10 Wrestlers Who Have SERIOUSLY Regressed In The Ring
Asuka, Nakamura, Wyatt - Who else has found their match quality going downhill?
Wrestling is, without a doubt, one of the most demanding athletic industries in the world.
Performing to a high calibre with so little time off and the pressure of being watched by thousands is something most people will never come close to understanding. There's no doubt that to even be at the lowest level of this business; you need to be good. But that doesn't mean it's not obvious when someone's in-ring work hits a decline.
The wrestling world is full of great performers constantly vying for the top positions in their respective companies, and thus, those seated at the top aren't always safe. Just as one new star is made, another younger talent starts to make a name for themselves, so superstars have to work hard to stay consistent.
With all the work, pain and effort that goes into being an excellent in-ring performer, it's no surprise that so many once in a lifetime talents begin to regress. It doesn't mean they don't still have incredible value, just that their abilities within the ring have started to lag a little behind.
These wrestlers are all worthy of your respect, even if their five-star days appear to be behind them...
10. Baron Corbin
If anyone told you - at any point during his career - that they were confident Baron Corbin would be a future Hall of Famer, then you'd have been well within your rights to laugh them out of the room. With that being said, it's not too much of a stretch to say that the explosive work of Corbin during his initial days in the company did impress.
It's a far cry from the work he performs regularly now.
When he burst onto the NXT scene with his new look in 2014, he caught everyone's attention. His awesome array of moves like the Deep Six and epic End Of Days finish made him seem so unique, and the shortness of his matches also helped with this. He seemed like an unstoppable lone wolf, but once he made his way out of NXT and short squash matches, his struggles became clear.
During his time on the main roster, Corbin's flaws would become far too obvious. As the clock ticked by - bringing us to right now - his matches have become a chore to watch, as his lumbering pace, lack of investment and dull presentation turn his bouts into snore-fests. Not even his classic signature moves can make up for it now.
9. Shinsuke Nakamura
If Corbin's fall from grace could be compared to tumbling down Mount Snowden, then his current rival Nakamura's is like losing your footing on Mount Everest.
The King of Strong Style cultivated his nickname, persona and incredible in-ring prestige in the world of NJPW. While in that promotion, he became a company ace, and a lot of that success came from his incredible in-ring work. Nakamura's ring style combined brutal strikes with an explosive move-set and was tied into a neat package thanks to his overt showmanship. So, when he joined WWE NXT in 2016, the thought of what he'd do was mouth-watering.
Thankfully for fans, it didn't just start great, but incredibly, as his debut bout against Sami Zayn at NXT TakeOver: Dallas is still considered one of the most iconic matches in the company's history. Oh, how the mighty have fallen.
This star still brought all his quirky character work and charisma with him, but it became clear quite soon that WWE weren't getting Nakamura at his best. As a result, his matches took a steady decline, with his disappointing WrestleMania 34 showdown with AJ Styles becoming the norm for him.
Nowadays, his matches are serviceable, but their slow pacing and lack of individuality aren't what you'd expect from this icon of the business.
8. Matt Hardy
Matt Hardy's entrance music used to say he could "slap a tornado", nowadays he might be able to handle poking a storm at best.
While Hardy has declined in his in-ring performances, the man is still brilliant, as his wrestling abilities have been on a slippery slope for some time, but he's kept himself relevant thanks to his unique character work and forward-thinking. Still, that doesn't mean he'll be standing toe-to-toe with Kenny Omega anytime soon.
It's not very often that you see "Big Money Matt" in the ring anymore, as he's transitioned chiefly to a valet/manager position. But whenever he does step in - like in the recent Double or Nothing Casino Battle Royale - it's clear that his age is catching up to him.
Seeing the older Hardy brother in the ring now clarifies that he's regressed, as his movements are often quite fumbling, and he can't move very quickly. He can still hit some moves, but they don't look nearly as damaging as they used to.
His character work will keep him going for a long time, but there's no doubt that he's slowed down inside the squared circle.
7. Bray Wyatt
For the sake of fairness, it seems necessary to point out that a lot of Wyatt's declining match quality has come from the company's over-reliance on gimmick. How exactly are you supposed to do your best work with projections of cockroaches, red lighting and Alexa Bliss bleeding oil while sat on a Jack in the Box? Wrestling is strange sometimes.
Still, even without these unnecessary additions, Wyatt's performances have been lacklustre compared to his earlier years. When he first debuted the character on the main roster, he seemed like a future HOF member, not just because of the gimmick but because his in-ring work was so exciting. This led to classic matches, such as his Royal Rumble bout against Daniel Bryan in 2014, that stole the show.
However, watching his matches now, it's clear that the magic is gone. His offence is not convincing at all, and even when he's afforded more freedom to perform without the supernatural stuff, he still doesn't match up to his old self. Case in point, his strap match against Bryan at the 2020 Royal Rumble, which was Bray's best work in The Fiend persona, and was decent but didn't match up to his old self.
Even at his best, he has still regressed. If you'd been as poorly treated as him, you'd probably fall behind as well.
6. Robert Roode
Robert Roode may have until recently been one half of the SmackDown Tag Team Champions, but that doesn't mean his match quality has been golden. Looking at his position on the card and how he's faired in the company thus far, it is safe to say that he may have hit his peak in TNA.
This former member of Beer Money Inc. came to WWE as an illustrious figure, with a decade worth of experience as a top-tier talent. At first, he seemed to carry this legacy with him, as Roode quickly became a significant fixture in NXT and held championship gold.
His in-ring work had a distinct feel to it, as although it was slow, it was also methodical, old school and full of great storytelling. He put on some solid matches with the likes of Shinsuke Nakamura and Drew McIntyre, and while he wasn't "exciting" to watch, he still proved his worth. However, looking at him now is like night and day - or Bobby and Robert.
The former TNA World Champion's matches have gone from feeling planned out and traditional to simply blasé and boring. While that could be blamed on the fact he's in a tag team, it shouldn't be, as the man spent his formative years in that same division in TNA and made a name for himself with it.
5. Samoa Joe
It hurts to put the Samoan Submission Machine here, especially after his untimely WWE release. However, his time spent inside the squared circle has indeed regressed from his glory days. That doesn't mean he's lost his magic, as Joe is still terrifying to watch in the ring, but he's no longer the five-star matchmaker type.
Towards the end of his time in WWE, Joe was killing it outside the ring on commentary because of injury. Now that he's been released from the company, fans might get to see him step back into the ring for another promotion, and while that is a tantalising prospect, it probably won't live up to the legacy he's left behind.
His multiple decade-spanning career has been mostly full of highs, as the big man's agility, submission expertise, and unique offence made him one of the most exciting wrestlers outwith the world's biggest promotions. When he finally made it to WWE, he was hotter than the sun and even found success on the main roster, coming ever so close to dethroning Brock Lesnar.
But his booking became inconsistent, and so did his matches, as the singles bouts in the latter stages of his career - like the Kofi Kingston Extreme Rules PPV match - were a shadow of what you'd expect from this icon. His movements were slower, his agility was shot and he lacked the hungry fire he once had.
4. Jeff Hardy
This list already has one of the Hardy Boyz in it. Unfortunately, it's time to take a look at the other, as both of them are clearly showing signs that their time at the top of the wrestling world has finally dissipated. Unlike his older brother, Jeff's in-ring work has taken a larger tumble, as he used to be considered one of the most exciting and creative in-ring performers of his time. Now, not so much.
The multiple-time World Champion's return to WWE alongside his brother in 2017 came with the promise that we might finally see the Charismatic Enigma make it to the top of the card and stay there. But that hasn't been the case, as he's mostly tottered around in the midcard.
Nowadays, you don't see a huge spotlight on the colourful star, as he's mostly a multi-match competitor and any feuds he does see are lacklustre - looking at you, Elias. When it comes to his work inside the ring, it's clear that his time performing death-defying stunts might have been what made him so exciting, as his move-set isn't all too strong, and he moves at a much slower pace now.
At the age of forty-three, it makes sense that he isn't the high-flying superstar he used to be. But that has made his matches feel like a pale comparison to his past.
3. Chris Jericho
Chris Jericho is the oldest performer on this list, and the fact that he's still able to go as well as he can at the ripe age of 50 is astonishing. But you're lying if you say that his in-ring work is at the same calibre as it used to be. Like the intelligent performer he is, he knows how to hide his flaws, but they still seep through the cracks from time to time.
At the tail end of his WWE career, it was clear Jericho was starting to slow down, as his matches weren't quite as spectacular as when he was writing The List. After his time in NJPW and jump to AEW, it became clear that his in-ring performances were starting to slow down, and lack that sense of pacing and variety they used to have.
Le Champion is by no means done with wrestling, and he's still putting on entertaining showdowns. But his age is starting to show as his matches tend to focus on more story-driven angles as opposed to the wrestling prowess he made his name with. Nevertheless, this is a smart move and will keep the legend going for years to come.
2. Asuka
Asuka's latest year in WWE has been blistered with poor booking and a lack of spotlight, even though she was the Raw Women's Champion. However, bad choices from creative haven't been the only thing bringing the formerly undefeated star down, as her matches have also regressed from what fans became used to with her.
It's hard to think of a performer who has had a better time in NXT than Asuka, as she absolutely dominated the brand's women's division. She did so with vicious matches that were uncomfortable to watch, thanks to her harsh strikes and painful submission holds. This turned her into a star, and that star did remain when she transitioned to the main roster; it just didn't shine as bright.
In her last year, the spectacle of Asuka's matches have declined, as she doesn't feel as dangerous anymore. This has led to a variety of disappointing matches, with her potentially show-stealing WrestleMania battle against Rhea Ripley in particular falling way short of expectations.
She'll hopefully be able to pick herself up sometime soon, but as of right now, it seems not even Asuka is "Ready for Asuka".
1. AJ Styles
AJ Styles came so close to being Vince's "one that got away". This decorated TNA alumnus was the biggest thing outside of the company before his debut, and after he finally stepped foot into WWE, he ultimately proved why.
Styles had one of the best rookie years in WWE history and was consistently putting on future classics with the likes of John Cena, Chris Jericho and The Undertaker. But his incredible speed, precision and show-stealing qualities are no longer present in his matches.
AJ still has the potential to steal the show, as was made clear with his SmackDown TV match with Daniel Bryan, which rocked the house down. Still, he's gone from being in the top three best matches of every single PPV to a dependable performer who is consistent, but no longer the highlight.
Many people forget that Styles is 44 years old, the same age as John Cena. It's easy to overlook this as he felt like such an underground hit for so long that he felt inherently youthful. But it seems that his age has been holding him back, and while he's still putting on good matches, he's not as phenomenal as he used to be.