10 WWE Midcarders Who Would Be Main Eventers In AEW
The only way is up.
AEW already has a promising main event scene: with veterans the likes of Chris Jericho, new blood like Adam Page, internationally-proven stars like Kenny Omega, and ex-WWE main eventers like Jon Moxely.
While AEW wouldn't want to make the same mistakes as Impact Wrestling - by filling their roster with any former WWE talents they can get their hands on and immediately interjecting them into the main event picture - there are some WWE competitors who are simply too good for their current positions within the company: competitors who AEW wouldn't be able to resist granting a deserved headline spot to.
With AEW looking to offer a more sports centered presentation - as opposed to Vince McMahon's entertainment first initiative - it paves the way for higher work rate wrestlers to rise up the cards, particularly those capable of hanging in a sixty-minute bout with the likes of Omega. WWE has such stars in abundance, but they're usually regulated to the mid-card at best, and purgatory at worst.
These stars may not necessarily ever find themselves within WWE's newest rival's ranks, but if they were to jump ship, their stock would instantly rise and they would suddenly find themselves as pivotal players within an organisation.
10. Dolph Ziggler
Yes, we're in the age where a former two time world champion - currently feuding over the WWE title nonetheless - can be considered a midcarder. Yet, that has always been the status quo for 'The Show Off'. He was never taken seriously as champ - being handed his first world title and losing it the same night, before losing his second world title on the first defence.
Once considered the next Shawn Michaels, Dolph never quite became the prodigy he seemed destined to be. Ziggler even joked himself once that he would be far more successful if he were just a couple inches taller. Despite his *ahem* shortcomings, Ziggler has a good look and isn't too shabby on the mic either; it's his in-ring abilities where he shines the most however. For a grappler who doesn't have an extensive background on the indies like a lot of his co-workers, he's proven he can still hang with the best of them - stealing the show with the likes of Daniel Bryan and Seth Rollins.
It's the latter skills that would pave the way for glory, if Ziggler were to ever seek fortunes outside of his home for the last decade plus. A change of scenery would be just the revitalization Dolph needs, finally allowing him to live up to his full and untapped potential.
9. Sami Zayn
It's no secret Sami Zayn is as good as they come in the squared circle - he demonstrated as much long before he ever stepped foot into the McMahon kingdom. In recent times, he's come into his own on the stick as well, cutting some of the more entertaining promos of 2019. Despite all that however, Zayn is yet to capture a single championship on the main roster.
That's not to say he never will - he captured the NXT title prior to his call-up to the big leagues after all - but Sami ever being considered a top guy is a stretch. Him headlining WrestleManias against Roman Reigns is the longest of shots.
One place Zayn - or perhaps El Generico - would be taken seriously as a contender for the top prize, is AEW. Sami could put on a wrestling masterclass against the elite of AEW (pun intended). In a promotion that takes its in-ring competition deadly serious, Zayn would flourish. He could even capitalise on his newly acquired mic skills to sell the big match-ups he would regularly be competing in.
Gone would be the days of being Kevin Owen's lackey, or being the chairman's conduit to put the fans in their place - replaced by the reckoning of Sami Zayn as a main attraction and top star.
8. Kevin Owens
Speaking of Kevin Owens, he too appears destined to never quite crack the glass ceiling, with the brass ring always a whisker away. Yes, he did have a stint as Universal Champion - a blessing only ever awarded to him thanks to Finn Bálor getting put on the shelf. His reign then ended unceremoniously via a squash defeat by Bill Goldberg.
Owens has flirted with the main event scene since, but is yet to recapture the top prize; midcard belts being more his forte. Unfortunately, the former Kevin Steen has been unable to regain the spark he had when he first burst onto the main roster to defeat John Cena. To think, the Canadian star was so hot back then, fans were considering him as a worthy opponent for Brock Lesnar. How the mighty fell.
The sentiment soon changed when he booked to lose back to back rematches to 'Super Cena'. A dream match with Lesnar never ended up happening and was no longer warranted.
All these past woes would be a thing of the distant past were K.O. to ever grace AEW with his presence. Whether it would be to rekindle rivalries of old with the likes of 'Y2J' or 'The Lunatic Fringe', or to pick a fight with some fresh competition, Owens would be well and truly living up his 'Prize Fighter' moniker.
7. Finn Bálor
The aforementioned Finn Bálor was also a universal title holder, being forced to relinquish the strap 24 hours after capturing it due to injury. He's yet to win it back.
As of writing, Finn holds the intercontinental title - long looked at as the midcard championship. It's a prestigious award no doubt, but still not representative of the heights the Irishman reached early during his main roster tenure.
Whether 'The Demon' can ever taste world championship gold again remains to be seen. There's a stacked roster to compete with after all, and he's already been waiting an awfully long time for his turn back on the mountain top. The hope fans had for him back when he was the longest ever reigning NXT champion appears to be fading.
That wouldn't be the case if Finn was to become the latest signing of AEW. Bálor would feel right at home with other former Bullet Club members surrounding him - he is the founder of the faction and all. That fact alone would give him the respect of the AEW higher ups. His talent and ability would take him the rest of the way - straight to the top of the food chain.
Who knows, AEW may even let him explore the many personas he showed off on the independent scene, before he was confined to just having 'The Demon' in his closet.
6. Samoa Joe
'The Samoan Submission Machine' has reached the pinnacle of every federation he's fought for, other than WWE. ROH, TNA, even WWE's own NXT were conquered, but he's just been unable to capture the big one on either Raw or SmackDown.
It's not like there hasn't been opportunities either - Joe has competed for the universal title against 'The Beast' Brock Lesnar and the WWE title numerous times against long time foe AJ Styles. He's never been given the go ahead to actually raise the gold above his head however.
Instead, Joe has currently been relegated to holding the US championship - a consolation prize indeed, but still not what Joe's fans had dreamed of. This seems it might be as far as Joe will be allowed to go, which is a shame seeing as he could easily be portrayed as one of the most dominant heels in the industry today - with the look, mic skills and intensity to back it up.
You can bet your bottom dollar AEW wouldn't let such a talent go underutilised. Joe is the villain you can build a company around and AEW would be foolish not to do just that. WWE's loss would be their gain. All they would have to do is be brave enough to pull the trigger on Joe as their guy and he would do the rest, by putting the majority of their roster to sleep!
5. Aleister Black
"The Dutch Destroyer" paid his dues on the independents as Tommy End before venturing into the mainstream of wrestling landscapes. After a successful NXT stint which saw him have a reign as champ, he debuted on the main roster with Ricochet as his partner. Now that partnership has expired and Black is on the verge of a singles run.
Aleister's path could go a myriad of ways and an eventual run on the top spot can't be ruled out. He has a great aura about him that matches his ominous look. In the realm of WWE storytelling though, he could just as easily be booked to fail as succeed. It would be far from the first time a superstar who seemingly ticked all the right boxes fell from grace by no fault of their own.
This is where AEW could make the save. Black has the credibility that All Elite would look for, thanks to his previously mentioned experience on the indies. That, combined with his impressive mixture of stiff striking and acrobatic aerial ability would make him a perfect fit for the fledgling promotion.
Aleister may yet find glory in the sports entertainment sand box he currently plays in, but there would be less of a gamble and faster route to success within the new wrestling game on the block.
4. Ricochet
It's not just Aleister Black who emerged from his tag team with Ricochet for a solo endeavour. Ricochet is ahead of Black in fact, already earning a shot at a singles belt. Like Aleister, Ricochet is a promising young talent who could go either way in the company. The WWE's long term booking is notoriously spontaneous, making it impossible to predict where the high flyer will be a month from now on the card, let alone a year or two. Will he excel like other former indie darlings have before him, or will he become just another victim of creative, pining for his NXT days?
A former NXT north American title holder, Ricochet would have no doubt been crowned NXT champ as well, if allowed to stay there to blossom even more so. You can see why the higher ups were eager to bring up such an eye catching star to TV sooner than later mind you; long term plan or no long term plan. Ricochet also captured gold for Lucha Underground and has impressed in Japan too.
All the above make for the perfect ingredients for a AEW household name. Ricochet is a walking wrestling clinic who could reach an even higher level with the AEW roster on hand to match him move for move.
3. Andrade
On the subject of phenomenal athletes, former masked star Andrade is up there with the best of them. His history in Mexico and Japan speaks for itself, not to mention he was one half of the first WWE matches to receive a five star rating from the Wrestling Observer in years!
After a stop start push in NXT, Andrade picked up a shock win for the NXT title against a freshly crowned champ in Drew McIntyre. Heart pounding title defences followed, including the five star classic against Johnny Gargano. Eventually, it was the afore mentioned Aleister Back who dethroned the Mexican highlight reel for the strap.
Andrade's main roster career hasn't been quite so successful just yet, though he has shown promise. While no one can argue with his skills within the squared circle, his lack of English as a first language may be what restricts him in his pursuit for success within the sports entertainment powerhouse.
Such roadblocks wouldn't be an issue in a sports focused wrestling promotion, where wrestling ability does the talking for you. The potential match ups Andrade could have with the likes of Kenny Omega and Hangman Adam Page are the stuff of wrestling fanatic's dreams and would have Dave Meltzer seeing stars for weeks!
2. Cesaro
Oh Cesaro, how we've been teased over you getting a push for so long. Capturing the US title wasn't enough. Winning the Andre The Giant memorial battle royal wasn't enough. Being aligned with Paul Heyman wasn't enough. Pushing John Cena to his limits wasn't enough. Steve Austin speaking up on your behalf to the boss on a podcast wasn't enough. Nothing is ever enough!
After finding success as a tag team competitor as a part of The Bar with Sheamus, Cesaro is back out on his own due to an injury to the Irishman. Will this finally be where 'The Swiss Superman' overcomes years of false hope within the promotion and is finally rewarded with a world title!? Nah, they'll probably just wait for Sheamus to come back and have them re-team like nothing ever happened.
If anyone on the WWE roster has a reason to be frustrated and want a way out, it's Cesaro. Being the consummate professional the man is though, we rarely ever hear of any complains from the veteran. That doesn't mean something isn't festering inside though, and that he wouldn't be more appreciated elsewhere.
Cesaro has proven he can tangle with anyone in the ring, gelling perfectly with high flyers and big men all the same. There's no wrestler type Cesaro can't have a barn burner of a match with. He would well and truly be in his element in AEW, finally allowed to shine to his full potential.
1. Shinsuke Nakamura
Has there ever been a bigger star than Shinsuke Nakamura who WWE has wasted? Sure, he won the Royal Rumble and went on to challenge for the WWE title at WrestleMania. But he lost, and his subsequent heel turn - though promising at first - fizzled out after repeated failed attempts to capture the big one.
Another star who's first language isn't English, WWE surely didn't sign 'The Rock Star' to cut ten minute promos. They signed him for his charisma, in-ring presence, and legendary status that he built for himself in NJPW. Clearly, they've forgot all of that though, as the Japanese superstar has been left to dwindle in a typical foreign heel tag team with Rusev.
'The King of Strong Style' had the crowd eating out of his hands during his days as NXT champ. He could do no wrong, and always brought a big fight feel with him to main events. Typically, as soon as he got to the main roster he was booked underwhelmingly. Even on his first appearance on SmackDown, he simply made his entrance and then did... nothing. Huh? Why not have a heel issue an open challenge, only for Shinsuke to come out to a surprise pop and totally decimate his opponent with hard hitting strikes? Of course, that wouldn't be possible as WWE has neutered his vintage in ring-style.
AEW would be a destination where Nakamura wouldn't be handcuffed in the ring and be given the respect and admiration he deserves.