10 Wrestling Observer Newsletter Star Ratings Dave Meltzer Got Wrong

The few times Meltzer dropped the ball.

nakamura zayn.jpg
WWE.com

The Wrestling Observer Newsletter is a grand institution within the hardcore wrestling fandom.

Since 1983, it has served as a valuable resource for generations of wrestling fans, enlightening them as to which talents and promotions to pay attention. Rarely in its rich, thirty year-plus history has its editor, the venerable Dave Meltzer, got it wrong - or at least not drastically so. By 'it', we are referring to his method of match appraisal, the star rating system, from which the phrase 'five star match' is (often incorrectly) bandied about.

There are certain matches, though, which I feel he may have been a little too critical or generous towards. The (tired) joke going the rounds is that Meltzer exhibits an anti-WWE bias which, while largely untrue - Shane McMahon has been bestowed two ****+ matches in 2017 - contains within it an element of truth. To date, Meltzer has awarded just five WWE matches the full five star treatment - a bit of a oversight at best, an indictment at worst.

To do this fairly, his own criteria must be taken into account. Meltzer assigns ratings based primarily on work-rate, the way in which storylines are progressed through utilisation of moves, the execution and difficulty of the moves themselves, the crowd reaction, and, if applicable, the history between the wrestlers contesting the match.

10. Bret Hart Vs. Owen Hart - WWF WrestleMania X

WrestleMania X Bret Hart Owen Hart
WWE.com

Actual Rating: ****3/4, Revised Rating: *****

“Arguments are made for make ups,” James Murphy sings on LCD Soundsystem’s ‘Dance Yrself Clean’. It works the opposite way in wrestling; tag teams and factions are often grouped together purely to facilitate a feud once the act runs its course. The aim of the seminal (if overlong) Bret vs. Owen Hart feud was precisely that, and Bret handily completed the objective of getting his younger brother over in a masterfully characterful way at the ‘Granddaddy of ‘em all’.

Initially reluctant to get stuck in, due to the mixed emotions experienced fighting his own brother, Bret expertly crafts the story and escalates the drama by adding extra oomph to his every clothesline and Russian leg sweep each time the bratty ‘Black Hart’ transgresses upon the pure wrestling code. Water is thicker than blood by the climax of the intense finishing sequence, which sees Owen squeak out a shocking win in a genius piece of forward-thinking booking.

It's hard to fathom why Meltzer didn't award this match a perfect score; it is an extremely rare fusion of emotion and technicality with a stunning finish, as well received as it was executed.


9. The Shield Vs. Ryback & Team Hell No - WWE TLC 2012

TLC 12
WWE.com

Actual Rating: ****1/2, Revised Rating: *****

This, arguably, is the greatest debut match in WWE history.

The competition is fierce. Shinsuke Nakamura vs. Sami Zayn is well up there. Even Tazz vs. Kurt Angle was a triumph, forgotten in the aftermath of the Human Suplex Machine's subsequent downturn in fortunes.

The primary purpose of this match was to put over huge both the team methodology employed by The Shield, as well as the unit itself. It delivered to an extent not thought possible by even the most optimistic of fans. It was feared at the time that the stipulation was shoehorned, as so many are in the gimmick PPV era - there was nothing to climb towards, after all. The Shield and Ryback & Team Hell No laid waste to those expectations and each other in a scintillating scrap, structured expertly to cement The Shield's pack of dogs mentality. Without such a memorable debut bout, The Shield may not have risen to the incredible heights they did during their phenomenal sub-two year run.

Massive chants of 'THIS IS AWESOME' rang out, at time before the chant lost all meaning, after the match's best spot, which saw Roman Reigns for the first time spear Kane through the barricade. Kane never returned to the match afterwards, and it rumbled on for some time, but it doesn't tarnish its awesome legacy.


8. Rey Mysterio, Jr. Vs. Psicosis - WCW Bash At The Beach 1996

Rey Mysterio Psciosis
WWE.com

Actual Rating: ****3/4, Revised Rating: ****

This match is an awesome entry in WCW's impressive canon of Cruiserweight action, but something is off with the scaling of this rating. Put simply, it's not quite as good as Rey's seminal Halloween Havoc match with Eddy Guerrero, to which he also assigned four and three quarters of a star. Then again, very little is.

The match is awesome, even by the sumptuous standards of the mid-90's cruiserweight landscape. It's impressive in its restraint, too; most of the flashiest aerials aren't deployed until each man has failed with the less risky entries in their repertoires. What lets is down primarily is the crowd, who are dead for all but the most breathtaking sequences. Without that rising crescendo to help ramp up the tension, the finishing sequence seems to arrive from out of nowhere.

The finish, though, to which the high rating is likely attributed, is awesome. Meltzer was big on inventive moves in the 90s. Mysterio, incredibly only 21 years old at the time, counters Psicosis' top rope Splash Mountain power-bomb into a Frankensteiner in unbelievably smooth fashion. Still, one move does not make a classic.


7. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels - WWE WrestleMania XXV

undertaker shawn michaels
WWE.com

Actual Rating: ****3/4, Revised Rating *****

It's hard to fathom what cost this unequivocal classic a quarter of a star.

It can't be the famous botch, if you can call it that, which saw the cameraman (Sam Snuka) fail to catch 'Taker in the correct spot. This match is so bulletproof it actually augments the drama. That it arrived at the point at which the Undertaker was due to beat the count-out at the last breath was actually incredibly fortuitous. It added a real sense of danger and realism to the proceedings.

It can't be the multiple finisher kick-outs, either. Meltzer famously admired All Japan Pro Wrestling, bestowing more five star ratings upon it than any other promotion. The gladiators of the King's Road kicked out of finishers so regularly that they had to invent new and ever more dangerous super finishers to preserve the power of the concept.

It might be the relative simplicity of the story, which was even promoted as a battle between the darkness and the light, two equal powers trying to conquer one another's legacy. Simple though it was, the execution was unparalleled. 'Taker had never struck his formidable arsenal with such elegance and bite before or since, and this match, more than any other, is emblematic of Shawn's status as the best seller of all time.


6. Sheamus Vs. Daniel Bryan - WWE Extreme Rules 2012

daniel bryan sheamus extreme rules
WWE.com

Actual Rating: ****, Revised Rating: *****

The 2 out of 3 falls match, by definition, is a suspension of disbelief killer. Almost invariably, the first and second falls are shared. Consequently, there is little drama in the latter. More often than not, fans are taken out of the action and left waiting for the inevitable third act.

A rare example in modern WWE of a stipulation matching the wider storyline perfectly, Bryan ingeniously circumvents this contrivance by intentionally getting himself disqualified in the first fall by pummelling his larger opponent's left shoulder relentlessly, ignoring the referee's five count to get himself intentionally disqualified. From there, he makes Sheamus pass out in the Yes! Lock, grinning in smug triumph - this, from a supposed "good little hand" with little charisma - before Sheamus expertly recalls their infamous WrestleMania XXVIII encounter. Playing possum, he smashes Bryan with the Brogue Kick for a breathtaking near fall, following which the finishing sequence is initiated. Masterfully selling his decimated arm, Sheamus nonetheless guts it out to successfully defend the then-prestigious World Heavyweight title at the 22:54 mark.

For one of the cleverest and most realistic uses of strategy ever seen in WWE, this bout deserves the full five stars.


5. Will Ospreay Vs. Ricochet - NJPW Best Of The Super Juniors Day 6 (2016)

Will Ospreay vs. Ricochet
NJPW World

Actual Rating: ****3/4, Revised Rating ****1/4

The most controversial match held in 2016, Ospreay vs. Ricochet divided the wrestling fandom. For some, it was the pinnacle of the athletic style developed over the last few years. For others, and most infamously the man they call Vader, it was a gymnastics routine devoid of story and logic. These guys were meant to want to best each other, after all.

The now-notorious synchronised handspring elbow spot isn't what makes this match overrated. On the contrary, it was a jaw-dropping update on the double kip-up or the test of strength - an inventive method of establishing the two men as equals, essentially. The moves themselves, if a little too collaborative, were executed flawlessly, but there was little connective tissue stringing them together. They seemed to get a little too carried away with the crowd heat, too, resulting in a few rushed sequences. Most vexing was the lack of conviction with which the Death Valley Driver spot to the apron was sold.

It was a fabulous exhibition of the modern cruiser style. But it wasn't near-perfect.


4. Sami Zayn Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - NXT TakeOver: Dallas

nakamura vs zayn
WWE.com

Actual Rating: ****1/2, Revised Rating: *****

This rating has been revised as much for what the match symbolised, as much as the content itself.

WWE's treatment of Japanese talent had until that night been mixed, to put it mildly. Though small strides had been with Hideo Itami, the memory of Kaientai and Kenzo Suzuki pervaded in the memory. Even Tajiri, who was depicted seriously at times, was used as comic relief as William Regal's underling.

Nakamura and Zayn wrote a new chapter at TakeOver: Dallas in both the depiction of Japanese talent and the very in-ring language of WWE. Using stiff strikes with a frequency and force hitherto unseen under Vince McMahon's umbrella, they assembled a stirring contest framed by a gripping narrative. Nakamura, the King of Strong Style, was intent on maiming Zayn to usher in his way of fighting. Zayn, ever the plucky underdog, symbolised the NXT he had defined, by overcoming overwhelming odds with an unbelievable degree of fortitude and internationally-honed flair.

In the end, Nakamura emerged victorious. Zayn soaked in the adulation of the crowd before tearfully departing. It was the perfect story of hello and goodbye.


3. Bayley Vs. Sasha Banks - NXT TakeOver: Respect

sasha banks bayley
WWE.com

Actual Rating: ****1/4, Revised Rating: ****3/4

Meltzer posits that this match is slightly inferior to their match at TakeOver: Brooklyn, the rating for which (****1/2) I'm in agreement with. In my opinion, this is marginally better, but just short of perfection.

The original is botch-free and more streamlined, with an arguably greater emotional heft resulting from Bayley's cathartic first title win. The Iron Man sequel, while flabbier and beset by minor timing errors and miscommunications in the early going (hence the not-quite-perfect rating), is a weightier affair. It's also a better demonstration of character. Banks is nasty in Brooklyn in her attempts to break Bayley's fingers with her heel, but is absolutely ruthless here. Stealing Bayley superfan Izzy's headband and tossing it away nonchalantly at the sight of her tears, Banks put on such a vicious clinic of a heel performance that it's no wonder most every hardcore fan treats her as one of the biggest faces in the company today.

Bayley too develops her character by astutely recalling their previous match and mauling Banks' fingers to force the win at the death, in an all-time great turnabout is fair play finish.


2. Kurt Angle Vs. Eddie Guerrero - WWE WrestleMania XX

Eddie Guerrero Kurt Angle WrestleMania XX Frog Splash.jpg
WWE.com

Actual Rating: ****, Revised Rating: ***

Overshadowed on the night by the superlative triple threat match which saw Chris Benoit wrest the World Heavyweight title away from Triple H, Angle vs. Guerrero, even on repeat viewing in isolation, is a crushing disappointment.

A star has been removed as much for what it could have been than for what it was. As two of the greatest ever to step foot in the ring, on its grandest stage no less, expectations were sky-high. As it happens, the match could fairly be described as self-indulgent. Seemingly enamoured with one another's virtuoso technical prowess, they assembled a bout a little too heavy on the scientific side.

That's being charitable - it was quite boring in places, redeemed mostly by its impressive smoothness. The match betrayed the wider storyline, too. Angle in the build had described Eddie as a drug addict and orchestrated his arrest. Much like the Triple H vs. Randy Orton WrestleMania XXV main event five years later, this was summarily ignored on the night. The fiery Eddie should have been intent on fighting Angle, not merely out-wrestling him.

The finish, which saw Guerrero out-think Angle by loosening his boot and leaving him too baffled to reapply the ankle lock, while inventive, was much too cheap for the Show of Shows.


1. Vader Vs. Cactus Jack - WCW Halloween Havoc 1993

Vader Cactus Jack
WWE.com

Actual Rating: ****3/4, Revised Rating: ****

This is another match rating which doesn't hold up in comparison to similar matches from the same era.

Sting vs. Vader, held just shy of a year prior at Starrcade 1992, is similar in dynamic and match length, but is superior in terms of (in-match) story and heat. Yet, it received a quarter of a star less. Foley and Vader did have the benefit of a wider blood feud storyline, which played very well into the match itself, while Vader and Sting were battling without a specific personal dispute for a now-meaningless 'King of Cable' trophy. But you wouldn't know that without context. Sting rallied with comeback after comeback, to, far louder fanfare. The Mastodon took this as a personal slight, and battered Sting with a barrage of blows so stiff and punishing, Jim Ross almost had a conniption fit on commentary.

There is no such moment in the more acclaimed Cactus Jack bout which matches that level of emotion, and it is purportedly a grudge match. Vader vs. Cactus may have been more visceral, and perhaps even more believable, but the Starrcade '92 effort is a better all-round effort.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!