10 WWE Main Eventers Fans Rejected
These are not "The Guys" you're looking for.
Jinder Mahal's sudden ascent as WWE Champion has been met with a swift, venomous backlash. A lifelong enhancement talent, he was plucked from obscurity and named Randy Orton's number one contender on 18 April, then took the title a month later. The company haven't thrust somebody with so little in-ring credibility into the spotlight in a long time, and it is already affecting business, with Backlash ticket sales stalling as soon as the match was announced.
It'll be a while before anyone can realistically deem Mahal's push a success or failure, but the metrics don't look good, even at this early stage. One thing's for sure, though: the online reaction has been largely negative, and huge chunks of the fanbase have already rejected Jinder as a top guy.
This isn't the first time, and it won't be the last. WWE fans don't always share the promotion's idea of who should be pushed, and they're never shy of letting the whole world know about it. The company can't please everyone all the time, but these miscast main eventers either put the audience to sleep, incited their anger, or compelled them to change the channel...
10. Batista (2014)
There was little wrong with Batista's first WWE run, but his second was a different matter entirely. The Guardians Of The Galaxy star returned to the company in January 2014, announcing his participation in the Royal Rumble, then confronting WWE Champion Randy Orton on the go-home episode of Raw.
Batista received a politely warm reception upon returning, but this would change by the end of the week. Entering the Rumble at number 28, he eliminated four other men to win the match for the second time in his career, setting him up for a big title fight at WrestleMania XXX.
There was just one major problem with this: he wasn’t Daniel Bryan. The “Yes!” Movement was at the height of its power, and DB’s huge fanbase were incensed at their hero’s exclusion from the Rumble. Batista was booed out of the building because he’d taken a spot many thought belonged to Bryan, and the “Bootista” meme was born.
The fans’ backlash was so severe that WWE had no choice but to turn Batista heel. ‘The Animal’ himself has since admitted that returning as a babyface was a huge mistake, and ultimately nuked his comeback’s chances of succeeding.
9. Bob Backlund
Bob Backlund's six-year WWE Championship reign is the second longest in company history. First capturing the belt in 1978, Backlund acted as a stepping stone from one era to another, as Bruno Sammartino’s career was winding down, and Hulkamania was still to peak.
He was perfectly acceptable as the face of the company for a while, but fans eventually grew weary of him, and by the '80s, Backlund's saccharine goody-two-shoes persona and increasingly repetitive matches had fans yearning for a more exciting and dynamic figurehead. Nicknamed 'Howdy Doody' by The Grand Wizard, Bob's act looked obsolete when compared to the surging Hulk Hogan, and his inability to evolve in line with the audience's expectations saw them turn on him.
With the fans clamouring for the more charismatic and eye-catching Hogan, Vince McMahon initially suggested Backlund turn heel to lose the title to 'The Hulkster.' Bob refused, however, showcasing the disconnect between his outdated mentality and what the fans wanted to see at the time. This led to him dropping the WWE Championship to The Iron Sheik, with the Iranian’s transitional reign quickly giving way to Hogan, who carried the company through wrestling's 'Golden Age.' Backlund, meanwhile took an eight-year hiatus from WWE, and didn't return until 1992.
8. Jack Swagger
Jack Swagger entered WWE full of promise. A former amateur wrestling standout, ‘The All-American American’ debuted on ECW, and captured his first piece of gold just four months later. He held onto the ECW Championship for over 100 days before eventually dropping it to Christian, and transitioning to Raw in 2009.
Swagger initially competed for the US Title, but soon shot towards the top of the card. He became Mr. Money In The Bank in 2010 and cashed-in just a few days later, pinning Chris Jericho to become World Heavyweight Champion.
It was a shocking move, and one that Swagger never truly recovered from. His push had come too fast and too soon for fans to believe in him as a top champion, and he couldn’t get over. Poor old Jack had been thrust into a spotlight that he just wasn’t ready for, and it was impossible to take him seriously as “the guy,” particularly when competing against the likes of Jericho and Randy Orton.
Swagger’s reign was destructive, and effectively ended all hope of becoming a permanent main eventer. A long, slow tumble down the card followed, leading to his eventual 2017 release, by which point he’d become utterly listless.
7. John Cena
When John Cena eventually retires, he’ll go down as one of the most divisive performers in WWE history. He has been pushed as the company’s franchise player for well over a decade, and the 15 years since his debut have been wrought with arguments over his push, character, wrestling ability, and unfortunate propensity to bury every rising star he does battle with.
Roman Reigns has since inherited Cena’s role as WWE’s most detested babyface, but the 16-time World Champion’s stubborn detractors remain. In fairness, his rap sheet is too long to ignore. Bray Wyatt, Wade Barrett, and countless others have seen their momentum squashed by the unstoppable Cena juggernaut, and the “never give up” shtick is trite and nauseating. This has more to do with the way John has been booked than any fault of the man himself, of course, but the backlash is understandable.
Cena’s heat diminishes with every passing year, as increasing numbers of fans grow to appreciate what he brings to the business. He has always had a huge following among younger fans, but Cena was one of the most hated men in the company at the peak of his Superman push, which can’t be disregarded.
6. Diesel
Few individual wrestlers had a bigger impact on the sport’s fortunes than Kevin Nash did in the 1990s. His jump to WCW with Scott Hall and the duo’s formation of the New World Order helped shift the Monday Night Wars in his new employers’ favour, and served as the catalyst for Nitro's 84 consecutive weeks of dominance in the ratings battle.
Before that, Nash was one of the lowest drawing WWE Champions of all time. Kicking off in 1994, Diesel’s title reign was supposed to reverse the decline in PPV buyrates and attendances, but had the opposite effect. PPV business tanked with Diesel as champion, with WrestleMania losing 80,000 buyers from the previous year, SummerSlam dropping 95,000, and Survivor Series 126,000.
The most astonishing thing is that Diesel held the belt for close to a year before finally dropping it to Hart in November 1995. His reign remains one of the most maligned in WWE history, and Nash would continue courting controversy throughout his career, with many citing him as one of the lead architects of WCW’s demise.
5. Rikishi
It’s easy to forget that Rikishi was a white-hot upper-midcard babyface at the turn of the century. His alignment with Too Cool made him one of the most popular guys on the roster, and after years of obscurity as Fatu and The Sultan, Rikishi had finally found his place as a fun-loving pseudo sumo blessed with surprising skill levels for a man of his size.
Unfortunately, Rikishi’s popularity came screeching to a halt in 2000. In a move designed to install him as WWE’s next big main event heel, the company revealed him as the man who ran down Stone Cold Steve Austin at Survivor Series ‘99, and nobody bought into it. One week prior, Rikishi was a happy go lucky hip-hop dancer with a fondness for rubbing his ample posterior in people’s faces: now, he was being painted as an attempted murderer.
Nobody took to Rikishi as a villain, and his turn was a total disaster. The angle soon ran out of steam, and WWE abandoned it quickly, unveiling Triple H as the real mastermind behind the incident. Rikishi’s reactions had gone from explosive face pops to complete silence, and he was never able to regain his lost popularity.
4. Mabel
Shawn Michaels’ face turn left WWE short of top heels in 1995, leaving Vince McMahon with the challenge of building a credible new villain to play antagonist to his plethora of good guys. He decided that Mabel of Men On A Mission was to be that guy, and the giant bruiser was crowned 1995 King Of The Ring that June, defeating Savio Vega in the finals.
Mabel’s push was a complete disaster. It was impossible to take his thuggish new persona seriously after his role in one of WWE’s corniest tag teams, and his slow, lumbering style made him painful to watch whenever he stepped into the ring. Thus, Mabel didn’t get over with the crowd, and his WWE Championship bout at SummerSlam ‘95 is widely regarded as one of the era’s worst main events.
WWE fortunately realised that Mabel was failing, and yanked him from the title picture shortly afterwards. Nobody was reacting to his push, and amidst allegations of clumsiness after injuring several of his colleagues, WWE had no choice but to demote him. Mabel’s elevation was ill advised from the start, and while the audience totally rejected him, at least they didn’t have to suffer him for long.
3. The Great Khali
Jinder Mahal’s run as a main event heel has only just begun, but while ‘The Maharaja’ has already attracted plenty of rejection, it’d take a gargantuan effort for him to tank as hard as his countryman, The Great Khali.
A lumbering 7’1" brute, Khali had next to nothing going for him in the ring. His moveset was beyond basic, featuring only a couple of legitimate wrestling holds, and his execution was sloppy at best. Khali was also so slow and plodding that he made Mark Henry look like a sprightly young Cruiserweight by comparison, and his name quickly became a running joke among the WWE faithful as a result.
Khali’s crippling shortcomings meant he never got over as a monster heel, but Vince McMahon kept pushing him regardless. The big man destroyed the likes of Batista and Kane with ease, manhandling his way through the roster throughout his first year with the company, before eventually becoming World Heavyweight Champion in July 2007.
Widely regarded as one of the worst wrestlers to ever hold the belt, Khali mercifully dropped the title after just two months. Size, unfortunately, was the only thing he ever had going for him, and the sole reason he was pushed in the first place.
2. The Ultimate Warrior
One of the most controversial figures in wrestling history he may be, but The Ultimate Warrior was absurdly popular at one point. His initial success was so strong that he was eventually groomed as Hulk Hogan’s long-term replacement as WWE’s franchise player, and WrestleMania VI was his grand coronation.
‘The Ultimate Challenge’ put Warrior’s Intercontinental Title against Hogan’s WWE Championship, and Warrior was victorious. He left the building as a double champion, which should have been the making of him as “the guy,” but instead transformed into the beginning of the end of Warrior’s ascent, with a swift decline soon to follow.
WWE were ready to move on from Hogan, but the fans weren’t. Warrior just couldn’t escape ‘The Hulkster’s’ shadow as WWE Champion, and it didn’t help that he’d already crushed most of his potential challengers on his road to the top. Warrior’s crowd reactions plummeted as a result, and attendances soon followed suit, as more and more of the fanbase rejected him as the company’s centrepiece.
WWE were eventually forced to hand the belt back to Hogan after a transitional Sgt. Slaughter reign just to stop the rot, sending them back to square one, and marking Warrior’s push as the ultimate failure.
1. Roman Reigns
With John Cena’s career finally on the downswing, Roman Reigns has inherited the mantle of WWE’s hand-picked golden boy. Though presented as a babyface, the Samoan regularly draws the company’s loudest heel reactions, and he’s routinely pushed as the most important and protected wrestler on the roster, whether championships are involved or not.
The Reigns backlash really kicked into overdrive at the 2015 Royal Rumble, when even The Rock couldn’t save him from the baying masses. In spite of this, Reigns' push has slowed at points, but never truly stalled, and no matter how overwhelming the fans’ negativity becomes, WWE are happy to stay their course.
It’s hard to imagine Roman ever being fully accepted in his current role. He’s a tremendous wrestler, and would likely make an excellent heel, but he’s booked so dominantly that it’s impossible to feel sympathy for him. Regardless, Roman isn’t going anywhere, and will be pushed as “the guy” for as long as Vince McMahon is around.
Like Cena, Reigns is a huge merch-shifter, and very popular among certain fan demographics. His detractors are much louder than his supporters, however, and they’ll never accept his main event status without a significant shift in character.