10 WWE Attitude Era Stars Who Could Replace Today's Roster

Imagine if Shane McMahon was the head of The Authority?

We've all sat and imagined how much better off The Shield would've been if The Rock (even say, 1996 Rock) were in Roman Reigns' shoes. As well, imagine if Jeff Jarrett, Owen Hart and numerous other Attitude Era performers were on the modern WWE roster. Seriously. Take a look at what we're watching right now, and put certain other performers (at the same point in their careers) in the same position. Pro wrestling was arguably best when getting to WWE was a destination point after spending well over a decade everywhere else, honing your craft for an opportunity to showcase yourself on the main stage. Now, pro wrestling is a much different industry, wherein WWE is oftentimes the first stop along the way. To be frank, the competition in NXT is great, but nowhere near say, working through Memphis, Smoky Mountain, ECW, Japan and Europe before reaching WWE. Let's think back to the Attitude Era, and let's remember some of its stars who were truly tremendous in their roles. As well, let's also note the cyclical nature of the pro wrestling industry and just how shockingly congruent the modern era is to the past, and how much we may miss the talented veterans occupying the spots now held by less proven professionals. Here are ten Attitude Era stars who could easily replace 10 current WWE performers (and why).

10. D-Lo Brown/Big E

This one is intriguing only because it's entirely possible that Big E is slowly moving into a D-Lo-style role in The New Day after largely failing as a monster big-man heater. Big E is stocky and powerful, but in lacking height and a mean streak, just isn't believable as someone who can rip off heads with any credibility. Big E is six years into his wrestling career. At six years in, D-Lo Brown had already been in the Nation of Domination, was a multiple-time title holder and had learned the art of how to be a convincing mid-card sh*t stirrer of a heel. A guy with that type of experience in The New Day would be awesome, as that trio needs a veteran who knows the job in order to be as effective as they can ideally be. Kofi's great in a tag-team pairing. Xavier Woods is growing as a mouthpiece and manager-in-tights. Subbing out Big E for D-Lo Brown would just make sense.

9. Jeff Jarrett/Heath Slater

Heath Slater's gifted at getting that "what a bag of d***s heat." It's not the heat that makes you change the channel, rather it's the heat that makes you love pro wrestling as a carny enterprise. However, if you swapped out Heath Slater for Jeff Jarrett, just imagine how much greater and more beneficial that heat could actually become. Heath Slater's an 11-year veteran. When Jeff Jarrett was an 11-year veteran he was a 25-time champion in his father's Memphis promotion and had worked some of the most legendary heels and babyfaces in wrestling history. As well, he had already also been a three-time WWE Intercontinental Champion and one-time WCW United States Champion, too. Sliding into a role as a mid-card comedy act who could occasionally ramp things up and get serious? Totally possible for good ol' Double J.

8. Terri Runnels/Rosa Mendes

Rosa Mendes has been in WWE for a decade and probably hasn't done anything of note to stand out as a performer past her debut season on Total Divas. At a time when talent relations always tells younger talent to "maximize their minutes," Mendes hasn't really done that. As well, with someone as physically attractive and uniquely entertaining as Mendes around, she could have been put into situations where here non-wrestling gifts were put to good use in a manner similar to say, Terri Runnels. After 10 years in pro wrestling, Terri Runnels' captivating beauty had become her drawing card in the industry. From day one in the business as WCW's Alexandra York, her character's benefits of both beauty and intelligence were put to great use alongside a group of top heels including Ricky Morton, Mike Rotounda, Terry Taylor and Tommy Rich. That level of visibility was then taken to another level in the WWF in 1996 as Marlena was as important as Dustin Runnels' gender-bending to Goldust's presentation. "Pretty Mean Sisters"-era Terri alongside a young talent struggling for relevance like Adam Rose is certainly a much better situation than Rosa Mendes in the same position.

7. X-Pac/Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler's reached this level where he's just good enough to be very competitive, but not necessarily seen by the company as a guy who can absolutely "win the big one" every time. However, where that's an issue for Ziggler, for a star like X-Pac, it's exactly how he made a name for himself throughout his entire career. Part of the issue with Ziggler is that in the late 2000s/early 2010s when WWE was attempting to locate new main eventers, the company pushed Ziggler as a heavyweight when in all reality he's far better off as X-Pac, the guy who Jim Ross always said "had more guts than brains." Ziggler as a gutsy underneath babyface who can contend for the big belts but not necessarily win them would be ideal. After 11 years in wrestling Dolph Ziggler's wrestled on all levels of WWE's card, but in being favorable positioned as the World Champion -- but likely being better as a perpetual runner up -- has been henpecked. Similarly, after 11 years in the wrestling business, X-Pac had been in the same position, but thankfully, in never quite reaching the pinnacle of the business, was able to truly excel in a major way as a mid-card stalwart who could be credibly pushed for more. Ideally, that's Ziggler's best role that he can't occupy.

6. Ryback/Ken Shamrock

Imagine if Ryback had a sliver of some sort of legitimate reason for being so jacked and intense in order to have some sort of reason for holding the number two championship in WWE? Instead, he doesn't, and in missing that background, he's much less a B-grade Ultimate Warrior than he is actually a B-grade Ken Shamrock. At some point, WWE would've done SO well as to get Ryback into some sort of MMA-style training environment that they could film. Having Ryback even aligned with MMA (hell, what about with Shamrock???) would be an immense assist for his career at-present. Ryback "snapping" before doing the Meat Hook clothesline and the Shellshocked would be so much better than him bumping and feeding like every other wrestler ever. The crowd LOVES Ryback. What about digging into the way-back machine and pairing him with another guy who actually did his gimmick better?

5. Shawn Michaels/Daniel Bryan

This is a sad one. One of the most unfortunate things about the Attitude Era is that Shawn Michaels was injured and had to retire before having great matches with The Rock, put over Triple H's heel turn in say, 1999 or have rematches against Stone Cold Steve Austin. Similarly, Daniel Bryan can't wrestle Kevin Owens, Veville or Finn Balor in WWE, and joins his trainer in becoming a sad WWE footnote. However WWE is missing the ball in not doing with Bryan what they did with Michaels in having him appear as a commissioner or referee. Bryan could actually eclipse what Michaels offered in those roles, and WWE missing out is unfortunate.

4. Sable/Lana

Lana's breakup from Rusev sadly is not as great as Sable's breakup from Marc Mero. In this being the case, the fuel that allowed Sable to become a mega-star is missing from the rocket on Lana's back, and the potential crossover star that Lana could be is being under-served. Marc Mero being married to Sable actually made Mero better in the "jealous husband" role than Rusev is in playing Lana's jealous boyfriend. Sable also is MUCH more of a camera-hungry ham than Lana is, and was also afforded the opportunity to do so much more as a performer than Lana, too. But imagine Sable being in Lana's role on TV right now. It'd probably be a VERY different situation.

3. Owen Hart/Seth Rollins

Imagine if Wrestlemania X-era Owen Hart were the WWE World Champion right now, and how much of an insufferable jerk he'd be. Imagine Wrestlemania X-era Owen having Vince and Linda McMahon, Yokozuna, Mabel, The Brooklyn Brawler and Barry Horowitz around him, too. Imagine Wrestlemania X-era Owen wrestling anyone in the main event scene on the Raw roster right now. For every awesome thing that Seth Rollins is doing, thinking of Owen Hart doing it also kinda makes every awesome thing that Seth Rollins is doing feel so bush league by comparison, right?

2. The Rock/Roman Reigns

This one is obvious, but, yeah. There's a gear missing that comes from The Rock being five years into the industry and having already studied under Pat Patterson, Vince McMahon, Dr. Tom Prichard, a slew of the best workers in the business in their prime and being raised in and around the wrestling business that's just missing from Roman Reigns' backstory. If 2000 era Rocky (at five years in the industry) were booed at Wrestlemania 31 the same way Roman Reigns (similarly at five years in the industry) were booed, we all know the result would've been MUCH different.

1. Shane McMahon/Triple H

Stop for a second and imagine if "Shane-O-Mac" were the head of The Authority. Imagine the heat. Exactly. Now imagine if Shane O asked his little sister to get her husband away from NXT long enough to defend the honor of his father and grandfather's company against WCW interloper Sting. Also imagine Shane sending down DX to combat the NWO at Wrestlemania, too. Also, imagine The Authority's theme being "Here Comes The Money" instead of "Bow Down To The King." Also, imagine Shane McMahon and Seth Rollins' backstage interactions. All of this can be described as "excellent." Sadly, this will never happen. But let's all sit here and imagine if it did. Wow.

Contributor
Contributor

Besides having been an independent professional wrestling manager for a decade, Marcus Dowling is a Washington, DC-based writer who has contributed to a plethora of online and print magazines and newspapers writing about music and popular culture over the past 15 years.