10 WWE "Divas" Who Missed The Revolution

The Butterfly belt is long gone, but who among the former Divas could have excelled in today's WWE?

Aj Lee
WWE.com

Though it undeniably got off on the wrong foot last year, WWE's "#DivasRevolution" eventually did find its footing, and the women are now presented as the tough, athletic competitors that they are. It was far from a smooth transition, however, and there were many bumps and hiccups along the road to this point.

Many fans who watched through the era of the Butterfly belt may have believed the entire division (although commonly excusing Natalya) needed a clear-out to make way for the up-and-coming female talent from NXT, however mainstays like Nikki Bella, Naomi and Alicia Fox have been eager to show their ability to keep up with the new wave and justify their place on the roster.

NXT Takeover Toronto's women's championship bout between Asuka and Mickie James proved that even the previous generation of WWE Divas had what it takes to put on great matches if only given the time and opportunity. This raises the question - how many women suffered from being in the WWE at the wrong time? Now that their 'Superstar' status is in place, the Butterfly has flown away, and the Revolution is given time to be televised - here are 10 former WWE "Divas" who could have flourished in 2016.

10. Mickie James

Asuka Mickie James
WWE.com

Obviously the first pick for this collection, Mickie James proved at NXT Takeover: Toronto that she could go toe-to-toe with the notoriously stiff Asuka, and was capable of far more than the kicks, slaps, and lesbian-pollen angles she was limited to in her WWE run.

This may have come as no surprise to those who watched her rise from the early days alongside CM Punk and Julio Dinero in Raven's NWA-TNA stable The Gathering, but to many fans she is just remembered as Trish Stratus' crazy stalker, or the victim of Layla and Michelle McCool's weird bullying angle. If anyone thinks the current presentation of women in WWE isn’t a step forward, remember Piggie James?

Speaking of horrendous angles, Mickie James could have quietly disappeared into obscurity following the James Storm and Magnus feud last year in TNA, which included the infamous train tracks moment.

Takeover showed that when you throw out the ridiculous angles and just let the story be told in the ring, Mickie James has what it takes to hang with the best.


9. Gail Kim

Gail Kim TNA
IMPACT Wrestling

Gail Kim is remarkable for being a missed opportunity of WWE not just once, but on two separate runs with the company. Widely considered one of the best female wrestlers of the last generation, Gail Kim endured two stints with a company who, until now, had no real use for a talented wrestler except bikini contests and girlfriend storylines.

Prior to Gail Kim’s arrival in TNA, their women’s scene wavered between underwhelming wrestling (Leilani Kai defending the NWA women’s title in dark matches) and softcore porn (Lollipop vs Holly Wood in topless catfights). Kim served as the figurehead for a new era of women’s wrestling in TNA, stripping out the eye-candy angles and putting the focus back on the ringwork, and doing so created a viable platform for women to wrestle on television in the US without succumbing to the Diva style.

She became the inaugural TNA Knockout champion, and has since gone on to hold that title a record 6 times. This isn’t to say that TNA have utilised her to full potential either, but when they take the effort to portray her as a dominant athlete, they’re going leaps and bounds beyond were WWE drew their line.

Gail Kim has to be a massive influence to the current wave of upcoming women in wrestling, and she was supremely wasted in WWE.


8. Molly Holly

Molly Holly
WWE.com

Dating all the way back to WCW, Molly's one of the names often overlooked when Trish and Lita get the spotlight. Alongside names like Ivory, she was slotted into an automatic heel role simply for not being a sex object.

Although the irony is no doubt missed by WWE, the ‘Revolution’ which has distanced the current wave of women in WWE from the bra -&-panties, lingerie-battle-royal matches of the Divas moniker was a cause beckoned for by the top heels of that time. This is glaring with Ivory’s run with the Right To Censor, but Molly Holly’s second-wave heel character also tapped into this same genre, and seemingly based entirely around her unwillingness to shed clothing like the Smackdown divas, who were feuding over Playboy shoots and who would become the other’s mother in law.

Instead, on Raw, Molly Holly was fighting as a “pure and wholesome” athlete, who even put her hair on the line in order for the women’s championship match to not be cut from Wrestlemania XX. As the Raw Diva Search took off, Holly was quietly sidelined from TV before eventually leaving the company. If the Nora Greenwald of the year 2000 walked into 2016 WWE, we’d have seen a very different presentation.


7. AJ Lee

AJ lee Promo Divas Champion
WWE.com

AJ Lee left WWE right in a very interesting time. The #GiveDivasAChance hashtag kicked off in late February in regards to Paige & Emma losing in a one-move, 30-second match against the Bella Twins, just a week after Sasha Banks had defeated Charlotte, Bayley and Becky Lynch in an amazing fatal 4-way match for the NXT women’s championship at Takeover: Rival. The contrast between the two products was clear, and the rumblings had began. A few controversial tweets questioning Stephanie McMahon’s handling of the women in WWE and one Wrestlemania later, and AJ was gone by April.

But don’t get it twisted, even after three of the four in that Takeover fatal 4-way were brought up to the main roster, the first move of the Bellas v B.A.D. v PCB era of the ‘Revolution’ was to ensure Nikki Bella eclipsed AJ Lee’s record on the butterfly belt before Charlotte reached it.

It’s easy to say “What If AJ Had Stayed One More Year”, to wonder if she would have still quit with the presentation and personnel of the division as it is currently; but it’s also possible that without her making the noise and leaving, the changes never would have been as major as they were. Kinda comparable to one CM Punk, eh?


6. Victoria

Tara TNA
TNA

Victoria’s kayfabe career progression is astounding: She debuted as prostitute, the Godfather’s “head ho”, and went on to defeat Trish Stratus for the women’s champion within just two years. Slotted into the “Crazy Bitch” archetype for Divas angles, Victoria was presented as a legitimately dominant threat to the women’s division - partly because of the aforementioned crazy, and also due to her sidekick Steven Richards, who wasn’t afraid to hit a woman.

Victoria’s initial run throughout 2002-04 was actually a bit of a hot-streak for the women’s scene, as the Raw half of the roster had been given a bit more meat to chew on than the Smackdown eye-candy roles, including WWE’s first women’s cage match, where Victoria defeated Lita.

Sadly, it wasn’t long before she was relegated to the Divas storylines that were the norm through this era of WWE. After four or so years of nothing much (the Vince’s Devils angle goes here), Victoria retired from WWE, only to resurface months later as TNA’s Tara.

Somewhat of a Jake Roberts-esque take on the Knockouts division, Tara would carry her pet tarantula to the ring and leave it to walk across the bodies of those she defeated. Her stint with TNA lasted two years, but in that time she showed a great ability to not only hang with the likes of Gail Kim and Mickie James, but also recreate herself as a new character and new entity after surviving WWE.


5. Ivory

Ivory WWE Women's Champion
WWE.com

Ivory is legit. Wrestling since 1986, the former GLOW and POWW champion was a veteran even by the time she first reached WWE in 1999. Ever the clear case of a good heel - you may have hated her back in the day, but man do you appreciate her in retrospect. She came into WWE in a time where they simply didn’t give a damn about women’s wrestling, and still managed to leave an impact.

Comparable to Molly Holly’s run as the heel prude with no sex appeal, Ivory is most remembered for her Right To Censor character, where simply wanting to be seen as a wrestler rather than a model in a pool of jello makes you the villain of the story.

Ivory was signed with WWE until 2005, although had been absent from TV since December of 2003. It’s hard to imagine that one of the few women of the Attitude Era who could actually wrestle a match was left to fade into such obscurity, but also to be almost ignored in an era where Trish and Lita are constantly heralded as legends.


4. Ivelisse

Ivelisse Lucha Underground
El Rey Network

Ever the tale of “What Could Have Been”, one of Lucha Underground’s shining stars Ivelisse Vélez was once signed to WWE. Long before the Temple called, she was Sofia Cortez on the fifth season of Tough Enough, who went onto be founding member of The Anti-Divas stable alongside Paige and Raquel Diaz (Eddie Guerrero’s daughter) before FCW rebranded as the NXT we know and love today.

Ivelisse left due to issues with then-head coach Bill DeMott, who resigned in 2015 following a flood of misconduct accusations, but she’s noted as having left the developmental system at the same time as Sasha Banks, Bayley, and Charlotte were joining as new recruits.

While she has gone onto create an impact in Lucha Underground parallel to that of those very recruits in NXT, the question remains of Ivelisse’s potential in the current climate had she remained in WWE.


3. Jacqueline

Jacqueline Women's Champion
WWE.com

If all you saw of Jackie Moore’s career was her induction to the WWE Hall of Fame, you’d believe she was a pioneer who set the WWE ablaze, paving the way for a whole generation of women’s wrestlers. While it’s hard to argue that she didn’t achieve a lot in her run, it seems very convenient for WWE to have retroactively presented her as a dominant force of the women's division around the time of Wrestlemania 32 (which featured the retirement of the Divas name and title), and suspiciously less-so afterwards.

Jackie had a long history before WWE, dating back to 1991 on the independent circuit (including a brief stint in WCW). Unfortunately for Jackie, she joined WWE in the wake of Alundra Blayze and had to carry Sable through the late 90's boom of eye-candy instead of wrestling. She was a mainstay of the Attitude era, and was released in 2004 when creative was at a loss as to how to utilise her, despite having a stacked roster of talented female wrestlers to pair her with.

She made the rounds of TNA, working with other mainstays of this list like Mickie James and Gail Kim. For a brief period in the late 00’s, the Knockouts division was everything the WWE is trying to create today, but cast with wrestlers WWE didn’t see the worth in keeping around.


2. Kaitlyn

Kaitlyn WWE
WWE.com

With a spear to rival Roman Reigns (or even the topical Goldberg), genuine charisma on the mic, and aggressive chemistry alongside the then-core of the division, AJ Lee, Kaitlyn seemed to have all the makings of a long-term star.

Her match against AJ Lee at 2013’s Payback is considered by many to have been the best Divas division match in years, in an era where the only women’s wrestling of note in WWE was strictly on NXT. The two were often compared to Trish and Lita, a likeness not only drawn from their base character types, but also their undeniable chemistry together both in the ring and in promos.

Unfortunately, just when it seemed she was settling into position, the focus for the division took a turn towards the cast of Total Divas, and Kaitlyn dropped into the background. Shortly afterwards, Celeste Bonin and WWE mutually parted ways, and with the exception of Big E’s twitter feed, her run as Kaitlyn is not looked back upon with any lasting significance.


1. Paige

paige raw
WWE.com

Time will tell on this one, but at the time of writing Paige’s status post-Divas Revolution has been a complete bust.

When Paige made the leap from NXT to the main roster, she looked to be the change of direction long overdue in the division. An equal to AJ Lee, and a decided departure from the likes of an Eva Marie, Rosa Mendes or Cameron. When nothing really changed below the surface of the division, however, the common excuse was that she had no one else to work with.

Of course, after taking the title from AJ Lee, Paige worked in lacklustre matches against Aksana, Tamina Snuka, and Brie Bella before playing her and AJ Lee played hot potato with the title a few times. The solution then became clear, that when the current run of NXT women joined the ranks of the division, Paige would finally have people at her level to work with.

Now, more than a year after the awful P.C.B./B.A.D./Team Bella feud, Paige is still yet to put on an interesting match outside of her NXT run, and she has become more notable for controversy outside of the ring than within.

Has she missed her shot? We’ll have to wait and see.


Contributor

An Australian fan of wrestling, keen proponent of NXT Takeover: Boggo Road, and the repackaging of Nathan Jones as Road Warrior Dingo.