10 WWE Stars Undertaker Failed To Elevate To The Next Level

Not even the legendary Undertaker could make these guys into Superstars...

Bret Hart once quipped that the Undertaker 'could make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.' This was a reference to his incredible ring work, amazing gimmick commitment, and overall ring presence. Many times during of his career, the Undertaker has been assigned the dubious task of working with a new or rising star in WWE in the hopes of elevating them to new heights. While this has worked on several occasions, there are also just as many instances that prove that the Undertaker isn't always the miracle worker he's believed to be. There have been several notable cases where the Undertaker was assigned feuds with certain stars, with the general idea being that, because it's the Undertaker, those wrestlers would be elevated to a higher level just by sharing the ring with him. Sadly this didn't always work out as planned, as those wrestlers couldn't make the best out of a perfect situation to get over by working with the Deadman, and 'Taker himself ended up wasting his time. This article will highlight ten people that WWE tried to make into greater stars by pairing them with the Undertaker, in the hopes that this winning formula (which had worked on so many occasions in the past), would lead WWE to finding their next big star, but failed. These ten individuals either challenged the Undertaker or teamed with him for a time, and unfortunately, none of them became as big of a star as WWE had hoped in the first place.

10. Mabel/Viscera/Big Daddy V

Vince's decision to give Nelson Frazier Jr. multiple pushes as a major threat failed on each attempt. The main reason for this was that he was the wrong kind of huge; instead of a chiseled physique and large muscles, he was incredibly fat and, when he started wearing a singlet as Big Daddy V, his horrible physique was exposed. If there was ever a reason for people to believe that wrestlers lived unhealthy lives, it was seeing Big Daddy V. WWE tried to elevate him as a credible star by putting him with the Undertaker on several occasions. First, as 'King' Mabel, which ended with the Undertaker suffering a broken orbital bone. Then as Viscera, although by the end of that storyline he ended up as nothing more than a background character. Finally as Big Daddy V, a mercenary for hire that we were expected to believe could harm the Undertaker. Unfortunately, his career ended up being a disappointment. No matter how many times he was thrust into prominent storylines versus such opponents as the Undertaker, Frazier never caught on with the audience. Whatever the reason for it, not even the Undertaker could use his own star power to make Viscera and his other incarnations seem like bigger stars.

9. Luther Reigns

For a short period in 2005, WWE wanted to see if Luther Reigns could become something more than a hired gun. After all, he had the 'big guy' look that Vince loved, and looked very intimidating. Given those assets, it was hoped that he could become a strong draw as a top star, which is why he was placed in a short feud with the Undertaker. Unfortunately, that feud had the exact opposite result of the one intended. Reigns had one major match with the Deadman at No Way Out 2005, and it was in that match that Luther's flaws and lack of experience were badly exposed. His in-ring work was very shoddy, and he had very little in terms of unique personality. That match, and the brief storyline that led to it, was Luther Reigns' one opportunity to prove to WWE's powers-that-be that he was more than just a big man with the right look. Regrettably for him, a high-profile match with the Undertaker wasn't enough for him to elevate himself to a higher position. Because of that disappointing match, WWE had to shoehorn the Undertaker into a new rivalry with Randy Orton. While that was the right decision, the build-up to WrestleMania felt short and rushed, mainly because WWE was misguided in their attempt to make Luther Reigns a bigger star at the Undertaker's expense.

8. Rikishi

For quite some time, WWE tried to elevate Rikishi into the main event. After he was revealed to have ran Austin down, he was supposed to be presented as a major wrestler all of a sudden, despite having spent years as a midcarder. Part of this attempt to establish him as a main-eventer involved pairing him with the Undertaker for a while and building a rivalry between them. Unfortunately, Rikishi didn't benefit that much from this feud. Even though Rikishi eliminated the Undertaker from the 2001 Royal Rumble and got Chokeslammed off of the cell onto a truck at Armageddon 2000, that didn't help his main-event career take off. Undertaker tried to make this rivalry work, but despite defeating the Undertaker in both singles and tag team competition, the audience didn't buy the notion of Rikishi as a World-Champion-calibre athlete. A big part of that is how he was booked as a heel. He was still giving his opponents the Stinkface, and when he spoke, he did so with an underlying face tone. As such, he couldn't be taken seriously as the kind of 'evil bad guy' that could've run Steve Austin down. But as we've seen with the Undertaker before and after this rivalry, when his opponents face him, they're suddenly treated like a much bigger deal. But that treatment didn't work with Rikishi.

7. JBL

When 2004 began, the roster was stacked with many potential draws: Lesnar, Eddie, Benoit, Angle, and to a lesser extent, Mysterio and Undertaker. But by the time WrestleMania XX ended, Lesnar was gone, Benoit was on RAW, Angle needed time off to deal with injuries, Rey was back in the cruiserweight division, Eddie's body and mind weren't coping with being WWE Champion well, and Undertaker had transitioned completely into the 'work with the new guys' role instead of chasing the championship. Out of desperation, the company made career midcarder Bradshaw into a main-event-level heel, giving him a long World Title reign. After Eddie lost his rematch, WWE decided to best JBL's main-event value by putting him against long-time friend the Undertaker. Guess how that turned out. JBL didn't prove his skill as SmackDown's main event, not even against the Dead Man. Their SummerSlam match was so disappointing that the Toronto audience did the Mexican wave; their Last Ride Match at No Mercy 2004 was only slightly better, and their segments on SmackDown throughout mid-to-late 2004 were good but not good enough to convince fans to buy tickets to PPVs. Maybe it was the lack of clear chemistry between them, but one thing is clear: the Undertaker, with all his star power and respect, couldn't convince the WWE Universe that JBL was a worthy top guy.

6. The Great Khali

At first glance, the Great Khali looked like he might actually make it in WWE. Unfortunately, once he actually started €˜wrestling€™, everyone could see the writing on the wall: this mammoth of a human being could barely wrestle at all, and was hired solely due to his size and ethnicity. The Undertaker was stuck getting demolished by Khali for a few months, and in that time, Khali showed just how limited he was from his own stature. While Undertaker had demonstrated over the years that he could do many things and adapt to different styles, Khali was straightforward and boring when it came to offense. He swung his arms slowly and lazily, lifted his leg for a big boot in an even lazier fashion, and his two finishers, the Chokebomb and the Vice Grip, were so simplistic that even if Khali had actually put his opponents in a real head vice and squeezed, it wouldn't look good on TV. Khali and Undertaker had a plodding rivalry that did little to elevate Khali€™s career. He would constantly get chants of €˜you can€™t wrestle€™, and his reign as World Heavyweight Champion was a catastrophic flop. Even though he was portrayed as a true monster that was believed to have €˜broken the Undertaker€™s spirit€™, not even the Deadman could make this lumbering giant look like a real Superstar.

5. The Big Show

WWE had no idea what to do with Big Show in order to repeat the success Andre had. Sure, they tried to make him look like a dangerous juggernaut, but it wasn't long before he was jobbing out to bigger stars like the Rock and Steve Austin on a regular basis. So they tried to put him with the Undertaker, in the hopes that it would bring about significant positive change. Unfortunately, it didn't. From 1999 to 2009, Big Show and the Undertaker faced off and teamed together on numerous occasions, with Taker trying to make his opponent look like the multi-million-dollar draw he was supposed to become. Sadly, their matches were incredibly disappointing on several occasions. Taker's match with Big Show at WrestleMania XIX remains one of the worst of the Streak's history, and his renewed feud with Show in 2008 into 2009, which included both a Casket match and a Last Man Standing Match, were incredibly underwhelming. In the end, no one benefitted from this feud. Despite Big Show admitting that the Undertaker was his mentor, Big Show himself wasn't 100% committed to the changes that Undertaker had suggested he adopt. There were very strong rumours circulating in the early-to-mid 2000s that Big Show was lazy and preferred fast food to exercising, which prevented some of WWE's top brass from taking him seriously.

4. A-Train

It isn€™t hard to see why WWE was so keen on pushing A-Train. He was a former football player, he looked monstrous, and he had immense strength. When you put these elements together, you have a solid €˜strength-based€™ wrestler that can use that most traditional aspect of pro wrestling (i.e. said abnormal strength) to draw in crowds. But not even the Undertaker could make A-Train a credible main-event draw. It wasn€™t entirely A-Train€™s fault that he wasn€™t taken seriously by the WWE Universe; a major reason for his failure came from his earlier booking by WWE. As with his 2012 return to WWE as Lord Tensai, A-Train suffered from negative preconceptions from fans who remembered him as (Prince) Albert, the wrestler named for the penile piercing. Even if A-Train looked far more menacing than Prince Albert, the fans never forgot his more comedic origins, which tarnished his reputation. Furthermore, in the ring, A-Train wasn€™t the best. He was very straightforward in terms of his presentation, and was better off as a big man who demolished smaller guys. But given the fact that he was on SmackDown during a period highlighted by the work of the SmackDown Six, Brock Lesnar and the Undertaker himself, there was simply no way for him to get into the fans good graces while being presented as a monster.

3. Giant Gonzalez

The funny thing about Undertaker working with new signees in WWE is that it isn't a new phenomenon. In fact, this trend goes all the way back to his first few years in the company, when WWE would sign as many big guys as they could find in order to 'feed' them to the Undertaker, all while hoping that one of them would actually benefit from wrestling him. Giant Gonzalez is arguably the worst example of this philosophy in action during the 1990s. Considered by many to be the tallest pro wrestler ever, Gonzalez demonstrated everything wrong with signing unathletic giants solely due to their stature. Sure, he was tall, but he lacked physical definition so much that WWE had to airbrush muscles and physique onto a full-body suit for him. In doing so, he looked downright horrible. As if that wasn't bad enough, Gonzalez couldn't wrestle well at all. People complained back then that the Undertaker rarely left his feet to sell, but Gonzalez was worse. He wouldn't even fall to the mat ever, and looked like a complete fool waving his arms trying to keep his balance. There's a reason that Undertaker's match with Gonzalez is undoubtedly his worst Manis performance ever. Gonzalez made the Undertaker's offense look almost cartoonish, and he himself looked horrible in the ring.

2. Heidenreich

WWE thought that Heidenreich could become a big star, presumably because he had the size that Vince loved. Unfortunately, his stature didn€™t translate into in-ring skill or charisma in any way, and his feud with €˜Taker ended up being a massive disappointment. The two of them feuded from No Mercy 2004 to the 2005 Royal Rumble. During that period, Heidenreich demonstrated little development in terms of in-ring skill, despite the fact that he was working with one of the most versatile and skilled wrestlers in the entire company. Worse yet, his promos were terrible, and so he relied heavily on Paul Heyman to convey even the simplest of stories. No matter how much Heidenreich tried to use his strength to overpower the Undertaker, there was a level of inexperience in him that became quite obvious in their matches. At the risk of putting all the blame on Heidenreich, €˜Taker deserves a bit of a mention in this case as well. There was something€off€about his match quality throughout 2004 and during the first bit of 2005 until before WrestleMania. That period made one thing abundantly clear: Undertaker couldn€™t work with the bigger men anymore without his match quality dropping. Thankfully, WWE realized what was going on and nixed the planned tag team match involving Undertaker & Kane against Heidenreich and Snitsky. That one would have been bowling shoe ugly, for sure.


1. Nathan Jones

There is no bigger failure and waste of the Undertaker's time than Nathan Jones. The Australian was enormous and possessed that oh-so-loved chiseled physique that Vince and his underlings in Talent Relations desired more than anything else. Of course, not everyone can be Triple H, in that they can achieve major accomplishments in both wrestling and bodybuilding. While Jones did succeed in the latter, he was abysmal in the former. WWE tried to make a big deal out of him by pairing him with the Undertaker; this time, as a partner instead of as an opponent. Jones would spend precious screen time standing near the Undertaker, and would take part in many segments with him, in the hopes that 'Taker's legendary status would rub off somewhat on Jones. It didn't. No matter how much WWE (and Jones) tried to make things work, nothing did. Jones was so unskilled at wrestling that the company was forced to change his planned tag team with Undertaker into a handicap match where the Deadman had to face both Big Show and A-Train alone. On the plus side, Jones did have a small run-in spot that saved the Undertaker (if that moment can truly be considered as such), but by that point, Jones' days in WWE were numbered.

Contributor

Alexander Podgorski is a writer for WhatCulture that has been a fan of professional wrestling since he was 8 years old. He loves all kinds of wrestling, from WWE and sports entertainment, to puroresu in Japan. He holds a Bachelor of Arts degree from Queen's University in Political Studies and French, and a Master's Degree in Public Administration. He speaks English, French, Polish, a bit of German, and knows some odd words and phrases in half a dozen other languages.