10 Wrestling Matches With The Most Unexpected Consequences

The Butterfly-Suplex Effect.

WWE SummerSlam 2018 Charlotte Flair Becky Lynch The Man
WWE

Wrestling matches aren't just about two huge dudes slapping against each other for thirty minutes.

Okay, some of them are, but that's besides the point.

They're there to tell stories, to convey the emotions being felt by the fighters in the ring. A good match should serve the same purpose as the episode of a TV show; furthering existing storylines whilst introducing new wrinkles into the narrative.

It's a booker's job to make sure these wrinkles are put in. They craft the story, the wrestlers bring it to life. Sometimes though, all plans get shoved to one side and matches take on a life of their own.

The nature of live entertainment means that anything can happen at any time. You can never truly tell how a match will pan out or how a crowd will react to it. That's definitely the case for these ten matches, which all has consequences far beyond what was expected.

Some of the consequences were good, some were not so good, but they all played their part in changing wrestling history.

They also all did this completely by accident, no matter what WWE try to tell you.

10. Ryback Vs 3MB - Raw 25/03/2013

When Drew McIntyre returned to WWE in 2017, he was a very different performer to the one who got released three years prior.

Firstly, he looked like he'd eaten his previous self, packing more muscles than a seafood shop. Secondly, he had a greatly enhanced move set including a badass new finisher.

The Claymore - a running kick to the face - replaced McIntyre's Future Shock DDT as the Scot's weapon of choice. It was a much more impactful looking move and its popularity aided Drew's eventual rise to the main event.

As said by the man himself, the move was invented by accident. Whilst part of jobber deluxe stable 3MB, McIntyre, Heath Slater, and Jinder Mahal all took on Ryback in a handicap match on a March 2013 episode of Raw.

During the encounter, McIntyre ran at The Big Guy to deliver what was meant to be a big boot. However, because of the ridiculously tight leather pants he was wearing, he couldn't get his leg up. So, to compensate, he fell backwards, hitting a very primitive version of the Claymore.

Drew decided after the match to incorporate the move into his arsenal, and the rest is history.


9. Braun Strowman Vs James Ellsworth - WWE Raw 25/07/2016

Braun Strowman James Ellsworth
WWE.com

Though various allegations against him might have soured some people's view on the man, there was a time where James Ellsworth was an extremely popular part of WWE's roster.

He famously pinned then-WWE Champion AJ Styles (after a heavy assist from Dean Ambrose) and won the first ever Women's Money in the Bank ladder match!

Which makes about as much sense now as it did in 2017.

All of this started for the chinless wonder when he became the first victim of a newly repackaged Braun Strowman.

After failing to impress in The Wyatt Family, Strowman came out on the July 25th 2016 episode of Raw with a new look and a new fearsome attitude. His opponent that night was a jobber by the name of James Ellsworth.

Ellsworth wasn't supposed to get over, but endearing dorkiness and catchphrase "Any man with two hands has a fighting chance" earned him a lot of support. A few months later, Ellsworth was signed to a proper WWE contract.

From a one-off enhancement talent to a staple of the SmackDown roster, Ellsworth made the most of his minutes and turned his 15 minutes of fame into a lifetime of recognition.


8. Bret Hart Vs Goldberg - WCW Starrcade 1999

Bill Goldberg Bret Hart
WWE Network

Ever wondered why Bret Hart has massive beef with Bill Goldberg? This is why.

The main event of WCW's biggest show of 1999 was Starrcade, the company's equivalent to WrestleMania. The main event for that show was a truly tantalising clash between world champion Bret Hart and challenger Goldberg.

During a sequence in the match, Hart bounced off the ropes to take a thrust kick from Goldberg. The master of the Jackhammer must have thought he was back in his football days, because he kicked Hart really hard directly in the head.

Despite finishing the match and working for a few more weeks afterwards, Hart's days in the ring were numbered as soon as the kick hit. He received a major concussion that would force him to take time away from the ring and eventually retire from wrestling for good.

Unless you count that run he had in WWE in 2010, which you shouldn't.

One errant kick was all it took to end one of the greatest wrestling careers of all time. Few could have predicted that such a dream match would end under such tragic circumstances.


7. The Rock Vs Hulk Hogan - WWE WrestleMania X8

The Rock Hulk Hogan Mike Chioda
WWE.com

Speaking of dream matches, fewer have ever lived up to their hype quite like Hulk Hogan vs The Rock at WrestleMania X8.

Upon returning to the promotion with which he made his name, Hogan was immediately put into a programme with Big Dwayne ahead of the biggest show of the year in Toronto.

Hogan was definitely the heel going in. He'd hit Rock's ambulance with a truck for God's sake! However, Canada is backwards-land. How could you forget that?

The crowd cheered Hogan like a returning hero, piling applause onto him like he'd just ended world hunger. What's more, they booed The Rock! How do you boo the Scorpion King?

The crowd's unexpected reaction forced WWE to abandon all plans for a Hogan heel run. He was immediately turned babyface and placed into a programme for the WWE Title.

Aww, that's nice. Give the legend one last shot at the big time before he quietly... oh... he won the title... off the newly-crowned Triple H... right...

Aftermath to one side, the WrestleMania X8 match remains one of the most outstanding in the event's history and proof once and for all that crowds make wrestling matches.


6. The Gauntlet Match - WWE SmackDown 12/02/2019

Kofi Kingston Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

When Mustafa Ali went down with an injury in early 2019, the wrestling community's hearts collectively broke.

He'd just debuted properly on SmackDown, earning a huge win over WWE Champion Daniel Bryan. He was set to be involved in the upcoming Elimination Chamber match for Bryan's belt, until he got hurt.

Kofi Kingston was announced as Ali's replacement to a fairly tepid response.

"Whoopie, it's that guy who's been here forever and has never won the big one. He'll make a decent filler, we suppose."

But we supposed wrong.

During a gauntlet match on an episode of SmackDown ahead of the pay-per-view, Kingston put on a star-making performance. He entered first alongside Bryan, pinning the champion to advance. Then he beat Jeff Hardy, and then Samoa Joe, before finally succumbing to AJ Styles.

Kingston put in the better part of an hour's work in this match and the fans noticed. Off the back of this showing, fan support for Kofi grew and grew. KofiMania was born.

This led to Kingston winning his first ever WWE Championship at WrestleMania 35, a moment nobody could have predicted just two months earlier.

Shame about his actual title reign, but that's for another time.


5. Charlotte Flair Vs Carmella Vs Becky Lynch - WWE SummerSlam 2018

Becky Lynch Charlotte Flair Summerslam 2018
WWE

The SmackDown Women's Championship match at SummerSlam 2018 was supposed to be a one-on-one contest between champion Carmella and Becky Lynch.

Lynch had earned her spot by beating Carmella in a non-title match and saw it as a opportunity to get her career back on track after a few years in the wilderness. Then Charlotte Flair turned up to ruin it all.

Flair also pinned Mella and inserted herself into the SummerSlam bout, much to Lynch's chagrin. Things only got worse when Flair pinned her Irish friend at the event to win the title.

And that's when Becky got mad.

She snapped on Flair, beating her to a pulp and turning heel in the process. The crowd rained boos down on her, as she... hang on, they're cheering her. Why are they cheering her?

They were cheering because fans were just as sick of seeing Charlotte win all the time as Becky was. They viewed the Lass Kicker as an avatar for their own frustrations and supported her wholeheartedly.

This led to Lynch adopting a more braggadocios attitude, which led to her calling herself The Man, which led to WrestleMania 35 and beyond.

Not bad for a botched heel turn.


4. Sheamus Vs Daniel Bryan - WWE WrestleMania XXVIII

Daniel Bryan Sheamus Gif
Youtube

The number 18 followed by the word "seconds" can still be triggering to fans of Bryan Danielson.

Then called Daniel Bryan, the American Dragon was set to defend his World Heavyweight Championship in the opening contest of WrestleMania XXVIII.

The bell rang, but before the action could begin, Bryan turned to give his storyline girlfriend AJ Lee a kiss for good luck. This "good luck" manifested itself as opponent Sheamus kicking Bryan's head off and pinning him to end his reign.

At the time, fans were furious. They felt that Bryan deserved a better ending to his reign than being humiliated at WrestleMania. They saw this as yet another example of WWE burying a wrestler due to their size and they were not best pleased.

This led to a huge swell of support for Bryan. The Yes Movement really started to take effect, with audiences warming to the grappler's hot-headed charm.

You know how this story ends; Royal Rumble 2014, WrestleMania XXX, Bryan winning the world title in New Orleans. It's one of the biggest and best wrestling sagas of the 21st Century and it all began with what many thought was a disaster.


3. The Bella Twins Vs Paige & Emma - WWE Raw 23/02/2015

Bella Emma
WWE

On the surface, there really isn't much to this match at all.

Paige trash talks Nikki, Brie takes her out, Emma gets distracted, Brie hits a Bella Buster and wins. It's all done in about 30 seconds. Paige and Nikki don't even get tagged in.

It is precisely the briefness of this encounter that affords it a sport on this list. See, this half-minute of "action" was the only women's section on the entire three hour Raw show. Fans picked up on this and were not happy.

Tweets began flooding in about how unfairly WWE treated their female performers, how these talented women were getting sidelined based solely on their gender. The phrase "Give Divas a Chance" began trending online and the company took notice.

Over the next few months, things began to change. They changed ridiculously slowly, but they did change. By the end of the year, the much-heralded "Women's Revolution" was in full effect, leading to far more fleshed out women's division we see today.

Give Divas a Chance didn't directly cause the change in the company's presentation of women, but this thirty second match on an episode of Raw did have its part to play.


2. Booker T Vs Buff Bagwell - WWE Raw 02/07/2001

Booker T Buff Bagwell
WWE.com

When Vince McMahon bought out World Championship Wrestling in 2001, everything changed.

Fans waited with baited breath to see what would become of the Georgia-based operation, though none of them could have predicted this.

McMahon's original plan was to run WCW as a separate show, maintaining its original roster, championships, and branding. He even considered giving it Raw's coveted Monday night TV slot.

Those plans crumbled to dust after one disastrous match on Raw in July 2001.

WWE tested the waters for a WCW show by having their world champion Booker T defend the belt against Buff Bagwell on an episode of Raw. Unfortunately, because WWE had done nothing but present WCW as a bunch of chumps since the buyout, the fans dumped on this match hard.

Who could have known?!

As a result, plans were radically changed. The idea of a split was nixed and so began the Invasion.

Whilst it could be argued that this segment was always doomed to fail, it's a lot harder to say that anyone could have foretold that this one poorly-received match could have ushered in the biggest missed opportunity in wrestling history.


1. Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs Owen Hart - WWE SummerSlam 1997

Summerslam 1997 Owen Hart Stone Cold
WWE.com

There's only one match most people remember SummerSlam '97 for and it sure as hell ain't Los Boricuas vs The Disciples of Apocalypse.

In fact, it's not even the match that most people remember. It's one move.

After a pretty decent contest, Intercontinental champion Owen Hart scooped Steve Austin up to hit him with a piledriver. A Tombstone Piledriver. A sit-out Tombstone Piledriver.

Uh oh.

Austin's head was way too low when Hart hit the move, compressing his neck into the canvas in a sickening sight. The Rattlesnake was left temporarily paralysed by the incident, informing referee Earl Hebner not to touch him in the ring.

After a lot of stalling for time, Austin regained enough strength to weakly roll Owen up to win the match. But his ordeal was far from over.

Austin's neck would be a constant issue throughout his career. He took time off immediately after this match, would need further time away a few years later, and ended up retiring in 2003 as a result of this one injury.

Although he would become a legend, imagine just how much more Stone Cold could have achieved had his career not been cut short by a single botched piledriver.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.