10 Worst WWE Pay-Per-Views Of The Ruthless Aggression Era

From No Mercy 2004 to Unforgiven 2007, there were some total turkeys in the mid-2000s.

Eddie Guerrero JBL
WWE.com

WWE's Ruthless Aggression Era was a time period that stemmed loosely from 2002-2008. The idea behind the change in direction from WWE was that following the end of the Attitude Era and the acquirement of WCW, WWE needed to adjust for the future of their programming.

This reset wasn't just because of the introduction of numerous WCW talents throughout 2001 and 2002. It was also because of the fact that in 2003, WWE's two top stars - Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock - were virtually retired. This meant that WWE had to drastically make stars that could generate revenue and be in a position to carry the company into the immediate future.

RAW and SmackDown would then become two separate entities and WWE prioritised the aim of making stars. One of the things this brand split introduced was the idea of brand-exclusive PPV events. This means that each month, one brand would host that month's PPV event.

The Ruthless Aggression Era was well known for top quality in-ring work. This in-ring resulted in some of the best PPV events of all time. On the flip side, there were indeed some unfortunate stinkers in the mix. Despite the number of good PPVs during this era outnumbering the number of lacklustre PPVs, it sadly doesn't take away from the fact that some of the PPVs in the forthcoming list being some of the worst WWE events of all time.

Here are the top 10 worst WWE PPVs of the Ruthless Aggression Era.

10. No Mercy 2006

No Mercy 2006
WWE

The first PPV on the list highlights some of the issues with brand-exclusive PPV events. No Mercy 2006 was a PPV that took place in the middle of the World Title reign of King Booker. The World Title reign of Booker was most well known for the comedic segments and Booker's fake English accent. Sadly, the majority of the matches during his reign were underwhelming at best.

The main event of the PPV featured Booker defending his World Title against Batista, Finlay and Bobby Lashley. The problem with the fatal-four-way was that Batista was the only one who had a chance of taking the title from Booker. Finlay was nothing more than a mid-carder and Lashley was yet to put it all together to be a top star in WWE. This meant that the match felt kind of flat and didn't really feel like it belonged in a PPV main event slot.

Elsewhere on the show, Chris Benoit and William Regal had the match of the night which shouldn't come as a surprise. Sadly, it wasn't even announced prior and was added as a "PPV surprise". Rey Mysterio would defeat Chavo Guerrero in a Falls Count Anywhere match in another good contest.

The PPV was unfortunately full of filler matches that either served no purpose or served to further a storyline for a later date. Matt Hardy would face Gregory Helms in the opening match. MVP would defeat Marty Garner in his PPV debut. Mr Kennedy would defeat the legendary Undertaker by DQ in a finish that received audible groans from the 9,000 WWE fans in attendance.


9. Royal Rumble 2006

Mark Henry Kurt Angle Royal Rumble 2006
WWE

Royal Rumble 2006 was one of the worst booked Rumble PPVs of all time. To this very day, what WWE was thinking with the booking decisions on this show is still a big question.

The Rumble itself took place in the middle of the show. This meant the match and the eventual winner Rey Mysterio looked like a complete afterthought. This would be the first time that the Rumble match hadn't the main evented the PPV since 1998.

The WWE Title would be decided between Edge and John Cena on the show. Edge would then proceed to lose the WWE Title to Cena after only holding it for two weeks. The main event of the show was a terrible World Title match between Kurt Angle and Mark Henry. It was arguably one of the worst matches of Angle's career and only served to set up Angle vs. The Undertaker at the following PPV.

Other matches on the show included JBL vs. The Boogeyman and Mickie James vs. Ashley. Neither of which were PPV quality and neither of which added anything of substance to the uninspired and flat show.


8. SummerSlam 2007

SummerSlam 2007 Umaga Mr Kennedy Carlito
WWE.com

SummerSlam 2007 marketed two things for the show. One was the return of Triple H to in-ring competition and the other was the first 1 vs. 1 match on PPV between Randy Orton and John Cena.

The latter of the two was the only highlight of one of the worst SummerSlam PPVs ever. The WWE Title match between Orton and Cena was a great match, which was arguably one of their better matches together in their extended feud. Triple H, on the other hand, would return to face King Booker, in one of Booker's last matches in WWE. The match was nothing special and just was a marketing ploy to make Triple H's return to WWE seem like a huge deal.

The rest of the card was extremely poor. Batista and The Great Khali had one of the worst SummerSlam matches ever which ended in a DQ. Umaga defended the Intercontinental Title against Carlito and Mr Kennedy, both of whom were heels, which in turn made the match extremely awkward and fans had no idea who they were supposed to be cheering for.

Elsewhere on the card, Rey Mysterio also returned to in-ring competition to face Chavo Guerrero in a re-match from the prior year's edition of the event. The rest of the card was filled out with TV level matches with the likes of Kane vs. Finlay and a Divas battle royal offering nothing to warrant a place on a big-four PPV.


7. No Mercy 2004

WWE No Mercy 2004 JBL
WWE.com

By the time No Mercy 2004 took place, the SmackDown World Title scene looked extremely different than the year prior. Long gone were the days of classic matches between Kurt Angle and Brock Lesnar. The former Bradshaw had transitioned into SmackDown's top heel and had become JBL. JBL had a great character and exceptional promo work. The former Tag Champion went from one half of the APA to being WWE Champion in the space of four months. It was hard for WWE fans to get on board with and take JBL seriously as a legitimate main event talent.

One of the more infamous feuds of JBL's WWE Title run was with The Undertaker. The two would have numerous PPV matches and one of the worst was the main event of the aforementioned show. The two would have a Last Ride match, the purpose of the match would be to put your opponent in the back of a hearse. The match was extremely messy and uninspiring.

The rest of the match card prominently featured matches you would find on a random episode on SmackDown, just presented on a PPV card. Matches such as Spike Dudley vs Nunzio, Eddie Guerrero vs Luther Reigns and Paul London vs Billy Gunn all made fans question the existence of the PPV event.


6. Unforgiven 2007

Undertaker Unforgiven 2007
WWE.com

The entire marketing for the Unforgiven 2007 PPV centred around the in-ring return of The Undertaker. The Undertaker would face Mark Henry as Undertaker would seek revenge for Henry costing him the World Title months prior. The match between the two would main event the PPV, which unfortunately didn't exactly light the world on fire. The matches between the two men were usually poor so WWE marketing this as the sole reason to buy the PPV did little to generate fan interest.

The rest of the card was equally as underwhelming. John Cena and Randy Orton would continue their WWE Title feud, sadly their match would end in six minutes after a DQ finish. The PPV highlight was The Great Khali's horrendous World Title reign finally coming to an end. Batista won a triple threat match which also consisted of Rey Mysterio, in a short eight-minute match.

Other matches on the card included Triple H vs Carlito and CM Punk vs Elijah Burke, both of delivered TV quality matches. The PPV took place during a time period where brand exclusive PPVs had been discontinued. Therefore, WWE orchestrating a PPV as terrible as this with all the talent they had available was extremely disappointing.


5. The Great American Bash 2005

JBL Great American Bash 2005
WWE.com

The Great American Bash 2005 marked the first PPV event after WWE decided to switch Batista and John Cena on their respective shows. With Batista now on the blue brand, his first feud would against the top heel on the brand, JBL. The pairing would be an absolute disaster as the two would go on to have some extremely poor matches. The worst of their series of the matches took place on this faithful night.

Other matches included The Undertaker vs Muhammed Hassan. This would act as the final appearance of the Hassan character, this was due to an extremely controversial segment that aired weeks prior. The majority of the rest of the card was full of lazy filler. Matches such as Torrie Wilson vs Melina and The Mexicools vs The Blue World Order had zero place on a PPV card and made fans question their purpose.

The PPV did have a highlight, however. A match between Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero was another classic between the two legendary talents. Unfortunately, it wasn't enough to save this PPV from being one of the worst PPV events of 2005.


4. Vengeance 2006

Spirit Squad DX Vengeance 2006
wwe

Vengeance 2006 suffered greatly because it was placed two weeks after ECW One Night Stand. This meant that the RAW brand had to build an entire card in the space of two-weeks and unfortunately it showed.

The main event featured the returning DX facing the entire Spirit Squad in a handicap match. Whilst the match had some comedic moments, it had no place in the main event slot of a PPV. The first and only PPV match of the WWE Title reign of RVD would be placed in the middle of the card, which spoke volumes as to the perception of him as WWE Champion at the time.

Other underwhelming matches included Kane vs Kane, which was so poorly received that the storyline would be dropped 24 hours later on RAW. Umaga would face Eugune and Ric Flair would face Mick Foley in a 2-out-of-3-falls match. Both of which had different purposes on the show, but fan intrigue in both certainly wasn't to the degree WWE wanted.

The PPV did have one highlight. Kurt Angle's last ever WWE PPV match for over ten-years took place. He would face Randy Orton in the opening match in the best match of the show by leaps and bounds.


3. Judgment Day 2006

Rey Mysterio Jbl Judgment Day 2006
WWE.com

The 2006 World Title reign of Rey Mysterio was one of the most poorly booked World Title reigns of all time. Rey was never presented as a credible World Champion and his first PPV with the title was true testament to this. Rey would face JBL in the main event of the PPV. Sadly - it was presented as if Rey didn't have a chance to retain the title and was guaranteed to lose. The finish involved Rey drop kicking a chair into JBL's face and then followed it up by a 619 to win the match. The issue was that Rey had to cheat to win, meaning it didn't remotely present him as a credibly in any way shape or form.

The rest of the card was equally as poor. The Great Khali made his PPV debut defeating The Undertaker in one of The Undertaker's worst-ever matches. Mark Henry defeated Kurt Angle by count-out in yet another lacklustre affair between the two.

The undercard featured matches such as Jillian Hall vs Melina, Gregory Helms vs Super Crazy and Booker T vs Bobby Lashley. The 2006 edition of Judgment Day was truly one of the worst brand exclusive PPVs of all time and it would be the last ever brand exclusive Judgment Day in WWE history.


2. The Great American Bash 2004

Mordecai Hardcore Holly Great American Bash 2004
WWE.com

The Great American Bash 2004 wasn't just one of the worst PPV events of the Ruthless Aggression Era, it was truly one of the worst WWE PPVs of all time. The main event of the show featured The Undertaker v The Dudley Boyz in a Handicap Concrete Crypt match. If The Undertaker won he would be able to free Paul Bearer from the crypt placed at the top of the stage; however, if The Undertaker lost, Bearer would be trapped in concrete in a glass crypt. The match was terrible as The Undertaker and The Dudley Boyz had no chemistry. The finish of the match involved The Undertaker winning and then deciding to fill the crypt with concrete, killing off his manager in the process. This rendered the storyline and the match as a complete waste of everyone's time.

The undercard of the PPV featured some of the worst PPV matches of all time. Matches such as Luther Reigns v Charlie Haas, Mordecai v Scotty 2 Hotty and Torrie Wilson v Sable were all Velocity level at best.

The first and only WWE Title reign of the legendary Eddie Guerrero would also come to an end at the PPV. Eddie would lose the WWE Title to JBL in a Texas Bullrope match. Unfortunately, following this PPV the SmackDown product would drastically take a downward turn.


1. December To Dismember 2006

Paul Heyman December to Dismember Facepalm
WWE

The December to Dismember 2006 PPV is without question one of the worst wrestling PPVs of all time. A PPV that is infamous for all the wrong reasons, and has become synonymous for everything wrong with this time period in WWE.

Going into the show, only two matches were announced prior. The Extreme Elimination Chamber match for the ECW Title and The Hardy Boyz v MnM. The ECW Title match booking would ultimately lead to the WWE departure of Paul Heyman after he was virtually blamed for the failure of the event. The match itself featured Bobby Lashley winning the ECW Title. This despite the crowd, Heyman and the then-ECW Champion The Big Show all wanting CM Punk to win the match. Even before the match began, it was doomed to fail. WWE decided to take out Sabu and place Hardcore Holly in the match instead, showing just how out of touch their idea of an ECW PPV truly was.

The undercard of the event was put together on the day of the PPV which unfortunately led to some incredibly poor matches being on the card. Matches such as Balls Mahoney v Matt Striker, Davari v Tommy Dreamer and Ariel and Kevin Thorn v Kelly Kelly and Mike Knox were all absolutely dreadful.

The PPV became the least purchased WWE PPV of all time and the PPV would become well establisged for being one of the biggest trainwrecks in WWE history.


 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Brad Preston hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.