10 Worst WWE Wrestlers Of 2016
WWE's Hall of Shame keeps growing and growing.
2016 has been another year of incredibly high personnel turnover for WWE, and the company's current roster composition is almost unrecognisable to what it was a year ago. Dozens of new faces have risen up to grab the roster spots left behind by those departed, and with close to 30 on-air personalities handed their walking papers this year, opportunities have been plentiful.
AJ Styles has become one of the company's biggest stars since debuting in January, Finn Balor became Universal Champion within a month of his call-up, and 2016 also saw Kevin Owens' first major title reign. The likes of Chris Jericho and The Miz have rebuilt their ailing careers on their respective brands, and Sasha Banks, Becky Lynch, and Charlotte have legitimised the Women's Revolution as one of WWE's biggest assets.
Not every wrestler has prospered in the increased spotlight, however. The turnover has forced WWE to push a number of wrestlers into roles that they're just not comfortable with, and whether through age, inexperience, or an underdeveloped skillset, the roster is crammed with struggling grapplers.
Some wrestlers have stood out for all the wrong reasons this year. While not always their fault (WWE Creative have much to answer for), these men and women have done nothing but clog WWE's programming this year. They've had a terrible time of it, and when the clock strikes midnight on January 1st, 2017, they'll be glad to leave the past 12 months behind.
Here are the 10 worst WWE wrestlers of 20016.
10. Kane
Kane’s decline hasn’t been quite as stark as the Big Show’s, but it’s still very noticeable. Once one of the most skilled big men in the business, the 49-year-old’s mystique and menace died a long time ago, and he has become a filler athlete on SmackDown. Age has crippled Kane’s physical capabilities, and years of poor booking and suspect creative decisions have killed his character.
Kane has been with the company for 21 years now, but he’s had a horrendous 2016. He has been involved with The Wyatt Family’s affairs for much of it, but he’s done little to enhance his position or theirs. Kane’s presence opposite The Family has felt particularly tiresome since the Brand Split, when he was injected into the ongoing Randy Orton storyline seemingly without reason, and his Survivor Series win over Luke Harper was completely needless.
He’s never going to become a featured performer at this stage in his career, and aside from playing a role in The Undertaker’s eventual retirement, it’s hard to see what Kane brings to the table anymore. He’s not awful, but he’s completely listless, and his stint as Corporate Kane has obliterated his monstrous presence. Kane’s a future Hall of Famer inductee, but he brought next to nothing to the table in 2016.
9. Eva Marie
Eva Marie is always a popular choice when discussing WWE’s least complete performers, and justifiably so. She has made some gradual improvements over the past couple of years, but she still struggles in all aspects of her performance. Eva’s not a good wrestler, not a good talker, and she serves up more botches than the rest of her colleagues combined.
She’s the antithesis of everything the Women’s Revolution has become, and one of the most inexperienced wrestlers to ever set foot in a WWE ring. For all the green fitness models WWE have hired since the Attitude Era, Eva might be the worst. Her heat levels are through the roof, but not because she’s an effective heel: fans just don’t want to see her perform, and those boos come from a rejection of her as a performer.
SmackDown looked like they’d found a niche for Eva in the Brand Split’s early days, but she’s been off television since mid-August. First struck down by a Wellness Policy violation, Eva then disappeared to film a movie with Nicolas Cage of all people, and there’s no word on when she’ll return. She’d feature higher if not for her paucity of appearances throughout 2016, and it’s safe to say her in-ring return won’t be one of 2017’s most anticipated comebacks.
8. Darren Young
A clear play on Donald Trump’s presidential campaign, WWE’s quest to “make Darren Young great again” has been a complete failure. Young and his life coach Bob Backlund have made just one Raw appearance since mid-September, but perhaps the angle was doomed from the start. The former Prime Time Player is a decent enough performer, but with all due respect, when was he ever “great” in the first place?
The campaign debuted on a May episode of SmackDown, but Young and Backlund didn’t make their first live TV appearance together for over two months. This long delay killed whatever interest the vignettes had drummed up, and poor Darren was met by nothing but cricket chirps when he eventually appeared. He entered a brief Intercontinental Title program with The Miz, but it ended with a double countout at Battleground, and Young has struggled ever since.
The ensuing feud with Titus O’Neil was a total flop, and one of 2016’s worst. Nobody gave a hoot about either performer from the get go, and it speaks volumes that WWE eventually decided to end it without a proper blow-off match. Young has been dealt an awful hand by WWE this year, and his attempted reboot hasn’t worked at all.
7. Carmella
WWE’s announcement that six NXT wrestlers would be included in the 2016 Draft had fans dreaming of Bayley, Finn Balor, and Shinsuke Nakamura. Balor inevitably came up, but the NXT call-ups were largely comprised of green, inexperienced rookies who looked far from the finished article at Full Sail, let alone on the main roster.
Carmella was among that group, and she has consistently struggled on SmackDown. Her early days as a babyface were a complete flop, and away from her old allies Enzo Amore & Big Cass, Carmella just couldn’t get herself cheered. Things improved when she turned heel on Nikki Bella, and the two have had a solid mid-level feud on the blue brand, but Carmella still isn’t getting over despite being paired with one of the division’s most popular competitors.
Carmella has only been wrestling for two years, and while she has made some slight improvements since her call-up, she still looks a step or two behind her more tenured colleagues. Carmella's offense is particularly sloppy and meek-looking, and while her best years should theoretically be ahead of her, her limited skillset means she probably won’t be advancing up the card anytime soon.
6. The Shining Stars
As if Los Matadore’s cartoony bullfighter schtick wasn’t bad enough, Primo & Epico took things to a whole new level in 2016. El Torito was released from WWE in the spring, and with the two Puerto Ricans stuck in flux, WWE decided to repackage them in bewildering fashion.
Primo & Epico started appearing in a series of bizarre promo videos enticing viewers to come to Puerto Rico, “the Shining Star of the Caribbean,” and it continued when they made television. If they’re on your screen, The Shining Stars will spend their time handing out tourism brochures and attempting to sell cut-price timeshares to potential opponents. They’ve become sleazy travel agents, and the gimmick change has seen them rooted to the foot of the Raw tag division.
The Shining Stars are an unwanted throwback to the mid-90s’ paper thin occupational gimmicks, and it’s not getting them over. They struggled for heat as Los Matadores, and they’re struggling for heat as the Stars. Now five years into their run, Primo & Epico have just a single Tag Team Title reign to their name, and seem destined to an eternity of putting everyone else over.
The Stars entered a brief feud with Enzo & Cass in September and even notched a couple of pinfalls over the popular duo, but the story ended without explanation. For now, Primo & Epico are the heel equivalent of The Golden Truth, and one of the company’s most cringe-worthy acts.
5. Curt Hawkins
Just as fans were let down by the 2016 Draft’s lacklustre NXT call-ups, the Brand Split’s returning superstars were hugely disappointing. Reports that WWE were looking to bring back a number of old heroes to fill-out their post-Draft rosters saw names like Kurt Angle thrown around, but who did we get instead? Rhyno, Jinder Mahal, and Curt Hawkins.
Rhyno has had a good little run on SmackDown, but Hawkins? Not so much. The former WWE Tag Team Champion was packaged with a goofy Chuck Norris facts style gimmick that might have gotten over back in 2006 when the meme was still popular, but comes off forced and corny 10 years later. Then again though, when have WWE ever had their finger on the pulse of such things? Look for a debuting wrestler to show up in a crying Michael Jordan t-shirt sometime in 2026.
WWE attempted to pull some Eva Marie heat by having Hawkins draw his protracted in-ring debut out over several weeks, but it didn’t work. Hawkins was eventually slain by Dolph Ziggler in just seven seconds in his first televised match since returning, and Apollo Crews is the only wrestler who’s been made to “face the facts” thus far. As limp and uninspiring a return as you’ll find, and one that shows no signs of progression.
4. The Ascension
The Ascension might be the longest-reigning NXT Tag Team Champions of all-time, but their 364-day run with the gold was a tedious mess of squash matches and ironic crowd chants. Still, it gave Konnor and Viktor a solid selling point upon hitting the main roster, but they’ve never been able to get over, and have looked worse than ever in 2016.
Viktor’s a reasonably capable worker, but Konnor is one of the most awkward big men in the company. Slow, lumbering, and clumsy, he brings very little to the table, and the team are going nowhere on SmackDown. It likely doesn’t help that Konnor was struck down by a Wellness Policy violation in April, but regardless, The Ascension are a bog standard tag team with little to no charisma, and a failed attempt at reviving the popular “power & paint” teams of the ‘80s and ‘90s.
They’ve got a fearsome entrance theme, but that’s about it. Nothing about The Ascension works, from their look to their wrestling style, and they’re doomed on SmackDown. Perhaps they’d have been more successful in an era without such an emphasis on workrate, but for now, The Ascension are comfortably the worst tag team in WWE today.
3. Dana Brooke
Dana Brooke was brought onto the main roster to reignite her old NXT partnership with Emma earlier this year, but it fell apart as soon as Emma was injured. She was thrown alongside Charlotte shortly afterwards, but while originally introduced Dana as the Women’s Champion’s protege, she soon became a dogsbody.
Instead of letting Brooke play to the smarmy, obnoxious persona she’d developed in NXT, Brooke became completely subservient. She was too often reduced to a quivering, whimpering wreck in Charlotte’s presence, and while Dana showed some backbone by slapping her bully of a mentor in September, it wasn’t to last. Brooke soon reverted to her lapdog role, then fell out of the story all-together: it’s been weeks since we’ve seen Dana and Charlotte together, and their allegiance may already be over.
As a performer, Dana looks like she has regressed since leaving NXT. She’s clumsy on the microphone and even worse in the ring, and the fact that even Bayley couldn’t drag a decent match out of her speaks volumes. Pair these deficiencies with the heat-vacuum that was the Bayley feud, and you have one of the least impressive superstar resumes of 2016.
It was originally rumoured that WWE were planning on setting Brooke up as a major babyface to fight Charlotte at WrestleMania, but it looks like those plans have been abandoned. A good move, as for all Dana’s hard work, she’s one of the least convincing workers in the company.
2. Mojo Rawley
Mojo Rawley is enthusiastic, exuberant, and clearly loves being a professional wrestler. His NXT call-up has given Zack Ryder something to do other than pushing up daisies in the Intercontinental Title division, and until Ryder’s injury, the duo were set to challenge for The Wyatt Family’s SmackDown Tag Team Titles. Unfortunately, these are about the nicest things you can say for Rawley, who was never particularly impressive in NXT, and looks even more out of place on the main roster.
Rawley is irritating to the extreme. His over-exuberant personality gets tedious after about 30 seconds of exposure, and the guy just doesn’t have an “off” switch. Mojo is that obnoxious, screaming child who sits behind you on a long haul flight and won’t stop kicking your chair throughout, and he doesn’t even have the in-ring chops to back it up.
The majority of Mojo’s offence consists of running really fast and bumping into his opponent, supplemented by that horrendous “Hammer Time” sitout axe handle. On-air, he’s a 30 year old man with the mindset of a pre-teen, and out of every wrestler to be called-up from NXT this year, Mojo would’ve benefited most from a longer stint in developmental. He’s nothing more than an annoyance at this point, and Ryder’s injury leaves his immediate future up in the air.
1. Titus O'Neil
Titus O’Neil has never really shone in WWE, particularly as a singles act, but things seemed to be looking up for him at the turn of the year. Titus was being used with increasing regularity and it seemed like he was set for a solid mini-push through the midcard, but disaster struck in February. O’Neil innocuously grabbed Vince McMahon’s arm during Daniel Bryan’s retirement ceremony, and that was that: Titus was suspended for 60 days, and his push died there and then.
Things got even worse when he came back. Titus was immediately fed to Rusev, who beat the 2015 Celebrity Dad of the Year down and berated him in front of his family, before slotting into a horrible feud with Darren Young, his former tag team partner. The feud ended after Titus stumbled his way through one of the most brutal promos in WWE history in late August (a segment so bad it almost warrants Titus’ inclusion on its own), and from there, O’Neil debuted his new “Titus Brand” gimmick, and inherited a sizeable losing streak.
Now 39 years old, this is probably as good as it gets for Titus. He’s a valuable figure behind the scene and someone WWE always rely on for PR and marketing events, but that’s about the extent of his worth. O’Neil’s a cumbersome power wrestler with little charisma, and the McMahon incident has all but buried him.