10 WWE Debuts That Were DOOMED From The Start
Not all wrestlers are created equal, as proven in these troublesome WWE debuts.
Every wrestler arrives on our screen with a blank slate. Be that for a returning favourite or a new superstar, WWE debuts are designed to get us excited about a new addition to the main roster of Monday Night Raw or SmackDown. However, not all of these debuts go to plan.
Whether purposefully sabotaged, having a gimmick that is instantly dismissed, or the performer themselves being below the level required, some debuts are memorable for all of the wrong reasons.
In every era of WWE, there are performers who may as well be pronounced dead on arrival. The classic method of airing vignettes for so long that a baby could be conceived and born within that time period is one such way to ensure this comes to pass. Hyping a performer to oblivion, or repackaging a known superstar in a way that is inconceivable for the audience, are some other ways WWE has made sure that a talent is doomed from the start.
Whatever the reason, the following ten WWE superstars were given zero chance of succeeding from the night they arrived on our screens.
10. Gable Steveson
Brock Lesnar was an NCAA Division I Champion who had a physique that was built to blow minds, and had Paul Heyman as a mouthpiece and loyal supporter behind the scenes. Kurt Angle was an Olympic gold medalist with natural charisma to burn, with more layers to his act than anyone could have predicted.
With previous success stories like this from the world of amateur wrestling, it was easy to see why WWE would conclude that 2020 Olympic gold medalist Gable Steveson was a home run in waiting. However, they couldn't have been more wrong.
The world of pro wrestling is bombastic in every sense. Steveson had all the flamboyance of a cardboard sandwich and couldn't get close to translating his considerable amateur wrestling talent into a WWE ring.
After extensive training, a WrestleMania 38 appearance, and being drafted to Monday Night Raw in October 2021, Gable's only match in WWE came over 18 months later at NXT Great American Bash 2023. Poor Baron Corbin tried his best to get anything out of Steveson, but this was completely futile. Fans can smell when they're being sold something rotten, and Gable was booed out of the building, while Corbin was cheered on despite being in the midst of a heel run.
Gable Steveson never appeared on WWE television again.
9. Stalker DDP
Diamond Dallas Page was one of the most beloved babyfaces of WCW's most successful era. A real-life fairytale story, DDP overcame the odds to break into pro wrestling late in his life, taking every shot he was given, and capturing the hearts of fans everywhere.
Hiring Page and running him as a heel is kind of like hiring Bluey to be the villain in the new James Bond movie.
The storyline that he was put into also made this bizarre decision even worse. For weeks, viewers were shown someone stalking The Undertaker's wife, Sara. Filming her from afar and inside 'The Deadman's home, this sinister angle, where one of the most well-loved wrestlers in WWE history was having his home violated and his family preyed upon, was something so heinous that whoever was revealed as 'Taker's stalker would be an instant figure of hate.
Only when DDP was revealed, this story was so far removed from the lovable everyman that fans were used to seeing on their screens that audiences didn't go for it in any way. Buying DDP as a heel would've been difficult enough, but attempting to portray him as a man who'd stalk a woman in her own home was a complete misfire on every level.
8. Emmalina
Emma was one of the purest, most wholesome wrestlers in NXT's early years. Best known for her quirky dance and coming to the ring with bubbles falling from the ceiling, she had some pedigree in those burgeoning years of the promotion, even going as far as being in the finals to crown the first NXT Women's Champion at NXT Arrival back in 2014.
After becoming the first Australian woman to appear on WWE's main roster, a back injury would keep Emma off TV for a large part of 2016. This is when WWE decided that a rebrand would be best, and vignettes began to air for Emma's repackaging as 'Emmalina'.
These confusing vignettes would feature Emma posing like a glamour model, with soft-focus pics showcasing her in scantily clad bikinis in all manner of exotic locations. This was a giant leap from the clutzy character fans had become accustomed to, with Dave Meltzer going as far as to suggest these clips were nothing more than an inside joke for WWE creative, as they had nothing for Emma to do. These vignettes aired for four whole months before one toe-curling, awkward promo on the February 13th, 2017 episode of Monday Night Raw put paid to the whole thing.
7. Veer Mahaan
As wrestling fans, it's our specialist subject to take something small and turn it into something that's going to change the whole universe. However, when we are baited for six months with vignettes and the promise of a powerhouse wrestler who is set to alter the landscape of WWE, we can be forgiven for expecting far more than we were given with Veer Mahaan.
Similar to the last entry, excessive vignettes were a real problem. Veer Mahaan was given six whole months of promos advertising that he was coming to Raw. Starting in October 2021, by February 2022, fans were being told that Veer "could not be contained for much longer", before being forced to wait a further two months for his actual debut, where he attacked Rey and Dominik Mysterio on April 4th, 2022.
As if this wasn't enough, WWE social media also had a part to play. Coming during a period when the momentum was seriously with AEW, WWE literally stole their rival's "Send Hook" memes, replacing Taz's son's name with "Send Veer". He never really found a place for himself on WWE or NXT television and is best known for those excessive promo vignettes.
6. JC Mateo
When it comes to accomplishments outside of the two biggest wrestling companies in the game, Jeff Cobb has it all. Having held titles in NJPW, Lucha Underground, and Ring Of Honor, as well as being a former winner of the prestigious Battle Of Los Angeles tournament in PWG, Cobb is a powerhouse beast of a man who is an asset to any company lucky enough to have them on their roster.
It begs the question, then, how has WWE managed to fumble this man's momentum in next to no time at all? Debuting as part of Solo Sikoa's MFTs, JC Mateo has been reduced to substandard matches and limited in-ring work that doesn't show a fraction of what he's capable of.
Now part of a tag team that shows little sign of being anywhere near championship caliber, Mateo's role as a bit-part player of a stable that is essentially a vehicle for Solo Sikoa is a criminal waste of his talent. Factor in that this Filipino man, born in Hawaii, is being presented as part of the very Samoan Bloodline dynasty, and this confusing mess of a character was doomed from the start.
5. Christian on ECW
Christian is a Hall of Famer by any metric you want to judge a superstar. He has elite in-ring psychology, his mic work is out of this world as both a lovable face and a dastardly heel, and his accolades and championships stand among the biggest names to ever work in the industry. Perhaps most poignantly, when it comes to this list, Christian's solo work away from the clutches of Vince McMahon has reaped the biggest rewards of his career.
After years away from WWE, the former Intercontinental, European, Hardcore, and Tag Team Champion returned as part of the new-look ECW to confront their then-World Champion, Jack Swagger. As the crowd goes suitably ballistic, Todd Grisham gives a barely interested "It's... Christian" call on commentary that totally detracts from the crowd's ovation and significance of his return to the WWE.
It would be easy to be frustrated with the announcer, but in a recent social media post, Grisham reveals that McMahon himself ordered Todd to give a muted response to Christian's arrival, going as far as to tell him to "not get excited at all". When that is the man in charge of your creative future, it becomes the definition of "dead on arrival".
4. Karrion Kross
Karrion Kross had a helter-skelter ride as an employee of WWE. Leaving with more buzz than he had at any point in his career, his initial run in NXT saw him hold the brand's world championship and have one of the most iconic entrances in the history of NXT. He may not have had the inevitability of a Seth Rollins or Kevin Owens, but any NXT World Champion arriving on the main roster is a big deal under any circumstances.
Coming during an era where WWE was in the creative doldrums, Vince McMahon's decision-making ranged from baffling to downright insulting. Among the most egregious of these plays, Karrion Kross debuted on the July 19th, 2021 edition of Monday Night Raw while still holding the NXT Championship to face Jeff Hardy. Things felt off from the beginning, as Kross was stripped of his dramatic chromatic entrance and was not flanked by his usual accomplice, Scarlett.
Hardy is an all-time legend in WWE, but had suffered losses to John Morrison, Veer, Mustafa Ali, and Jinder Mahal in the six weeks prior to his match against Kross. Jeff would defeat Kross with a roll-up in less than two minutes in a win that baffled the watching audience, in a move that took Kross literally years to recover from. He finally did and was then let go by WWE in August of this year.
3. The Viking Experience
For a few years, it was the IWC's running joke that performers were about to get a silly name change when debuting on WWE's main roster. We may all love Gunther now, but the artist formerly known as Walter had to overcome initial ridicule when Vince McMahon decided to alter the name of a performer who was known and loved all over the world.
The War Raiders were a deadly NXT Tag Team with a name that was as intimidating as their look and in-ring prowess. The Viking Experience sounds like an on-the-nose name for an exhibit at your stuffy local museum, but that didn't stop Vinnie Mac from messing with Erik and Ivar's aura in one badly thought-out swoop.
The meltdown from fans was nuclear. In an interview with Chris Van Vliet, Erik admits to approaching Triple H to ask him if their new name was a rib or not. The whole story gets even more bizarre when it was revealed that Vince was obsessed with the TV show 'Vikings' at the time. The name was changed to The Viking Raiders the next week, but The Viking Experience is a running joke that follows The War Raiders to this day.
2. Tensai
Matt Bloom has been a vital cog in the WWE machine in recent years, serving as the company's head trainer. You may have known him by one of his many in-ring names. Prince Albert or A-Train will probably ring a few bells, but Bloom's rebrand as Lord Tensai may not be on as many people's radars.
Vignettes began to air in the first quarter of 2012, using traditional Japanese music, while showing an incense-charged altar and a bald figure with Japanese writing on the back of his head. So far, so fine, but the man in these promo videos was from Peabody, Massachusetts and a recognisable former Intercontinental Champion.
Debuting the evening after WrestleMania 28, on the same Monday Night Raw that saw Brock Lesnar return to WWE, Tensai came to the ring and defeated Alex Riley, and bizarrely even beat John Cena in an Extreme Rules match mere weeks after redebuting. However, the man formerly named after a penis piercing rarely got any kind of reaction and was dropped after a few months of indifferent reaction from the WWE Universe.
1. Hector Guerrero As The Gobbledy Gooker
If you thought returning on the same night that Brock Lesnar returned was a tough break, spare a thought for a man that was bulit-up intensely for months in the run up to one of the WWE's biggest shows of the year, only to be asked to jump out of an egg while dressed as a turkey on the same night that The Undertaker made his first ever company appearance.
The '90s were a much more colorful era, when our tolerance for nonsense was much higher, given that we couldn't pick up a device to share our collective "WTF?!" with everybody on Earth at an instant. That said, after months of being promised a surprise that would change the game at Survivor Series 1990, and with rumors swirling of Ric Flair's arrival, being served The Gobbledy Gooker was an all-time gaffe from WWE.
The stunned silence of the audience before they erupt into a chorus of boos is glorious. Roddy Piper and Gorilla Monsoon on commentary do their best to try and convince the audience watching at home that the crowd at the Civic Center in Hartford, CT had been won over. Meanwhile, the audience looks on with a mixture of dismay and despair. The Gooker was actually played by Hector Guerrero, and unsurprisingly dropped around a month after his Survivor Series debut.