10 WWE Stars The Undertaker Failed To Have A Good Match With

The Deadman is a WWE legend but even he couldn't make these guys look good.

WWE.comWWE.comThe Undertaker has accomplished a lot in his legendary WWE career. He's won multiple World Titles, has a 21-1 record at WrestleMania, main evented WrestleMania a number of times and generally been considered one of WWE's biggest names of the last quarter century. He's also a guy that has been put in situations where he was forced to wrestle bad wrestlers that led to awful matches. It makes you realize why he was so happy when he got to be in there with the likes of Shawn Michaels, Bret Hart and Kurt Angle. A lot of these bad feuds had the same sort of formula. Undertaker would get his ass kicked by some heel, then he would get taken out and the announcers would say that nobody has ever done that to Undertaker before even though we saw it happen dozens of times. Then they would have their big match, Undertaker would get the win and it would be over. In some cases, guys When you wrestle for 24 years in WWE like The Undertaker has done then you're going to have some awful matches. That's just part of the wrestling business. Even if you are a huge fan of him, you can't deny that WWE really did put him in a lot of bad feuds especially early in his career. It's painful to relive them, but they're also difficult to ignore. Here are ten WWE stars that The Undertaker failed to have a good match with.

10. Mabel

WWE.comWWE.comThe Undertaker had multiple bad matches with Mabel, who got a big push in 1995 simply because he was a big guy. That's how a lot of guys got their pushes. It wasn't a matter of being talented or not. It's just that WWE really loved pushing the big guys especially in the mid 1990s when they kept feeding them to Undertaker. Their first bad match happened at the 1995 King of the Ring when Mabel was on his way to receiving a main event push. He actually beat Undertaker thanks to the interference of Kama. That led to an Undertaker feud with Kama, which also wasn't very good. There was another Undertaker/Mabel match at the December 1995 In Your House PPV with Casket Match rules. Mabel actually looks bigger and with a worse haircut in this match compared to the one six months earlier. What's telling about their Casket Match was that they only got about 7 minutes. It's one of the shorter one of those matches you're ever going to see. That's because of how limited Mabel was and they must have known that it was going to be bad. It sure was.

9. Mark Henry

Wrestlemania 22 vs Mark Henry

There was a stretch in the mid 2000s when Undertaker had a lot of bad matches. It wasn't necessarily his fault. It was just that WWE kept putting him against bad opponents. There were some gems like at No Way Out 2006 against Kurt Angle (probably his best match not at a WrestleMania), but then that was followed up with this stinker at WresteMania 22 against Mark Henry in a Casket Match. Since WWE spent so much money on Henry for so many years they felt like they had to get something out of him, so they made him a serious heel challenger to The Undertaker. The result of that push was a boring, plodding battle at WrestleMania 22. At no point in the match did anybody really think that Undertaker would lose. Henry did some things where his power was impressive for a short period of time, but it wasn't a compelling match in any way. The only part of the match that was good was when Undertaker did a dive over the top that took out Henry. That led right into the Tombstone finish for the win in a 10 minute match that felt longer. They had other matches too. There was a rematch on Smackdown that led to debut of The Great Khali (more on that awful rivalry later) and even a Casket Match rematch two years after this. At least Henry did in improve in 2011, which was 15 years after his debut.

8. Yokozuna

WWE.comWWE.comThe build up to The Undertaker's showdown with Yokozuna at the 1994 Royal Rumble was good. Since Yoko was a top guy in WWE for a year before this it was a big deal to see him facing off with a top babyface like Undertaker with Yoko defending the WWE Title. While the build may have been good, the execution was awful. When they had the Casket Match at the 1994 Rumble the story was that Yoko was scared of the casket, which was a common theme for Undertaker opponents. Six minutes into the match, The Undertaker placed Yoko in the Casket and had the match won, but then Crush showed up to attack him. For the next seven minutes, there were about a dozen heels in the ring attacking Undertaker. It was one of the most overbooked match finishes ever. Then there was the famous scene of Undertaker doing a promo from inside the casket. He was out in the storyline for seven months. Later in the year at Survivor Series 1994 they did the Casket Match again with Chuck Norris as the celebrity special enforcer at ringside to make sure there wasn't interference again. That match was a bit better than the one at the Rumble, but it wasn't very good either. There were probably some other Undertaker/Yokozuna matches too. They all had a common theme in that they were generally pretty awful.

7. Sycho Sid

WWE.comWWE.comWrestleMania main events are supposed to be great matches or at least memorable in some way. When The Undertaker finally got a chance to main event, it was against WWE Champion Sycho Sid at WrestleMania 13. Sid was known for being a guy that had an intimidating look and presence about him, but he was below average in the ring. His promos were okay sometimes. His matches? They were never good unless Shawn Michaels was there to carry him. Even then he was still a limited performer. The match should have been a 10 minute win for Undertaker that was clean. Instead, Bret Hart interfered during the finish, which cost Sid and led to Undertaker winning clean with the Tombstone after 20 excruciating minutes. Who came up with the idea of giving Sid 20 minutes in a match? This match sucked. There wasn't much in terms of psychology, the rest holds sucked and even though Undertaker won it could have been done in a cleaner fashion. Sid was barely used after WrestleMania and was gone from the company three months after this. There's a story about this match that Sid literally s**t in his shorts during the match although we have no idea if that's true or not. It could have been some other match or it could be a totally made up story. Maybe it's better if we don't know the truth about it.

6. Kronik

WWE.comWWE.comThe Undertaker and Kane were holding the "coveted" WCW Tag Team Titles when they went into this match with Kronik (Adams & Clarke) at the Unforgiven PPV in September 2001. They were feuding because Kronik cost Undertaker and Kane the WWE Tag Team Titles. It was such a confusing period because of all the titles that were in WWE following the WCW Invasion storyline. Having a tag team match between four bigger wrestlers is a challenge because it's just a bunch of basic wrestling holds without any smaller guys bumping around the ring to make it more exciting. This was a 10 minute match that felt like 20 minutes because of how boring it was. The fans didn't know much about Kronik and they didn't care about them either. The Undertaker/Kane team won pretty easily. Following the match Kronik was gone from WWE because this match was so bad that WWE never wanted to use them again. After watching this match again, clearly WWE made the right decision there. It's pretty bad when you get brought in for a feud, have a PPV match and then get fired right after.

5. Fake Undertaker (Brian Lee)

WWE.comWWE.com"This is the moment you've all been waiting for." - Vince McMahon. Sorry Vince, but you're wrong. Very wrong. The Undertaker was off for about seven months in 1994 due to a back injury and also to build up to this big match at SummerSlam 1994. The character was really cartoonish, so WWE played into that by trying to portray things as if something was seriously wrong with him after his 1994 Royal Rumble loss to Yokozuna. A fake Undertaker was brought in by evil Ted Dibiase and that led to the real Undertaker returning to face off with him in a match. Their match was one of the main matches at SummerSlam that year. It was really bad. The fake Undertaker (played by Brian Lee) didn't do a great impersonation. The crowd never really bought into it. Once the real Undertaker planted him with three Tombstone piledrivers that ended the fake Undertaker experiment. In fact, they had him taken away in a casket and they really didn't mention the storyline much after that. It was a really cheesy storyline that looks even worse 20 years later.


4. Heidenreich

wwe.comwwe.comJohn Heidenreich was another guy in a long list of big guys that threatened the Undertaker's career by attacking him out of nowhere to set up a feud. WWE really loved setting up Undertaker feuds that way. There were actually two terrible PPV matches between them. The first one was a boring match at Survivor Series 2004. No gimmicks for this match. Just a regular match that Undertaker won clean. It's one of those matches that just wouldn't end. Really boring. The second terrible match in question was a Casket Match at the 1995 Royal Rumble. It was another case of the crowd not really believing in the heel because they knew he wasn't very good. To WWE's credit they tried to make the match more entertaining by having Snitsky and Kane do run-ins, but it really didn't help much. Undertaker won and thankfully that was the end of the Heidenreich push. Why do you think WWE never mentions that the great Paul Heyman managed Heidenreich leading up to this feud? Probably because WWE knows Heidenreich wasn't very good and they don't like mentioning things like that when talking about Heyman as the best manager ever. Because ignoring Heidenreich is good for business.

3. Big Boss Man

YoutubeYoutubeIt's probably the worst Hell in a Cell match ever with an ending that we all want to forget. When fans think about the Undertaker's great matches at WrestleMania this one at WM15 is one they shouldn't remember because it was awful. It was a heel vs. heel match. Those rarely work out well. By this point in his career, the Big Boss Man served a purpose as a security guy for Vince McMahon. He really wasn't in a position where he should have been in a Hell in a Cell match with somebody of The Undertaker's caliber. Nobody believed that he had a shot to win before the match or during the match, so it took the drama out of it immediately. The crowd was so dead for this match. Nobody cared. It wasn't interesting either. Undertaker won with the Tombstone and it was the first time that there was any kind of reaction. When it was over, Undertaker got the help of the Brood and they hung Bossman from a rope. The camera cut away, then it was completely ignored and we had to just move on from a guy hanging in the ring. Brutal.

2. The Great Khali

WWE.comWWE.comThere were a few bad matches between The Undertaker and Great Khali, but it's not like a lot of people had good matches with Khali. He's always been one of the most immobile wrestlers ever and if you can barely move then how can somebody have a decent match with him? Following Khali's attacks on Undertaker on Smackdown post-WrestleMania in 2006, they had a match at Judgment Day 2006. Khali won clean. Keep in mind that Undertaker rarely lost clean. What did Khali win clean with? A boot to the face, then a chop to the head and then another boot to the face that looked weaker than the others. Khali won by putting his foot on Undertaker's chest. The crowd was dead for it. Their scheduled Punjabi Prison match at the Great American Bash didn't happen because of Khali having an issue with liver enzymes, so Big Show took his place in what was a very awkward setting. This feud failed so much that WWE had originally planned the blowoff match at SummerSlam 2006. It was so bad that they just did their last match - a Last Man Standing Match - on the August 18 edition of Smackdown, which ended things in whimper not a bang. Undertaker used some stiff chair shots to help win that match and end the feud for good.

1. Giant Gonzalez

WWE.comWWE.comThis one had disaster written all over it from the moment the Giant Gonzalez slowly walked to the ring at the 1993 Royal Rumble and attacked Undertaker. Gonzalez was a very tall man that wasn't very muscular, so WWE made up for it by having him wear a body suit outfit that looked absolutely ridiculous even for the 1990s. Their match at WrestleMania 9 was awful. There was nothing that Gonzalez could do to make it interesting. Undertaker tried to show babyface heart to get the fans into it, but Gonzalez was unable to sell the right way or make it interesting. Then it ended via DQ thanks to Gonzalez using chloroform and it just fell totally flat. When they had the second match at SummerSlam 1993 it wasn't much better. At least it ended with a clean Undertaker win, which was with a clothesline off the top because Gonzalez was probably unable to take any other moves. The best part about it was that the feud was over. Gonzalez was out of WWE soon after. Since Undertaker had two terrible matches with him where it looked like an embarrassment to what pro wrestling is supposed to be, Giant Gonzalez is the winner of this coveted honor as the wrestler that Undertaker truly was unable to get a good match out of.

Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.