10 WWE Matches That Delivered On Their Massive Hype
"This is awesome."
Sunday's Traditional Men's Survivor Series Elimination Match did not deliver on its massive hype. They should have renamed it Satire Series: this match was the gravest fears of the most jaded pocket of the fanbase, manifested.
"They'll eliminate Shinsuke Nakamura first."
"Bobby Roode is only in there for comic relief."
"Everything will come down to Shane McMahon."
"Triple H will bury at least one member of Team SmackDown."
Shinsuke Nakamura was eliminated first, but he at least was treated with a degree of dignity; Bobby Roode was only in there for comic relief. He did his 'Glorious' pose, and that's about it. Shane McMahon outlasted his entire team - which included John Cena! - in order to portray him as a man of of immense intestinal fortitude. Triple H exhumed the shovel, and so clearly positioned himself as above everybody but Braun Strowman it was beyond parody - and he only protected Strowman to get a match out of him down the line. It was arguably worse than satire; nobody expected Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn to run worse interference than Brutus Beefcake trying to talk down Randy Savage in 1989.
WWE's pay-per-view canon is littered with disappointments - and many of those involve Triple H, incidentally. That said, you cannot entirely loathe the man; he was responsible for something absolutely incredible just 24 hours earlier...
10. WarGames Match - NXT TakeOver: WarGames
WarGames was so awesome.
If the Survivor Series main event was an exercise in abject nostalgia, WarGames was its complete antithesis. On Saturday night, the elixir of nostalgia was used to make something new from something old.
The iconic roof was removed in order to remove the shackles of a long-defunct style. The classic five-on-five formula was shelved in order to let the organic storyline play out. The single entrances were doubled down upon to further suit that storyline, reinforce the classic heel gang psychology, and speed up the build to suit an audience used to something approaching warp speed.
The inherent brutality of the WarGames match was magnified via modern weaponry, introduced by Killian Dain in what was a magnificent star-making performance. The man's appetite for destruction was made literal when he ate a d*mn key, and his star shone as he rocked the Kyle O'Reilly with the Coast To Coast. Adam Cole also benefited from this grand platform; his astute slimy heel act got over huge as he evaded the carnage with a sh*t-eating grin. The match as a whole was an über-dangerous spectacle benefitting from hardway blood and the sort of insane stunts not possible under the old constrictions.
New stars; new drama; new tropes: new WarGames was nostalgia made perfect.
9. Ric Flair Vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania XXIV
Ric Flair and Shawn Michaels had already wrestled at Bad Blood 2003 in a match within the good/respectable range. Considering the advanced ages of the performers, it was a sterling effort - but nothing truly memorable.
This belated sequel was such a masterclass of a storyline that it almost guaranteed an emotional masterpiece of a match. Flair was thrust into a career-threatening storyline by Mr. McMahon that only yielded true emotion on the night of his enforced retirement and, though tissues were at the ready, there was an element of concern among the fandom. Flair was decades removed from his prime, and years removed from a sort of mini-renaissance in which he fought The Undertaker and Triple H in shortcut-stuffed minor gems. This match was a major component of WrestleMania XXIV - but the precedent was there for pity to become the overriding emotion.
It was, but in the most rewarding way; through weaving a fabulous intra-match story in which Michaels could not bring himself to shoot Old Yeller, Flair was enraged into showcasing the fire - and deceit - of old.
We got the old, whole Flair - the sympathetic babyface and the dastardly heel - in one of the most emotional matches in WWE history.
8. Brock Lesnar Vs. Braun Strowman Vs. Samoa Joe Vs. Roman Reigns - SummerSlam 2017
WWE promised carnage.
They delivered; this WWE Match of the Year candidate saved a drawn-out SummerSlam card through virtue of being an utterly chaotic, furniture-destroying free-for-all that was simply too intense, too major, too exciting to fall asleep in front of.
It also delivered the hidden promise of a stature-enhancing performance from one Braun Strowman; the Monster Among Men established his credentials as not only an established headline talent, not only a candidate for 'The Guy', but as an actual equal to the invincible aura of Brock Lesnar, who he threw around the ringside area with careless abandon.
Unfortunately, Vince McMahon's 'The Guy' remains 'The Big Dog' - hence why Strowman was beaten so easily in a drab No Mercy singles sequel - but he emerged from the literal wreckage with enough currency to guarantee storyline protection beyond September. Strowman looked so bloody great in this match that it would not be a surprise if this was the night Triple H put his order in for WrestleMania 34.
Strowman is the Game's main course, it would seem - quite why he needs five starters is beyond comprehension.
7. Hulk Hogan Vs. The Ultimate Warrior - WrestleMania VI
The WWF, as you'd expect from the participants involved and the grand occasion, went all in on the hype for what they, with a typical lack of restraint, labelled the 'Ultimate Challenge'.
Not only was this essentially marketed as the most important match in company history, it was also a paradigm-shifter; never before had two babyfaces of this standing squared off in a WWF ring. It just didn't happen, and only happened here to firmly cement the Warrior as the new top guy of the promotion, something a transitional heel champion would have undermined.
The WWF didn't deliver a changing of the guard - Hogan's self-serving politicking, and the sand shifting below the feet of the Federation put paid to that - but ultimately, the Ultimate Challenge delivered a classic wrestling match involving a man who often needed to be a carried and a man who could only be carried to three matches of any note.
The Warrior didn't become The Guy, but this became the template for all-babyface WWF matches - a trope WWE returned to at No Mercy this year - and ushered in a revolution, if not an evolution.
6. John Cena Vs. CM Punk - Money In The Bank 2011
WWE promised a re-ordering of the wrestling world itself ahead of Money In The Bank 2011.
Wrestling a true modern classic held in what might as well have been a volcano, they over-delivered. That promise was quickly rescinded with a fit of catastrophic booking in the ensuing months, but the memory of that night remains cherished.
CM Punk's famous Pipebomb promo set the scene; disgruntled and furious, his razor-sharp incision of the WWE landscape opened up the eyes of the fanbase to the company's toxicity and creative failures. Over the course of 34 scintillating minutes, Punk and John Cena realised Punk's quest for change and (near) perfection. One of the loudest WWE matches ever was also one of the best, botches or no: Punk's brilliant Houdini act granted himself - and us - sorely-needed reprieve from John Cena's profoundly overexposed repertoire in a match of searing, nail-biting drama.
We were conditioned to expect not merely a classic, but a veritable game-changer. Punk completed a gripping story arc by escaping Cena's holds, and with his title.
He didn't split with the title. He didn't defend it in Ring of Honor, nor New Japan Pro Wrestling. But he did prove, on this night at least, that he was the best.
5. Triple H Vs. Shawn Michaels - SummerSlam 2002
Obviously, Triple H is capable of brilliance. He wouldn't inherit the Earth through being as boring as the narrative prevailing in some circles. Of course, his opponent the night of 25 August 2002, did much to glorify his CV. On that specific night; their later matches were bloated in the extreme.
This incredibly dramatic and cathartic match was hyped not as a prospective technical classic, but a war of unspeakable, life-threatening danger. Given that all watching did so with hearts in mouths over the course of 28 anxious minutes, this is one match the polarising 'Game' can hold up as a categorical classic.
You could even blame this for the genesis of the 'Triple H Match' - the slow, methodical plodders that would define his latter career for better or, in too many cases, worse. Triple H, in prime psychopath mode, slaughtered Michaels' surgically-repaired back. Michaels also drafted his latter career template in Uniondale, New York; using his near-peerless selling ability, Michaels hoodwinked his audience into believing he would emerge from this four-year absence crippled, if he emerged from it all.
This needed to be slow, in order to reinforce the emotional crux. The problem, as still isn't clear to Trips, is that few if anybody can master the space between moves as Michaels did.
4. The Rock Vs. Steve Austin - WrestleMania X-Seven
Often held aloft as the greatest video vignette the WWF ever produced, the magic of this pre-match promo was such that it elevated Limp Bizkit to mythical status. Even for those nu-metal kids who have long since grown out of baggy pants, the song in this context remains something truly emotive.
Fred Durst's "Yeah!", in the song, is a cheap, nasally way of getting to the chorus. In the promo, it's a powerful rallying cry readying you for the biggest match of a generation.
The match itself, of course, retroactively lends that promo its power; for nearly a full half hour, The Rock and Steve Austin perfected the Attitude Era popcorn brawl in a bloody, blistering and brutal performance in which they simply could not be separated via conventional means. Both men were the man; both were equally over to a stratospheric extent, both had an answer for the other's arsenal; both had stolen and perfected the other's...
Austin's heel turn, though a long-term catastrophe, was the only way logical way to separate them, at least in the storyline context of the match. For a half hour alone, it was a creative triumph.
3. Triple H Vs. Cactus Jack - Royal Rumble 2000
The classic 'Triple H Match' was structured years later, when Trips receded into older age having never recovered his physical prime.
His classic insecurity manifested as something far more palatable than would follow at Royal Rumble 2000. Unlike Randy Orton, Brock Lesnar et al., Trips did not subject Cactus Jack to a slog; he wrestled a Cactus Jack match. It was so good that you could accurately describe it as the Cactus Jack match; never before had this dangerous performer been presented as something this dangerous.
The WWF promised something grotesquely violent - "Your blood will stain New York City, I promise you that," Trips told Jack in the buildup - and we got it. That promise, while delivered, was brilliantly subverted; the 'Game' bled buckets in this ultra-violent classic in which he sold as bountifully as he bladed. This was as good as wrestling gets; Triple H entered a performance of sublime balance, in that he survived a massacre but was so repulsive in it that zero sympathy was directed towards him.
Respect, yes: sympathy, no. It wasn't 'all about the Game' - and was far better for it.
2. Hulk Hogan Vs. André The Giant - WrestleMania III
Re-watching this match, it's hard not to snort as Bob Uecker announced a "one-hour" time limit. This was never going an hour. It was never going to be a mechanical classic.
The WWF promised a meeting between the Irresistible Force Vs. the Immovable Object - an unpredictable mega-match in which something unthinkable had to happen. Either Hulkamania was to die, or the most unconquerable wrestling force ever was to be conquered. It didn't matter that the premise was built on a lie; with no internet and only a minute newsletter circulation, you couldn't smell the bullsh*t.
It also didn't matter that the preceding 11:52 of the 12:01 match consisted of nought else but a physically deteriorated André slowly stalking Hogan, who to his credit did work hard to create the illusion of some action. His selling was histrionic but believable, his comebacks timed to his peerless perfection - at least in terms of eliciting a crowd response. It only mattered that the WWF delivered; they created an iconic moment that buttressed the company as a cultural cornerstone, and generated unprecedented revenue.
The unthinkable did happen, and André's manager, Bobby Heenan, sold it wonderfully. As he headed to the back in a cart, he held his head in his hands the whole way.
1. The Rock Vs. Hollywood Hogan - WrestleMania X8
Icon Vs. Icon worked as sublimely as it did because it created one of the most iconic ever WrestleMania matches and moments. Anything less would have represented total failure - but was it ever in doubt?
Yes. Hulk Hogan's WCW run was atrocious in the ring; once the (admittedly huge) novelty of his nWo heel turn wore off, it was business as usual insofar as the crowd reactions to his pitiful performances went. Late into his WCW stint, back in the red and yellow and fighting The Wall, Hogan's drawing muscle looked as shot as his physical being - and the pathetic WWFnWo reprise hardly helped fans reciprocate the astonishing hype hawked ahead of Toronto.
Hogan is one of the smartest ever wrestling politicians - but he needed only ears in the SkyDome to recognise that the fans were firmly on his side, riding a wave of wild nostalgia. With one flex of his 24 inch pythons, the alignments had changed: Hogan was now the face, Rock was now the heel - and the look of sudden delight etched on his face was mirrored by one of the hottest WWF/E crowds ever.
The match evolved from epic to industry-changing, and Hogan hadn't even applied a wrestling hold. That's why he's the greatest worker of all time.