10 WWE Moments Everyone Was Waiting For (That Never Happened)

WWE still owes us Sting vs. Undertaker.

SS 2001 DREAM
WWE

What’s that saying about things you’re waiting for never actually happening? A watched pot is right twice a day? Or a bird in the hand never boils? You know the one I mean.

Anyway, your dad’s tin-pot pub philosophy to one side I’d find it hard to argue that the universe actually rewards your enthusiasm for anything. By and large if you really, really, really, really want something, it’ll conspire to make sure it never actually happens. This was true when the Spice Girls reformed this month and I couldn’t get tickets, and it's almost always true in WWE.

That's because, at its core, it's an organisation that genuinely seems to grow a big rubbery one over the idea of crushing the dreams of its audience. Deliberately or otherwise. Yes, sometimes plans do legitimately have to change but, more often than not, the company's constant desire to surprise its fans means it'll steer away from angles or matches if they believe we're expecting them.

Now that's not inherently a bad thing - after all if everything just went the way we expected it to the product would be boring - but it does come at the cost of some potentially epic moments of wrestling...


10. Finn Bálor’s Universal Title Rematch

Finn Balor WWE Universal Title
WWE.com

Nobody has had a misleadingly strong start in wrestling quite like Finn Bálor on the main roster.

In his first match after his call-up he beat Roman Reigns clean, then at his first PPV he beat Seth Rollins to become the first ever WWE Universal Champion. There has never been a debut like it but, sadly, an injury sustained in that match put him on the shelf for nearly six months.

His return in April last year inevitably raised the question about when he’d be reinstated into the main event and given the title rematch he was very obviously due but it just never materialised. Instead it took two whole months for him to even get into a Number 1 contenders Fatal 5 Way, before being put into a bafflingly bad program with Bray Wyatt.

He worked Kane, he worked Goldust, he worked the Miztourage, and it wasn’t until August 2018, one day short of the two year anniversary of him actually winning the thing, that he got a crack at the belt. A rematch of sorts, yes, but would a high-profile one on his return have been too much to ask for?


9. The Rock Vs. Shawn Michaels

The Rock Shawn Michaels
WWE

In what was, at the time, the biggest moment in SmackDown history at that point - being, as it was, the first episode - a returning Shawn Michaels screwed the Rock out of winning the WWF Championship.

Actually, can we just take a moment to appreciate the camera work on this? Despite HBK looking like he’s rollerblading down a beach in Tenerife trying to sell you tickets to a nightclub that doesn’t exist, you somehow entirely forget he’s there until BANG. Superkick. Goodbye. 10/10 to the folks in production there.

Having done Rock/Triple H to death at this point, fans the world over gleefully took this as a) Michaels was coming out of retirement full-time and b) he was going to work the People's Champion. The man who had defined the previous era in the company vs. the man who was starting to define this one.

But then, nothing. No match, no real follow up to it, and a huge moment in WWE went precisely nowhere. I mean, we’d later learn that the pair absolutely hated each other because Michaels had been a dick to the Rock’s gran, but still, total bummer.


8. A Bad NXT Takeover

takeover tag
WWE.com

My criteria for this list was that I wouldn’t include anything that could still happen and, I guess, it is very possible that one day we’re going to get a bad one. However, crucially, nobody’s actually waiting for it anymore.

That’s the real testament to its success I think. After the first run of jaw-dropping shows the question was always whether they could somehow keep this streak going. The modest Full Sail shows that comprised the first five exceeded expectations and from there things just got ridiculous.

Brooklyn had that Bálor/Owens Ladder match, Respect was Bayley/Sasha’s Iron Woman, Dallas had Nakamura’s debut, The End had one of the greatest tag team matches I’ve ever seen, Brooklyn II had that DIY match and then we all just stopped asking the question.

In the 12 months between Brooklyn and Brooklyn II, the headlines around NXT TakeOver weren’t about them being surprisingly good, merely that the overall standard of the product was stupidly high. Sure, there might be a stinker in the pipeline somewhere, but none of us are waiting expectantly for it anymore.


7. Crown Jewel Getting Cancelled

Crown Jewel Thumb
wwe

10.30pm was the time I sat around WhatCulture towers that night waiting for WWE to cancel Crown Jewel. Article effectively already written, just needing a few specifics and a swift smash of the publish button, video script in largely a similar state and the studio entirely prepped. 10.30pm: not a glamorous industry, this.

Yes despite everybody knowing they were going to stop Crown Jewel - and indeed many outlets actually reporting they were going to stop Crown Jewel - they did not stop Crown Jewel. Instead, they pressed ahead with it despite the immense criticism from fans and pressure from advertisers.

In hindsight, binning off a massive show at little over a week’s notice, when stages, production, logistics, catering, travel, accommodation and marketing had all likely been paid for, was probably a contractual impossibility. But, still, the situation sort of demanded it.

Instead we got the show as intended, albeit with all reference to Saudi Arabia removed, and every single banter slider shoved up to 11. Shane McMahon: Best In The World.


6. Sting Vs. The Undertaker

Sting Undertaker
WWE.com

I’ll get to the Invasion in a little bit, but can we all just take a moment to agree that when we fantasy booked WWF vs. WCW, the one match we all had in common was this. Undertaker vs. Sting. If you didn’t, well I mean, who do you think you are? Vince Russo.

In an era when wrestling was slowly moving towards more believable and relatable gimmicks - Austin hating his boss, Angle being an Olympian, that sort of thing - these were the two big lads who were still absurd. A big goth who would fly in from the ceiling, and a man who was literally dead.

But when Sting didn’t come across with WCW’s other big names like Chris Kanyon, Hugh Morris and Kronik... I know, I can’t believe the whole thing was a let down either... it looked like the best possible chance to make this match happen had passed us all by.

Sadly in the years since their paths never managed to cross, even when Sting did finally make his WWE debut in 2015. He has said though , with his actual mouth, that a match with The Deadman is his only unfinished business in wrestling. Don’t count on it though.


5. Shane To Take Over WWE

Vince Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Yeah speaking of the Invasion, the one thing above everything else that it sort of suggested was that one day Vinnie Mac would tire of all of this nonsense and sell up. Say goodbye to all the oil and the drama and the booing and just retire to his own private island where a different beautiful woman would suck each of his toes.

But as the years and years and years and years and, admittedly, years rolled by, Vince was unmoving in his role as The Big Dick. Shane moved onto other things and it turned out that his favoured son was, in fact, Steph. Obviously perceiving her balls to be bigger than Shane’s either metaphorically or literally, I’ll let you decide which.

Even upon his return to the company for what actually looked like a long-awaited power struggle angle, he promptly found himself feuding with wrestlers instead. The Undertaker, AJ Styles, Kevin Owens, all merely wannabes compared to the literal Best In The World. He does still have a minor stake in the company, but unlike his sister who is very much upstairs decision-maker first and on-screen annoyance second, Shane's power within the WWE's walls is purely performative.


4. CM Punk At All In

CM Punk ALL IN
WWE/ALL IN

Is there anything on this earth that would spice up your life more than a CM Punk return? I mean, look, we’ve debated at length whether it’s actually a good idea and spoiler, it probably isn’t, but still, can you imagine how good things would feel if he did come back?

Walking back into WWE might still one day happen, but if there was ever a time a return to the business felt actually probable, it was this year. All In, the biggest celebration of independent wrestling ever conceived, being organised by people he liked and taking place in his home town. Surely, surely, this was it.

But alas, no. Despite appearing at the fan convention the day before, Punk was nowhere to be seen on the actual night itself. Five or six times eyes shot excitedly to the ramp anticipating a surprise appearance but not once did Cult of Personality hit. A shame really, as this could have been the moment to rekindle the great man’s love of the industry. Oh well.


3. Ric Flair Vs. Hulk Hogan At WrestleMania

Flair Hogan
WWE

Some people will tell you that Hogan vs. Bret Hart was the one everyone was waiting for but I’ve actually run this by magical translator machine and…

*Blip Blip Boop Blip Beep Beep Blip*

… yeah, it says here that it’s not.

In the 1980s Hogan and Flair were the two biggest stars in the entire wrestling world. One was the big name in WWF, the other in WCW and the entire rest of the world. When the latter finally joined the WWF in 1991 everyone assumed it was so they could finally deliver the Hogan/Flair WrestleMania main event everyone had been fantasy booking for years.

From his very debut, Flair even went after Hogan with his promos and his actions, signalling a build to the match that would take the better part of a year. Then, oh mama, a series of under-performing house show experiments made WWF scrap the idea and we got Flair vs. Savage and Hogan vs. Sid Justice instead. Which was… weird.

We did actually get the match in WCW in 1994, admittedly, but it just wasn’t the on stage it deserved. Specifically the grandest one of them all.


2. The John Cena Heel Turn

10 Biggest WWE Missed Opportunities To Turn John Cena Heel
whatculture.com

Ask John Cena himself, and obviously I can because as a global wrestling personality he is in my inner circle of close personal friends and confidants, and he’ll tell that this actually happened. Look, here he is talking directly to me and definitely not GQ.

Anyway, thousands and thousands of people chanting "John Cena Sucks" is one thing, but the actual bonafide heel turn is quite another. At the height of his powers Cena was in a repetitive cycle of defending WWE against groups that would seek to harm it. This was ground for a heel turn more fertile than Ric Flair’s bedsheets in the '80s.

He could have been recruited by Bray Wyatt, he could have embraced the hate with Kane, he could have joined The Nexus for real, he could have beaten the streak, he could have done a double turn with Orton, but he never did. WWE instead went full viva forever on tweener Cena.

Quite what the landscape of the company would have looked like had they fully turned him is open to debate. Arguably a lot of the mid-'00s also-rans would have had a shot at the very, very top of the card and WWE's now cemented ideology of just doing whatever they like might not have been so fully committed to.


1. A WCW Invasion

Lance Storm Mike Awesome The Invasion
WWE.com

Yes, I know, technically this did happen but... it didn’t did it? Not the way any of us actually wanted.

In short, every single wrestling fan in the '90s fantasy booked a war between the WWF and WCW. The clashes were epic, the match-ups were mouth-watering, huge stars facing off in never-before-seen contests and, simply put, that is not what we got. I'm not as down on the whole Invasion angle as a lot of people - it was Actually Pretty OK - but it was nowhere near as good as it could have been.

Owing to the absurd contractual situations of WCW’s top stars, your Goldbergs, your Stings, your Hogans, Halls and Nashes were nowhere to be seen during the angle. Instead we got the likes of Chris Kanyon, Hugh Morris and Kronik and I cannot believe I’ve had to say that twice in one list.

The big lads did all eventually make their way over in time, but by then the WCW was long dead and an invasion angle a bitter disappointing memory. Yes we finally got the 2 Become 1 story we’d been waiting for, but not the proper inter-promotional war we’d long craved.


Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine