10 Wrestling Gimmick Matches That Only Happened Once

One time's a charm.

Dean Ambrose Asylum
WWE.com

Without any effort at all, you can probably reel off about 15 to 20 gimmick matches that have, over the years, become veritable staples of professional wrestling.

Whether WWE's planned 50-man Royal Rumble - which is scheduled to take place (probably untelevised) next month in Saudi Arabia - joins this ever-growing list remains to be seen. There are few clues at present as to whether the company plans on making it a permanent part of its calendar.

Given just how many match-types have fallen by the wayside, however, we probably shouldn't get our hopes up. Wrestling's creative geniuses can always - and you suspect, will always - be relied upon to come up with harebrained ideas which sound great on paper, but whose flaws are immediately made clear the second they are put into practice.

Inexplicably, the Punjabi Prison Match is not among them. In fact, WWE saw fit to dust the cobwebs off The Great Khali's playhouse as recently as last year when Jinder Mahal and Randy Orton met at Battleground for the world title. Proof, if it were needed, that someone backstage is trolling us.

10. House Of Horrors

Bray Wyatt Randy Orton House of Horrors
WWE.com

Bray Wyatt's House of Horrors - not to be confused with the "compound" on which his army of brothers tangled with The New Day a couple of years ago - has only hosted one WWE match to date, and the strong likelihood is that it will not do so again.

Mostly, this is because the format just isn't palatable for fans in the arena, who at Payback last year only got a viewing experience you would ordinarily associate with a premium-rate WWE live event when The Eater of Worlds and opponent Randy Orton rocked up in the ring for the final two or three minutes.

Up until that point, they watched the action unfold on a screen like the rest of us. And we're using the word "action" liberally here: much of what we were seeing less resembled a wrestling match than it did a sequence from a low-budget horror movie overly reliant on jump scares.

By definition, a trick of this kind - trying to pull in extra subscribers by promising a wacky match familiar to nobody outside of Vince McMahon's circle of trust - can only work once. They may pull out something similar in the future, but it almost certainly won't go by the same name.


9. San Fransisco 49ers Match

Booker T Scott Hall
Dailymotion

WCW - and specifically, if you believe online reports, Vince Russo - absolutely loved gimmick matches in which an object is placed on the end of a pole attached to one of the turnbuckles. If you could hit someone with it, they put it on a pole.

Of these matches, the San Fransisco 49ers Match that took place on an episode of Nitro from October 2000 stands out. Here, they didn't just put one object on the end of a pole, but four - one for each corner of the ring.

One box, naturally, contained the World Heavyweight Championship, with the remaining three instead offering a novelty item: a blow-up doll, a glove, and - best of all - a framed portrait of Scott Hall, of which Booker T was particularly unimpressed by.

There's no reason for this match to ever happen again, but if it did our one piece of advice to anyone attempting to replicate its, ahem, success would be to use sturdier boxes. In the climactic moments to the first one, the belt ended up falling out of the bottom, and the ring, as the winner went to claim his prize - which isn't exactly highlight reel material.


8. Asylum Match

extreme rules asylum match
WWE.com

In his capacity as a complete lunatic (whose finisher is a DDT variation), Dean Ambrose personally invented his own gimmick match back in 2016 as way of settling the score with long-time adversary Chris Jericho at Extreme Rules.

In essence, the Asylum Match - so named because Y2J had put his opponent in a straight-jacket in the build-up - was just a Steel Cage with a roof, except that hanging from the roof were some of the most dangerous weapons you can get in WWE.

Comparisons between this and TNA's Lethal Lockdown variant were drawn, but the latter actually works much better. Since it features teams rather than singles competitors, wrestlers can scale the cage to collect weapons while their colleagues hold the crowd's gaze down in the ring.

With Ambrose's match, however, there were several prolonged sequences where we were literally watching nothing but the competitors trying to retrieve the things with which they would then be hitting one another. It ended up being more than 25 minutes long in total, and you felt every second of it.


7. Duchess Of Queensbury Rules Match

Duchess Of Queensbury
WWE Network

Gimmick matches often feature an elaborate structure that engulfs the entire ring, or at the very least a usually-not-seen weapon hanging from one of its turnbuckles. The Duchess of Queensbury Rules match, however, relies principally on comedy.

We got our first (and, to date, only) glimpse of this format at Backlash in 2001, where William Regal and Chris Jericho - two of the out-and-out funniest men ever to lace up a pair of wrestling boots - tussled under the watchful eye of, you guessed it: The Duchess of Queensbury.

The brilliance of this match was that she was the only one in the arena who knew the rules. When Y2J went for a pin, she informed him the round had expired; when he went for a submission hold, she told him tap outs didn't count.

It wasn't a technical masterclass, obviously, but it brought a sense of fun to a match that may otherwise have gone the way of all the other forgettable mid-card bouts of the Attitude Era. It's exactly the kind of thing that they should do more of (of course, in moderation) today.


6. Fish Market Street Fight

TNA Destination X 2008 Fish Market Street Fight
ImpactWrestling.com

A great many wrestling match-types have been conceived by affixing a few random words (typically, the name of the location in which it takes place) onto the already-established "Street Fight". See, for example: Greenwich Street Fight, Philadelphia Street Fight, and so on.

But TNA went one better than this at Destination X 2008 with its Fish Market Street Fight. Here, the match was so named not because of its location - like all TNA pay-per-views, it was held in the Impact Zone - but because there was loads of fish at ringside.

And not just fish either; there was also a fishing rod, which was used by Curry Man as a means of offence against Bubba Ray Dudley. You're probably imagining him beating him over the head with the handle, but no - he actually tricked his opponent into biting the hook on the end of the line by dangling a piece of cod in front of his nose.

Obviously, this was completely ridiculous, but at least it was self-consciously ridiculous. The TNA creative team knew they weren't breaking any new ground here, but instead putting a fun spin on an otherwise drab and unremarkable match-up.


5. Biker Chain Match

Brock Lesnar The Undertaker No Mercy 2003
WWE.com

The Undertaker's gimmick matches, like the man himself, tend to stick around longer than normal. The Casket Match, for example, has become a staple of WWE pay-per-views over the last 20 or so years (though he wasn't strictly the inventor), with Buried Alive wheeled out every now and then too.

But the Biker Chain match - in which he faced Brock Lesnar for the WWE Championship at No Mercy 2003 - has only gotten one airing, a consequence of the fact that Big Evil was soon to undergo yet another radical image change.

Since he hasn't returned to his biker guise since (and, all things considered, probably won't be doing so any time soon), there's been no occasion for him to start attacking an opponent with motorcycle paraphernalia.

It's not really a huge miss either. Like all on-a-pole matches, this one was soured somewhat by its inherent lack of suspense. You know that neither competitor can go for a pin until they've actually pulled down the object in question, and that once they have it's probably not going to be long before the final bell.


4. Blindfold Steel Cage Match

Blindfold Cage Match Lockdown 2007
TNA

TNA has gotten a lot wrong over the years, but by popular consent Lockdown - a pay-per-view on which every match takes place inside Six Sides of Steel - isn't one of them. In fact, it was almost always one of the best wrestling shows of the year.

That said, it's hard to ignore the toe-curling disaster that was Chris Harris versus James Storm at the 2007 edition of the event, a match notable for the fact that both men wrestled it with bags covering their heads.

Needless to say, as a spectacle, this wasn't particularly compelling. The duo spent most of the near-10-minute run-time grappling the air, and on what few occasions they did manage to get a hold of each other the moves were - for obvious reasons - slower and less impactful than usual.

All of that perhaps would have been forgivable if it was a mere undercard bout contested by, say, Tomko and Scott Steiner - but this was supposed to be a grudge match between the stars of America's Most Wanted. In other words, TNA split up its best tag team for this.


3. Good Housekeeping Match

Good Housekeeping Match
WWE.com

Another variant on the Street Fight, the Good Housekeeping Match was essentially a bout in which competitors were permitted to use "weapons" typically found in one's kitchen, such as an ironing board and a broomstick.

This match, so say online reports, was dreamed up by Vince McMahon as a way to humiliate WCW-bound Jeff Jarrett in one of his final appearances in WWE. He would be beaten up by Chyna, robbed of his Intercontinental Championship, and sent on his way.

And, to give them their due, this wasn't a complete disaster. It actually made for pretty entertaining viewing, not least of all when Jarrett appeared to win the title after nailing his opponent with the title belt, only for the ref to rule that it didn't qualify as a "household object".

Given that this was how WWE heads last bid adieu to the future TNA co-founder, it seems almost incredible that they are now preparing to induct him into their Hall of Fame. Wrestling, so we have come to accept, is pretty weird sometimes.


2. Junkyard Invitational

Junkyard Invitational
WWE Network

In a bid to prove that they could do hardcore wrestling as well, WCW staged a so-called "Junkyard Invitational" at Bash at the Beach in July 1999, bringing together a heavy-blend of cruiserweights and jobbers from the lower reaches of the roster.

The premise here was pretty simple: it was every man for himself, the only way to claim victory - and a trophy (yeah, not a title belt, a trophy) - being escaping before any of your opponents. Oh, and it took place at an actual junkyard.

Like House of Horrors, a big problem here was that fans in the arena just felt like they weren't getting their money's worth. They bought their tickets with the expectation of seeing action unfold inside the ring, not filmed by helicopter at an undisclosed location a few miles away.

But, mainly, this won't be revisited any time soon because of how superbly dangerous it all was. According to reports, several of those involved came away with serious injury, not least of all eventual winner Finlay (and, as they never tire in reminding us, he's absolutely tough as nails).


1. Kennel From Hell Match

Kennel From Hell
WWE.com

Nearly two decades later, it's still something of a mystery as to exactly how the WWE creative team came to convince themselves that Unforgiven 1999's Kennel From Hell Match was anything other than a terrible, terrible idea.

The company trades in wrestling, and though its cast of on-air talent are plenty skilled in the art of flying in and around the ring, they are not thespians. Given that, it seems hugely ambitious to think that they could somehow teach animals to act.

Instead of pacing between the Hell in a Cell and Steel Cage structures staring menacingly at the two competitors, the weapon dogs ostensibly tasked with bringing the match to life just sort of - well, sat there looking disinterested (when they weren't relieving themselves, of course).

For all the wrong reasons, this match is now the abiding memory with which one associates both Al Snow and Big Boss Man. They could have shared a five-star classic at WrestleMania the following year, and this would still be their most Googled moment.


Watch Next


Contributor