10 Wrestlers Who Took Kayfabe WAY Too Seriously
There's commitment, and then there's that...
In the modern age of dirt sheets and vats of mimosa, kayfabe isn't quite what it once was.
For decades, the gibberish word was the key to wrestling culture, something that professionals upheld at all times. To kayfabe was to simply maintain the illusion of reality, with stars often going to great lengths to attempt to convince audiences that their personas, angles, and matches were far more legitimate than fans know them to be.
While blurring the lines between fiction and reality has frequently been a money-making strategy for professional wrestling, some instances have simply gone way too far. From prompting real-life conflicts and scandals to simply hindering their own health and well-being, a wide variety of wrestlers' total commitment to their craft has led to chaos.
With matches and angles going awry, or non-wrestlers biting off more than they could ever hope to chew in the face of some of the industry's countless hard cases, the dark side of kayfabe is almost as compelling as the good stuff. In the ever-controversial, colourful world of professional wrestling, certain instances of kayfabe being stretched too far stand out scarily more than the rest.
10. Chris Jericho
Chris Jericho's 2012 run in the WWE saw him portraying what essentially amounted to a heel troll character. From making light of CM Punk's familial issues to encouraging audiences to cheer for him only to bail before wrestling or cutting a promo, Y2J was on especially irritating form.
One crowd that did not appreciate the future Demo God's heat-seeking behaviour was the fans in attendance for a São Paulo house show in May of that year. In a bid to rile the fans up, Jericho snatched up a Brazilian flag and kicked it, almost prompting a riot in the process. The police in attendance then gave the rambunctious veteran two options: either apologise on the spot, or spend the night in jail.
In a desperate bid to cool the escalating tension, Jericho quickly broke character and kayfabe mid-match to apologise to the crowd. Desecrating the flag is an imprisonable crime in Brazil, and Jericho's commitment to playing a disrespectful villain almost cost him dearly.
While the show went on without any further issue, Jericho was slapped with a 30-day suspension for his antics, ruining a potentially hot feud with Randy Orton that was on the cards at the time.
9. MJF
The Salt of the Earth's commitment to maintaining kayfabe beyond the ring has won him plenty of praise over the years. However, considering his obnoxious jerk persona, it's led to some rather unpleasant fan encounters as well.
Earlier this year at Revolution, MJF retained the AEW World Championship in an instant classic iron man match with Bryan Danielson. At one point, the champ threw a drink at an infant fan, prompting a fresh garnishing of boos in the process. Unfortunately, the cheap heat moment was not pre-planned, and the fans involved were less than pleased.
The incident drew criticism within the wrestling sphere as well, with even long time super heel Ric Flair dismissing it as a step too far. Fellow AEW star Scorpio Sky was also unimpressed, dissing the fans who thought MJF's actions were entertaining.
Another incident occurred back in June, when the Long Islander went to knock the hat off of a ringside fan, and wound up doing considerably more damage, sending the fan's glasses flying. Despite being on the biggest run yet in his young career, these recent antics have left some wondering if the Burberry enthusiast is taking his persona a little too far.
8. The Boogeyman
Former Tough Enough competitor Martin Wright put his absolute all into his long-awaited arrival on the main roster. Unfortunately, that arrival came at the grim, worms-laden cost of portraying The Boogeyman.
Sporting red, black, and occasionally yellow face paint, Wright would foam at the mouth, smash clocks over his head, and gyrate bizarrely on his way to the ring. A key facet of the grossout gimmick was The Boogeyman's penchant for snacking on worms. Dead set against fakery, Wright made munching on legit worms a staple of his gig, feasting on the slimy, limbless creatures on TV, PPV, and house show events.
As if endangering his health on a nightly basis wasn't enough, Wright would frequently sport a beekeeper's mask when travelling to further preserve the aura of mystery. The good news about the mask was it disguised another key piece of maddened commitment from the colourful star: his teeth.
After losing several of his bottom teeth during his stint in OVW, Booker T's biggest tormentor opted to not have his grill fixed. The logic was simple: missing teeth would add to the overall creep factor of his new, horror-inspired persona. Despite the maddened dedication to the character, Wright never quite progressed past the undercard novelty act level.
7. JBL
In 2004, longtime tag team wrestler Bradshaw was reborn as JBL, a true titan of cheap heat. Mercilessly dissing every town he visited, the arrogant Texan would have the crowds riled up before he even got to the actual angle he was working that week.
Unfortunately, a trip to Munich saw him take the act too far, right in the midst of his first proper main event push. During a house show bout, Layfield did the unthinkable and threw up a Nazi salute, much to the horror of the German audience.
In Germany, such behaviour is considered a criminal act, something JBL quickly learned the hard way. At the time, he'd enjoyed a side gig working as a financial analyst for CNBC. In light of the backlash from the incident, however, the American news channel dropped the WWE star.
On the bright side for Layfield, Fox News didn't seem all that fussed with his eyebrow-raising antics, and he went on to do financial analysis there soon after. WWE, who were badly starved of main eventers at the time - with Brock Lesnar and Goldberg gone, and the likes of Kurt Angle and Shawn Michaels dealing with injury woes - moved full steam ahead with the JBL super-push that came to dominate SmackDown all the way up to WrestleMania 21 the next year.
6. John Tenta
Arguably best known for that time he crushed Hulk Hogan's ribs in a heated post-WrestleMania VI angle as Earthquake, John Tenta endured a litany of odd gimmick re-packagings throughout his pro-wrestling run.
Originally a sumo wrestler, the gargantuan Tenta's bicep tattoo of a tiger was covered up throughout his run in the sport. In Japan, tattoos are widely frowned upon thanks to their prevalence in Yakuza culture. Considering the difficulty Tenta's ink had caused him, surely he wouldn't go and do something silly like, say, getting a much larger tattoo done over it...
Unfortunately, Tenta's inexplicable dedication to a new persona in WCW prompted him to do just that. In 1995, the behemoth was handed a new, shark-themed character. In a staggering show of commitment to being The Shark, Tenta got in the tattoo chair for a total session time of 24 hours to have his tiger piece covered up with a far more sizeable ocean predator.
Considering the gimmick came and went quicker than an RKO outta nowhere, Tenta's efforts looked utterly ridiculous not long after they were first unveiled. Eating pinfalls like they were going out of style, the Shark persona was a long, sad fall from the Canadian super heavyweight's brief run as a Cartoon Era beast.
5. Sabu
The 1994 edition of ECW's November to Remember event saw a potentially thrilling bout between Chris Benoit and Sabu get badly derailed. Seemingly going for a flapjack, Benoit threw the hardcore icon in the air, who proceeded to land directly on his head and neck in a grim, contorted mess.
The match was quickly stopped, with the injured Sabu being rushed out of the venue whilst Too Cold Scorpio was hurried in as a surprise replacement. Much like his legendary uncle, The Shiek, Sabu was a big believer in committing to kayfabe to get his dangerous persona more over. Unfortunately, the gimmick required a lack of speaking on Sabu's part, making life especially difficult for the doctors who had to communicate with him at the hospital.
Given his potentially broken neck, failing to break character was a life-threatening decision on the real-life Terry Brunk's part. Fortunately, Paul Heyman, who was managing Sabu on-screen at the time on top of his booking duties, was present to sort the fiasco out.
Incredibly, despite the severity of the injury, Sabu was back in the ring just two weeks later, continuing to amaze and terrify audiences with his chaotic, high-flying style.
4. Umaga
Umaga's '06 monster push saw him dismantle everyone from legends like Ric Flair to two very unlucky members of the Jackass cast.
Steve-O and Chris Pontius were enjoying a predictably goofy segment on Monday Night RAW when the Samoan Bulldozing Machine made his presence felt. The real-life Eddie Fatu's then-new gimmick saw him don face paint and savagely plough through the opposition, crushing them with explosive Samoan drops and devastating top rope splashes.
When the big man mauled the two pranksters, Steve-O's selling left a lot to be desired. Essentially breaking kayfabe to enjoy a good laugh at the more adequately selling Pontius, the man with a tattoo of his own face on his back incurred the scarily real wrath of the Samoan star. Perpetually in character, the vicious heel enjoyed a beastly aura that had been enhanced by his opponents selling like death. Getting back in the ring, Umaga handed out a new, considerably less protected beat down of the self-destructive entertainer until he finally stayed down and sold accordingly.
Stiffly slamming Steve-O repeatedly, Umaga received an alarmed, out-of-character plea from Jerry Lawler on commentary to ease up. Johnny Knoxville has since confirmed that the real-life Stephen Glover suffered a concussion from the mishap.
3. Hulk Hogan
Considering his notoriously safety-conscious style, there's something cruelly ironic about The Hulkster coming under legal fire for working stiff with a non-wrestler.
During a 1985 episode of Hot Properties, Hogan made an appearance to promote the upcoming first WrestleMania. Also on the show was comedian Richard Belzer, who initially had a merry old time joking about with the then-face of the WWF.
The initially lighthearted segment collapsed into chaos when Hogan slapped a chokehold on Belzer. Shockingly, Hogan wrenched in the hold way too tight on the comedian, who was far thinner and smaller than the usual folks The Hulkster tussled with in the ring. Belzer turned pale, and soon lost consciousness, collapsing on stage much to the horror of those watching.
Hogan, who'd been on the receiving end of some jokes from Belzer on the broadcast, essentially dropped the comedian from the hold, leading to him bumping his head on the way down. In character for the show, the future nWo leader's alarming incident here highlighted the fine line between scripted entertainment and real-life consequences.
A legal battle raged between the pair, with them ultimately settling out of court in 1990.
2. Antonio Inoki
The likes of Jake Paul and KSI should count themselves lucky a menace like Inoki isn't competing in their celebrity fights. When the New Japan founder squared off with the iconic Muhammad Ali in 1976, it was not all fun and games, but rather a grim showcase of Inoki's obsession with maintaining the realism and legitimacy of professional wrestling.
Under the tutelage of catch wrestling legend Karl Gotch, Inoki went through a hellish training regimen for the bout. Ali, meanwhile, stepped into the ring in boxing gloves, showboating ahead of a match with a bizarre ruleset that forbade his opponent from grappling, tackling, or throwing standing kicks.
Inoki took to the mat and threw kicks from the ground, badly hobbling The Greatest over 15 punishing rounds of combat that left audiences worldwide scratching their heads. The puroresu megastar later claimed that Ali and co. expected a more performance-oriented exhibition, whereas the architect of strong style was determined to keep it real. The damage done to Ali's legs was horrific, with blood clots threatening a potential amputation.
The notoriously harsh Inoki went on to pulverise others in the name of kayfabe, including The Great Antonio the next year, who was beaten into a bloody, unconscious heap after no-selling and going off-script. Bizarrely, the 21st century saw the Rikidozan student set kayfabe alight, from inexplicably interrupting a match to punch a young Shinsuke Nakamura in the face to calling off a match in IGF because he wasn't enjoying it.
1. David Schultz
During a 1984 episode of ABC's 20/20, famed TV host John Stossel questioned the legitimacy of professional wrestling. The problem was he questioned it in front of a fully in kayfabe David Schultz. Enraged by the audacity of being asked whether or not his craft was a work, Schultz slapped Stossel silly on camera. Both stiff shots from Schultz sent the reporter to the ground.
The quick beating unsurprisingly garnered widespread controversy and coverage, with the Nashville-born grappler quickly coming under fire.
Suspended from the ring by the New York State Athletic Commission for his actions, Schultz was quick to apologise. However, it was simply not enough in the court of public opinion, with Stossel complaining of hearing damage and nagging pains two months after the incident. Schultz was later cut completely from the promotion after a rumoured altercation with Mr. T. Interestingly, Dr. D has denied the validity of the story, claiming he merely had a word with the Rocky III star. Regardless, police were purportedly called in and Schultz was later dropped from the promotion, having simply caused too many troublesome incidents.
Curiously, Schultz has since claimed that his decision to stay in character and rough Stossel up came from none other than Vince McMahon himself. While the validity of his claims is debatable, it does confirm that it was indeed the attempted preservation of kayfabe - right at a time when the business was starting to get seriously exposed - that led to the Stossel blow up.