10 Wrestling Storylines That Vanished Without A Trace

The words "lock box" haunt too many WWE fans considering it was only ever said once.

Vince McMahon Shane McMahon
WWE

Wrestling is a giant melting pot of basically everything you can think of. It's drama. It's athleticism. It's fighting... except it's not... except when it is.

It's also, unlike the vast majority of television programming, never-ending. Week in and week out the top promotions in the world put together show after show to entertain their fans, doing their best to move from one story smoothly to the next and create new and captivating angles to keep their audience engaged.

It's easy to criticise it when it goes wrong but it sounds like a hell of a job to continuously come up with fresh and exciting storylines. However when something doesn't land, as happens not infrequently, it's better to perhaps just move on entirely. As such, there are a lot of wrestling storylines that just don't go anywhere.

The problem with this of course that diehard wrestling fans don't forget. It doesn't matter if a feud was good or bad, audiences can't help but wonder what could've been if a story had reached an actual conclusion instead of just disappearing in a puff of smoke.

10. The Black Liquid

Alexa Bliss WrestleMania 37
WWE

Supernatural wrestling can get away with a lot of truly nonsensical stuff for the very same reason that horror films can. It asks you to suspend your disbelief further than you may well have already done, surrendering to the idea that there are things we may not truly understand. And, in fact, we may not want to for the sake of entertainment. After all, not knowing is half of the chills.

As part of the never-ending 2020/2021 feud between Randy Orton and the Firefly Funhouse, the Viper found himself constantly harassed and tormented by Alexa "I'm 29 but dressed like a small child" Bliss. One of these, in March 2021, saw your standard fare of turnbuckle pyro to frighten Orton, but was followed by the odd sight of him falling to his knees vomiting a strange black liquid. Calls of "possession" courtesy of the then-MIA Fiend were heard from the portion of the fanbase who try to make any sense of supernatural wrestling.

But at WrestleMania 37 it was firmly established that the black liquid was the domain of Alexa Bliss. As the match between Orton and the Fiend drew to a close, Bliss appeared from inside the "box-like structure" at ringside. Gone was her usual brightly-coloured overalls, instead Bliss sat cross-legged in gothic wear, a crown around her head covering her in the mysterious black secretion.

This moment led to Bliss splitting solo from Wyatt, but the black liquid - where it came from and what it represented - was never mentioned again. Which is weird, as the ability to force your opponents to choke on supernatural goo seems like quite a handy talent in a wrestling ring. Oh well!


9. GTV

Al Snow GTV
WWE Network

WWE love jumping on a trend. Sometimes it works, other time it's times it's GTV. With the rise of reality TV and hidden camera shows in the late 90s, the company began to air superstars caught unaware backstage in grainy black-and-white CCTV-like vignettes.

What started as rather banal candid moments of wrestlers picking their noses or stinking out the men's restrooms started to escalate. The hidden cameras caught Meat cheating on Terri Runnells and the Mean Street Posse faking injuries, furthering storylines.

The original plan was to have the culprit be Goldust, which was pretty clear from the get-go since they were originally marked as "GDTV" before someone backstage realised how obvious that was. This fit since the character would be used for a lot of seedy, perverse, or boundary-pushing stories and at that time was looking to return to air. However, when Dustin Runnels departed the company for WCW, it left WWE at an impasse. Famously, MTV comedian Tom Green (whom you might know from Freddy Got Fingered or Road Trip) was considered but Vince didn't like Green's style of humour.

As such, they did what WWE always does when they can't think of an answer: they pointed in another direction to distract their audience and then brushed it under the rug.


8. Dusty Rhodes' Kiss Of Death

Dusty Rhodes Baby Doll
YouTube

It's not just WWE that have had their fair share of stories that went nowhere. In 1988, Jim Crockett Promotions started an angle that could've added an interesting element to perennial hero Dusty Rhodes if it hadn't go awry.

On an unassuming airing of the show, Larry Zbyszko's valet Baby Doll hand-delivered Rhodes a mysterious envelope, threatening the American Dream with blackmail in exchange for a United States title shot. To close things off, Baby Doll took Dusty by the chin and pecked him on the cheek. This was apparently meant to symbolise a "kiss of death" for Dusty's career.

By some stroke of hilarious irony, it was this kiss that allegedly brought down not Dusty Rhodes, but the angle instead.

So the story goes, according to Zbyszko, that Baby Doll made the choice to kiss Dusty on the cheek rather than the lips as originally pitched. Incensed by what they viewed as insubordination, Crockett and Rhodes fired Baby Doll on the spot. The valet tells it differently, saying she was fired for a "conflict of interest" after her husband, fellow Crockett star Sam Houston, got hired by WWE.

Because of this, the story was dropped and it looked on-screen as though Zbyszko had issued an empty threat.


7. I Still Remember

Booker T I Still Remember
WWE

Do you remember "I still remember"? Considering how inconsequential it was, you'd be forgiven for forgetting.

The November 2003 segment, which is less than a full minute long, starts with Booker T hanging out backstage with Heidenreich, advertising/reading WWE's Unscripted annual. However, it all takes a very odd turn when there's a knock at the door which marks the arrival of an envelope for Book. Unlike the contents of Dusty's, which was kept a secret, this one was shown to contain a piece of paper that simply read "I still remember".

Was this a threat? Was someone from Booker's past coming back to haunt him? Was it a reference to better days, and someone was about to enter the former WCW Champion's life in order to get him to the top of the WWE mountain?

This may well be the most mysterious of the entries on this list because it's never really had any concrete answers about the plans either. Much like GTV, fans have long theorised that it was a way for Goldust to step back into a story with Booker T after their legendary feud but your guess is your guess is literally as good as anyone's of course because, by virtue of being on this list, there is no answer. These 59 seconds are all that exist of this angle.


6. Who Attacked Hideo Itami?

hideo itami
WWE.com

For the fans, and clearly for head booker Triple H too, it was an exciting prospect to have indie star KENTA on the NXT books.

Performing under the name Hideo Itami, the former Pro Wrestling Noah heavyweight champion wasted no time getting to work, teaming with fellow indie-signee Finn Bálor and even making an accelerated jump to WrestleMania 31 with a featured appearance in that year's André the Giant Memorial Battle Royal. In May 2015, Itami was scheduled to take part in a triple-threat number one contender's match for the NXT Championship before he suffered a legitimate injury.

Making the best of a bad situation, WWE attempted to turn the injury into its latest "whodunnit". Itami was found in the parking lot after being taken out by a mysterious attacker. This surely meant that, when he returned, he would have a ready-made feud to slot into.

The problem was that Itami was out for a full year and NXT moved fast. The man who made the most sense to be Itami's attacker, Kevin Owens, had moved up to the main roster a long time ago. Other possible picks like Samoa Joe or even Bálor were otherwise busy. More than this, WWE's desire to do much with Itami seemed to have fizzled out, which was made worse by another injury he suffered later the same year.

Maybe Itami just tripped and fell. Yeah, that was probably it.


5. Lacey Evans' Pregnancy

Ric Flair Lacey Evans
WWE.com

Very clearly a Vince McMahon story because he seems to find the same roles for women over and over again in wrestling, Lacey Evans found a new way to get under the skin of rival Charlotte Flair in 2021. At first, flirting with Charlotte's Father Ric seemed like a playful use of her feminine wiles to further the feud but on the February 15th episode of Raw the storyline took a very weird turn.

Teaming with Peyton Royce against Charlotte Flair and Asuka, Evans refused to tag into the match for reasons that became apparently clear when - mid-way through the bout - she backed away from the ring. The Southern Belle then shocked the world by announcing that she was pregnant, implying that Flair was the Father as he belted out "call me Daddy".

But later that night, after the show, it was confirmed that Evans was pregnant for real in her personal life and would be taking time away from the ring. For some reason, WWE had decided to add it to her burgeoning story with Naitch... without really thinking about where to go next with it.

It was like the company figured this generate great heat for her future WrestleMania bout against Charlotte... which obviously didn't happen because Lacey was legitimately pregnant.


4. Samoa Joe Is Kidnapped By Ninjas

Samoa Joe Kidnapped TNA
Impact Wrestling/TNA

In February 2009, Samoa Joe was abducted by ninjas. Wrestling is weird.

In actuality, it's just a bunch of guys in black hoodies but they somehow got the moniker of ninjas which makes the proposed story even weirder. This idea came out of nowhere, ending a random episode of TNA Impact with the former world champion being bundled into a white van and driven off into the night.

Originally, Joe was apparently going to return as a psychopathic heel character. However, TNA needed faces. As such, by the end of April, Joe had made a grand return to fill a gap in the babyface Team Hogan against Team Flair. And thus, it was never mentioned again.

In 2021, writer Vince Russo attested that Bischoff's original plan was to have Jimmy Snuka of all people be behind the strange attack but it didn't pan out. Thus, left with an unfinished story and a hole in their roster they chose to completely abandon it.

Whilst TNA never went back to the well with the kidnapping, Joe himself made a cute reference to it in 2020 during his time on WWE commentary when he remarked "ninjas can really ruin a night".


3. Vince's Lockbox

Vince Shane McMahon The Undertaker
WWE

At WrestleMania 32, a post-streak Undertaker defeated Shane McMahon in a fairly forgettable match propped up by a story about as water-tight as a slice of swiss cheese. If Shane returned to the WWE to blackmail Vince, why did he agree to compete in a match? Why did Vince think the Undertaker was his pawn - and, so too, why did Taker go along with it? Worst of all, the most interesting wrinkle was a totally passed over.

Vince McMahon had not been the centre point of a WWE story for some time by 2016. As such, the mention of a mysterious lockbox - including apparently blackmail-ready goods - was something that caught many fans' attention.

The first and final mention of this MacGuffin came from Vince's mouth as part of his terms for Shane. If Shane-O beat the Undertaker, he'd have control of Raw. If he lost, he would destroy the lockbox and its contents.

But by merely presenting the mystery box, fans wanted to know what was inside of it. It was a Chekhov's Gun of sorts. And, bizarrely, considering that Shane lost to Taker and still got what he wanted as a temporary general manager of Raw (for about three months until the brand split), he did so without revealing the dirt he had on his Father.

What Vince might be hiding was the most interesting part of the tale, so it's quite incredible that taken in the full context of the story it looks more like an ad-lib that McMahon made.


2. The Nightmare Collective's Hair Collection

Nightmare Collective
AEW

AEW's issues with booking a half-decent women's division have been the subject of much debate over the last few years but the truth is they have always struggled. Nowhere is this more apparent in what may well be the worst storyline they've ever put to television, not to mention the most confusing, in the Nightmare Collective.

It was bad from the get-go, experiencing the whiplash of Brandi Rhodes being her husband and super-face Cody's valet to her apparently being a cartoon bad guy. More than this, after aligning herself with Awesome Kong, Brandi began a weird obsession with cutting clumps of hair out of their defeated opponents.

There was no explanation for what this was for, which made the indoctrination of "fan plant" Melanie Cruz painful to watch. With the Nightmare Collective so poorly defined, watching Mel get her head shaved was a painfully big commitment to a story that the audience simply didn't care about. At least she could pull the look off.

There was similarly no reaction to the debut of Luther, filling the gap left by Awesome Kong departing the company, and so the company dropped the gimmick. Admittedly, one final note was supposed to wrap this up when it was shown that Brandi had gone to to "therapy". But what about Luther and Mel? Did they continue to lurk backstage at Dynamite with clippers?


1. The Attempted Murders Of Vince McMahon

Million Dollar Mania
WWE.com

One of the most famous unfinished WWE storylines is Vince's exploding limo. There's nothing more to the angle that that phrase: Vince steps in his car and it's engulfed in flame. Of course, this was all ignored in the wake of the Benoit tragedy in the following days.

But it's not the only time Vince set up a story where someone seemed to want him dead. 2008's Millior Dollar Mania was ratings grab that saw Vince dial phone numbers and promise cash to those that could give the correct phrase.

The concept was a total car-crash that resulted in some of the most uncomfortable television imaginable. The biggest highlight was Vince being rickrolle'd twice by a fan who then went on to win $20,000. What a great night for that person. All in all, it wasn't working and so Vince put an end to the idea by writing an event where the stage exploded and collapsed upon him.

Perhaps most strangely of all, to hype up Vince's return to TV six months later the January 19th 2009 episode of Raw opened with a video package with footage of precisely what led to Vince missing TV but it never truly went told us why. Debatably, there was no angle - it was simply to allow Vince to end the Million Dollar Failure. However, it was prime for a whodunnit... that we never got.


Watch Next


Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite