10 WWE Royal Rumble 2019 Nightmares That Could Come True

The Man? Nah. The Mandy.

Royal Rumble 2019 Who Will Win
WWE.com

The question posed in the above graphic is a pertinent one. Who will win both 2019 Rumbles, and which memories are WWE gonna' create this Sunday that'll get even the frostiest fans giddy about WrestleMania 35?

After months of fairly nondescript TV and pay-per-views creative couldn't wait to get through, the Royal Rumble comes at a good time. This, surely, will be the show that rescues things, reminds us all why we love this stuff and shifts beer kegs aplenty before the big day in New Jersey this spring.

What if it isn't though? What if this year's Rumble turns into a complete disaster full of nonsensical booking or pushes no-one asked for, and ends up causing social media sh*tstorms and mass drinking brought on by depression rather than celebration? In short, what if the 2019 Rumble is a nightmare?

If you're thinking that's all a bit too negative, then we don't blame you, but this is surely why you're here. So, how could things go so spectacularly wrong in Phoenix that everyone is left making Vince McMahon voodoo dolls come Monday morning?

This is how...


10. Shane McMahon Destroys The Bar On His Own

The Miz Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Nightmare: Jon Jones, Daniel Cormier and even the mighty Amanda Nunes have nothing on that strike-heavy, boxing-based bad ass Shane McMahon. At the Rumble, The Miz will be knocked out early and Shane will overcome Sheamus and Cesaro on his own to win the SmackDown Tag-Team Titles.

Chances Of It Coming True: Sadly, this is how WWE present Shane-O-Mac on occasion, and we have an awful feeling they might do so again at the Rumble. The nightmare image of McMahon pasting one of the best teams around despite a numbers disadvantage is something that won't leave this dude's head.

He'll perform his big diving elbow through the announce table (that had to be why WWE teased it on SmackDown), and Shane will also get in some rabbit punches as the announcers treat him like the second coming of Mike Tyson.

As over the top and melodramatic as it sounds, this could be the end of The Bar.


9. The WWE Title Match Goes Five Minutes

AJ Styles Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Nightmare: WWE have two Royal Rumble matches to plough through, and they've only gone and booked seven other matches on the same card. That, whether fans like it or not, means some time sacrifices will have be made outside the hour-long 30-man/woman bouts. What if AJ Styles vs. Daniel Bryan only gets a handful of minutes?

Chances Of It Coming True: It wouldn't exactly be out of character for WWE to promote a short, explosive brawl over the WWE Title at the Rumble. They've done so before, including Brock Lesnar vs. Big Show at the 2014 event and Lesnar vs. Hardcore Holly 2004.

Also, brawling fits the story between AJ and Bryan. They may well end up getting one of the shorter matches on the card, if only because that extra match (there were six main card matches in 2018 as opposed to seven) will need some minutes too.


8. Brock Lesnar Squashes Finn Bálor's Demon

Finn Balor Brock Lesnar
WWE

Nightmare: OK, so Finn Bálor has already gone on record as saying he won't be turning up in Arizona with his face paints, but that could easily be a swerve to take fans off the scent of some Demon-related madness. If he does show face in make up, we fear Bálor's alter-ego will get a Brock Lesnar-sized whupping that'll ruin the character's mystic.

Chances Of It Coming True: Surely not. WWE are capable of a lot of things, but they surely wouldn't make Finn's last remaining main event threat look like a total wuss during WrestleMania season. Would they? No, no they can't. It'd be tragic if the 'Demon' took a glorified squash match loss on Sunday.

If it happens, Bálor is done as a credible headliner in the company. He'd have to move to SmackDown, or possibly rebuild his career on NXT. This must be a back-and-forth epic that relies on Raw's David vs. Goliath storytelling.


7. WWE Rebook Santino Marella's 2011 Magic With R-Truth

Carmella R-Truth
WWE.com

Nightmare: The sometimes funny, sometimes irritating R-Truth channels the spirit of Santino Marella circa 2011 and almost defies the odds to win the men's Rumble. Hey, it worked back then as an unlikely underdog moment, and WWE might want to relive it in 2019.

Chances Of It Coming True: We're undecided.

On one hand, something about Truth getting the #30 berth stinks. Why bother with that whole Mixed Match Challenge prize guff if he's not gonna' be written in some fanciful nearly-man moment? On the other, this is just a bad idea waiting to happen, and one WWE's writers should avoid when laying out the Rumble.

Marella was a unique kind of character. Fans felt genuine warmth for his outlandish behaviour, delusional tactics and funnyman scrapes and jams. Truth, despite stirring a few giggles, doesn't have the same kind of relationship with the audience these days. A serious Rumble finish would be much better here.


6. Batista's Worst Nightmares Reprise

Batista Royal Rumble 2014
WWE.com

Nightmare: This is more of a nightmare from Batista's perspective than anyone else's. Imagine he roared out as a late entrant in the 2019 Rumble and experienced the same kind of apathy he did five years ago; that may be enough to make the man break. He was already super-p*ssed about fans favouring Daniel Bryan back then.

Chances Of It Coming True: Five years is a long time in wrestling, and so much has happened since big Dave looked foolish in Pittsburgh. There's been some audience turnover, and he's become a bigger star in Hollywood. Both points may help his cause and make a Rumble cameo (even one littered with eliminations and the threat he could win) worthwhile.

Movie star fame or not though, Batista isn't someone most fans would accept as a Rumble winner. People crave someone fresh, someone with weekly momentum, not a returning legend who's blatantly only there to work an Evolution retread with Triple H.


5. Becky Lynch Isn't In The Women's Rumble

Asuka Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Nightmare: Becky Lynch, one of the hottest stars in the business since last summer, may find herself doing little beyond her SmackDown Women's Title match at the Rumble. The worst case scenario here is that she jobs cleanly to Asuka then isn't seen again for the rest of the night. In other words, she'd take her beating and like it.

Chances Of It Coming True: If Becky is going to lose and creative have any sense, they'll make sure her outspoken and brash persona has the last word. That's been her thing since becoming 'The Man', and it shouldn't stop during the most important time of WWE's year.

She needs to be in the Rumble.

Think back to Daniel Bryan in 2014. He jobbed to Bray Wyatt in the opener then sat idly by as the Rumble raced past. It'd be a nightmare for Becky if she followed suit; she has the same kind of organic kinship with the fans he did.


4. Mandy Rose Wins The Women's Rumble

Mandy Rose
WWE.com

Nightmare: Hold onto your hats, people, because there's a chance Vince McMahon may pull a power play and dictate that Divas throwback Mandy Rose trades flirting with The Usos to win the second women's Royal Rumble. Then, she'd roll onto 'Mania for a match with Asuka.

Chances Of It Coming True: As much as it'd suck, don't bet your mortgage against it.

Asuka was such a popular winner last year, and it was exactly what fans wanted to see. Now, it might be WWE's turn to push who they want to push, and they're blatantly high on Mandy's blonde bombshell looks. She's a WWE creation, don't forget, and that has always meant everything to Vince.

Picture faces around ringside if Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair or Alexa Bliss didn't win the Rumble but Mandy did. What was that we were saying about a social media meltdown? Maybe that's the kind of chatter WWE wish to provoke.


3. Spots Repeat Across Both Rumble Matches

Royal Rumble 2018
WWE.com

Nightmare: It cannot be an easy task to ensure two Royal Rumble matches on the same show have distinctly different layouts, but WWE have produced enough of these things to come armed with a plethora of tropes and spots. Or, they might do what they did last year and lazily rehash moments from one Rumble in the other.

Chances Of It Coming True: Very, very good.

Last year, the men's Rumble had surprise legend The Hurricane going toe-to-toe with top male star John Cena. Then, the female match followed suit by having returning icon Beth Phoenix trade blows with top female name Nia Jax. It all felt a bit samey, and it kept the Phoenix spot from being truly memorable.

WWE have to find a way to make each Rumble match stand out for its own reasons. Reusing the same booking is careless, especially when there's only a few hours (at most) between the two matches. WWE don't have a full year between Rumbles like they used to.


2. The Show Runs Too Long

Sasha Banks Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

Nightmare: It was mentioned in the WWE Title entry earlier, and it's worth repeating. This year's Royal Rumble has nine matches on the card, seven of which will take place on the main show. Although that's the same number as last year all in, 2018 had three bouts on the Kickoff compared to 2019's two.

This could be problematic.

Chances Of It Coming True: The Rumble will feel like a marathon, not a sprint. WWE pay-per-views are excellent value for money now (for Network subscribers), and yet they do drag on at times. If 2018's Rumble ran for over four hours with one less match to worry about, then imagine how long 2019's could be.

This was avoidable. Some of the matches, like Ronda Rousey vs. Sasha Banks, feel like they didn't need to happen at all, and there's a chance their inclusion will hurt the Rumble's flow. Nobody wants to criticise WWE for giving fans more content, but common sense should have prevailed on this occasion.


1. There's Too Much McMahon Influence

Vince McMahon Stephanie Shane Triple H
WWE.com

Nightmare: By the end of the Rumble, Shane McMahon could be a Tag Team Champion, Vince may have shown face and Stephanie might have entered the women's Rumble. Then there's Triple H and his possible intrusion on Batista's big comeback (assuming Dave is on the return trail as a legendary surprise).

All that flies in the face of Trips saying WWE would shine the light onto their superstars and away from "absentee management".

Chances Of It Coming True: There's a place for each of the four on this pay-per-view, and that must be worrying to anybody who hoped they were being honest during that pre-Christmas self-depreciating promo speech on Raw. This is WrestleMania season, a time when WWE serve up their biggest stars on a platter, and that includes the McMahon family.

Come the 2019 Rumble's conclusion, people may be talking more about all the lofty spots they enjoyed than anything else that happened.

What other Rumble 2019 nightmares do you have? Let us know down in the comments section below!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.