10 Wrestlers Who Did Their Best Work In TNA/IMPACT

You could say they really made an Impact...

Christian Cage Tomko
Impact Wrestling

Once the closest thing to a number two promotion to WWE in the western hemisphere, TNA/IMPACT has fallen hard in recent years. Beyond serving as a trusty sidekick to the new number two promotion in the western hemisphere, the promotion has become infamous in recent times for constantly losing all of their stars.

Throughout its prime years, TNA was renowned for two things: great action and bad booking. Their roster had all the talent in the world from top to bottom and the promotion concocted some genuinely great match-ups, such as Ultimate X. Unfortunately, TNA creative was often headed by the likes of Vince Russo who just loved devolving angles into Jerry Springer-esque nonsense.

There was also a key issue early on regarding Jeff Jarrett's all-consuming obsession with being king of the mountain. Despite homegrown fan favourites like AJ Styles, Samoa Joe and Abyss being on hand, Double J's title death grip refused to let up.. until a young up and comer named Sting took him down.

For former WWE talent, TNA also used to be a post-McMahon haven where they'd be treated like superstars. While some cashed in for the easy payday, others made the most of a new push to do some of the finest work of their career. Then there were those who got their start in TNA and never quite matched it anywhere else they plied their trade.

With all that being said, here are 10 talents that hit the peak of their powers in TNA/IMPACT.

10. Mr Anderson

mr anderson tna champion
ImpactWrestling.com

MISTERRRRR ANNNNDDERRRRSSSONNNNNN...... ANNNNNNDERSONNNN wasn't quite as catchy as Mr Kennedy unless you were a major Matrix fan. Luckily for Mr Mic Check, everything else wrestling-related went much better for him in the house that Jarrett built. Treated as a main event prospect right out the gate (like seemingly all former WWE stars at the time), Anderson enjoyed the best matches of his career with Kurt Angle in 2010 and held the world title twice in 2011.

Once viewed as a future megastar by top WWE brass, a miserable cocktail of injuries, foot-in-mouth syndrome whenever PEDs came up in interviews, and dropping Randy Orton led to his downfall and release. While TNA kept him in a prominent spot on their roster throughout his initial run with them, he was never given the ball to completely run with.

Both of Anderson's world title reigns lasted a month before dropping them back to Jeff Hardy and Sting, respectively (apparently face paint is Anderson's kryptonite). The other flaw in his booking concerned his constant heel and face turns, causing him to come across as a regular-sized Big Show.

While Anderson's time in TNA wasn't exactly Ric Flair in 1989, it was a more effective showcase of his talents and credibility than WWE ever gave him.


9. Bully Ray

Bully Ray
TNA

Team 3D appeared to be on the tail end of their careers when they split in 2010. Following a much better than expected blood feud, the newly renamed Bully Ray then filled in the excommunicated Jeff Hardy's slot in Immortal.

Initially dismissed as a woefully inadequate replacement for the biggest star the promotion had at the time, Ray stuck it to his critics by getting into the best shape of his life. Cutting exceptionally unpleasant heel promos week to week, Ray became a natural heat magnet. His feuds with the likes of AJ Styles, Austin Aries and Mr. Anderson during this time kept the often topsy turvy TNA product interesting.

The company were so impressed with Ray's efforts that they rewarded him with a world title win in 2013. Bully Ray as a despicable champ should've been phenomenal. While his matches and promos remained good throughout, his time in the main event was hampered by the ridiculous Aces and Eights angle.

As the leader of one of TNA's many poor cracks at a heel faction, Ray was the face of both the promotion and its decline. After a stellar 2012, TNA took a dozen steps backwards in 2013 and never really recovered.

Despite the flaws, the quality of Bully Ray's work was high throughout. After two decades as a tag guy, he revealed a top level singles heel had always been waiting to break out. It's a pity his ROH run couldn't quite live up to his work rate here.


8. Awesome Kong

Awesome Kong
ImpactWrestling.com

Awesome Kong is one of the most intimidating women's wrestlers of all time. Carrying herself with a ferocious intensity, she got her first break in the United States as a member of the Knockouts division. Her feud with Gail Kim throughout '07 and early '08 remains one of TNA's finest thanks to their incendiary chemistry in the ring.

Incredibly agile and technically skilled, Kong went on a warpath through TNA's roster, getting monumentally over with the Impact Zone crowds in the process. Sadly, as is so often the case with unbeatable characters, Kong's heat began to dwindle once she finally ate a pin-fall.

A long-running angle where Kong would decimate fans (all planted wrestlers of course) in an open challenge gave way to Taylor Wilde picking up an unthinkable win over the Shimmer veteran. While the result was thrilling at the time, the genie was out of the bottle in regards to Kong's monster aura. While still prominent for the rest of her initial run there, she never quite regained the same level of heat.

Of her many standout runs across several promotions, Awesome Kong's first tenure in TNA remains her peak as both a character and worker.


7. Christopher Daniels

Christopher Daniels Tna
ImpactWrestling.com

The master of the moonsault is still going strong after 28 years of hard bumps. However, Christopher Daniels' time in TNA is fascinatingly odd. From a heel nemesis for AJ Styles, to a babyface veteran, to one half of Bad Influence with Kazarian (hilariously re-titled 'The World Tag Team Champions of the World' whenever they held the belts), Daniels showcased his insane versatility for years in the Impact Zone.

As The Fallen Angel, Daniels racked up multiple X-Division and Tag Team title runs whilst being consistently over with fans as both a heel and a face. With a sharp mind for wrestling psychology, the former Curry Man knew how to tweak his character for the desired reaction without ever retconning his prior storytelling.

Speaking of Curry Man, his Feast or Fired firing from TNA in 2008 led to the priceless '2008-2008, We Barely Knew Thee' tribute video. An example of comedy in wrestling working like a charm, it further added to the consensus that Daniels can thrive with any angle or persona thrown his way.

While he never held the world title in TNA, his outstanding body of work over 10 plus years with the promotion remains truly exceptional.


6. EC3

EC3 Impact Wrestling
IMPACT

Derrick Bateman looked like he had at least a little potential on NXT. Brought in as Daniel Bryan's rookie for season 4 of the old gameshow format, Bateman's promos were funny and well-delivered. Unimpressed, WWE left him in the unending purgatory of NXT: Redemption before letting him go.

With a sharp new haircut, Bateman arrived on IMPACT as Ethan Carter III, Dixie Carter's insufferable nephew. The gimmick had people rolling their eyes initially. Dixie Carter's presence on screen as a heel authority figure had bombed hard and EC3 was feared to be merely an extension of her angle.

Instead, he cut the finest promos of his career, had a genuinely great blood feud with Rockstar Spud of all people and went on a heat-building unbeaten streak. EC3 managed to strike a chord with the often deflated IMPACT crowds, drawing genuine hatred for his spoilt brat antics. Assuming the mantle of top heel quicker than anyone in the promotion's history, EC3 became the show's must-see star for several years.

The high anticipation surrounding his WWE return was matched only by its eventual disappointment. Eating pin-falls left, right and centre in the NXT midcard, EC3 wasn't even granted the chance to speak when he moved to the main roster. The Top One Percent wound up getting totally jabronified by WWE and has sadly failed to live up to his original IMPACT run in the years since.


5. Gail Kim

Gail Kim TNA
IMPACT Wrestling

The sky appeared to be the limit for Gail Kim when she arrived in WWE. Winning the Women's Championship in her June 2003 debut, Kim went on to lose it just four weeks later. From there, she tumbled down the card into obscurity before being unceremoniously let go in November 2004.

Moving over to TNA in 2005, Kim initially worked as AMW's manager before finally transitioning into a full time wrestling role in 2007. With a brand new Knockouts Division and title on the way in, Kim started a steady push to the top. As the inaugural champion, she went to war with the monstrous Awesome Kong and reached new heights as a performer.

The pair rocked the house with hard-hitting, main event bouts at a time when the concept of a women's revolution in WWE was unthinkable. Proving she could be a best in the world calibre talent, Kim left TNA for another crack at WWE stardom in 2009. Despite the stellar reputation she'd built up since last time, Kim's second WWE run was even more disappointing.

Fed up with the handling of women's wrestling in WWE, Kim eliminated herself during a battle royal in protest of creative telling her to be eliminated within the first minute. The incident led to her being taken off TV for the remainder of her contract.

Having been given nothing of note, the understandably frustrated Kim returned to IMPACT and stayed there until her retirement in 2019.


4. Austin Aries

Austin Aries Tna
TNA.com

A-Double's initial TNA run as Austin Starr was nothing to write home about. Unhappy with his new persona and schedule, Aries was suspended due to his attitude and refusal to tape some promos on a day he believed to be his day-off. Heading back to ROH, he enjoyed a career renaissance with the vainglorious 'The Greatest Man Who Ever Lived' persona.

Now a much bigger star than last time, TNA rehired Aries as a tentpole for their X-Division moving forward. Catching on with fans in record time, Aries became an increasingly prominent figure throughout 2012 with even Hulk Hogan putting over his abilities. In a massive upset, Aries put an end to Robert Roode's record-setting world title reign to firmly establish himself as a main event talent.

Aries' well-received 'Option C' angle with the X-Division title became a staple of the show for several years after. By the time Aries left, he was more popular than ever and ready for a WWE run. Due to behavioural problems that have come to plague him in recent years, Aries' WWE run was short-lived and he returned to Impact to rule once again.

Aries' world title work throughout 2018 was on par with his previous main event run with the promotion. His bouts with stars like Pentagon Jr. and Johnny Impact were hot main events for the promotion. Sadly though, as good as his work was, Aries was once again unhappy with his booking, unceremoniously bowing out after his Bound for Glory bout with Impact.


3. Robert Roode

Bobby Roode TNA
Impact Wrestling

The Glorious One's time in WWE has been a mixed bag. On one hand, there's his excellent NXT title run from 2017. On the other, there's everything since. While Roode was moving up a bit in the age category by the time WWE signed him, he still had plenty more to give than he's been allowed to.

Roode's lengthy run in TNA showcased both his talents and his consistent improvements year to year. Starting out as a member of Team Canada, Roode was repackaged as a scummy rich guy before really finding his feet as one half of Beer Money Inc. with James Storm. Carrying the tag division like old pros, it seemed to be just a matter of time before Roode and Storm moved on to main event singles action.

Following a surprise heel turn on his tag partner, Roode went on the best run of his career as the Leader of the Selfish Generation. As TNA's world champ, the shameless Roode kept a death grip on his title, committing all manner of underhanded hijinks to keep it around his waist. Along with garnering a good deal of heat for his behaviour, Roode ensured an aura of prestige surrounded the title by treating it as the most important thing in the world to him. One can't help but feel his talents have ultimately been wasted in recent years.


2. Bobby Lashley

Bobby Lashley Impact Grand Champion
Impact Wrestling

The current WWE champ was tipped to be a major player all the way back in 2005. Debuting as a soft-spoken, hard-hitting powerhouse for WWE, he began a slow burn push to the main event. While Lashley had all of the athletic tools to reign at the top, he hadn't quite found his voice and persona yet.

After leaving WWE under mysterious circumstances in 2008, he eventually rebuilt his name as a crossover star by wrestling for TNA whilst fighting in Bellator. Now boasting legit fighter cred, TNA presented Lashley as a beast on the level of Brock Lesnar in WWE. Implementing more MMA-focused offence into his style, the Dominator was more than convincing as the deadliest man in the promotion.

Lashley eventually got so over with the Impact Zone faithful that the bookers moved ahead with putting every title they had on the big man. He also improved leaps and bounds on the microphone and was the backbone of the show in a time where it was otherwise struggling. His matches with the likes of Kurt Angle, Brian Cage and Drew Galloway (definitely worth a watch before this year's 'Mania) remain his finest work in the ring to date.


1. Christian Cage

christian tna
ImpactWrestling.com

Captain Charisma was the number one t-shirt seller in WWE at one point in 2005. To cash in on his popularity, WWE took away his RAW main event prospects and dumped him in the SmackDown undercard. Beyond frustrated with his ever-lowering ceiling in the company, Christian jumped ship to TNA where he was awarded a surname.

The Instant Classic received a mega push right out of the gate, quickly defeating Jeff Jarrett for the NWA title. While TNA's heavy emphasis on former WWE talents was typically cause for eye-rolls, Cage's back breaking efforts on top quickly won over fans and peers alike. His exceptional babyface work was topped only by the heel run that followed. Giving old pal Edge a run for his money in the detestable villain category, Cage's second run with the world title remains one of the best in company history 14 years on.

Having proven himself to be a main event level star, Cage returned to WWE, sacrificing his surname in the hopes of reaching the pinnacle there also. While a grudge feud with Jeff Hardy was initially on the cards, internet spoilers led to him making an anaemic debut on ECW instead.

Christian was never presented as a first class act in WWE, with both of his world title runs in 2011 booked to give him zero credibility. Given the general disappointment of WWE's treatment of him, it's hardly surprising he jumped ship to AEW this year.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

John Cunningham hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.