10 WWE Name Changes That IMMEDIATELY Backfired
WWE just didn't see these fails coming. They really, really should've!
What's in a name?
If you're a pro wrestler, the answer is a lot. Granted, countless silly WWE names have led to wonderful things over the years. It's a bit like music - bands such as Pink Floyd and artists like Dua Lipa sound ridiculous in isolation on paper, but they've gone on to top charts and become household names despite that. So, there's hope yet for current NXT man Lexis King (even if he does sound like a car brand)!
A lot of name changes go hand in hand with WWE gimmick switches that immediately backfired. For example, Chad Gable turning into the woeful 'Shorty G' springs to mind, and so does Chavo Guerrero's mercifully short stint as Kerwin White. Neither of those are featured here though, because they've been torn to shreds elsewhere - only one name from the list linked above has house room here.
WWE deserve another tongue lashing for that one. They deserve a ticking off for all of these, truth be told. You've really got to wonder what goes on in crunch creative meetings sometimes. Somebody thought these name changes ruled, and they figured each one would get fans on board with shelling out cash on tickets and merchandise.
More fool them, but some of the workers involved did survive and go onto bigger/better things. Even they must've realised early on that they were doomed to fail unless fate intervened or they could come up with a replacement name themselves.
WWE's frankly crap NXT > main roster name generator doesn't get a pass here either. You won't believe some of the tripe that has spewed out over the years!
10. War Raiders Ride The Viking Experience
Someone on the creative squad said: 'I've got it! I know exactly how to turn a popular tag-team into a museum exhibit'. Replying, a beaming Vince McMahon shouted: 'I love it!'. That's what happened. Probably. Maybe. How else could one explain why WWE turned War Machine into The War Raiders and then (eventually) a lifeless sounding tourist attraction known as "The Viking Experience"?
That's what happened to Erik and Ivar when they took their main roster bow on the 15 April 2019 episode of Raw. The Experience was born, but that'd soon be changed to The Viking Raiders. Fans threw their arms up in frustration at all of this silliness - the fact that McMahon couldn't see any issues with such a stuttering start summed up his dotage creatively.
He took a team of ex-New Japan and ROH standouts who'd smashed it in his own NXT system, then stripped them of all menace. Erik and Ivar might as well have come to the ring handling out leaflets for guided tours like some sort of Norse version of The Shining Stars. Roll up, roll up. Come see The Viking Experience with your friendly, bearded warriors who are straight out of Skyrim (or something).
That's how it came across.
The pair have since reverted to their War Raiders name, but mud sticks. Repeated attempts to make something of these guys keep falling on deaf ears with an audience who were pretty much conditioned to view them as silly from the beginning. People did not want The Viking Experience. That was one ride everybody wanted to get off ASAP.
9. Piper Niven? Nah, Doudrop!
Enter another McMahon pearler.
Who honestly knows what Vince was thinking when he changed Piper Niven (known as Viper on the independent circuit) to Doudrop in 2021? Drop hung around with Eva Marie for…reasons before striking out on her own then forming a tag team with Nikki A.S.H. Thankfully, WWE saw sense and Triple H returned her to the Piper Niven name during the 2023 Royal Rumble. It was about time too.
On screen, it was Marie who handed Niven the Doudrop tag. This was surely some sort of inside joke at Piper’s look/body shape from McMahon, but it was just flat out rubbish presentation that did a talented newcomer no favours. Perhaps the most tragic thing about this halfhearted attempt at bodyshaming is that Niven has always owned her appearance, and reasonable fans don't care for something that's outright ridiculing somebody anyway.
In fairness, maybe that wasn't what WWE were going for, but it wouldn't have been outlandish for such a repeatedly tone deaf company under McMahon to publicly embarrass somebody for daring to be themselves. At least they didn't have Eva bully Doudrop on television or anything of the sort - Marie was just a stuck up bitch generally, then Piper Niven cast her aside before eventually being reborn.
No-one could figure out what WWE wanted to reach for with the whole Doudrop thing. It was a crap name relative to Piper/Viper, and the thinly-veiled Bertha Faye aesthetics should've stayed in 1995. Oh well, what's that phrase? All's well that ends well? Niven has had the last laugh.
8. Shawn Stasiak Becomes Meat
Picture the scene: Son of former World Champion walks into the building one day and finds out that he's about to become a walking sex toy to titillate the 'Attitude Era' masses. Or, more accurately, to give Vince Russo one of his final hurrahs on the WWF/WWE payroll before darting off to help destroy WCW's product later that same year. Shawn Stasiak became "Meat" in April 1999.
This would be sort of like Dominik Mysterio finding out that he's about to be renamed Dildo just for the hell of it. OK, that might be a tad extreme, and 'Dirty Dom' is way more talented than Stasiak ever was. Even so, you've got to feel sorry for Shawn. He was cast as an oversexed and totally knackered "piece of fresh meat" for PMS pals like Terri Runnels, Jacqueline and Ryan Shamrock.
The gag was that Stasiak (son of Stan) couldn't win any of his matches or perform well inside the ring because he was worn out from getting freaky with these women backstage. Fingers crossed that wasn't going on whilst serious business was happening elsewhere in the arena - it's doubtful that Steve Austin could concentrate on building his biggest matches if PMS were wearing down Meat.
What a sentence, and one only 'Attitude' could throw up.
The less said about PMS standing for "Pretty Mean Sisters" but actually being a joke about women on their periods the better too. 'WWF Attitude' earns a ton of plaudits even today, but some of the garbage pushed out in front of fans had to be seen to be believed. WWE didn't have much better waiting for Shawn following his return from WCW either. "Planet Stasiak" was another flop, but Meat got their first.
7. Val Venis Brings The Big Valbowski
Not many wrestling fans openly said things like: 'So I'm off to see The Big Valbowski wrestle tonight' when attending WWF events in the late-1990s. They might well have mentioned popular rising (steady!) midcarder Val Venis in amongst a number of other names when someone asked who was on the card, but The Big Valbowski? Forget about it.
Admittedly, Val Venis was already a silly name, but it was silly in a catchy way and fit his porn star gimmick without being too in your face. Again, steady. Then, in 2002, someone had the bright idea to just call him his nickname, and so The Big Valbowski was what announcers referred to Val as for a while. Shockingly, it didn’t catch on. There was no way fans were going to say it permanently, and it became even harder to take Val seriously.
Things changed from absurd to boring when WWE switched Valbowski to Sean ‘Chief’ Morley shortly afterwards. He'd gone from shooting adult content, to joining Right To Censor, to becoming a lamer version of his old gimmick, to...being Eric Bischoff's lackey for a while. 'Chief' Morley was every bit as thrilling as 'Constable' Baron Corbin was years later, and we all know how that one turned out; even the McMahon family had to admit that it made for rotten telly.
Fans didn't want to start calling Venis by his nickname. It was ridiculous anyway, especially when commentators said the full thing every single time. Simply calling him Val for short was far catchier. 'Oh look, it's The Big Valbowski. The Big Valbowski is going up to the top turnbuckle, and now The Big Valbowski comes flying off with an elbow. The Big Valbowski with the cover now, and it's a win for The Big Valbowski'.
Talk about too much.
6. Terry Taylor = Red Rooster
Cock-a-doodle-don't. Just don't.
In 1988, solid in-ring worker Terry Taylor linked up with star-enhancing manager Bobby Heenan, and it seemed like the sky was the limit for him. Unfortunately for Taylor, the WWF decided that he should become a 'cock of the walk' performer who was all talk and not much else. That was Heenan's role in things - he was there to guide Terry towards victory using his managerial expertise.
All fine enough so far, eh? Then the wheels fell off. Taylor was redubbed 'The Red Rooster' (cock of the walk, remember) and began literally acting like a rooster once he turned babyface. He dyed some of his blonde hair red and spiked it up, and even strutted around the place giving it a little cock-a-doodle-doo action. Immediately, all hopes of creating a new star out of the technically excellent Taylor were dashed, and things would only get worse from there.
Legend has it that Terry was in the running to become Mr. Perfect, but that gimmick went to Curt Hennig instead. It's unclear just how much truth there is to this (Bruce Prichard has laughed at it on his 'Something To Wrestle With' podcast in the past), but if it is then Taylor certainly drew the short straw.
He looked so silly doing his rooster bit, and fans hoping he'd become a fine technician with some heel edge under Heenan's watch were left bitterly disappointed that Taylor became a walking cartoon. Not a good WWF-style walking cartoon like Hulk Hogan, The Ultimate Warrior or even Big Boss Man either.
5. Joe Hennig Is Michael McGillicutty
There's probs some alternate timeline somewhere in which Curtis Axel is still stuttering his way through that "genesis of (Michael) McGillicutty" promo from the 1 September 2010 episode of NXT. That sounds like punishment. Imagine being forced to watch that nonsense for the rest of eternity?! Even Matt Striker, who was fond of talking nonsense himself, looked on totally bemused.
Joe Hennig, the man behind the McGillicutty name, was saddled with one of the least-flattering and most dorky-sounding names in WWE history when they called him Michael McGillicutty. He was the son of Mr. Perfect, for crying out loud. How did it come to this? Poor Michael had no McCredibility as soon as that name was committed to tape. People were too busy giggling at him.
Then, McGillicutty cut that promo. He droned on and on and on and on and one about this being "the genesis of McGillicutty". It's "starting this moment...from now...from this moment on...this'll be the moment...starting now". Anytime you're ready, Michael. Jeez! Being put on the spot and then farting out such rubbish dialogue sure didn't do McGillicutty any favours, but he was toast with that name to start with.
A change to Curtis Axel in May 2013 helped him refocus and even earn some success, but it didn't last for too long. Sadly, he became the latest victim WWE’s name generator, then went all in on one of the worst improvised promos going. McGillicutty's speech was an argument for heavily scripted segments, if anything.
Going from the lineage of the Hennig name to McGillicutty was one hell of a downgrade.
4. Pete Dunne’s Bruising Time As Butch
The intro to this piece teased an entry that had already been examined when looking at gimmick changes that badly backfired on WWE. Take a bow, Butch, because you're getting to double dip. Pete Dunne's time as the scrappy lil' no-good 'Brawling Brute' Butch might've worked out had the company kept his 'Bruiserweight' stylings in tact. Sadly, creative fancied turning him into a street urchin Oliver Twist media would've turned its nose up at.
Dunne hit the main roster in March 2022 with a new look. He had a flat cap like his 'big brother' Sheamus, wore braces like someone had a fire sale on Peaky Blinders costumes, and Pete just generally looked totally uncomfortable in the role he was being asked to play. OK, so wrestlers don't always get to do everything they want (and Dunne just wanted to work lengthy and engaging back and forth matches), but this idea was too under-developed and cartoonish for someone with his skillset.
There was a disconnect in WWE's presentation of Butch too. He was stony faced and looked like he meant business, but even Sheamus laughed at how much of a scrap this lil' fella liked. It was jarring to hear about his violent exploits when he was walking around looking for all the world like someone who'd turned up at the wrong venue for his high school drama class.
To think, Dunne didn't return to his original name until January 2024. That means he spend almost 2 full years as Butch; and not even Bushwhacker Butch. Just plain ol' Butch. No wonder he looked glum all the time!
3. Steve Austin Is The WWF’s Ringmaster
Anyone who watched Steve Austin's work in WCW throughout the early-1990s could tell you that he had charisma coming out of his ears. His shoved together (for the dreaded 'creative has nothing else for you' reason) tag-team with Brian Pillman had yielded excellent results, and Austin seemed likely to become a true star for the company pre-Hulk Hogan and mates arrival.
A cathartic run in ECW followed his WCW exit, then Austin finally found his way to the market leader. In late-1995, Vince McMahon brought him into the WWF, but not as 'Superstar' or 'Stunning' Steve Austin. No, he was the nuts and bolts Ringmaster. All of the star quality Steve had exuded vanished as soon as he began showing up as a boots n' tights wrestler alongside Ted DiBiase.
On that, Austin didn't want Ted as his manager. He had nothing against DiBiase personally, but felt he didn't need anybody else cutting his promos for him. Further, McMahon might as well have called him, ‘Generic Wrestler I Won’t Push’ by calling him The Ringmaster. That was a death knell for anybody considering Vince's love of OTT "sports entertainment" over pro wrestling.
Praise the lord that Austin was so creative and came up with his own ’Stone Cold’ repackaging at a later date, because he was going nowhere as Ringmaster. This would be like WWE hiring a promising AEW midcarder then calling them, '#1 Wrestler'. It's go nowhere, wouldn't feel inspiring to the audience, and it'd be tough for that person to get hyped themselves.
Stripping away everything that brought Austin to the dance was certainly a choice.
2. Practically Every Member Of Retribution
Retribution will always be pointed to and laughed at for being a colossal waste of everyone's time in 2020-2021. WWE fans needed some fresh acts to sink their teeth into whilst stuck at home mid-pandemic, and it looked like the promotion would provide when a brand new faction of destructive hooligans burst onto the scene in August 2020. Their initial mission? Destroy WWE from within.
The fun was only just getting started.
Eventually, Retribution members started to get cheesy names: T-BAR, Mace, Slapjack, Reckoning and Retaliation arrived. The first trio sounded especially corny, and they signified WWE's intent to gleefully turn a renegade stable of vandals into extras from Streets Of Rage. Being fair, the group’s evolving story didn’t help, but man those names were crap.
Nobody could take Retribution seriously once they saw the new masks and heard those names. Slapjack? Seriously?! The creative team would've been as well calling him Slapnuts in honour of Jeff Jarrett. Aha! Ain't he great? Exactly nobody was saying that about T-BAR, Mace or Slapjack. All anyone wanted to do was kick and punch their health bars down so they'd fall to the ground, blink then disappear.
Back to that story. T-BAR alleged that these invading ex-NXT'ers wanted WWE contracts. One problem: They already had WWE contracts, but apparently that was a logic loophole the writers planned to ignore for good. Things threatened to get fun again once Mustafa Ali came onboard, but he was powerless to stop the flow of bad creative.
It was curtains for Retribution once the masks and names showed up. One hell of a first chapter though.
1. Walter Becomes Gunther Stark
Full credit goes to Gunther for being such an excellent pro wrestler he managed to offset this PR nightmare and turn his career into a success story. It was one of the most embarrassing episodes in WWE history, being brutally honest, and it would've been totally avoidable had anyone conducted a simple Google search before ploughing full steam ahead on his name change from Walter.
WWE changed Walter’s name to Gunther Stark when he debuted on the NXT brand in February 2022. Then, the public backlash started. It turned out that Gunther Stark was the name of a Nazi U-boat commander during World War II, so the PR backlash was brutal. Company staffers just didn’t do their homework on this one. Realising the hard way that they'd messed up, WWE immediately dropped the surname portion, but some damage was already done.
Thankfully, fully down to Triple H's straightforward and no frills presentation of the guy and his own superior skills, Gunther has bounced back from this calamitous initial name change to become a true heavyweight of WWE's product. Would that have happened under Vince McMahon's watch? Presumably not, because McMahon reportedly didn't see what all the fuss was about.
Wrestling is a subjective biz, but sorry - that's idiotic.
Speaking of idiotic, failing to Google the Stark name was an incredible 'oopsy' moment from the promotion's top brass. The reaction was severe and swift as social media lapped up WWE's stupidity. Meanwhile, poor Gunther was stuck in the middle of a storm when all he wanted to do was wrestle better than most.
What other WWE name changes backfired immediately? For more wrestling, check out 12 WWE Face & Heel Turns That IMMEDIATELY Backfired and 12 Misconceptions About WCW You Probably Believe!