10 WWE Stars Who Are Horrendously Miscast
There's a new arrival in WWE, but they still don't know what a babyface is.
Hard luck old bean, but the one time Vince McMahon promotes a top babyface that can do the whole mandated witty banter schtick - without alienating an adult-oriented crowd - there's no crowd to not reject him.
It is exponentially more cruel to Drew McIntyre, who - thus far - is somehow perfect in the impossible role that is babyface WWE Champion. He is a tall, handsome bastard who is absolutely shredded. He looks like a Vince McMahon guy, but he doesn't work like one. There's nothing histrionic nor cartoonish about his act; thrillingly, he wrestles like he's in the G1 Climax, and not under the wearying grip of an eternal chin lock. That is until he wrestles Baron Corbin on RAW next week.
He is also an affable presence, who can do mock arrogance, and then deftly transition into self-deprecation, a comedic device that allows him to get over and remain humble. He is killing a run made doubly impossible by the horrendous, unprecedented circumstances, and is easily the best WWE Champion in absolutely forever.
For once, WWE got the most important part right - but they still don't know their ar*eholes from their elbows further down the card...
10. Matt Riddle
Is playing:
The goof in an odd couple tag team, Matt Riddle is currently undergoing what appears to be an ethically suspect experiment of sorts on NXT. It's as if he is being injected with trope after trope of the worst of the WWE style guide in order to suffuse him with enough antibodies to withstand the main roster. TitanTron karaoke, catchphrase singalongs, quiz shows with Byron Saxton: the man is weeks away from getting his own talk show and mocking the recently-deceased family member of one of his peers, and by God, it's alive! It's alive! NXT has built a star so dumbly engaging that he can actually get that sh*t over, and he's rather helped by the idea that he is absolutely killer in that ring. WWE has a genuine superstar on their hands with Matt Riddle. The only thing they need to not do here is deliberately f*ck it up!
Should be playing:
The top guy on SmackDown because WWE, inexplicably, has a good top guy on RAW. Riddle is 34, he's in his prime, he has the look, skill, smile and balls coveted by Vince McMahon and should be transitioned from supporting actor to leading man yesterday.
9. Cesaro
Is playing:
A heel who, per the informed and bemused words of Arn Anderson, was "leaned on to stop doing that stuff as a heel, it was too flashy". By that stuff, Arn is referring to the shotgun bullet speed and balletic grace with which Cesaro is capable of exploding around the ring to either strike or scythe down his opponents. Instead, and he's still very good at it, he's a nondescript bully heel who is never not fun to watch, until you recall and wince at the fact that the over-produced and over-scripted wrestling company that tells the man how not to perform markets him as an "artist".
Should be playing:
Cesaro isn't Top WWE Guy material; it's mental to position him in that role having watched more than one WWE TV show. He isn't the best talker. He doesn't exude a megastar aura.
But for f*ck's sake, and it doesn't take much - you can even stop the pissants complaining if you do this - encourage the guy to go ballistic, because the byproduct of which is often the mythical "banger". But then you remember that the company with an official corporate policy of "putting smiles on people's faces" won't give the nerds their candies.
8. Kairi Sane
Is playing:
Kairi Sane is phenomenal in a miscast role because she is a phenomenal performer. She plays a mischievous heel unlike virtually anything ever seen on WWE television, but, because she is a phenomenal performer, grasps the universal (yet somehow lost) concept of cheating. She applies it so uniquely and so hilariously that she rescued a career that, genuinely, was trending towards an all-time Fed f*ck-up. She is a total joy to watch on what can very much be a totally joyless programme, but she is vastly capable of more than what can at times degenerate into comedic undercard fare with a ceiling. She lacks Asuka's legitimately dangerous energy, and that is because...
Should be playing:
...Kairi Sane is babyface on principle and it's an indictment of everything that she isn't a babyface on my TV screen. A great babyface worker with boundless charm and a willingness to surrender her body entirely to a sh*t-kicking, she has a skill that cannot be taught: the ability to draw a crowd into her plight and make them believe she can overcome it. It's not a typical WWE presentation, but then, typical WWE isn't retaining its viewership.
7. Johnny Gargano
Is playing:
A heel, and just in case there was any ambiguity over this development, tracing back to that time in 2018 when he was out there on bridges only tentatively enjoying the dark, he loves him some dark now. He is a full-blown heel; he has new music and everything, and to reinforce the message, he cheated during every available opportunity in his recent match with Dominik Dijakovic in a very obvious story very atypical of NXT Producer Shawn Michaels!
Should be playing:
Come back home to the babyface side of that bridge, Jonny, and stop looking at your hands. They'll still be there in the morning. Gargano can play heel...in a pro wrestling company. In the sports entertainment company, he is depended upon to act, and his melodramatic acting is the cause of his fall from grace. Gargano was once the hottest star in all of wrestling. He had fused emotive babyface work with state-of-the-art technicality to become great, and now he's a punchline in certain circles. This is an indictment of NXT's approach. His act used to convince. He was phenomenal as the earnest, explosive 21st century Ricky Steamboat. He needs to mouth "I'm sorry, I love you" in the direction of Shawn Michaels but not, under any circumstances, in the context of a pro wrestling match.
6. Candice LeRae
Is playing:
A heel, which is helpfully denoted by her wearing black lipstick - a potent visual metaphor for an ailing, once-proud creative regime. She is playing a heel because her husband is, which also doesn't count as character development, and yes, while she would support her husband in real life, this isn't real life. It is quite the opposite. She might like working alongside Johnny Gargano, but since she dutifully aligns with him whenever he goes through another Hawthorne Heights phase, for the viewer, it's as if she can only exist in his orbit. This is a pity, because...
Should be playing:
While "just turn her at the same time as her husband" potentially undermines that point, just turn her at the same time as her husband. LeRae is an effervescent, über-gutsy working babyface, and the depth to her rare and authentic skill hasn't been remotely explored. She also has a tremendously relatable girl-next-door appeal that renders her patchy, man-dependent feeling goth might delete later arc a travesty, and the sad thing is that she never really had that awesome long-term babyface run. She endured nothing that would warrant such a dramatic transformation, and that's why it feels like she's just wearing black lipstick.
5. Bayley
Is playing:
This is where WWE finds itself through the looking glass of its brand-first, self-referential approach to storytelling and character development. Bayley struggled badly to adjust to the main roster brand, and this has informed a character that must mystify those without a deep knowledge of the company. Her deadpan trash talking, miserable promos and eye-rolling demeanour put across the idea that she has developed through sheer work dread a sense of nihilism which, while not unrealistic, works exponentially better on social media on television. Whatever the hell it is, some of the tweets are funny, but it's just not right. This is Bayley. She shouldn't be playing the manifestation of a Smiths lyric.
Should be playing:
A babyface, goddamn it. If WWE can't channel her infectious magic through the TV set, that's their problem and one that requires, post-Becky Lynch, immediate correction. Get to the Sasha feud already. It's not going to be as good as it was in 2015, anyway. And if the old Bayley character needs an "edge" - what she really needs is to not be booked by decrepit old men who have no capacity for wholesome joy - just put her on RAW and have Paul Heyman put the word "Bitch!" at the end of every other sentence.
4. Jake Atlas
Is playing:
A guy. Jake Atlas is a guy who wrestles in WWE for the NXT brand presented with an appalling lack of effort and conviction. He jobbed to Dexter Lumis one week, on his debut, but was swiftly presented as a championship-calibre performer through his participation in the interim Cruiserweight title tournament, as the commentary team murmured something or other about his potential and hype as an Indy standout. The whole thing is weird; Atlas was the most talked-about guy on the scene last year, so they're under-selling him. For a company so big on bluster and presentation, it's very odd, as is his role. It's not helped that he's a very flashy athlete with no crowd to pop for him, but wrestling companies should over-compensate, if anything, to build interest amid this crisis.
Should be playing:
Atlas is an openly gay man who proudly wore the flag on his trunks on the Independent scene. Why he doesn't in NXT leads one down a rabbit hole of suspicion only light, anecdotal evidence can support. But if the reason is that reason, if Hulk Hogan can fight for the rights of every man, why can't Jake Atlas fight to represent the marginalised?
At the very least, push him big as the damn prodigy he is. He already has one of the best finishes in the company, and he's worked all of three TV matches.
3. Braun Strowman
Is playing:
A tired and less mobile version of the same character he played three years ago, only this time, he's the Universal Champion. The bit has expired; Strowman can no longer do his fabulously cartoonish feats of strength on these smaller-scale productions, and the novelty of "massive hoss who can earnestly go against the right opponent" has long since worn off because there was no depth to the act. He is magnetic - not in a "star quality" way but rather an "eats the damn ring post in every damn match" way.
Should be playing:
A heel. He revealed himself to be quite the real-life sh*thead with his remorseless take on Indy wrestlers trying to survive, and just worked an embarrassing match with Bray Wyatt in which his attempt at showing range went about as well as the first few months of 205 Live. He can't do anything else, and while he was once a joy as the explosive, dumb brick sh*thouse, there is now no need for him to run around the ring other than "Duh, the road agent told me to!"
*Hans Moleman voice*
"No, that's too dumb."
2. Big E
Is playing:
An entertaining if played out tag team star fated, at this point, to continue setting records the precise number of which, much less the chronology, has long since blurred into itself. Is it nine? It's impressive - on paper - we are told that much. The formula is wearing as thin now as E is thicc; New Day win doubles gold, put on a couple of exciting if rote Triple Threat or Fatal Four-Way ***1/2 mini-bangers, lose gold, put on a couple of...rinse, repeat, patter steadily crumbles, much like a scotch pancake that needs more syrup - and the thing about syrup is that sh*t gets sickly.
Should be playing:
The top babyface in the company, or at least be positioned as a major singles star. Big E can work the hell out of a convoluted and frantic match, knows the value of the odd high spot and when to do it, and possesses the heavyweight stopping power and sheer charisma to get over in a challenging role - particularly since he will mercilessly banter off the piss-poor writing top WWE faces have historically been subjected to. They should put him over Goldberg to launch the push, purely so that he can repeat this promo verbatim.
1. Malcolm Bivens
Is playing:
It's looking like was, past tense. After attacking Matt Riddle recently to stake a claim for the NXT Tag Team Championships, Malcolm Bivens' crew of Rinku and Saurav appear to have disappeared. The abysmal quality of said beatdown very much had a developmental feel to it, which is just as well. They're in the right place. Bivens is not; he doesn't suit the role of glorified heel translator doing intimidating things with his eyes because he's not intimidating. Bloody love lads doing stuff with their eyes down in NXT, don't they? Shawn Michaels probably read that this is a smart acting choice in a manual.
Should be playing:
There's a gag in Seinfeld in which George Costanza compares his irritating - but ultimately catchy - personality to a jingle. "Co-stanza." This accurately describes the essence of Malcolm Bivens: he is a short, stocky bald man who can play many a role through this idiosyncratic personality spectrum. He is also piss funny, the exact shape with which to fill NXT's patter void, and there are two immediate means of doing this that spring to mind. He could commentate, balancing out the incredibly convoluted intensity of Mauro Ranallo, or, better yet, solve NXT's directionless midcard, one-dimensional tone, and lack of episodic intrigue by recruiting a stable with which to challenge for the Tag and North American Titles.