10 WrestleMania Rematches That Were Better Than The Originals

When WWE stars didn't need the showcase of the immortals to put on a classic.

WWE pushes WrestleMania as the be-all and end-all of its schedule, the date when all of the storylines and tensions of the previous year reach their conclusions in historic fashion. One only needs to watch WWE for a few years, though, to realize that isn't quite the case €“ yes, WrestleMania is when the eyes of the world are attuned to WWE, but for a variety of reasons, sometimes the show is just the beginning of a story. Matches are cut short due to time constraints on packed WrestleMania cards. Sometimes, specific feuds work better than expected and demand to be continued after the show. In other cases, WrestleMania encounters are first-time affairs, and WWE decides to milk all they can out of certain programs in the ensuing months. Regardless of the reason, we get a lot of rematches after WrestleMania (heck, there was even a Pay-Per-View event named "Backlash" in April for a decade). Here's a guide to the rematches you should seek out to accentuate (or in some cases, help you forget) the first-time bouts. Just a note on the criteria: to be eligible, the match must be a direct rematch of the bout at WrestleMania, with all of the same competitors (though new stipulations are okay). It also has to have taken place prior to the following year's WrestleMania event. Let's go to the list!

10. John Cena vs. Bray Wyatt - Payback 2014

When The Wyatt Family interfered in John Cena's WWE World Heavyweight Championship match at the Royal Rumble, the direction the company had chosen to take Cena and Bray Wyatt leading into WrestleMania was obvious... and a bit questionable. Wyatt was the most interesting new heel WWE had seen in years, and a feud with Cena would only elevate his stock, but in the end, would the match halt his momentum? When the men collided at WrestleMania XXX, Cena did hand Wyatt his first defeat, but the clash was a strong, solid battle that made it clear the issue was not finished. After Wyatt won a cage match at Extreme Rules, the stage was set for the rubber match at Payback €“ and this time, it would be Last Man Standing. The two had a wild brawl that seemed out of place in today's WWE, and that made it all the more spectacular. Wyatt's henchmen, Luke Harper and Eric Rowan, tried to aid their leader, but WWE Tag Team Champions Jimmy and Jey Uso came to Cena's rescue. The two combatants fought around the arena, working their way over to some staging equipment. When Cena drove Wyatt through wooden paneling with the AA and "The Eater of Worlds" couldn't answer the count, the feud was over... and so was, arguably, WWE's best match of 2014.

9. The Hardy Boyz vs The Dudley Boyz vs Edge & Christian - SummerSlam 2000

The rivalry between hot young tag teams Edge and Christian and The Hardy Boyz seemed to culminate when the Hardyz won an amazingly innovative ladder match at No Mercy 1999, but it was rekindled when The Dudley Boyz decided to interject themselves into the teams' business. The Dudleyz's unorthodox style threw the teams for a loop, as did the tables the former ECW Tag Team Champions introduced to their battles. In the end, the first-ever three-way tag team ladder match was penciled in for WrestleMania 2000, and the exciting bout, which saw Edge and Christian capture their first World Tag Team Championship, was the highlight of the show. The score wasn't settled, though. While the Dudleyz soon found themselves fan favorites, Edge and Christian's new heelish attitudes saw them pick increasingly-personal rivalries with their opponents. The Canadian duo began using the Con-Chair-To to keep themselves ahead, a brutal double chairshot to an opponent's skull. With the Hardyz representing ladder matches, the Dudleyz continuing to use tables, and Edge and Christian picking chairs to get their dirty work done, combining all three was the only answer. At SummerSlam 2000, the teams battled in a Tables, Ladders, and Chairs (TLC) match that outdid their previous encounter. Sure, it was just a ladder match with more weapons at ringside, but those weapons were used to their full effect. In the end, reigning champions Edge and Christian once more retrieved the World Tag Team Titles... which, of course, set the stage for TLC II at WrestleMania X-Seven.

8. Eddie Guerrero vs. Rey Mysterio - Ladder Match For Custody Of Dominic (SummerSlam 2005)

WWE Tag Team Champions €“ and best friends €“ Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio clashed in friendly competition in the opening match of WrestleMania 21. Though the match wasn't bad, it was a bit of a disappointment considering the talent involved. Mysterio, who had trouble with his mask coming loose throughout the 12-minute match, eventually pinned former WWE Champion Guerrero. Then things got weird. After the champs lost their titles to MNM later in the month, Guerrero brutally turned on Mysterio, cementing himself as a heel despite his immense popularity. The two men would clash at Judgment Day and The Great American Bash with Rey winning both contests, but Eddie remained in his hair by indicated that he knew a secret about the masked superstar. Finally, he dropped the bomb: during a separation from his wife, Vickie, Eddie had fathered a child whom he "gave" to Rey to raise as his own. With the cat out of the bag, Eddie now wanted "his son," Dominic, back. A ladder match was made for SummerSlam, with custody papers suspended above the ring. As strange as that all sounds (and was), the match itself was great. After months of silly teases and halts, the former friends went all-out with something even more important than championship gold on the line. Even interference from Vickie Guerrero (helping to thwart her nefarious husband) only added to the drama of the contest. In the end, Mysterio won custody, his family was preserved, and a fantastic match capped off the feud.

7. Stone Cold Steve Austin vs Savio Vega - Caribbean Strap Match (In Your House VIII: Beware Of Dog)

Steve Austin's well-documented WWF debut as "The Ringmaster," Ted DiBiase's new Million Dollar Champion, did him no favors, but re-christening himself "Stone Cold" wasn't an overnight solution to the problem. Austin's first feud in the company was with future Los Boricuas leader Savio Vega, and with DiBiase still at his side, he was able to defeat Vega via submission at WrestleMania XII. Like with Cena and Wyatt, the 'Mania bout was a technically solid affair, but not the one people would remember. Two months later, at the In Your House: Beware of Dog Pay-Per-View, Austin and Vega clashed once more in a Caribbean Strap Match, where the two men were tied together and the winner would be the first to touch all four corners in succession. Unfortunately, a power outage during the show meant that the television viewers didn't get to see the brutal beating the two men inflicted on one another, and they had to repeat the match on a "do-over" PPV two nights later. This, Steve Austin's first classic WWE match, saw two hated rivals tear each other's skin off with the leather strap in a show of true savagery. Vega won, and as a result of his victory, DiBiase was forced to leave the company. It would soon be revealed, however, that Austin threw the match to break out on his own, without the shadow of the "Million Dollar Man" over him. The next month, he would win King of the Ring and begin his rise to superstardom.

6. CM Punk vs Chris Jericho (Extreme Rules 2012)

Chris Jericho returned to WWE on January 2, 2012 following a 16-month layoff, and he was exhibiting some truly strange behavior €“ he was silent (a very un-Jericho quality), and sported an LED-covered jacket that heralded his entrance into a dark arena. The odd behavior was all a ruse, though €“ he was lulling the fans (and his opponents) into a false sense of security, only so he could attack WWE Champion CM Punk. Punk's claims of being "The Best in the World" caused Jericho to take umbrage, and Y2J was determined to prove that only he deserved that appellation. The two met for the title at WrestleMania XXVIII, and Punk won a great match that was, unfortunately, overshadowed by the even better Undertaker-Triple H and Rock-John Cena matches on the card. Jericho's loss made him go insane with hatred. He exposed CM Punk's father's alcoholism (the reason for Punk's straight-edge lifestyle), berated the rest of the champion's family, and tried to force him to drink €“ even pouring whiskey on him at one point. When the two met at Extreme Rules, it was in a street fight €“ the classic "come as you are" kind. In front of Punk's Chicago brethren, the two went tooth and nail, beating each other with hockey sticks, fire extinguishers, and of course, beer. In the end, a GTS ensured that the result was the same as at WrestleMania. Once again, there were two other amazing encounters on the show (Brock Lesnar versus John Cena and another we'll get to in a bit), but this time, Jericho and Punk stood alongside them proudly.

5. John Cena vs. Shawn Michaels, Monday Night Raw €“ April 23, 2007

An injury to Triple H at New Year's Revolution 2007 meant that "The Game" would miss WrestleMania 23, and as such, his rumored rematch with John Cena was off the card. Instead, his D-Generation X partner, Shawn Michaels, filled in in the main event of the show, taking Cena to the limit in a great contest that saw reversals, false finishes, and drama galore. Finally, it was Cena who won, catching HBK in the STF and forcing him to tap out, just as he had done to HHH a year earlier. Though Cena and HBK were uneasy allies (a relationship which saw them capture the World Tag Team Titles), Michaels needed to prove to himself that he could best Cena. On a London-based edition of Monday Night Raw airing on April 23, 2007 (Cena's 30th birthday), the two would clash once more, in non-title action. At the top of the second hour, the two masters of the art met in the center of the ring and began to have a classic exhibition. The match stretched through a commercial break, then another. The announcers relayed the message that the scheduled main event, Randy Orton versus Edge, would have to be canceled due to time constraints. The match continued, the live crowd and TV viewers realizing they were seeing something truly special. Finally, near the 60-minute mark, Michaels caught Cena with Sweet Chin Music and pinned him. He had proven he was Cena's equal, and the result was a contest that would never be forgotten.

4. Batista vs. Triple H, Vengeance 2005

The buildup to Batista and HHH's big showdown in the main event of WrestleMania 21 was so good that it helped WWE garner their highest number of Pay-Per-View buys up to that point. Long story short: Batista wins the Rumble, Evolution buddy Triple H tries to manipulate Big Dave into challenging for the WWE Championship rather than HHH's World Championship, Batista is wise to HHH's game, and the underling ends the alliance in violent fashion. The match itself, though, didn't deliver €“ we got a boring, plodding affair from the master of them, and his would-be successor certainly didn't dazzle. The following month at Backlash, a rematch between the two ended in a lame disqualification. This all set the stage for Vengeance, where World Heavyweight Champion Batista defended against Triple H in their third encounter €“ this one a Hell in a Cell match. Though the previous two encounters were dull, and HHH's two most recent HIAC matches were just as bad (against Kevin Nash and Shawn Michaels), the planets aligned on June 26, and the two men had a fantastic encounter. After classic cage brawling, Batista put HHH down with a Batista Bomb, retaining his title. The feud could end on a high note.

3. Sheamus vs. Daniel Bryan - Extreme Rules 2012

When Sheamus beat Daniel Bryan to win the World Heavyweight Championship in WrestleMania XXVIII's opener, a wave of anger spread over the Miami crowd €“ not for the result itself, but because the match was only 18 seconds long. It felt like a slap in the face to the hardcore fans who had traveled hundreds (or in some cases, thousands) of miles, many of whom were avid Bryan supporters. His ultra-entertaining title reign just€ ended, and once again Bryan was screwed out of a real place on the WrestleMania card. Exercising his rematch clause, Bryan demanded a two-out-of-three falls match to prevent being caught off-guard by Sheamus. "The Celtic Warrior" agreed, and so the rematch at Extreme Rules got a bit more time to breathe. Bryan used his technical expertise to keep Sheamus under control in the early goings, but the challenger seemingly lost his own grip, getting disqualified for beating on the World Heavyweight Champion while he had the ropes. It was part of the plan, though €“ Sheamus's arm was injured, and so when Bryan applied the Yes! Lock, the Irishman soon passed out, evening the count. Unfortunately for Bryan, he couldn't maintain his momentum €“ Sheamus fought back, nailing all of his big moves and finally putting his opponent away with a Brogue Kick. Again, Daniel Bryan was defeated, but this time, he got to go down like a champion.

2. John Cena vs. JBL - Judgment Day 2005

In late 2004, it became evident that John Cena was the WWE's next big star, and the man to end the seemingly-interminable WWE Championship reign of John "Bradshaw" Layfield. Though he failed to win the Royal Rumble, a win over multi-time champion Kurt Angle assured that the Doctor of Thuganomics would compete for the gold. A hard-fought win over Bradshaw would legitimize Cena as a main event player... unfortunately, we got a truncated match that saw JBL dominate in plodding fashion, then Cena pull out the victory with an AA out of nowhere. Who'd have thought the end of JBL's title reign would be such a disappointment? The next month, though, JBL became the number one contender, and at Judgment Day, we got the brutal blow-off WrestleMania couldn't give us. In this "I Quit" match, Cena and Bradshaw beat each raw using a variety of weapons including chairs, tables, monitors, and parts of a flatbed truck Cena rode into the arena. In the end, Cena threatened JBL with the truck's exhaust pipe, and the big man quickly quit. Nevertheless, Cena obliterated him with the pipe, then stood triumphant, celebrating the first of many classic matches the Chain Gang Leader would have as WWE Champion.

1. Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart, SummerSlam 1994

The match Bret and Owen Hart had at WrestleMania X isn't just one of the best Pay-Per-View openers of all time €“ it's one of the best wrestling encounters of all time, period. A classic hold-for-hold contest that saw Owen outmaneuver and outsmart his brother to pick up the clean victory, it forever established the youngest Hart as a WWE legend €“ and when Bret won the WWF Championship two hours later, it was clear that a rematch would be necessary. The battle came at SummerSlam, this time in a cage match €“ which, at the time, meant one of WWF's unmistakable big blue cages would be needed. Owen was out to prove he could repeat history €“ this time, with the title on he line €“ and he fought tenaciously, as did his brother. The King of Harts took every opportunity he could to try and escape the cage, making for one of the most realistic, logical matches in WWE history. In the end, both brothers scaled the cage and climbed over the top... but an attack from Bret led to Owen catching his leg in the cage, and "The Hitman" was able to drop to the floor and retain the title.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013