10 Wrestling Combinations That Shouldn't Have Worked But Did
These odd couples shocked everyone with how much they got over.
Sometimes a wrestling combination just makes sense.
The Undisputed Era was made up of four guys who all cut their teeth in Ring of Honor, the Blackpool Combat Club is comprised of realistic fighters with a connection to William Regal, and Right to Censor contained a pimp and a porn star who'd both been brainwashed into seeing the errors of their ways.
Other times, however, a pair or group of performers come together with seemingly no rhyme or reason. They may have totally opposite gimmicks, come from totally different eras, or just have absolutely nothing in common.
Most of the time, combos like this flop and disappear within a month or so. But, every now and then, an unlikely partnership strikes gold and the wrestlers or managers involved have their careers changed forever.
That is exactly what happened with these ten examples. All ten were seemingly thrown together at random, only to somehow make it work and create a truly memorable act.
Don't judge a book by its cover, all that glitters is not gold, and never ever discount a wrestling combination by the way it looks on paper.
10. Rhea Ripley And Dominik Mysterio
One of the best wrestling transformations of 2022 has been Dominik Mysterio's turn from mullet-loving daddy's boy to full-on goth.
After he turned on Edge and his own father at Clash at the Castle, Dom joined up with The Judgement Day and has barely left Rhea Ripley's side ever since.
Ripley made a habit of intimidating the younger Mysterio in the weeks leading up to the turn, but this is clearly something Dom is into, as it's what eventually led to him moving over to the dark side.
Both parties have played their roles in the partnership perfectly; Dom as the subservient follower and Rhea as the dominating manipulator. It's a brave direction for WWE to take, but one that has worked out pretty well so far. It's made a new man out of Dom, added a memorable edge to Rhea's character, and has elevated the entire Judgement Day faction.
Dominik had been crying out for some character prior to his heel turn, but nobody could have predicted that his character would from being part of an implied sadomasochistic relationship.
Still, it was better than his old personality, which was... umm... umm... nope, nothing.
9. The Acclaimed And Billy Gunn
Few could have predicted that The Acclaimed and The Gunn Club teaming up for some skits would have led to one of those teams becoming AEW Tag Team Champions.
After a couple of confusing weeks of each team turning on each other and then turning back, their break-up was solidified when Austin and Colton Gunn attacked their father on an episode of Dynamite. Max Caster and Anthony Bowens made the save, reuniting with Daddy Ass.
The root of this combo's success can be described in four simple words - "Scissor Me, Daddy Ass!" This catchphrase took over the wrestling world and turned the talented duo into megastars almost overnight.
Of course, it helps that both Caster and Bowens are super charismatic and that Billy always looks pleased as punch whenever he's with The Acclaimed. Ironically, he looks way prouder of them than he even did with his own kids.
Whilst this pairing may not last forever, it's almost guaranteed that "Scissor Me, Daddy Ass" will live on in the hearts of minds of wrestling fans for the rest of time.
8. Glamarella
Santino Marella has had a few memorable romance angles over the years, but his dalliances with Maria and Emma have got nothing on the time he was loved up with Beth Phoenix.
After Phoenix wrestled and beat Santino on an episode of Raw, they began to develop strange feelings for each other. This led to Glamarella, a nod to Santino's surname and Phoenix's nickname, "The Glamazon".
Whilst they were definitely an odd couple, Pheonix's no nonsense attitude and Marella's bumbling comedy really complimented each other. She was the perfect straight woman to his hapless antics and the crowds absolutely lapped their segments up.
The pairing also led to championship success, as Glamarella defeated Kofi Kingston and Mickie James to win their respective Intercontinental and Women's Championships.
This was the title reign that saw Santino introduce the "Honk-a-Meter", comparing his run to that of The Honky Tonk Man's - yet another brilliant feature of Glamarella's time together.
Glamarella came to a tragic end when Santino entered and won the Miss WrestleMania Battle Royal as "Santina", causing Beth to get jealous. Not the greatest of finales for the couple, but at least we'll always have the memories.
7. Darby Allin And Sting
Aside from face paint and a penchant for the colour black, there wasn't really much that connected Sting to Darby Allin when the Stinger made his AEW bow.
Sting was a decorated legend with over a dozen World Championship reigns under his belt, whilst Darby was a scrappy up-and-comer with a blatant disregard for his own body and well-being.
But none of this stopped them from teaming for Sting's first match in AEW - a cinematic encounter against Team Taz's Ricky Starks and Powerhouse Hobbs.
This return match set the tone for the rest of the pair's run in AEW. It presented Sting as much darker than we'd been used to, fusing his mystical WCW persona with Allin's grungy, punky demeanour.
Darby's love for endangering himself also seemed to rub off on the older fella. Over the following months, Sting went from competing in pre-taped matches to taking full-on bumps to diving off balconies through tables in his early 60s.
Rather than the legend teaching the youngster a few tricks, it was the other way around with Sting embracing Darby's lifestyle and earning legions of new fans in the process.
Just watch your hips, Sting, they really aren't what they used to be.
6. Booker T And Goldust
Booker T and Goldust first came together after the former was unceremoniously booted out of the New World Order. Despite initially rejecting Goldust's advances, Booker eventually let The Bizarre One in and two got over with a series of sketches featuring some hilarious movie parodies.
The team were a classic mismatch with Booker constantly in shock and horror at Goldust's strange and often disturbing actions. However, over time, the pair grew to like each other just as much as the audience grew to like them.
Their popularity inevitably led the duo to challenge for the World Tag Team Championships on numerous occasions. They were unsuccessful at SummerSlam and No Mercy in 2002, but finally won the big one at Armageddon that year. Unfortunately, this feel-good moment only translated into a three-week reign for the pair.
Ultimately though, this was for the best, as Booker was being primed for a singles run against Triple H for the World Heavyweight Championship. Even Goldust acknowledged this when he asked to amicably split from Booker so he could focus on his singles career.
A nice moment, but let's move on before we find out how that Booker T/Triple H feuded ended...
5. The Broserweights
Before there was RK-Bro, Matt Riddle was part of another odd couple pairing in NXT, alongside The Bruiserweight, Pete Dunne.
Dunne's ultra-serious demeanour was the perfect foil to Riddle's wacky personality and the two got seriously over with fans, leading them to not only compete in the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, but to win the whole thing.
Then, they cashed in their shot at the NXT Tag Team Championships, unseating The Undisputed Era at NXT TakeOver: Portland in 2020. Big things were surely in the pipeline for both Riddle and Dunne, but their time together was about to be cruelly cut short.
TakeOver: Portland took place just a few weeks before the Coronavirus pandemic completely changed the world. Part of that change meant that international travel was basically non-existent, leaving Dunne stranded away from Riddle in his native England.
This led to Riddle finding a replacement partner in Timothy Thatcher, only for him to turn on Matt and lose him the titles.
The Broserweights were a fantastic act that were sadly cut short by external influences. However, with Triple H now in control, could we see this storyline get its proper conclusion on the main roster?
4. Heath Slater And Rhyno
If you ever feel left out or ignored, then just remember that Heath Slater was the only person not drafted in the 2016 Brand Split.
Not content with being left on the sideline, Slater demanded to get hired. After all, he "had kids" to feed. After an appearance on Raw led to a disastrous interaction with Brock Lesnar, Heath focussed his efforts on the blue show, especially the tournament for the SmackDown Tag Team Championships.
It was agreed that, if Slater could find a partner and win the tournament, then he would earn himself a contract. That partner arrived in the form of Rhyno, who had been attacking Slater in recent weeks. Now all this unlikely pairing had to do was win the tournament.
At Backlash 2016, Slater and Rhyno overcame the odds and beat The Usos to become the first ever SmackDown Tag Team Champions. Not only that, but Heath had gotten himself hired, leading to a double whammy of elation from the crowd.
Not only were Slater and Rhyno a fantastic combination, they also had a great storyline carrying them through the tournament. The duo's popularity was so strong that they are steaming together in Impact Wrestling. Now that's longevity.
3. Kane And X-Pac
Kane has had his fair share of odd couple partners over the years - Daniel Bryan, The Hurricane, Rob Van Dam - but the one that started it all was his partnership with X-Pac.
Both men found themselves exiled from their respective groups following the merger of The Corporation and DX at WrestleMania XV, and so found comfort in each other.
X-Pac did a lot for the evolution of Kane's character, helping him win the heart of Tori and even encouraging him to speak for the first time.
Although, depending on how you like your Kane, this may not be a good thing.
This little and large combo were an extremely successful tag team, winning the World Tag Team Championship twice. But this success was not to last, as X-Pac betrayed his Big Red friend to re-join DX.
Even if it did end in tragedy, Kane and X-Pac's friendship was one of the most emotional of the entire Attitude Era. They were two outcasts who found each other and helped each other to grow, only for one to cruelly turn on the other in pursuit of fame and fortune.
It's a tale as old as time, only this version had pyrotechnics.
2. The Miz And Damien Mizdow
Damien Sandow's stock looked to be on the rise in WWE when he won Money in the Bank in 2013. Unfortunately, this was just the beginning of the end.
After Sandow lost his cash-in match against John Cena, he plummeted down the card to become a jobber of the lowest order. Thankfully, Sandow had a knack for impressions.
Playing into his movie star persona, The Miz decided that he wasn't going to endanger himself any more than he had to. He got himself a stunt double, who was Damien Sandow dressed exactly like The Miz and given the new name "Damien Mizdow".
Mizdow took the role and ran with it. He would copy The Miz move for move, including taking the same bumps as he did when he wrestled. He even got himself a mini version of the tag team titles when he and Miz won them at Survivor Series 2014.
This shouldn't have as entertaining as it was, and full credit has to go to Sandow. He took a gimmick that could have died a death after a week and turned it into one of the best of the entire year.
1. The New Day
A Jamaican. A powerlifter. A PhD student. It sounds like the start of a bad joke, but it was actually a start of one of the best factions in WWE history.
The New Day got its humble start when Xavier Woods offered to help out the tag team of Big E and Kofi Kingston in 2014. All three men were at a low point in their careers, both in kayfabe and real life, so now was the time to take a chance.
From their origins as a gospel group, to their first heel turn, to KofiMania and everything in between, The New Day have been a constant presence in WWE without ever getting stale.
Their continued popularity is testament to the real life friendship of all three men and they serve as an inspiration to any wrestler who is ever debating taking a chance on themselves.
When this group started, it seemed like just another random stable that would be gone in a few months. But, through sheer determination of those involved, The New Day have defied all expectations and will no doubt one day take their place in the WWE Hall of Fame.