10 Wrestling Storylines Where Evil Won

In which the corporation always wins - to the misery of Booker T, Steve Austin, and Kofi Kingston...

stephanie mcmahon brie bella
WWE.com

Good should ultimately prevail in professional wrestling. It isn't some complex, thought-provoking meditation on the human condition.

Well, it is when Hangman Page is involved, because his arc is genuinely magnificent advanced storytelling that transcends the medium he is in the midst of pioneering. Elsewhere, it is an escapist fantasy designed to entertain the audience and allow a little light and vicarious triumph into their miserable lives. It exists, yes, to put smiles on people's faces. Quite how that is accomplished through Edge being really, really intense and every other match ending in a deflating disqualification is unclear - but that's what wrestling is meant to do.

The soap opera machinations of the form mean there are actually few happy endings, since it never ends. But the good guy should win when it's right for the good guy to win.

That's not to say that every babyface has to win every programme, obviously - the chase is all the more powerful when it is finally realised at the expense of a dominant, almost overbearing villain - but maybe the institutional racist avatar shouldn't have went over the black man he buried for being black that time...

10. Triple H Vs. Booker T

Triple H Booker T
WWE Network

Is this the worst thing WWE ever did?

Forget the choo-choo noises, midcard champions losing more matches than Chris Hamrick, and the total destruction of tag team wrestling. These things were mere atrocities of fiction for which WWE has become infamous in recent years.

Here is your winner...and still World Heavyweight Champion...the White Supremacist! was a level of disgusting scarcely believable.

On his Something To Wrestle With podcast, Bruce Prichard is adamant that, when Triple H said "People like you don't get to be World Champion," he was referring to Booker T's status as a "WCW guy," which was funny. Booker T was already a five-time World Champion, and Triple H knew this because he was wearing the exact same physical belt at the time. And, if WCW guys didn't get to be World Champion, Terra Ryzing's reigns should have been disqualified. Triple H didn't exactly begin his career in PWG. Everybody he shook hands with to make himself look cool did, but he didn't.

He never said WCW guy Goldberg had "nappy hair". He never said WCW guy Sting should merely dance for his entertainment. The Undertaker didn't treat WCW guy Diamond Dallas Page like a bathroom attendant.

This was, unmistakably, a storyline in which the avatar of institutional racism defeated the black man, and took 23 whole seconds to make the cover in a spot you only ever f*cking do to protect the finisher when it's kicked out of. Hideous.

The only reason Prichard's claim was halfway believable is because...


9. Triple H Vs. Sting

Sting Triple H WrestleMania 31
WWE.com

The end to the Sting Vs. The Authority storyline was inexplicable because it didn't logically follow the established premise.

At Survivor Series 2014, Sting debuted for WWE as the very last hold-out, the ultimate outsider. So entrenched was Sting as the enemy that he debuted as the vigilante with a calling to dismantle the corrupt system once and for all. After a wild, twisting main event, Sting took Triple H down with the Scorpion Death Drop to equalise the interference and restore justice. Sting couldn't join WWE without first saving it. There was a certain poetry to the angle informed by years of history converging. It was a good storyline.

WWE changed it, nonsensically, at the eleventh hour.

Sometime ahead of WrestleMania, the big brains of WWE seemed to work themselves into a shoot. "The f*ck's this guy's problem? We're the best!" they said, growing annoyed by the...scripted events they themselves penned.

At WrestleMania 31, suddenly, Sting was the embodiment of WCW fighting the last battle of a war that ended 14 years prior. He was assisted on the battlefield by the nWo, with whom he'd quite famously feuded, and lost, because WWE is the f*cking best you face-painted southern yokel.

F*ck you.


8. Stephanie McMahon Vs. Mick Foley

Mick Foley Stephanie McMahon
WWE.com

This was as weird as it was depressing as it was boring as it was, in the end, thoroughly anticlimactic.

In 2016, Mick Foley was installed by Stephanie McMahon as the General Manager of Monday Night RAW. Foley, loveable folk hero, operated as a fair authority figure, which annoyed Stephanie McMahon, the heel. But then again, what didn't?

She expressed annoyance with the babyface Dean Ambrose (scruffy) and the heel Charlotte Flair (nasty to her dad) across two episodes of the programme. Her character, simply, was that of an insufferable and impossible to please Commissioner who made up the rules as she went along. Foley was the dunce for his inability to follow them.

Also: why did she hire a nice bloke when her M.O. was to protect her own, nefarious interests? Also: in what world is watching two management figures have passive aggressive conversations centred on administration the sort of escapism that puts smiles on people's faces?

She'd say things like "What do you have to say for yourself?" as if Foley was an insolent toddler. Foley in response would meekly concede that Stephanie was right and can he still have a job pretty please?

It was an oppressive viewing experience with no entertainment value nor, in the end, any catharsis. This power struggle wasn't settled in the end with Foley and Steph selecting wrestlers to fight for control of the programme.

Foley was simply bounced out unceremoniously, wasting almost an entire year of TV on ridicule and misery.


7. Kofimania

Brock Lesnar Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

11 years.

The Kofimania storyline, complete with at least one layer of suboptimal subtext, was premised on 11 years of struggle. Kofi wished to prove himself a true headline player. He had the ability, the drive, and, in a genuinely stirring organic development, the support.

So why did it take 11 years?

In storyline, this was partly explained away by Mr. McMahon believing Kofi to be a "B+ player" who was destined for the Hall of Fame, just not the first ballot. The subtext revealed something rather stark: if it took 11 years for WWE management to realise his potential, throughout which Kofi was positioned in an often aimless role, what did that say of the promotional machine behind him?

Regardless, in a euphoric moment, Kofi realised his ambitions after dethroning Planet's Champion Daniel Bryan in a masterclass at WrestleMania 35. A cracking, emotional match that articulated the scope of Kofi's struggle within 24 minutes of spellbinding drama, it was by some distance the best moment of the run.

Virtually every other match developed an unshakeable midcard vibe, and in truth, through its pointless/mandated rematches, the run went on too long. But the way in which it ended was a brutally depressing reminder of where WWE thought Kofi stood all along.

Annihilated by Brock Lesnar on the SmackDown FOX debut, he wasn't a headliner. Hell, he wasn't even a B+ Player.

He was a guy there to do a job.


6. Austin Vs. McMahon

Austin McMahon WM17
WWE.com

The highlight of a generation's wrestling fandom, Austin Vs. McMahon was a saga as entertaining as it was epic.

It spanned three years, and if it descended into retcon and parody by the finish, it couldn't tarnish the fabulous chemistry shared by the players. By 2001, it didn't matter if Austin and Vince had aligned as babyfaces twice via the Vince Russo-stained bullsh*t that was virtually all of 1999's pathetic and nonsensical gothic horror.

The dynamic was so wonderful that when it was restored, the magic still glowed. McMahon was seminal as the hammy, ass-showing menace; Austin hilarious as the man who kicked him there when the pants were down. Sublime physical comedy converged with outrageous stakes perfect for the cliffhanger episodic model to make the WWF the only destination on Monday nights.

But in the end, evil prevailed. Vince loathed the idea of Austin holding the WWF Title, and had asked him to be a corporate man to better embody what that meant. In 1998, Austin hit him in the d*ck; in 2001, Austin shook him by the hand.

Years later, Austin side-eyed McMahon in various segments that sought to forget all of that silly, business-killing bother, and McMahon ate the odd stunner on various retro shows. But in the real ending, he got his man.

Austin was hardly a hero for his millionth about-face after Survivor Series 2001, and the numbers proved it.


5. The Miz Vs. Daniel Bryan

the miz daniel bryan
WWE.com

The tale of the Miz Vs. Daniel Bryan was knotty.

A fusion of reality and fiction, sometimes within the same worked segments, Daniel Bryan and The Miz were diametric opposites. Bryan was the in-ring killer who treated wrestling as art to the detriment of his health; The Miz valued doing his job safely so that he'd never miss a date or a responsibility.

When this was adapted into their criminally piss-poor programme of 2018, WWE couldn't exactly go full meta. The Bryan and Miz conflict was repurposed as more traditional fare.

Bryan was virtuous, Miz took the shortcuts, and in the end - after a shockingly subdued crowd reaction at SummerSlam indicted this outrageous botch of a programme - Bryan won in two minutes at Super ShowDown with a small cradle. The projected euphoric WrestleMania main event manifested, instead, as a few sheepish knob gags.

Bryan technically won the feud - in the most anticlimactic fashion, of course - but he lost his character in doing so. He turned heel almost immediately after it ended, sensing that the "fickle" fans who sat on their hands were no longer behind him.

Probably because of all that bullsh*t with toy babies.


4. Stephanie McMahon Vs. Brie Bella

Stephanie McMahon Brie Bella SummerSlam 2014
WWE.com

In an attempt to extract every last bit of juice from the Daniel Bryan Vs. The Authority storyline, Brie Bella was folded into the saga long after it was dead, and in a miraculous development, this subplot was actually really good!

For a bit!

It was good because Stephanie McMahon was a great heel character undermined by just one rather glaring flaw: she can't put anybody over. Since that is the exact f*cking point, most everything she did from 2013 onwards, beyond the odd obligatory bump at WrestleMania, was unbearable.

Her delivery was great.

She was almost phenomenal at depicting herself as the domineering boss who held sway over everything and everyone. The disingenuous cadence; the aloof disgust; the specific awfulness of the dialogue: if she'd just taken a slap to the f*cking bracket every other week, she'd have been an elite-tier heel.

She did take a slap in the build to her match with Brie Bella at SummerSlam 2014. Brie slapped a giggling Stephanie square in the mush. It was great. It was the endgame for Steph's very character!

Steph slapped back when the feud heated up, and won the match at the pape when Nikki turned on her sister. Evil won, and WWE separated a big drawing act, only to put them back together when Brie also turned. Turns out Stephanie's awfulness is catching. Good.

Good escapism.


3. CM Punk Vs. Jeff Hardy

CM Punk Jeff Hardy
WWE.com

Evil prevailed for a reason; Jeff Hardy was on the way out, and WWE made sure to get CM Punk over at his expense.

Arguably, this was the best wholly fictional A-Z story has WWE penned post-2001. Virtually every other acclaimed storyline either descended into bullsh*t (Summer of Punk), was plagued by a damning meta premise and a botched final chapter (WWE eventually recognises Becky Lynch as division Ace, throws Charlotte Flair in WrestleMania main event anyway) or was retconned via farce (End of an Era is tarnished through zombified blood money pursuit).

Punk Vs. Hardy was gloriously simple.

Punk was jeered for winning the Money In The Bank briefcase for a second consecutive year. Ironically, given the reaction to his debut at AEW Revolution 2021, Christian was their man. Punk cashed in on the wildly popular Jeff Hardy, further disconnecting him from the fanbase. He used that reaction to inform his exceptional sanctimonious heel act. After a slow-burn turn that was plotted tremendously, Punk raged that Jeff Hardy was no hero. He was an unreliable drug addict who didn't deserve the love of the crowd.

This programme peaked fabulously across a pair of stunning gimmick matches: the best singles TLC match ever, the very genre of which formalised Punk's superiority, and a Loser Leaves Town Cage match.

Still, as effective as it was, the specific beats of the story were jarring. The flawed hero, in the end, was just flawed - and it wasn't that effective, since the Undertaker programme undid everything just months later.

As a self-contained story, however, this was incredible.


2. Edge Vs. Matt Hardy

Edge, Matt Hardy
WWE.com

It's not exactly a tale of good versus evil, this - more a tale of adulterer versus toxic emo who mobilised his fans against his ex, who the fans, being wrestling fans, treated as the real heel in the carny adaptation of a distressing love triangle.

It's more complex than labelling Hardy as the good guy in all of this, since he had no qualms about publicising the matter and doing less than nothing to stem the backlash that all but scorched Lita's psyche. He wasn't to know that Lita would be turned into a one-dimensional "slut" character. Nor was he to know that the character would become so over and so known for this transgression that Vince would later threaten to fire her if she refused to participate in the infamous Live Sex Celebration angle.

Christ, the whole deal was such a mess, looking back at things, and the catharsis was never realised in the fiction. Hardy was beaten down horribly at SummerSlam, and while he gained a measure of revenge at Unforgiven, the memory of the elongated squash - and Hardy's ultimate loss - prevails.

The lesser of evils lost because WWE saw more money in the man, Edge, who was lionised as an entertaining heel shagger.


1. Shawn Michaels Vs. Bret Hart

Montreal Screwjob Bret Hart Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

People have debated for years who the better wrestler was.

The debate remains as bitter as it ever was: the snug, hermetic strategy of Bret Hart, who really did embody his 'Excellence of Execution' moniker, or the searing melodramatic flash of Shawn Michaels, who did, in fact, stop many a show with his big-bumping thrill rides?

What's more clear is who was the baddie.

Shawn Michaels was the baddie. His problems with addiction complicate the narrative in retrospect, when it's viewed with more maturity. But he was a c*nt to Dax Harwood when he was clean, so...

Shawn Michaels was the man who cultivated a toxic atmosphere. Michaels was the man who dropped a title without doing a job and returned ahead of schedule to confirm that he more likely than not could have gone out on his back. Michaels was the man who questioned Hart's integrity as a husband, and while Hart was in fact a fanny rat by his own admission, you don't out that on national television. Michaels was the man who - setting the events of Montreal into motion - directly told Hart that he wouldn't do what Hart had done, and had said he'd happily do again: the job, clean in the middle.

Michaels wasn't the man who pitched the Screwjob. Out of exasperation (Jim Cornette) and career-minded sabotage (Triple H), this was arrived at independently. But he went along with it, and had the humanity, at least, to cut a despondent figure backstage in a moment of introspection.

There's a wonderfully karmic postscript to all of this - the Tom Magee Holy Grail Vs. Crown Jewel fiasco saw Bret win something of a legacy battle - but evil had taken root for decades.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!