10 Wrestlers Who REFUSED To Win

Rare times when wrestlers refused NOT to do the job... including the story of the REVERSE Montreal!

Edge WWE
WWE.com

There are plenty of situations and scenarios where wrestlers have refused to lose over the years. Look to Hulk Hogan beating Shawn Michaels clean at SummerSlam (2005) even though HBK was an active wrestler on Raw every week or Stone Cold Steve Austin getting so fed up with creative that he walked out on WWE when they booked him to lose to ‘The Next Big Thing’ Brock Lesnar on Raw or Survivor Series (2017) where Bret Hart rejected every idea the WWF threw at him for Shawn to go over.

Pro wrestling is scripted/predetermined but Superstars take great care in making sure their characters remain strong and over on TV. Fragile egos runs rampant in the wrasslin’ business, as Vince McMahon and other promoters have extensively learnt from experience. There’s a blurred line between character and performer, hence the egos.

Issues commonly arise about the outcome of a match. CM Punk, Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose for example thought it was moronic Punk was booked to win over The Shield at the TLC: Tables, Ladders & Chairs PPV (2013) in a 3-on-1 handicap match but they couldn’t get the finish changed.

There are known cases though of wrestlers refusing no matter what to win a match. Where wrestlers feel so strongly about losing that they won’t accept any other outcome.

Let’s look at 10 instances where wrestlers have straight-up refused to win...


10. Bret Hart Refused To Defeat The Rock - (Raw Is War 31/03/97)

Bret Hart The Rock
WWE.com

Bret ‘The Hitman’ Hart and the Heartbreak Kid Shawn Michaels were considered the two best and biggest Superstars signed to the World Wrestling Federation in ’97. The endless competition between the two of who was better bell-to-bell brought out a lot of ego, with them falling out and fighting for real backstage on many occasions. A big difference between the two though was Bret tried to make talent and Shawn tried to hold them down.

Bret’s spoken of how Shawn and Triple H ganged up and made Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson’s life hell when he first started in the WWF. Shawn saw Rock’s potential and tried to hinder it (which is a large reason why Rock rejected pitches for him to wrestle HBK in the early ‘00s).

Bret immediately saw Rock’s potential too but tried to cultivate it. On an episode of Raw Is War Bret was told to go out and beat Rocky Maivia, who was a rookie struggling to find his feet in wrestling at the time, for the Intercontinental Championship but Bret made a point of getting the finish of the match changed to a DQ, knowing it would only bury Rock if he beat him for the title. Bret and especially his brother Owen went to bat for Rock when he was first starting out, something Rock never forgot.


9. Brock Lesnar Wanted To Put Goldberg Over (Survivor Series 2016)

Brock Lesnar, Goldberg
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar losing is a rarity. So it’s almost shocking to learn he refused to win a match against Goldberg (who hadn’t wrestled in 12 years) at Survivor Series. The match came together after the moderate success of Goldberg being announced as the pre-order bonus for the upcoming WWE 2K17 video game, with Paul Heyman convincing the higherups in WWE it would be a spectacle for Goldberg to return to face ‘The Beast Incarnate’. Goldberg has spoken how originally he was supposed to only come back for that one match and put Lesnar over.

It was only the night before Survivor Series that the finish of the match got changed. Brock didn’t want to lose to Goldberg as he saw too much money and potential on the table. So Lesnar and Heyman again orchestrated Goldberg to have an extended run in the company up until WrestleMania. They mapped out a storyline where Goldberg would go over and squash Lesnar to the shock of everyone. Then he would eliminate and humiliate Lesnar once more at the Royal Rumble. Then finally Lesnar would get the much-desired win back at WrestleMania 33.

Lesnar and Goldberg’s first match together got booed out of the building at WrestleMania XX. A stark contrast to the hellacious match they had at ‘Mania 33 that popped the crowd big.


8. Edge Refused To Break The Undertaker's Streak (WrestleMania XXIV)

Edge The Undertaker
WWE.com

In a 25-minute thriller The Undertaker made Edge tap out to Hell’s Gate to win the World Heavyweight Championship in the main event of WrestleMania 24. But this was not always the plan.

There have been rumblings over the years there were a few wrestlers under consideration to break Undertaker’s Streak before Brock Lesnar F5’d it away at WrestleMania 30, like Randy Orton at 21 and Mark Henry at 22. But The Deadman’s real-life wife Michelle McCool confirmed in an interview the rumour of Edge being heavily under consideration to break The Streak at WrestleMania 24 was true. Not only that, Edge was the one to straight-up refuse to break it. McCool commented:

“Actually I remember at WrestleMania (24) versus Edge they talked about Edge breaking the streak. It was Edge that was actually like, ‘That makes zero sense. I don’t want to do that. Why would I do that?’ The fans already love him. What’s it gonna do for Edge? It was Edge that went to bat for the streak. I know they had talked about it prior to the match with Brock, but you know it happened.”

Edge was a well-established main event heel in 2008 when WrestleMania XXIV took place, inciting genuine heat from audiences. He didn’t need the Streak win. Lesnar though, whilst established, rode the momentum of ending the Streak and became an unstoppable force in the years that followed, headlining big events and becoming “the reigning, defending, undisputed, heavyweight champion of the world!”


7. Curt Hawkins Refused To Beat... ANYBODY! - (2016-2019)

Heath Slater Curt Hawkins
WWE.com

In 2016 WWE were in severe need of reliable talent to fill the gaps in their rosters after going ahead with the brand extension. One of the wrestlers signed to help was Curt Hawkins. Hawkins remerged on SmackDown with an Eva Marie-like gimmick where sudden unfortunate incidents stopped him from competing. When he did finally get in the ring Hawkins picked up a win against Apollo Crews in November 2016 which would be his last victory until April 2019.

He went on a mammoth losing streak. WWE management didn’t particularly notice or pay attention either as they booked him to finally get a win over Heath Slater on some secondary lower-card show. Curt rejected the idea when it was given to him, claiming his losing streak was picking up fan support and when it eventually got broken it should mean something.

Curt explained:

"I was supposed to beat Heath on like Superstars or Main Event, and that was when finally I went to a writer. I made him go to Vince. Can you tell him I'd rather not? It was in Barclays, and he said something like, 'Let Hawkins get one in his hometown.' I was like, 'I'd rather not.’ Let's see where this goes, and I just knew that organically, if I just committed to it, something would come of it. I didn't realize how much I was going to lose, but it finally did pick up steam where I truly felt like people were invested in my matches like they had never been before."

On the WrestleMania 35 kickoff show the streak finally came to an end when Curt and Zack Ryder beat The Revival for the WWE Raw Tag Team Championships, with Hawkins scoring the pin with a roll-up for his team. It was a career highlight for Hawkins.


6. David Sammartino Does A Reverse Montreal (House Show In Philadelphia)

In the mid ‘80s David Sammartino was a talent the WWF used high on the card whenever he was involved in an angle with his legendary father Bruno. When he wasn’t he would soon drop to the bottom end of the card in forgettable appearances. David started noticing this, quitting the WWF on numerous occasions only to be convinced to return later.

In 1985 David Sammartino took on Big Ron Shaw at a house show for the WWF. David was booked to get a quick victory over Ron at the show but this didn’t happen. David was angry with the company at the time, knowing they creatively had nothing for him. So he made a point of going against instructions and refused to lose, wanting to make a joke out of the outcome. In the match Ron locked in a bearhug (Bruno’s finisher) on David and he immediately tapped out. The commentators were taken aback and even tried to cover it up.

The moment was christened ‘The Phantom Submission Match’ in wrestling folklore. David has admitted he was immature and young doing it, but ultimately frustrated at being solely used by the WWF to entice Bruno to come back.


5. Ric Flair Calls An Audible To Avoid A Riot - (Wrestling In The Dominican Republic)

Ric Flair Jack Veneno
Pro Wrestling Illustrated/ George Napolitano

Jack Veneno was a local legend in the Dominican Republic in the ‘80s. His charisma and charm on wrestling events made him an icon on the island. Ric Flair meanwhile was the travelling and defending NWA Heavyweight Champion that drew massive audiences and crowds wherever he went. A match was arranged between the two in ’82 that grew to be legendary and heavily controversial.

Ric was supposed to go over in the match, and that was always the plan right up until the very end of the match. Ric sensed there would be a full-scale riot and didn’t know if he would make it out the arena alive if he beat Veneno 1-2-3 in the ring. “Rowdy” Roddy Piper accompanied Flair on the trip to get involved in the match. Piper was supposed to interfere towards the end of the match to screw Veneno out of the gold. But when Piper tried to interfere real soldiers surrounding the ring pointed their rifles directly in his face.

Flair hastily improvised, instructing Veneno to roll him up with a small package for the impromptu win. Veneno won and was announced as the new NWA Champion. The National Wrestling Alliance back in America was livid at the outcome and didn’t recognise the title change in their history books.


4. Cody Rhodes Wanted To Make Darby Allin A Star - (Fyter Fest 2019)

Cody Darby Allin
AEW

Cody Rhodes was a big supporter of bringing Darby Allin into All Elite Wrestling when it launched in 2019. He saw the ability and natural charisma Darby possessed on the indie circuit and pushed hard for him to be signed to a contract.

Cody squared off against Darby at Fyter Fest (2019) in a match he was supposed to win, with AEW President/Owner Tony Khan wanting the victory for Cody to help certify him further in fans eyes as one of AEW’s main eventers going forward. Cody was going to challenge Chris Jericho for the AEW World Championship in a big-time match later that year at Full Gear (2019).

Cody refused the win though, wanting to lose to make Darby a star. Cody and Tony eventually came to the compromise of the two going to a 20-minute time limit draw instead. Tony commented afterwards: “Cody absolutely did not want to beat Darby, absolutely did not want to beat him. God bless him for that. It was a great call.”

Tony finally saw the massive potential Darby had after Fyter Fest, so at Full Gear (2020) Darby went one step further and won the TNT Championship from Cody with a roll-up.


3. Tommy Dreamer Refused To Lose To Raven (ECW)

Raven, Tommy Dreamer
WWE.com

Tommy Dreamer and Raven’s legendary feud in Extreme Championship Wrestling had an absorbing backstory of them being childhood friends who drifted apart and went their separate ways, with Beulah McGillicutty being introduced as the heartbroken girl out for vengeance. But it largely centred on Tommy never being able to get a victory over Raven. Tommy on so many occasions was the loveable loser and Raven was the villainous victor.

In a two-year long feud Raven beat Tommy at Holiday Hell ’95, December to Dismember ’95, Three Way Dance and all the house shows. But this was all intentional and set-up by Tommy genuinely not wanting to beat Raven. Any suggestion from Owner Paul Heyman that he win one Tommy shot down. He wanted to go his entire career coming so close to but without ever beating Raven. That and not winning the ECW World Heavyweight Championship, feeling it would only hurt his hardcore underdog character.

Unfortunately for Tommy events out of his control led to Heyman pleading with him to drop his beliefs and not only win the ECW World title (after ECW lost active wrestlers to WWF/WCW and injuries) but finally pin Raven at Wrestlepalooza ’97 in a Loser Leaves Town match after Raven signed with WCW. Dreamer hit Raven with his DDT to finally have his arm raised that night, much to Dreamer’s real-life annoyance.


2. Chris Jericho Convinces Vince McMahon That John Cena Should Win - Vengeance 2002

John Cena Chris Jericho
WWE.com

Post-WrestleMania 18 ‘The Living Legend’ Chris Jericho was coming down from a career high of becoming the first Undisputed Champion and headlining ‘Mania against Triple H. He was tasked to work with an upcoming rookie by the name of John Cena.

Cena had debuted in June and showed some “Ruthless aggression!” against Kurt Angle in his debut. He then was programmed into a feud with Jericho, with Jericho picking up a win over him in a singles match on SmackDown by using his feet on the ropes. The following week Cena teamed with Undertaker to take on Jericho and Kurt Angle, with Cena pinning Jericho this time around with a roll-up. This led to a PPV match at Vengeance, which Jericho was booked to win. Jericho though saw the untapped potential in Cena and put his foot down to the chairman that him winning was the wrong move.

Jericho recalled:

"I remember I called Vince the night before the show and basically told him that me winning was the wrong finish. It should be John. Vince didn't see it. I said, ‘I'm telling you this guy has got something.’ Vince was like, 'Fine. Put him over if you want.' And that was kind of the beginning with John."

So at Vengeance Jericho hooked in the Walls of Jericho only for Cena to roll him up for another surprise win.


1. Scott Hall Puts Chris Jericho Over - (Nitro 03/11/97)

Chris Jericho knows to help younger talent because that’s exactly what some of the elder statesman did with him when he was coming up in the business. Like how Scott Hall would always give him enough offence that fans got behind him in their matches in WCW. Scott went one further for Jericho at a Nitro show in ’97.

There was always rumours The Kliq in the WWF held down and bullied talent but Scott Hall is underappreciated for going out of his way for putting over rookies like the 1-2-3 Kid on Raw and helping Diamond Dallas Page get over in WCW. It was his demons that got the best of him throughout his career but everyone agrees he’s got a great mind for the business (having done training seminars at WWE’s Performance Centre and newcomers study his masterful heel work as Razor Ramon in the WWF).

It’s evident in his match with newcomer Chris Jericho on Nitro from November ’97 where Jericho shockingly picked up a victory over the nWo founder. But this wasn’t always meant to be the case. Hall was supposed to beat him senseless.

Hall, not satisfied with the booking, flipped the script and called an audible with Jericho that night. Hall’s said of the match:

“I was just supposed to keep hitting Chris with the Razor’s Edge, just keep dropping Jericho on his head until (Larry) Zbyszko came down. And I said, ‘Chris, but that’s not going to get a reaction.’ I said, ‘Think of some way to beat me out of my finish and get with me later’, so he came up with the idea to kick his feet off the turnbuckle and small package me and I said, ‘Don’t tell anybody. I’ll take all the heat.’ So when I came back through the curtain (after the match), Arn Anderson’s there at the Gorilla position just shaking his head, going, ‘You’re too much’. So now I’m walking back towards the locker room and I pass Eric Bischoff and he looks at me and he goes, ‘Didn’t I tell you to go over?’ and I’m going, ‘You’re telling me you didn’t like my segment?’ and he’s going, ‘No, no, but weren’t you supposed to win?’ and I said, ‘Does it really matter?’ and he just throws his hands up in the air.”


Watch Next


In this post: 
EDGE
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Rex Jones hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.