10 WWE Number One Contenders Nobody Actually Thought Could Win

If you thought Ricochet was going to beat Brock Lesnar, you might be interested in this old rope...

Cain Velasquez Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

A championship is only as credible as those who challenge for it. The IWGP Heavyweight Championship hasn't become the most coveted title in professional wrestling by chance; only the cream of the crop are worthy of coming within a victory of immortality. This most prestigious of tables lends weight to the championship belt at the head of it all, covering everything in a veneer of importance.

WWE doesn't seem to understand this. Challenging for the WWE Championship has often required little more than being the flavour of the month or having some perceived name value. The world's biggest wrestling promotion has treated its titles like little more than props over the years, to the point where they carry little or no value. We all know that someone is going to win the belt and carry it for a few months before dropping it to whoever is next in line. Each title reign is punctuated by challengers that tick boxes and little else.

Even in amongst all of that, there have been some number one contenders that really pushed the boundaries of ridiculousness. Men coming out of quite literally nowhere to challenge for what should be a prestigious title is nothing new in WWE, but these challengers took the biscuit. They were never in danger of taking the title, of course, so that biscuit had to suffice.

10. Cain Velasquez

Cain Velasquez Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Gosh, this really feels like a lifetime ago. Cain Velasquez made his WWE debut on the very first episode of SmackDown on Fox, confronting Brock Lesnar and setting up a WWE Championship match for Crown Jewel. Forgetting how irrelevant the whole thing made Kofi Kingston and his title reign look, Cain's debut was hardly the show-stopping moment that WWE officials may have hoped it was going to be. Velasquez looked tentative in the squared circle and not even some typically marvellous Lesnar facials could change that.

Did anyone think Cain Velasquez was going dethrone Brock Lesnar at Crown Jewel? Of course not. Not even Cain Velasquez believed it. The two-time UFC Heavyweight Champion may have famously vanquished Lesnar in the Octagon, but MMA and pro wrestling are two very different beasts. Having a rookie like Velasquez beat Brock for the title would have made no sense at all, and the response to Cain's debut suggests it wouldn't have been particularly popular.

It all led to a WWE Championship that was cold enough to freeze off the brass monkey's proverbials. The match itself was an absolute sh*t-show, a two-minute waste of time that practically killed Velasquez in the eyes of pro wrestling fans. Good job, everyone!


9. Kane

Daniel Bryan Kane
WWE

Daniel Bryan's quest for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship was exhilarating. The leader of the YES! Movement went from antagonistic heel to the most beloved babyface of an entire generation in the blink of an eye, leading crowds around the world in rapturous chants of the most simplistic kind. WWE didn't want it to happen but you can't stop destiny. Bryan finally ascended the mountain at WrestleMania XXX, overcoming Randy Orton and Batista to become champion of the world (and hearts worldwide).

The journey was a long one, and thoughts immediately turned to Bryan as champion as opposed to Bryan as underdog challenger. Fans began to wonder who lay in Bryan's future. Brock Lesnar? Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns or Dean Ambrose? A rematch with John Cena, or a reprise of his feud with Bray Wyatt? There were plenty of options, and Kane sure as sh*t wasn't one of them. The Big Red Machine was positioned as Bryan's first challenger, much to the excitement of approximately no-one.

Saying that, it would have been an extremely 'WWE' thing to have Bryan overcome all the odds before being shafted out of the title by Corporate Kane. Thankfully it didn't happen, although injury soon stopped DBry from competing at all. For a few years, at least.


8. Sting

Seth Rollins Sting
WWE.com

Sting's WWE career was an utter shambles, wasn't it? The WCW Icon was brought in way too late, wasted in a WrestleMania match that only Triple H was interested in, a match that preposterously saw Sting lose. That's right; Vince McMahon waited years to bring Sting in, only to have him stare at the lights for Hunter Hearst Helmsley. Make of that, what you will.

The whole affair reached even higher levels of WTF when Sting returned to challenge Seth Rollins in the autumn. Yes, the reveal of statue Sting made for a pretty excellent television moment, but what right did Sting have in challenging Rollins for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship? His WWE record at the time was 0-1. Kevin Federline has more wins. Snooki too. Don't forget Michael Cole or Earl Hebner either, they also have more WWE victories than Sting.

WWE has a real issue with this sort of stuff. Legendary status trumps wins and losses, in all cases. Sting was worthy of a championship match by virtue of being Sting, but everyone knew that it was more of an achievement award than a potential landmark. Not even the prospect of Rollins having to wrestle twice in one night made a Sting victory plausible.

The expected thus happened. Rollins defeated Sting, injured him in the process, and an icon's in-ring career was over.


7. Sheamus

Sheamus John Cena Tlc 2009
WWE.com

Sheamus is one of the most underrated performers of his generation, and that is a pro wrestling hill that I am willing to die on. The Celtic Warrior is one of the most consistent in-ring performers around, and he has shown that he can have bruising bouts with a wide variety of opponents. His list of accolades is entirely deserved.

But even the most enthusiastic of Sheamus supporters will agree that his rise to the top of WWE was, well, a little rushed. Sheamus went from a new face on WWECW TV to challenging John Cena for the WWE Championship in the blink of an eye, a path to the top that didn't really go through any roadblocks except Goldust. The Irishman won a battle royal for the right to challenge Cena, and the whole thing seemed entirely rushed. It felt for all the world like 'we need a challenger for this month, before we go back to Cena vs. Orton or something similar'.

Much like all the names on this list, fans didn't think that Sheamus had a chance of becoming WWE Champion. What makes Sheamus different to his contemporaries is that he actually did win, much to the shock of practically everyone involved. Cena went flying through a table as Sheamus skimmed one on the outside (it was a tables match), leading a section of fans to claim that this was a botch that led to title change.

Botch or not, the unthinkable had happened. Nobody thought that Sheamus had a chance, but he proved everyone wrong.


6. King Mabel

King Mabel
WWE

Is there an alternative world out there, a strange parallel universe where King Mabel won the WWF Championship back in 1995? Where the purple behemoth vanquished Diesel and went on to hold the title for months, before dropping it to Bret Hart at Survivor Series? Maybe Mabel becomes a major success, and Viscera never happens?

No, no there is not. The worst King of the Ring in the history of Kings of the Ring was an absolutely unbelievable challenger, an impressive achievement for mid-'90s WWF. Mabel won the '95 KotR and subsequently lost to Diesel in his championship match, although Vince McMahon had already given up on him before that even happened. Mabel was a liability in the ring, injuring a host of competitors in the build-up to the title match. Not injured in storyline either; his sit-down splash wasn't all that gimmicked.

The idea of random big men challenging for the world title had proven to be big business in decades prior, but times had changed. Nobody saw Mabel as a credible threat, and why would they? He was a disappointing tag team wrestler who had suddenly been thrust into the main event. To make matters worse, Mabel needed help to get to the King of the Ring finals, beating Undertaker after interference from Kama and getting a bye to the final, where he defeated Savio Vega in what was the Puerto Rican's fourth match of the night.

Despite all that, Savio Vega would have been a more credible challenger. Think about that for a second.


5. Dolph Ziggler

Dean Ambrose Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

When the dust settles on Dolph Ziggler's professional wrestling career, it'll be interesting to see how the Show-Off is remembered. Perennial underachiever? Criminally underrated? Both? Ziggler's career will forever be tainted by bad luck. Who knows what could have been if Jack Swagger hadn't given him a concussion in 2013? That World Heavyweight Championship reign could have been the making of him; instead, it was aborted before it could get off the ground.

Whatever your opinion of Ziggles, nobody saw him as a viable number one contender to Dean Ambrose's WWE Championship in the fall of 2016. The dust had barely settled on the WWE Draft and Ambrose was looking for a new challenger. Bray Wyatt was expected to get the call, although the wretched Ambrose/Bray feud of late 2014 was still somewhat fresh in the memory. AJ Styles maybe? Possibly, but Styles was locked in a feud with John Cena. Fans speculated about a potential triple threat match, but it became increasingly clear that Styles and Cena were on a separate collision course.

Dean Ambrose was left without a dance partner for SummerSlam, the second-biggest show of the year. Dolph Ziggler won a Six-Pack Challenge to fill that spot, but 'fill that spot' has never been used in a more apt manner. Ambrose won the match and Ziggler returned to the midcard to feud with The Miz.


4. Rey Mysterio

Brock Lesnar Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

You might ask yourself which Rey Mysterio championship challenge I'm talking about here, but the reality is that there are plenty to choose from. With the sole exception of his run to the title in 2006, Rey Mysterio hasn't been positioned or portrayed as someone who can win a world championship. Even when he won his sole WWE Championship in 2011, the title win functioned purely as a vehicle to move the title to Cena later in the evening.

But two Mysterio challenges stick out. The first came in 2010 when The Undertaker was World Heavyweight Champion. Mysterio was feuding with Batista at the time but found himself given the opportunity against the Deadman, although by this time the Rumble had become synonymous with forgettable title matches on the undercard. Nobody thought Mysterio was going to beat Undertaker, even if it was blindingly obvious that 'Taker was going to lose the title before WrestleMania. The inevitable eventually came true.

More recently, Mysterio found himself challenging another beast for the title, this time the Beast Incarnate. Brock Lesnar and Rey had a surprisingly fun feud towards the back end of 2019, culminating in an entertaining match at Survivor Series. Lesnar won - of course Lesnar won - but the feud is largely remembered for the impressive bumps taken by Dominick. That tells you all you need to know.


3. Ricochet

Brock Lesnar Ricochet
WWE.com

Poor, poor Richochet. WWE has done a number on the high-flying hero, to the point where redemption seems an eternity away. It is hard to believe that the former NXT North American Champion was the number one contender to the WWE Championship just three months ago, although in truth it was even harder believing that he had a chance against Brock Lesnar. The Beast Incarnate was always going to beat Ricochet.

That was an inevitability, but the wrestling world at least hoped for a vaguely competitive match. Lesnar had had thrilling bouts against smaller competitors like AJ Styles, Daniel Bryan and Finn Bálor; surely he could put together something special with Ricochet? Not even the former Prince Puma thought that the upset could happen, but at least put on a show along the way?

94 seconds. The match lasted 94 seconds.

Richochet challenging for the WWE Championship at Super ShowDown was an absolute waste of time, an egregious example of WWE's addiction to self-sabotage. It did nothing for Brock Lesnar, it did nothing for the show, it did nothing for the title. Nobody thought Ricochet was going to go win, but people didn't expect him to be buried quite so deeply underground.


2. Hardcore Holly

Brock Lesnar Hardcore Holly
WWE.com

Getting seriously injured is a dangerous way to guarantee a push in WWE. At least that is how it has seemed at times, where in-ring accidents have been left to fester until the injured party can return in search of revenge on his fellow professional. In 2002, Brock Lesnar and Hardcore Holly struggled to cooperate on a powerbomb, a move both men had taken and given on countless occasions but one that just didn't seem to work on this occasion. Holly was dropped onto the back of his head, breaking his neck in the process. He missed 13 months of action as a result.

Holly returned at the 2003 Survivor Series as a member of Team Angle, desperate for retribution against the then-WWE Champion. The former Thurman was disqualified before the match even began, beating the heck out of Brock and shoving a ref down in the process, but the elimination was irrelevant. A Brock Lesnar vs. Hardcore Holly feud was happening, with the WWE Championship on the line.

This is all well and good, but the problem was that Holly had spent his entire career in the middle part of the card. At no point, not even the very start, had he even flirted with the main event. All of a sudden, fans are expected to believe that this journeyman was WWE Championship material, purely because he got injured? Wrestling is weird.

Nobody was buying it. Lesnar duely dispatched Holly at the Royal Rumble, ending Hardcore's hopes in a little over six minutes.


1. R-Truth

R Truth John Cena
WWE.com

Immortalised in pro wrestling pub quiz questions for all eternity, R-Truth inexplicably found himself the recipient of a WWE Championship match in the summer of 2011. How did it happen? Well, a cigarette-fuelled heel turn led to a number of hilarious promos involving equal amounts of spite and Lil' Jimmy, which in turn led to the main event of WWE Capitol Punishment 2011. If ever there was a phrase that showed just how needed CM Punk's 'pipe bomb' was, that will be it.

Truth worked his way into the championship match by wildly claiming there was a conspiracy against him and verbally abusing Cena's fans, even going so far as to throw water in the face of one child's father. The Anonymous RAW General Manager was in charge at the time, an absent and incompetent leader who made matches based on whims and little else.

The match itself was slow, boring and awkward, a trio that don't make for a particularly entertaining main event. It takes two tango and thus Truth shouldn't shoulder all of the blame, but it wasn't a great outing for a man looking to make his mark in the main event. This was as good as it got in terms of the WWE Championship for Truth, as Punk's promo changed everything and the future 24/7 Champion found himself in the midcard once again.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.