10 Wrestlers Who Should Have Been NXT Champion

Which wrestlers would have benefited most from a run with the NXT Championship?

tyler breeze nxt champion
WWE.com

Over the past few years, we have witnessed the call-up of many of NXT's finest stars, but they do not all enjoy the same level of success on WWE's main roster.

In Orlando, a wrestler can look like a million bucks and be treated as a superstar by the Full Sail crowd, and yet, when it comes time for them to debut on Raw or SmackDown, only some of them reach those same lofty heights while others become mired in mediocrity.

If you look at the NXT call-ups over the past few years, the key variable is clearly whether or not that competitor won the elusive NXT Championship. Former champions Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn both wrestled John Cena in their first main roster encounter, while Finn Bálor pinned Roman Reigns clean to the mat on his first ever Raw. Debutants without the NXT Title win have gone on to mill around the mid-card, be involved in cringe-worthy angles, or be dismissed from the company altogether.

This list details just some of the talent that has passed through Full Sail that would have benefited hugely from being crowned champion of developmental.

10. Baron Corbin

baron corbin
WWE.com

Until quite recently, Baron Corbin would have been very close to the top of this list.

Despite making an instant impact in a debut WrestleMania victory that many WWE hopefuls would kill for, Corbin stagnated in a seemingly endless feud with Dolph Ziggler and made fans question why he had been rushed onto the main roster. The' Lone Wolf' had carved himself a solid role on NXT television and looked poised to enter the championship scene at any time, but the moment never came.

Since the brand split, where he was selected in a premium spot for SmackDown Live, as a destructive heel Corbin has regained some of his lost momentum. Now looking to go into WrestleMania 33 in a strong position, one could argue whether the NXT Championship really would have aided his progression. That would however be forgetting those middle months of 2016 where Corbin was finding it nearly impossible to gain any traction with the fans. Had he arrived as a former NXT Champion perhaps his ascension would have come earlier.


9. Curtis Axel

Curtis Axel
WWE.com

An argument could be made for a great many members of The Nexus to return to NXT after John Cena obliterated the stable's credibility, but Curtis Axel, then named Michael McGillicutty, was among the lucky ones who was afforded a fresh start away from the main roster.

Axel's NXT run was brief, as WWE planned to repackage him as Paul Heyman's newest client. While that seems on paper like a dream scenario for an up-and-comer, Axel crumbled under the weight of expectation that went with having the same manager as CM Punk and Brock Lesnar. He wasn't around in NXT long enough to be a part of the TakeOver boom, but had he been he would have likely been a top contender for face of the brand.

Boasting the Mr Perfect lineage, Axel could have easily played the dastardly NXT Champion that babyfaces like Neville and Sami Zayn needed to overcome. Instead, Axel has torn through a whole host of gimmicks in an attempt to salvage his main roster career.


8. CJ Parker

CJ Parker
WWE.com

Whether you agree with this entry or it utterly baffles you will heavily depend upon your exposure to New Japan Pro Wrestling. It is there that former NXT superstar CJ Parker is thriving as Juice Robinson, an eccentric foreign babyface who the Japanese audience is really starting to get behind.

The fact that a rival promotion has found the star quality in a talent where Triple H could not is probably something the WWE won't be shouting about. The fact remains however, that had they kept Juice on the roster, he could have developed into an integral part of NXT instead of 'the guy who Kevin Owens squashed in his debut'.

It is indeed possible that Parker needed to make the transition to Japan in order to find his feet at the top flight of wrestling. Had he been able to work out the kinks in his character while still in Orlando, it's tough to believe he wouldn't be NXT Champion by now, if not already a part of the main roster.


7. Solomon Crowe

solomon crowe
WWE.com

Going by Solomon Crowe in NXT, independent performer Sami Callahan seemed to be working with an intriguing enough hacker gimmick, but it ultimately failed to secure him any significant television time. Though he wrestled a handful of NXT live events, the veteran of CZW, PWG, and now Lucha Underground never quite managed to secure the faith of the WWE officials in Orlando.

Crowe had the talent and the charisma, but he saw no obvious route to success in Triple H's system, ultimately deciding to return to the independents in late 2015. What we must remember however, is that 2015 was the year of NXT. Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, Hideo Itami, and Finn Bálor were all raising the bar and changing wrestling fans' understanding of the term 'developmental'. Had Crowe stuck it out in this competitive era, he would likely have found room opening up in 2016 when most of the brand's top stars were moving on. His talent alone would certainly have propelled him into the NXT Championship picture eventually.


6. Austin Aries

Austin Aries takeover
WWE Network

Aries' NXT tenure was not becoming of 'The Greatest Man Who Ever Lived'. For starters, you could have counted the number of televised matches he had on one hand: he was outdone as a babyface by the debuting Nakamura, before quickly turning heel, when his long-awaited feud with Hideo Itami never materialised.

As he is now demonstrating on Raw and 205 Live, Aries has an infectious charisma that has quickly become one of the most consistent attractions of WWE's Cruiserweight Division. It makes fans wonder why he was never involved in the NXT Title scene, and the answer is quite clear: he was overshadowed by other incoming veterans. Nakamura took a vice-like grip on the surging babyface role, while his former TNA brethren Samoa Joe and Bobby Roode had the top heel persona covered.

Aries' stellar work on commentary has fortunately led to his transition back into an in-ring role. There is no doubting however, that he would have been one of the first names tied to WWE's Cruiserweight division had he entered the main roster as a former NXT Champion. Had he not been overshadowed, his elite skills would have made him a perfect ambassador to represent the NXT brand as champion.


5. Tye Dillinger

Tye Dillinger
WWE.com

Tye Dillinger's absence from NXT television, coupled with his debut at the number 10 spot in January's Royal Rumble, likely indicates that The Perfect 10 will finally be a part of WWE's main roster. While it would be absurd to say that his main roster run is doomed before it has even begun, we must consider the correlation between winning the NXT Title and success on Raw or SmackDown.

The NXT brand has developed to the point where the NXT Champion is more than just the best of the developmental bunch. It means you are on par with some of the biggest names in wrestling, like Samoa Joe and Shinsuke Nakamura. By not winning the title, WWE is implicitly telling us that Tye Dillinger is not that.

Though he never carried NXT's top strap, Dillinger is incredibly popular and that could translate into a meaningful spot on the main roster. There is no denying however, that his chances of doing so would have increased had he been treated as a truly elite talent in the developmental system.


4. Kalisto

kalisto smackdown
WWE.com

Like many of the entries on this list, Kalisto's main roster career has not been completely devoid of merit. A two-time United States Champion, he brought the belt into WrestleMania 32, albeit on the pre-show. The problem is that since then he has been allowed to stagnate dramatically. The baffling decision to keep him away from the new Cruiserweight division has left him without any true cause, moving in and out of mid-card feuds with the likes of Corbin and Ziggler.

Kalisto arrived on the main roster as a former NXT Tag Team Champion alongside Sin Cara, eventually breaking off on his own as it was clear he was the more exciting of the two. Had he worked longer in NXT however, Kalisto could have made an epic underdog run towards the NXT Championship. Had he actually won it, he could have debuted with the same hype as Rey Mysterio. Instead he's currently just doing some Lucha things.


3. Tyson Kidd

Tyson Kidd
WWE.com

Tyson Kidd's run on NXT television was a blessing to any of the up-and-comers that he encountered during his time there. It was clear that the man needed nothing to do with a developmental system, but simply hadn't been able to squeeze out a meaningful spot on the main roster. Kidd worked with the likes of Zayn, Neville, and Breeze to add a sense of legitimacy to the NXT brand as it was beginning its TakeOver era. He competed for the top belt, as a wrestler of his experience should have done, but he never won the title.

Kidd winning the NXT Championship would have been less about giving him a better chance to succeed on the main roster, as he eventually found his niche alongside Cesaro. For him to win the NXT Title would have been more about respect for a veteran who was willing to work on television with less experienced competitors, elevating them and the brand itself to an elite level. If by some miracle Kidd returns from his spinal injury, hopefully he will be afforded the respect he clearly deserves.


2. Tyler Breeze

Tyler Breeze
WWE.com

During his long tenure in NXT, Tyler Breeze worked incessantly to get his obnoxious male model character over. Through his on-screen antics and in-ring capability, Breeze gained massive popularity with the Full Sail audience and stayed in stride with some of the top stars of developmental, including Neville, Zayn, and Finn Bálor.

Despite being viewed as on-par with these guys, he never captured the NXT Championship as they did. Failing to secure the belt after several opportunities, Breeze arrived on the main roster with a whimper rather than a bang. To debut on SmackDown prior to the brand split is a damning enough indictment of what the WWE believed they had in him.

Breeze is now trying to work a second miracle, getting over a 'fashion police' gimmick with Fandango. The pairing is certainly fun, but it's highly unlikely that a former NXT Champion would have been involved in a sunburn angle. Breeze simply lacks the respect that the company affords the standard bearers of their developmental system. While it could be argued he did plenty to promote the emerging brand, he never held that one, true symbol of success in NXT.


1. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews
WWE.com

Apollo Crews, both as a character and a competitor, epitomises what the NXT Championship should be about.

Entering the developmental system with as much hype as any prospect, Crews struggled at first to get over with the NXT fanbase. His talent was undeniable, but his blind optimism and awkward name change hindered his climb up the NXT totem pole. What was almost certain however, was that Crews would eventually follow in the footsteps of Sami Zayn and Finn Bálor by completing his quest to become the brand's champion. Instead, he was brought to the main roster.

This move baffled the collective WWE fanbase. For one, it devalued the NXT system when a mid-carder was favoured for promotion over more obviously ready performers like Bálor and Samoa Joe. Secondly, WWE fans had become accustomed to high-impact main roster debuts from the likes of former champions Zayn and Owens. To then see a performer who had made no moves towards the NXT Championship debut on Raw was a bit of a bizarre start.

Crews has floundered disastrously on the main roster. When you compare it to Finn Bálor's debut a few months later, it is clear that Crews would have gained substantially from an NXT Title push.


Contributor
Contributor

University of Edinburgh student, freelance writer and all-round banter merchant.