10 Wrestlers AEW Failed In 2022

Those AEW names hoping for an upturn as we head into 2023.

AEW Failed CM Punk
AEW

One of the major problems of the wrestling business for any promotion, is keeping your roster happy and making the most of the talents at your disposal. And the bigger the roster, the harder those problems become to manage.

For Tony Khan, his All Elite Wrestling houses some of the absolute greatest pro wrestling stars on the planet. Whether you're talking in-ring work, verbal skills, or general character presentation, AEW has some of the very best in the game. While so many of those names are allowed to flourish under the All Elite banner and showcase their abilities, there are some others who unfortunately have been done dirty by AEW across 2022.

You can't keep everybody happy all of the time, of course, but there are so many glaring examples in AEW of stars who should have been utilised better in this last year, but for whatever reason have been left out in the cold or mistreated by Khan's promotion. Whether 2023 takes an upturn for these talents remains to be seen, but 2022 was certainly one to forget for these performers.

Looking back over these past 12 months, then, here are ten stars who have been failed by Tony Khan's AEW.

10. Lance Archer

Lance Archer Serpentico
AEW

Upon debuting with AEW, it initially looked as if Lance Archer would be utilised as a top tier talent who would often find himself in the main event picture.

While losing to Cody Rhodes in the tournament final to crown the inaugural TNT Champion took a whole bunch of steam away from the Murderhawk Monster, his presentation and presence in the time since has only served to make Archer an afterthought of All Elite Wrestling.

It's a strange one with Lance, for he will be absent from AEW TV for months at a time, then resurface to immediately have an AEW World Title match - as has been the case against both Jon Moxley and 'Hangman' Adam Page - before then disappearing again for a spell.

AEW want you to think that the 6'6" star is a major player and a genuine threat to the company's top talents, yet they rarely do anything to showcase why Archer is a major player and genuine threat. For every IWGP US Title win over Moxley, there's a three-month spell of solely working AEW Dark.

2022 may have seen the Suzuki-gun man work NJPW's G1 Climax and the Tag League tourneys, but that time in New Japan is no excuse for Lance Archer only having six televised AEW matches this year - with any match of significance resulting in a loss for the big man.


9. Private Party

Private Party
AEW

When AEW launched, Marq Quen and Isiah Kassidy were touted as a young tandem who had the potential to become a major force in tag team wrestling. Here we are, over three years later, and Private Party are no better off than they were when they made their AEW bow at June 2019's Fyter Fest.

It was their match against the Young Bucks on the second-ever episode of Dynamite which really had people sit up and take notice of Quen and Kassidy, with them presented as successors to the Bucks' throne. Alas, that role as successors seems a million miles away right now.

Private Party are two highly talented, promising performers who have a unique charisma and some special tandem offense. The problem is, it's tough for such an act to truly get better if they're not getting the opportunity to showcase their skills on TV and in meaningful rivalries against great teams.

There have only been a handful of Private Party matches on TV this year, and instead, Quen and Kassidy have been left to demonstrate their abilities in 19 YouTube outings. While Dark and Dark: Elevation are good places for young talents to hone their craft, there has to be that sink-or-swim moment where an act is given the ball to run with. And considering how much AEW talked up this duo as far back as 2019, it's frustrating to see the promotion so hesitant to feature Private Party as a regular in-ring act on Dynamite, Rampage or possibly even on PPVs.


8. Riho

Riho AEW
AEW

From the heady heights of being the inaugural AEW Women's Champion, to the lows of padding out six-person tag matches on YouTube. That's unfortunately been the AEW career trajectory of Riho.

2021 wasn't a great year for Riho in AEW, but hope was high that the 16-year pro would be featured in a more prominent All Elite role in 2022. Sadly, that was far from the case.

The start of '22 did find Riho back on AEW TV, at least, with her unsuccessfully challenging Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. for the AEW Women's Title. While that January Battle of the Belts clash resulted in a collarbone injury for Riho, the 25-year-old was back in action by May as part of the Owen Hart Foundation Women's Tournament. Since then, though, the Japanese star has only had five AEW matches, and just one of those - against Jamie Hayter in October - was televised.

Of course, we'll never outright know whether Riho's lack of AEW action is down to the company or a decision from the talent herself, but it's damning to see that, when Riho has been on AEW duty across 2022, it's usually been - as was the case in 2021 - restricted to Dark and Dark: Elevation.

The fact that Riho held the AEW Women's Title for an impressive 133 days makes her recent use (or lack thereof) even more questionable.


7. Brian Pillman Jr.

Brian Pillman Jr.
AEW

Having made his AEW bow way back in 2019 at the first Double or Nothing, the tail-end of last year suggested big things were on the horizon for Brian Pillman Jr.

When Dynamite and Rampage came to Pillman's hometown of Cincinnati, the second-generation star got to express himself in ways not seen before under the AEW banner. In getting fired up and verbally jousting with none other than MJF, this felt like it could be a real breakout moment for BPJ. Added to that, Pillman was also suddenly under the wing of fellow hometown hero Jon Moxley.

He may have ultimately lost to the Salt of the Earth at the big Grand Slam show from Arthur Ashe shortly after this, but there had been enough promise shown to suggest that 2022 could be a massive year for Brian Pillman Jr. Pairing the Varsity Blonds up against the House of Black early in the year was an intriguing prospect, and there were also several teases that Pillman and partner Griff Garrison may be about to go their separate ways.

Instead, 2022 has been a disappointing one for the Blonds, and in particular for Pillman. While there has been some success on Dark and Dark: Elevation, this year has been a winless one on TV in both tag and singles action for Brian Pillman Jr.


6. Scorpio Sky

Scorpio Sky
AEW

Scorpio Sky's on-off partner Ethan Page would've at one point been in the running for inclusion on this list, but the use of All Ego in this past month or so means he narrowly avoids that honour.

For Scorp though, it's been such an up and down year in 2022.

As part of the Men of the Year, Sky was a prominent part of AEW programming at the start of the year, and 2022 peaked for the star when he defeated Sammy Guevara in March to become the TNT Champion. While hope was high that Scorpio could embark on a great run with that prize in the same vein as a Cody Rhodes, a Mr. Brodie Lee, a Darby Allin, or a Miro, it was unfortunately at this point when the TNT Championship lost so much of its prestige.

That lose of prestige wasn't down to Scorpio Sky, of course, but more down to how the title was hot-potatoed from Sky back to Guevara, back to Sky, and then eventually to Wardlow.

A knee injury admittedly put Sky on the shelf after dropping the TNT Title to the War Dog in July, but reports last month noted how the 39-year-old has been cleared for "quite some time" and is simply not being used by AEW. Content was filmed with the former SCU man over the summer as part of his return to the ring... though nothing has happened with that footage.

So, Scorpio Sky is fit and healthy, his prior partner Page is now doing other things, and Sky is somewhat in limbo as we head into 2023.


5. Serena Deeb

Serena Deeb
AEW

Granted, Serena Deeb may be the veteran performer who helps to train and give advice to the young stars of tomorrow, but it's borderline criminal not to have featured the former NWA Women's Champion on AEW TV on a more consistent basis across this past year.

When looking across the female roster, Deeb is hands-down the best in-ring talent in the AEW women's division. The Professor absolutely lives up to her nickname each and every time she steps between the ropes, and Serena's style and technique brings legitimacy to everything that she does.

The beginning of 2022 started off promising for Serena, with her Professor's Five Minute Rookie Challenge being a welcome part of AEW programming, before she then began feuding with the brilliant Hikaru Shida. Once that Shida rivalry was wrapped up, though, it's been an incredibly stop-start year for Deeb.

Utilising the Virginia native's experience and ability, Tony Khan has wheeled her out for a few singles TV matches where a top name has needed someone to put on a decent match with - be that Thunder Rosa, Toni Storm or even Mercedes Martinez at Death Before Dishonor - but the vast majority of the second half of the year has seen Deeb working multi-women tags or stuck on Dark and Dark: Elevation.


4. Andrade El Idolo

Andrade El Idolo Jose the Assistant
AEW

Few mainstream wrestlers, period, have had as frustrating a 2022 as Andrade El Idolo.

When the one-time NXT Champion departed the Vince McMahon-led WWE in March 2021 - the star having requested his release from the market leader - hope was high that the former La Sombra would have the chance to shine. Such hope was only amped up further once Andrade strolled out on the 4 June '21 episode of AEW Dynamite.

If the second half of 2021 was a confusing one for Andrade - as he went from Vickie Guerrero, to Chavo Guerrero Jr., to Jose the Assistant - 2022 has been an even more baffling one when it comes to how El Idolo has been used on AEW programming.

Early 2022 battles with Sammy Guevara and Darby Allin highlighted what Andrade can bring to the AEW table, and the arrival of Rush and Dralistico was an opportunity to capture some of that Los Ingobernables energy. Unfortunately, the main issue with Andrade this year is the simple fact of how little he's been allowed to wrestle.

Of course, the star was afforded some time off to get married to Charlotte Flair, and he is currently dealing with an injury issue, but still, the fact that Andrade has only had ten televised AEW matches across 2022 is mind-blowing - as is the fact that only four of those bouts were one-on-one affairs.

There have been rumblings that Andrade is desperate to get out of his AEW deal - with a physical altercation with Sammy Guevara being a part of that - and it's easy to see why the ridiculously talented grappler would have frustrations with his AEW lot right now.


3. Hikaru Shida

Hikaru Shida
AEW

Truth be told, it's not just 2022 when AEW did dirty by Hikaru Shida. In reality, the Shining Samurai has often been an afterthought since losing the AEW Women's Championship to Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. at Double or Nothing in May 2021.

Following that title loss, it bafflingly took five months for Shida to resurface on AEW Dynamite, with those months seeing the hugely talented star toiling away on Dark and Dark: Elevation. While the first half of 2022 did see Hikaru's rivalry with Serena Deeb getting spotlighted on TV, that pair's Philadelphia Street Fight in April was followed by another four-month gap before Shida turned up on the Dynamite prior to All Out.

Of course, Thunder Rosa having to step away from in-ring action caused a reshuffle for All Out, with Shida thrust into a four-way offering to crown the Interim AEW Women's Championship. Since then, there's been just two Dynamite outings and two Rampage appearances for the 34-year-old.

Granted, Hikaru Shida took some time out to visit her homeland of Japan earlier this year, but there was so much time when the talent was healthy and available, but AEW instead opted to have her wasting time on its YouTube shows.


2. Miro

Miro AEW
AEW

The fall from grace of Miro has been spectacular to see... and said fall has zero to do with the talent himself.

After an incredibly ropey start to life in AEW - introduced as the Angry Video Game Nerd - Miro really found his footing in early 2021. Now presented as a genuine monster of a man, the Redeemer embarked on a dominant four-month reign as the TNT Champion, with him memorably bending and battering the likes of Darby Allin, Eddie Kingston, Lance Archer and Dante Martin.

Bafflingly, since losing that title to Sammy Guevara on a September '21 episode of Dynamite, the Bulgarian Brute has wrestled just six times, period, and only four of those have come in 2022.

There is the mild caveat that Miro took some time off to shoot the pilot for CBS' East New York, but that only ruled the powerhouse out of action for a relatively short amount of time.

Just last week saw reports of the one-time Rusev being completely healthy, eager to compete, and how AEW has nothing creatively for him right now. Considering how phenomenal a job he did with the TNT Title and with his God-threatening persona, it's insane to realise the 37-year-old hasn't even wrestled a full handful of matches in 2022 - two of which were thrown-together multi-man matches at Forbidden Door and All Out.


1. CM Punk

CM Punk
AEW

This one is likely to split opinion and is very much a different entry to the rest of this list, but CM Punk was failed by AEW in 2022.

While the other entries featured here are included due to how poorly they've been used across this past year, there's no doubting that the Second City Saint was utilised fantastically during his far-too-short spell being #AllElite. There was an unfortunate spell on the sidelines for Punk in 2022, but the Chicago native had the Feud of the Year with MJF, had great rivalries with 'Hangman' Adam Page and Jon Moxley, and elsewhere put on bangers with the likes of Dax Harwood, Penta Oscuro, Dustin Rhodes, and one of the most enjoyable tag bouts of the year when he teamed with Mox to battle Harwood and Cash Wheeler.

Where CM Punk was failed by AEW, then, was in how backstage issues were not addressed sooner.

Would we have got the infamous Brawl All if Tony Khan had stepped in when Hangman Page took an unplanned, unprofessional shot at Punk during a promo battle? Would things had come to an unfortunate head at All Out if certain EVPs weren't telling Dave Meltzer that Punk was the reason for Colt Cabana's absence... despite Khan stating several times how that was not the case? And would AEW be without the biggest draw in the company's short tenure if those same EVPs didn't angrily, unprofessionally confront the Straight-Edge Superstar after Punk's likewise unprofessional comments during the post-All Out presser?

CM Punk was clearly out of line with those press scrum comments, but the behaviour of Tony Khan and the promotion's EVPs could've put a stop to this fiery situation before it came to the point we're now sadly at.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.