrated that, yes, he actually is the hardest man on the roster. He never wins - that would represent a step too far, even for McMahon megalomania - but the message is insidiously clear. It's not even satire to suggest that, should Shane square off against Shinsuke Nakamura at WrestleMania 34, he'd kick him as hard.
The guy is a sweaty, 47 year-old part-time act. It's a disgrace to fiction.
At least, if the teased Triple H 'Mania match happens, he can mirror his 25 minute methodical special, and we'll know precisely when to take a break from the seven hour endurance test.
5. "The Greatest [At Being...In Love?]" Mike Kanellis
There's a decent act on paper here. Or was.
There's something sickening about a sap in love - and while Mike Kanellis' googly-eyed admiration of wife Maria wasn't quite the stomach-churning stuff of a sofa-jumping Tom Cruise, there was much scope for a suitably irritating midcard heel in the summer months. Their entrance theme was a cloying, overblown ear worm, and the choice decision to have Mike take his wife's surname was sure to trigger the anti-SJW pocket of the fandom.
That trigger was never pulled; Kanellis was removed from television almost as soon as he debuted, which confirmed to the audience that he was not worth the investment. The heat generated from Maria's interference was also doused; Mike went full 50/50 booking via pointless, almost parodic win-trading with Sami Zayn in his debut programme. It was astonishing, even by WWE standards: this act was chosen to bypass NXT?
It later emerged that Mike was struggling with a painkiller addiction, which might explain his free fall - but Maria's decision to fall pregnant so soon into the run indicted her faith in WWE's ability to restore the act.
4. "They Think It's All Over...It Is Now" Bray Wyatt
2017 was the year in which Bray Wyatt was officially demoted from "great lost hope" to "irredeemable joke".
It all started so well, too: there was something to his partnership with Randy Orton, lightning eyes and all - at least until it emerged that the entire programme was a plot hole-ridden retcon Randy conceived as vengeance for a routine backstage attack. Their WrestleMania WWE Championship bout was nonsensical - hollow supernatural spectacle designed to wrench from it a "WrestleMania Moment". To confirm it as contrived, Wyatt's projected bugs bit didn't do anything; he walked into an RKO after 10 turgid minutes.
The House Of Horrors rematch created crater-sized plot holes and yielded nought but derisive laughter. Wyatt crammed Orton under a refrigerator in that silly, silly match, which was very mundane for a so-called supernatural force. The mundanity did not end there; the "viscous, acidic liquid" summer blood bath spewed forth from a bucket. Any mere mortal could have done that, and that's precisely what Wyatt became in 2017: a complete charlatan masquerading as a boogeyman.
The Sister Abigail debut was so laughably bad that a serious illness must have been received by Bray with the euphoria of an orgasm.
3. "Prodigal Son" Jason Jordan
The abject failure of Jason Jordan, Kurt Angle's babyface son, isn't strictly the result of its biological impossibility. EC3 got over under similarly phoney pretences as the "nephew" of Dixie Carter because he played the entitled brat with a sense of credibility. On this week's RAW, we even bought WOKEN Matt Hardy's proclamation that he'd fought on battlefields alongside "Genghis Khan!" because it was so bloody entertaining.
No, Jordan failed in the face role because he was depicted, literally, at face value. If Jordan was immediately presented as a spoiled brat, leveraging his bloodline to stroll into marquee matches and cry his way out of genuine competition, the act may have caught on; as the absolute state of Stephanie McMahon suggests, undue favouritism is repellent. But no: Jason Jordan, actual babyface, was the initial blueprint. Hero worship of the father is the stuff of the playground, and thus the earnest, dry, blue chipper Jordan was not the apple of the Universe's eye.
Lines such as "You're the expert in getting boos, Miz!" punched the gut of those lamenting the lameness of WWE babyfaces, and with no winks in our direction, the character was as directionless as he was unanimously rejected.
2. "Unhindered" Jinder Mahal
Everything about 2017 vintage Jinder Mahal screamed "midcard!"
1991 midcard.
Which made his reign as WWE Heavyweight Champion - in 2017, a year defined by absurdly brilliant wrestling - that much more mystifying. Tedious, limited and repetitive in the ring, Mahal's title win at Chicago's Backlash was notable for its novelty heat - but elsewhere, the returns were as diminished as they were derivative. Virtually every marquee Mahal match ended with the interference of the Singh Brothers, which, if nothing else, deftly underscored the profound lack of imagination that led us to this point. The Singh Brothers were never deterred from this constant interference, proving that nothing matters - which, again, deftly underscored why Vince McMahon was allowed to go on with this farce for as long as he was: with no genuine competition opposing him, he can do as he pleases.
Mercifully, the mass rejection of the embryonic Survivor Series moved him from his slumber.
McMahon loves bellowing, alliteration, foreign heels, and bodybuilder physiques. The grotesquely-veined, cheap racial-baiting Modern Day MahaRAJA was his ugliest vision of sports entertainment, manifested.
1. "I Don't Want To Hurt Anybody" Bayley
Why become a f*cking pro wrestler, then?
After refusing to partake in a baffling and boring Kendo Stick On A Pole match opposite Alexa Bliss at Extreme Rules, Bayley offered a brain-melting explanation. She didn't want to use violence to make a name for herself - even though it was entirely within her remit. She wanted to succeed on her own terms as a pure wrestler, which compromised her entire persona of a sports entertainment superfan. Bayley, who grew up idolising violent TLC stunt shows and barbaric Hell In A Cell wars with a drive to become an elite sports entertainer, somehow never realised that she might have to use the weapons seen in one in every ten (at least) WWE matches.
It's not as if Bayley was a superfan of New Japan Pro Wrestling, or Ring of Honor. She loved WWE, back welts and all.
This gimmick not only cast her as a sap - she was antagonised into using weaponry and still didn't use it, misremembering also the classic turnabout-is-fair-play WWE trope - it was inflicted on her as a springboard for a boyfriend angle with Corey Graves. It never materialised.
So it was senseless and pointless.