10 Wrestling GOATs With ONE Fatal Flaw
Nobody is perfect - not even the best of the best. Featuring, somehow, Bryan Danielson...
Is there such a thing as a flawless professional wrestler?
Hiroshi Tanahashi is all but perfect. Unbelievable at the in-ring craft, he famously worked a match - one that put NJPW on the map and changed everything you know about the modern industry - with zero near-falls. An understated genius who is the master of the "when" to do moves, his babyface run transformed NJPW's fortunes in the early 2010s - but he was also outstanding at playing situational heel to drive support of his underdog opponents in accordance with puro psychology.
Kenta Kobashi was a more pure babyface, one so incredible that few if any have forged quite such an undying bond with their fanbase. Boasting a fire that is unrivalled, the sympathy he evoked should have been impossible. He was a formidable unit of a man.
GUNTHER is almost his heel equivalent, with his similarly impossible balance between invincibility and vulnerability. You can buy into his winning and losing every match. He is on that basis the perfect wrestling champion - and he's become really rather good at selling his guaranteed great matches in promos.
A lack of range is probably a small criticism one could levy at those three names. That's about it.
The following wrestlers are also all-time greats - but...
10. Bryan Danielson
GOAT credentials:
Bryan Danielson is probably the best wrestler of all time. Many have portrayed the role of 'Best in the World'. Nobody has embodied that in the guts of a professional wrestling match like the Dragon. He is able to appear unbeatable, exerting total dominion over his opponent. His job is to be the master, and he does it perfectly.
Re-watch the last 10 minutes of his Iron Man match against MJF at AEW Revolution 2023. A lot of AEW fans, the majority probably, knew the result ahead of time. Logic dictated that MJF, after such a rise and push, wasn't going to lose his first title match on PPV - but Danielson hits logic in the face with a Busaiku. In those incredible moments, lost helplessly in the fiction, it was impossible to see how he would lose. The best technical wrestler ever - those exchanges with Zack Sabre, Jr. at WrestleDream were as intricate as it gets - he's also, just for fun, the best brawler. The best underdog babyface. The best, most nasty domineering heel. Just the best.
Fatal flaw:
In this social media age, in which the real-life person informs the perception of their onscreen character, Danielson has spoken too freely about his lack of ambition. As refreshing as it is to watch a top star do business, Danielson is so selfless that - great as he is at promos nonetheless - it's difficult to buy the idea that he really and truly wants it. This has impacted the true potential of his top-level AEW programmes. His "last run" arc might actually correct that, but did you believe in your heart that he wanted nothing more in his life than to defeat Hangman Page or MJF?
This is pedantic. This "flaw" turns a ******* wrestler into a mere ******3/4.
Danielson is too good to play the first challenger for a newly-minted champion, but he has stigmatised himself in that role.
9. Kenny Omega
GOAT credentials:
Kenny Omega is the best sports-oriented storyteller in wrestling history. With a unique, delayed approach to selling, he understands that the old or "traditional" approach of clutching at a leg is a bit old hat. He uses fatigue, cramping, even a worked botch to convey the sense of struggle. He is the most plagiarised wrestler of his generation. His almost entirely original repertoire is stunning, so it's little wonder, but nobody else does it with his immaculate physical timing. The V-Trigger looks so incredible and sounds so utterly revolting that his not breaking any orbital bones should be a miracle. There's no miracle. He is simply a genius a level above everybody else.
His crumpled 2.99 kick-out is better than anybody's. Consider his rope break from Will Ospreay's Stormbreaker at Forbidden Door. Not a single soul in that building thought he was getting out of it. Omega is so unreal at building drama with his unprecedented athleticism that, every time he ascends the top turnbuckle alongside one of his opponents, it feels like somebody is about to die. His core strength in those frightening moments is inhuman.
Fatal flaw:
A strange reluctance to engage in the process of being a traditional TV star. Annoyingly, it's not as if he's incapable. He was a riot as AEW World champion in 2021, a big draw at that, but since returning from injury, he lacks the same presence. His unconventional approach to episodic storytelling was very compelling between January 2020 and Full Gear 2021 - his subtle use of foreshadowing was ingenious - but too often since then, he just seems oddly removed in non-wrestling segments. He's neither the 2020 nor 2021 Omega at present, the understated storyteller nor the hilarious caricature of a top star. He's a guy on the roster in a good spot.
Why are the two best wrestlers alive too often happy enough to be there?!
8. Shawn Michaels
GOAT credentials:
An undisputed North American in-ring great, nobody threw themselves around the ring like Shawn Michaels up to 1998. A sublime working heel, he was so electrifying but smug in there that it was easy to resent how great he was without ever once being bored. He radiated a sense of smugness in a dynamic, unique way. Where the heels of yore would show ass by getting blown away by a working punch, Michaels bumped to hysterical perfection. He was the Showstopper. As a heel, nobody made catharsis look quite as good. He was never as good as a babyface, and was still amazing in the role. His match against Mankind at In Your House: Mind Games was one of the best and most unique from-underneath performances ever. His 2002 return saw him evolve into a true fan favourite at long last...but...
Fatal flaw:
Michaels was corny between 2002 and 2010, but that is a subjective take. To many others, his emotive work was more elegant and rich than his physical prime. The objective take is that Michaels - in addition to being much too unreliable when he was actually needed - was not a draw. Business was dire when he was on top in the 1990s and, while he was a legend to the most dedicated WWE base, his 2002 return didn't arrest an alarming dip in popularity.
7. The Rock
GOAT credentials:
One of the biggest wrestling megastars ever. An actual household name who "the Casuals" are in fact aware of. He was so transcendently charismatic that it's easy to forget how much of a stud he was in the ring. After 1999, he could have been forgiven for hardly trying. The Rock - whose best lines you've almost certainly stolen in a tragic bid to be as cool as he was once upon a time - had mastered the art of popping crowds with a single raised eyebrow. He could have been Hulk Hogan in the '80s, but he was still an animal in there, blowing heels away with his power game or, when he was a heel, throwing himself around and selling finishers like he was caught in the backdraft of an explosion.
Fatal flaw:
His banter was sometimes shoddy. The Rock was one of the few wrestlers who made wrestling cool, but at the same time, you wouldn't want anybody walking into the room when he dropped a "Kung Pow bitch". Hollywood Rock was one of the funniest acts ever. Still, his problematic material has dated badly, and some of his more innocuous work was weirdly try-hard for a man who was so effortless entertaining.
6. Chris Jericho
GOAT credentials:
Has anybody been as good for as long as Chris Jericho?
As the man himself put it, he was never particularly fast. He could work the in-vogue cruiser style when he first broke through, but, with his eye on the long game, he was almost destined to become a great. He developed a way of working that enabled him to do it for a long, long time. He never absorbed himself into the WWE bubble. He knew when to leave, when to change, when to return, what fans wanted, what they didn't want. He was a super-charismatic composite fan favourite throughout the Attitude Era, knowing that the catchphrase and the aerial was in vogue at the same time, and after a legendary WWE run, he perfected the art of the brawl when even his hardly fast approach to the "workrate match" had been lapped by his disciples.
Fatal flaw:
Beyond his patchy form post-Le Champion, his ability to sense the pulse of the wrestling fandom is almost too keen. He gloms onto almost everything and has developed a rep as a clout vampire as a result. Great as he still is a lot of the time - that match with Tomohiro Ishii, Jesus Christ - he's the rocker who played synths in the 80s and the heavy band who went on a nu-metal misadventure in 1999.
5. FTR
GOAT credentials:
FTR have wrestled considerably more great matches than many of the supposed best tag teams of all time - the tag teams they themselves idolise. With unreal stamina and sense of craft, they are exceptional at moving around the ring at pace to deliver complex, lung-bursting matches overflowing with high drama. The rhythm of their best work is intoxicating; masterful at building tension with next-level ring positioning and dramatic timing, the near-falls in their classic outings generate a breathless atmosphere.
Cash Wheeler is a dynamo boasting the ring IQ to save his propulsive last-ditch bursts deep into the struggle, making it feel as though the stakes are all-or-nothing, while Dax Harwood is so intense and stiff that he's mean as all hell as a heel and a vengeful badass on the hot tag. At their best, they intersect old school credibility with new school to sequencing and plotting. At their worst...
Fatal flaw:
Self-consciousness. For a team that espouses old school virtues and demonises Dave Meltzer - and, by extension, critical opinion - they sure work acclaim-bait matches. This identity crisis is hard to reconcile. The desperation to build a "legacy" often manifests with excess and a tell-don't-show crutch. In more than one match, they have missed an organic peak with an insistence on going hog wild on false finishes. Similarly, they are sometimes guilty of begging for acclaim mid-match, either by not so subtly calling for a standing ovation, overdoing the easy finisher theft trope, or running back the "holding hands when trapped in dual submissions" bit. FTR are great.
They like being great a little too much.
4. AJ Styles
GOAT credentials:
AJ Styles was one of the most exciting wrestlers on the planet and is one of the most influential wrestlers ever. Several thousand acolytes put on a pair of kick pads and attempted to master the hybrid style of aerial, submission and striking at the turn of the 21st century - but none did so with the creativity, snap and exhilaration of AJ. Wasted for years in truth, he evolved into the main event talent everybody except the TNA decision-makers knew he could be in the mid-2010s. His New Japan Pro Wrestling run was legendary. Styles in the heel role was superb at cutting his opponents off. This was genius. The NJPW faithful go banana for a babyface comeback. Styles knew how to deflate them. In WWE, he became a top star against all odds, no pun intended - for a few years, anyway...
Fatal flaw:
AJ hasn't truly mastered the emotional layer of the main event in recent years. Look at his WrestleMania record as evidence. Has he done anything worthy of the 'Mania Moment highlight reel beyond 2017 at a push?
It's not that he hasn't aged gracefully, but also, he hasn't really learned how to work to a high level as a veteran. A true great gets the most out of their declining body. Is that true of AJ? He has wrestled a sobering amount of forgettable three star specials since 2019, and the last theoretically big programme he worked - against Edge in 2022 - was flat and boring. He isn't a must-watch TV star. A lot of the time, he just exists.
3. Brock Lesnar
GOAT credentials:
No other wrestler in the history of the form has summoned the same dread-inducing atmosphere as Brock Lesnar. Even in a spectacularly mean-spirited match against Ricochet - total promotional malpractice that accomplished less than nothing - Lesnar annihilating his utterly hapless opponent spoke to the inner ghoul within. Lesnar is a terrifying and compelling monster even at his worst; at his best, he can make a babyface feel like the best version of himself. Eddie Guerrero; CM Punk; Daniel Bryan: when Lesnar decides he wants to show a bit of ass, his opponent becomes the idealised underdog in the magic throes of suspended disbelief.
Fatal flaw:
Lesnar is more than happy to phone it in. It's one thing to half-kill Ricochet when Vince McMahon tells him that's his job for the night. On one too many occasions in the late 2010s, Lesnar didn't even throw a German with any real conviction nor cruelty. Beyond that, even when he's up for it, his matches are a bit familiar. His WrestleMania 39 main event with Roman Reigns was a cliché of a Paul Heyman finisher spam layout. It should be impossible to grow bored of Lesnar's strictest-definition awesome work - but he's managed that a fair few times.
2. Steve Austin
GOAT credentials:
While his megastar run was shorter than Hulk Hogan's, Steve Austin outdrew him at his brief, transformative peak. Austin was unbelievably skilled in every single facet of the game. He'd top all-timer lists in the fields of technical wrestling and brawling, and it was the latter stylistic shift with which Austin, preeminent badass, became a legend. He was beyond on the pulse. His fiery brawls all around the arena were perfect for the day, his promos were hilarious, and nobody was better at the skit. It was almost unfair that one of the greatest wrestlers of all-time was such an excessively entertaining TV star with an unshakeable bond with his public.
Fatal flaw:
Insecurity and paranoia.
This manifested more than once during his immortal 1998-99 run. SummerSlam '99 was a dire show not remotely helped by his unwillingness to put Triple H over. He was right - Triple H was some months away from becoming truly great - but Austin's keen instincts had a knock-on effect on the fiction. He ate more than one wrestler alive when he returned in late 2000, at which time his paranoia ruined the mood. He knew that the WWF had survived without him, and his presence collided with the joyful tone of Chris Kreski's product.
1. CM Punk
GOAT credentials:
With a mind as sharp as a diamond, Punk was a magician at getting over. How well wrestling ages as a form is hotly debated. Dave Meltzer holds the opinion that wrestling constantly surpasses itself, in no small part because wrestlers of a bygone time only worked for that crowd on that night, but Punk's matches and storylines will stand the test of time. Everything he did mattered and informed itself. When he sold a limb, you could study that limb frame-by-frame and watch, locked in, as he struggled through it. His episodic mastery will be missed hugely in AEW. The man knew how to tell a story - but he was never not the story, either...
Fatal flaw:
Being CM Punk, bluntly.
The total inability to not do things his own way is what drove CM Punk to and away from wrestling stardom. This is what made Punk Punk. His top-rope elbow drop looked like trash, but he had to do it. Nobody was going to tell him otherwise. If he didn't have that belief within himself, he wouldn't have changed pro wrestling. With Punk, a paradox of a man, the flaw is a strength and vice versa.
Yes, Punk could have played nicely and realised that Collision was as good as it was going to get for him and his prized freedom of expression and top star status - but without that boundless conviction and sense of mischief, he would not have sat cross-legged and told WWE down the lens that it sucked.