10 WWE Ideas EVEN Vince McMahon Thought Were Too Sleazy
Beaver silicone cleavage.
Vince McMahon is such a grotesque figure that you can never be too sure that any of this isn't a simulation, that you aren't a mere bystander in his story cruelly granted consciousness through the laws of the multiverse.
He is, simply, too broad and on-the-nose an antagonist in a satirical takedown of modern America.
Vince McMahon helpfully offered to become the onscreen father of his daughter's real, biological child when he wondered aloud how to properly monetise her. When Stephanie declined, he understood. Of course. I'm too old, that would be disgusting.
What about your brother Shane?
Blasphemy; simulated mock necrophilia; implied rape; terrorist attacks committed with piano wire; widow-pesterin'; simulated murder by hanging: angles in which women are dehumanised to the status of canines; angles in which cunnilingus is forced upon women; angles in which Olympic heroes express their desire to engage in "beastiality sex" with the black wives of their fellow athletes: all have made air.
There are however some ideas that Vince balked at, or otherwise couldn't bring himself to promote for longer than a week - and think of the ground, littered with piles of such good sh*t, that that covers...
10. Beaver Loves Cleavage
Vince McMahon had two 'white whales' he was beyond driven to pursue throughout his career as a wrestling promoter. One was to pack 100,000 punters into a football stadium, which he managed with a bald-faced lie.
The other was to script two blood relatives to f*ck each other on television.
In 1999, a series of rancid vignettes aired hyping the arrival of 'Beaver Cleavage'. A riff on Leave It To Beaver's preadolescent protagonist, where the Beaver of the 1960s staple got into various scrapes, discovering in the end that good behaviour is rewarded, the WWF's Beaver was named after a fanny and wanted to suck his mother's t*ts. This was the full scope of a gimmick that worked just the one televised match against Christian: he used his mischievous disposition to get his mother to touch him.
And if you're wondering why a man in arrested development with such a grotesquely close bond with his mother would choose the life of a travelling combat athlete, fear not: Mrs. Cleavage accompanied Beaver to the ring, allowing the WWF to promote another buxom blonde on TV.
This was too disgusting even for the most overtly 'Vince Russo' period of the WWF, and was swiftly abandoned.
9. Paul & Katie Lea Burchill: Too Close For Cumfort
Vince McMahon wanted two blood relatives to f*ck on his television programme with the same ungodly determination as Michael Jordan wanted to win a sixth NBA Championship.
A tasteless, appalling and pointless idea - these people are combat athletes, you daft auld f*cker - he persisted despite abject failure and total revulsion. Twice he had tried, and twice he was met with stunned, incredulous reactions.
But perhaps the third time was the charm, and so, with an unnatural desire pumping through his veins during those midnight gym sessions - this is why other people tend to sleep, Mr. McMahon - he debuted Katie Lea as the sister of UK standout Paul Burchill. The relatives exhibited an unsettling closeness on television, the overtones of which were further alluded to when Paul would remark "Whatever Katie wants, Katie gets".
The subtext, if you didn't manage to catch it, is that Katie wanted his c*ck.
Perhaps Vince McMahon is as good a man as 'Taker said he was on The Last Ride - a man capable of walking himself back from the cliff of immorality.
Or perhaps his ad revenue cut was threatened as WWE embarked on the PG Era around about the same time.
8. Mickie James Simulates Oral
In 2004, WWE presented the Diva Search: a contest held to determine the company's next purveyor of sex appeal in which, incredibly, its participants were allowed free rein with which to verbally slaughter one another on national television.
The infamous 'Diss The Diva' segment saw the women "diss" one another's penchant for burping up semen. This was presumably OK, since the Search continued for some number of years afterwards. What wasn't OK was the conduct of Mickie James at WrestleMania 22 in 2006.
In her match with Trish Stratus, James, playing a crazed, spurned obsessive stalker, grabbed Stratus by the crotch and simulated cunnilingus. This, at least, was in character. Vince - the man who pushed a son-in-law who told you to suck him off for 25 consecutive years - blew a gasket. The spot was removed from the home video broadcast of the show and its Network streams by the man who in parallel to this tickled the oesophagus of Candice Michelle.
Vince, a paradox, has a very strange personality foible in that he believes, selectively and with hypocrisy, that he is a man of sophistication.
7. Blading, General
Vince McMahon cannot abide the blade.
Bret Hart loved it so much that he named his kid after it.
And so began a dance of deception as old as time itself, in which Bret, so skilled at the dark art, was able to fool Vince McMahon twice. At WrestleMania VIII, Bret did that which Ric Flair failed to do, and bladed away from the incriminating glare of the camera. Again, at In Your House: Season's Beatings, Hart bladed in his match with the British Bulldog to no reprisal. His sleight of hand was so deft that it obscured from Vince the very convenient placement of the very shallow cut, which realistically could only materialise from a blade-job. On this basis, Bret could have shagged Linda, claimed she tripped, fell and landed on his d*ck, and Vince wouldn't order him to pay the fine.
Vince hated the practise, and deems it tawdry today, preferring instead the concussive blunt force trauma that is trained killer Brock Lesnar's massive, massive elbow as a means of forcibly extracting blood.
Vince McMahon cannot abide the blade.
6. Heidenreich Becomes A Nazi
There's Heidenreich pictured above reading from 'Mein Kampf'.
Or at least it might have been, had Vince McMahon approved former creative writer Dan Madigan's 2004 pitch: the pitch to repackage Heidenreich as a cryogenically frozen nazi stormtrooper resusciated by the Jewish son of a holocaust survivor, Paul Heyman.
The best thing about this rejected idea is that it in all likelihood punished what was a profoundly lazy thought process.
"Heidenreich..."
"Reich...."
"Third Reich..."
"I've got it! Let's make 'im a nazi!"
Had Heidenreich thawed out in 2020 and logged on to Twitter, he might have been quite happy. But alas he did not, because this was a spectacularly offensive idea so bad that it offended those in the power walls of Titan Towers, a place that ain't f*ckin' Disneyland, that's for sure. What a gigantic yikes. The Muhammad Hassan character was created a year later, so perhaps they were disgusted at how passé the distaste was?
Vince McMahon was famously so appalled that he left the room in disgust, and didn't return that day. He might have just been a bit hungry.
Can't rule that out.
5. Goldust's Bizarre Surgery Idea
Goldust was, if nothing else, a testament to the ability of the man behind the paint.
A giant Texan prodigy of a babyface, the WWF's mandatory random repackage generator somehow spewed out Goldust, an androgynous, bizarre psychological sex predator heel. Rhodes stumbled not into the WWF but opposite land in 1995, and he still pulled off the character so well that it became synonymous with him. An intoxicating and important time capsule, his outrageously compelling early run has dated horrendously - the psychology is regressive, the work an afterthought - and it didn't hook audiences after the initial, lurid furore.
The WWF subsequently ballooned in fascination, rendering Goldust normal, somehow, and he struggled to get over as The Artist Formerly Known as Goldust, a character that amounted to a weekly rejected pitch meeting of desperate, controversial new gimmicks that played out onscreen.
What if I'm a gimp?
What if I black up?
What if...
...I get breast implants?!
Yes, Rhodes, desperate to reverse his fading run, offered to surgically alter himself for real, Mechanical Animals-style, to set the conversation ablaze once more. Incredibly, Vince McMahon and Bruce Prichard talked him out of it. Perhaps out of kindness - this was an incredible sacrifice, when they couldn't put the silicone back in the tube - or perhaps because Vince truly felt this was problematic, hollow shock value.
They could have called him 'Goldbust'.
Thank you.
4. Marlena Smoking Cigars
On the subject of Goldust, to further shroud the character in mystery, fascination - and ratings, it was hoped - the androgynous character, played by a man who displayed overt homosexual tendencies, was flanked to the ring by Marlena. A buxom blonde bombshell patterned after classic film star Marlene Dietrich, she completed an ingenious act precision engineered to spark a grunting, interested frown in middle America.
Her orientation was less difficult to determine, because the hidden subtext of the ever-present cigar she smoked was a c*ck.
Vince McMahon famously loathes smoking, but it's not entirely clear whether his distaste for her smoking cigars in particular was linked to the simmering suggestion of oral sex which, as we've established, is perfectly fine for the son-in-law and not for women, plural. Unless that woman is Candice Michelle, which was fine, but only because she was getting noshed out at the same time as Triple H.
Jerry Lawler was a fan on commentary - no sh*t - telling Vince that you've gotta love a woman who smokes cigars. "No thank you" he said in response to the gentle rib.
Vince hated this sleazy update on Hollywood glamour so much that at first he was reluctant to allow Marlena to light them.
3. Batista: It's Weird To Even Print This, It's That Bad
In an appearance on the Talk Is Jericho podcast, Batista revealed a mercifully abandoned gimmick he was set to play before better judgment prevailed, or Vince McMahon simply forgot.
Batista was to play a constantly angry man enraged throughout his life because he was a product of rape which, no. WWE had zero chance of portraying such a character sensitively. The idea of a heel using the background of the character for heat is gross, obviously, but equally revolting is the idea of his arc cleansing his psyche in some way. Imagine the tactless implication of Batista achieving a psychological breakthrough through winning a World title or some b*llocks. Picture the scene. It's WrestleMania 21. Batista has just won the World Heavyweight Title.
"A lifetime of trauma washes away, King, as Triple H decides Batista has the requisite amount of muscles and a short enough career window to do the predetermined job!"
This gimmick never did make it to television explicitly, which is just as well; it was a hideous shock value consistent with Ruthless Aggression's charmless, dragged-out Attitude Era continuation.
2. Signing Brock Lesnar Ronda Rousey (Sort Of)
You're allowed to change your mind and all that, but this anecdote is very telling, as it pertains to Vince McMahon's mentality, things of that nature.
CM Punk revealed on his infamous Art of Wrestling bridge incineration that Vince McMahon refused him the opportunity to walk Chael Sonnen to the octagon for his UFC fight with Michael Bisping. Punk reckoned the publicity might generate some last-minute buys for the upcoming Royal Rumble 2012 held 24 hours later. Vince was appalled. UFC is "barbaric," he said, mere months before former UFC Heavyweight Champion Brock Lesnar drilled real blood from the skull of John Cena on WWE RAW to build their match at WWE Extreme Rules.
"Somebody's gonna die," Vince reasoned, UFC was that sleazy.
"God, they'd probably continue with the show!" he followed up.
The idea was nixed, and of course Lesnar's re-debut in April exposed his rank hypocrisy. Vince also asked Punk to think of the children, explaining, incredulously, that women were set to compete in UFC later that year.
Women!
Punk welcomed the development at which Vince was aghast...
...until January 2018, when Ronda Rousey made her debut as a contracted talent.
1. Chris Jericho Tattoos CM Punk
The CM Punk Vs. Chris Jericho programme of 2012 was missing something that elevated it to anywhere near its potential. It ended admirably enough, and it wasn't remotely bad, but the dynamic was absurdly rich. This should have banged across every verbal and physical story beat.
It didn't.
Jericho was an astute enough performer and dastardly enough prick heel to immediately grab the nearest bottle of liquor and force it down Punk's straight edge throat - but it wasn't a major, groundbreaking, unforgettable heat angle. It wasn't too dissimilar to what Jerry Lawler was doing to Jake Roberts in 1996. It lacked the real verve that ignites the performer with the grandest stage looming, and that's because the meh quality was a result of its compromise.
Jericho first had the ingenious idea to tattoo his initials on Punk's body. It had never been done, it would have been iconic, and it would have been perfectly in character for both hero and antagonist: Jericho did it to disrespect Punk and literally own him, or a part of him, where Punk would have used its constant reminder as fuel for vengeance.
It was a fantastic idea.
It was precisely what that feud needed.
It didn't happen because Vince was squeamish at the small trickle of blood that would be visible. The same Vince McMahon, again, who booked Brock Lesnar to drill a hole into John Cena's head about two months later.
That main event grievance thing: it's not just about where the match is positioned on the card.