10 Worst WWE Matches Of 2018
Worst Wrestling Entertainment.
There's always the temptation during end-of-year reflection to ignore deep-dives in favour of recency and/or beliefs that were held regardless of the actual content. Wrestling fans - your writer included - are relentlessly guilty of both. Your favourite wrestler shouldn't be afforded a free pass for assembling something wretched. Just as Something from last week hasn't had to linger as long in the memory like something from last month, but we apply these biases because WWE won't do it for us.
No longer are mistakes or missteps covered up. They are dwelled and built upon. No longer are fans allowed to reminisce about a character's back story. It is compromised and contradicted too often.
Revisiting the best (and in the case of this list, the absolute worst) of the year has never been more useful. Wrestling is moving at a faster pace than it did during the pomp of the Attitude Era, even at Raw's glacial worst. The rules and rosters are constantly changing, even if Vince McMahon inexplicably remains at the forefront to oversee it all. This juxtaposition is the most contradictory of all, and provides a big picture rationale for why so many of the following fights failed so frightfully...
10. Brock Lesnar Vs Roman Reigns (WrestleMania 34)
There was something depressingly familiar about Brock Lesnar's WrestleMania 34 victory over Roman Reigns.
Worst of all, it mattered not what either men did anyway. The boos, beachballs and boredom buried within the audience became the brutal truth of the issue between the two, rather than the kayfabe one the company had limply tried to establish. And what an utterly f*cking absurd story it was.
After a year of beating everybody - everybody - with a single F5, Lesnar delivered so many to 'The Big Dog' that finishing moves as a concept began to lose meaning. Designed around triggering the biggest reactions from crowds and teasing conclusions, the F5s failed at both. Over, and over and over again.
The two weren't doing anything outwardly bad, but the New Orleans faithful let their emotions flow like Roman's wasted blood. His claret only made them blue, meaning they missed Lesnar's actual victory. Of course they did - they weren't really looking for it. One had to wonder how Roman felt as Lesnar dragged a jagged arm across his head for the instructed gash. Especially when no comeback of significance was permitted before the winning fall. Stone Cold Steve Austin at WrestleMania 13, this - unsurprisingly - was not.
9. Carmella Vs Asuka (Money In The Bank)
It'd be too easy to rule out James Ellsworth's return here as catastrophic considering the controversy that engulfed him later in the year - he was at the time a useful component in the company's attempt to get Carmella over-the-top as some kind of a credible champion in division full of already-credible contenders.
His reintroduction could and should have helped 'The Princess Of Staten Island', but like Charlotte at WrestleMania before her, this match was less about the winner and more to do with the desperate decline of the loser.
Asuka's 'Show Of Shows' defeat against Charlotte Flair was divisive, but those in defence of the decision were on hand with the usual three-line whip; "Let the storyline play out and see where it goes", "All undefeated streaks have to come to an end", "She can now develop more as a character for the loss". Bullsh*t. Bullsh*t. Bullsh*t.
WWE is not that company anymore. WWE are the company where what happened yesterday doesn't matter today - not to those inside the walls anyway. Fans still care, and WWE used to adhere to such trivialities as audience emotion and investment. . In old money, WWE would adhere to such principles. Money In The Bank was the cold reality of Asuka plight, and things haven't really heated back up for her since.
8. The Revival Vs Gallows & Anderson (Raw 25)
2018 is ending exactly as it started for The Revival. The act - once so revered for their doubles mechanics that they were literally named as such - has been left to drown on a main roster tag division with little time for little men and their little moves, but the sheer pig-headedness surrounding their Raw 25 squash takes the medal for their dirt-worst match in place of countless other dreadful Monday Night moments that defined their year.
Jobbed out to Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson in order to get to real stars D-Generation-X syphoning the last remnants of Finn Bálor's heat, Dash Wilder and Scott Dawson weren't sacrificial lambs so much as piles of sheepsh*t the faces accidentally trod in en route to stamping out any mention of them on the celebratory supershow.
Of course, this was par for the course for Triple H, Shawn Michaels et al. DX obliterated any and everybody in their path back when Raw was a show actually worth paying lip service to, but WWE's model is now so broken that any pathetic attempt at a rebuild for the lukewarm rookies would have failed - had WWE even tried. Dawson and Wilder have continued jobbing ever since, failing to turn this high profile loss into a WrestleMania programme before propping up loser groups like The B-Team and Lucha House Party in the aftermath.
7. Jeff Hardy Vs Jinder Mahal (Greatest Royal Rumble)
WWE have made bang-average wrestling their currency in 2018. So much so in fact, that contests have to be critically calamitous - as is the case with the other nine shambolic sh*tshows within this list - or loaded with a botch so brutal it becomes the story not just of the match but the night itself.
Jinder Mahal can thank himself lucky that Titus O'Neil can't put one foot in front of the other.
Greatest Royal Rumble was the night of the "Worldsliiiiide" - the former Prime Time Player hitting the deck was enough of banter gif for WWE to make it themselves and save other social media accounts a bit of time. It gave Jinder Mahal the perfect escape hatch for the criminal bump he took from a completely missed Whisper In The Wind against United States Champion Jeff Hardy.
From a newcomer, greenhorn or rookie, this would have been an acceptable situation for a performer caught in panic. Jinder Mahal waived those rights when he welcomed his unearned WWE Championship reign a year earlier. 'The Modern Day Maharaja' lived by the sword that cut through many of his preferred peers then, and has died by the same one ever since.
6. Roman Reigns Vs Braun Strowman (Hell In A Cell)
The worst match of the night on one of the company's best shows of the year, Roman Reigns and Braun Strowman's Hell In A Cell headliner reflected the dim and grim futures of two potential stars broken by Brock Lesnar's brutal Universal Title dominance. His disruption of the dire clash - to earn megabucks in a Saudi Arabian rematch - was a rather fitting conclusion.
Before both failing - repeatedly - to wrestle the prize from 'The Conqueror', 'The Big Dog' and 'The Monster Among Men' were known for their hard-hitting stunt-filled main events. These neutered and altered beasts had lost their fans, their fire and their mojo to such a degree that the cartoonish red cell looked more intimidating to guest referee Mick Foley than anything they threw at each other during the laboured 24-minute clash.
It was one thing for Roman Reigns to be 'The Guy' according to Vince McMahon, but it was quite another for the fans to have their Guy taken away in yet another flawed effort to facilitate it. Strowman's heel turn has already been chalked from history, but - like all tragedies in the past - won't be forgotten by those that lived through it.
5. AJ Styles Vs Shinsuke Nakamura (Backlash)
Live not in hope, but of fear that WWE one day signs The Elite.
Ignoring the superb timing of the double d*ck kick that reduced a tragi-comedy to pure farce, the third of five deeply disappointing WWE encounters between AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura was the worst of the bunch because of how laboured the focus was on each man's targeted todger.
Styles should have known better, of course. 'The King Of Strong Style' had been relentless in his assaults on AJ's assets since his WrestleMania heel turn, and whilst Shinsuke performed his new duties with a certain style, there was an unshakeable air of awkward disappointment about the entire angle as a result.
Why didn't Nakamura just try and outwrestle him as he'd done once in New Japan Pro Wrestling and nearly did again at the 'Show Of Shows'? Upon turning to the dark side, why didn't up the viciousness of the weapons already at his disposal instead of trading said sick kicks for under-cracker uppercuts? And why - why the f*cking f*ck - did AJ Styles never ever even once wear a cup?
Backlash was an upsettingly poor card (more on that later), but this dreary and dire duel was the contest that proffered the grisly reality that any dynamic performers can have their balls cut off - or fist-flattened - by WWE.
4. Braun Strowman Vs Kevin Owens (Extreme Rules)
Kevin Owens was victorious once on pay-per-view in 2018 before a mid-year injury gave his character the escape from television it so desperately needed after years of wilful neglect.
A parody of a nickname it may now be, but 'The Prizefighter' was Universal Champion as recently as February 2017, and won a pay-per-view main event against a McMahon in October of the same year. His 2018 plunge was as figurative as it was literal - even his lone 'win' came as a result of an almighty forgotten fall.
The match was a terrible tale told terribly. Owens got his sh*t in immediately as the bell rang, before getting sh*t on en route to the most pyrrhic victory of the year. Even when he had the advantage, he was disabled by his own stupidity or too embittered to do the one thing required and leave the cage. There'd have been some sympathy for the abuse victim - and that's what Owens was - finally having control over his oppressor if the roles had been correctly assigned. Instead, Braun the babyface ripped away his handcuffs to return to brutalising 'KO' as vindication before the giant match-ending bump.
The mechanisms were knackered. The mechanisms are knackered. Braun Strowman is knackered. Kevin Owens was probably never more relieved to be knackered.
3. Roman Reigns Vs Samoa Joe (Backlash)
Fans headed for the exits early as Roman Reigns and Samoa Joe chinlocked their way to one of the most disappointing pay-per-view main events of the year, but was the abysmal assembling down to the men between the ropes or the ones pulling the strings from the relative safety of the backstage area.
Reigns was a Vince McMahon project in such an overt fashion it ruined him for the audience, but going to bat for 'The Big Dog' was presumably an easy win for the "glad-handed Yes Men" CM Punk alluded to when he dropped a pipe bomb years earlier. It's easy to see how Roman Reigns ended up in another pay-per-view main event just a month after WrestleMania's disastrous one, and the topline spot was the least Samoa Joe deserved. But the walk-out reflected a breaking point for New Jersey fans that had literally had enough.
They'd had enough WWE - it had been a week since Greatest Royal Rumble and four since WrestleMania. They'd had enough Roman Reigns - the 'Big Dog' was a two-time loser against Lesnar and wasn't exactly wrestling here like his career depended on it. They'd had enough Backlash - the show was the worst pay-per-view of 2018 and foreshadowed a post-'Mania slump unlike any in recent memory.
Beating the traffic meant so much more than witnessing Roman Reigns beat Samoa Joe. The core value of wrestling as a form of entertainment had never been lower.
2. The Brothers Of Destruction Vs D-Generation-X (Crown Jewel)
Four men allegedly earned a lot of money to work one night in Saudi Arabia at Crown Jewel, but the resultant "effort" was proof when zero was needed about how great riches corrupt.
The one man that helped a bonafide rookie assemble a bonafide masterpiece this year sustained a brutal injury in the first few minutes. The one man who used to get by on aura alone continued to strip himself of it. The one man who'd perhaps been retired too long to just snap back into it had been retired too long to just snap back into it. The one man who only needed to keep his f*cking mask and wig in place failed to tighten the f*cking straps.
These were not the quartet that left a blood-soaked Cell in 1997 having crafted one of the greatest moments in the history of the industry, nor even the three than ended an era in a WrestleMania this decade. These were tired and tragic versions, doing something resembling their best to try and recapture what made them such a draw to the Saudi Arabia Sports Authority in the first place.
They only just managed to avoid wrestling the worst match of the entire year. Well, two of them did...
1. The Undertaker Vs Triple H (Super Show-Down)
A devastating tribute to the wrestlers they used to be, Triple H and The Undertaker's Super Show-Down main event might have provided a brand new decades-old spectacle for the live-starved Australian audience, but the glacial catastrophe served as a harrowing foreshadowing of the only-marginally-better doubles effort the following month.
Watching along on the WWE Network, the high spots were in fact the lowest moments, as the pair dove into the archives to provide inferior replications of some of their finest hours. 'The Deadman' had the same slackened jaw from his WrestleMania 25 with Shawn Michaels when Hunter kicked out of the tombstone, but he was grasping at straws rather gasping for breath. Undertaker decked referees as he was prone to doing when he feuded with the original version of D-Generation-X 21 years ago. The pair even fought through the crowd as they did at WrestleMania X7 - though this match was as inferior a comparison to that spirited brawl as the Melbourne Cricket Ground lawn furniture was to the priceless padded chairs from the Houston Astrodome.
Predictably, the finish borrowed from their storied past with equal inelegance. A WrestleMania 28 near-fall between the three served as the actual fall for this encounter, but Triple H's tears felt as phoney as the intentionally-faked friendship offered by The Brothers Of Destruction after the match.
The "This Is Awesome" chants didn't exist when the pair actually warranted them, but the generosity only added further tragedy to the comedy that was this woeful war. In an effort to promote the aforementioned Saudi Arabian sh*tshow, WWE shamelessly delivered something as ponderous as the WCW meanderfests they once derided. Triple H isn't 'The Game' anymore, but at least he contributed to the best match of the year too. Regrettably, The Undertaker continues to just play at being a wrestler - the saddest end to one of the greatest ever careers.