10 WWE Stars Who Failed In WCW
Big pay cheques from Turner didn't always translate into a big push on screen.
The list of stars that flourished in the WWF only to flounder in WCW is a long and depressing read. From Rick Martel to Greg Valentine, countless legends of the industry found themselves on WCW payroll simply to make up the numbers.
With a bloated roster that saw everyone from One Man Gang to Shark Boy under contract at one time, it's no surprise that future names like AJ Styles, Edge and even Triple H all went under the WCW radar in favour of the Hogans of the world. Nevertheless, neglecting a potential star's talent is one thing; squandering a proven commodity is a totally different offence altogether.
During the Monday Night Wars in particular, WCW had a habit of snapping up superstars simply to hurt the competition. If a star was under contract with WCW, they couldn't fight the cause for Vince McMahon. With Ted Turner's seemingly endless funds at their disposal, the allure of big money was often more than enough to seal the deal.
As a result, the number of superstars that were misused and overlooked during their time in Turnertown is almost criminal. As they say, the grass isn't always greener on the other side.
10. Brutus Beefcake
Ed Leslie has had countless gimmicks over the years, yet none were more popular than his run in the WWF as Brutus Beefcake. A Tag Team Champion in his own right, Beefcake became a high-profile part of WrestleMania IX as Hulk Hogan's partner and would ride that celebrity all the way into WCW.
In Atlanta, Beefcake became simply The Butcher and incredibly even challenged Hogan for the WCW Title in the main event of Starrcade '94, based purely on his close-friendship with 'The Hulkster'.
The following year, The Butcher became The Man with No Name before settling on The Zodiac as part of Kevin Sullivan's Dungeon of Doom. After turning babyface, The Zodiac would change his name once again to The Booty Man. Phew.
After a two year hiatus from WCW, Leslie would return to WCW one last time under the gimmick of The Disciple. With a drastic new look, Leslie was barely recognisable; however, he slotted right into his usual spot by Hogan's side, in the ever-growing nWo.
Despite having a supporting role in the Hogan/Warrior feud, The Disciple largely became a jobber after Warrior departed. Shaving his beard and appearing more like his original WWF persona, Disciple was relegated to WCW Saturday Night and Worldwide before being released in late '99.
9. Jim Neidhart
After the Montreal Screwjob, Jim Neidhart loyally followed his brother-in-law, Bret Hart, in his exodus from WWF. Much like Bret, it wouldn't take long for Jim to make his way over to WCW.
Making a logical debut by verbally going to bat for his former partner, Neidhart initially got a good reaction from the WCW faithful. Going toe-to-toe with Ric Flair on his first night in, it seemed like a family reunion was on the cards when Bret came to his brother-in-law's aid.
Unfortunately for Neidhart, the altercation with Flair would be the high point of his WCW career and it was all downhill from there. It would be another month until Neidhart made his official in-ring debut.
Neidhart would soon reunite with fellow Hart Foundation brethren, Davey Boy Smith. Regardless of the pairing, Neidhart appeared mainly on B-Shows like WCW Saturday Night and would often appear on the losing end when solo.
Neidhart challenged for the WCW TV Title on two occasions during his tenure, losing to Fit Finlay in May and Chris Jericho in September. Despite being a TV regular throughout his tenure, he only appeared on one PPV, Fall Brawl '98. He was let go shortly after.
8. Marty Jannetty
Marty Jannetty rose to fame as one half of the hugely successful tag team, The Rockers. With the legendary Shawn Michaels by his side, the team helped to revolutionise the WWF's tag team division in the early '90s and both men became stars in the process.
While Michaels would go on to become arguably the greatest in-ring performer of all time, Jannetty's career would slip by the wayside. Despite a run with the IC Title in 1993, Jannetty once again became part of tag division.
After asking for his release in late '96, Jannetty eventually made his way to WCW to become part of the company's Cruiserweight Division in early '98. Despite his name value, Jannetty only challenged for the title on one occasion, losing to Chris Jericho in less than 90 seconds.
The run itself was largely uneventful and Jannetty appeared on just one WCW PPV during his time with the company. At Slamboree '98, Jannetty was part of a 15 man Battle Royal for a shot at the Cruiserweight Champion, Chris Jericho.
His last match came in August '98 in a losing effort to Konnan on Nitro. Jannetty injured his shoulder in the match and was released, in typical WCW style, while recovering from injury.
7. Road Warrior Animal
As the Legion of Doom, Animal and Hawk were one of the most successful tag teams in wrestling history. Winning titles in every promotion they went, the Road Warriors became the first and only team to complete the coveted Triple Crown, claiming the AWA, NWA and WWF Tag Team Championships.
However, Hawk's well-documented struggles led to the team going on hiatus on a number of occasions in the '90s - most notably post-SummerSlam '92. This trend would continue into the new millennium, leading Animal to his first and only WCW solo run in January 2001.
Debuting as Ric Flair's mystery fourth participant in the main event of Sin, Animal's debut was immediately tainted by the horrific leg injury sustained by Sid just minutes before.
Nevertheless, Animal got a decent pop when the reveal was made and officially formed what would become The Magnificent Seven stable when he helped Scott Steiner retain his WCW Title.
As the group's enforcer, Animal's run saw him once again wrestle exclusively in tag team competition. With a different partner virtually every week, he won just one match, losing to the likes of Kronik, Billy Kidman and Ernest 'The Cat' Miller.
The angle was dropped when WCW was bought by Vince McMahon in March 2001.
6. Big Boss Man
As Big Boss Man, Ray Traylor was one of the most recognisable characters on the WWF TV. That success did not carry over into WCW.
Making his debut as 'The Boss' in late '93, Traylor came into WCW with a victory over US Champion, Rick Rude, leading to an unsuccessful title challenge at Starrcade '93. Traylor was subsequently forced to change his name after WWF took issue with the obvious similarities.
As such, Traylor became 'The Guardian Angel', donning the attire of the unarmed crime-prevention patrollers of the The Guardian Angels organisation. The gimmick lasted about a year before Traylor turned heel and reverted back to his Big Bubba Rogers persona of the NWA.
After floundering in the awful Dungeon of Doom stable, Big Bubba briefly joined the nWo before being dropped from the group by Eric Bischoff. After switching to his real name and forming an alliance with The Steiners for a forgettable nWo feud, Traylor left WCW in mid '98.
Traylor would once again revive his Big Bossman character to much success in the WWF that same year. As part of Vince McMahon's heel Corporation stable, Bossman would win several championships and even challenge Big Show for the WWF Title at Armageddon '99.
5. Rick Rude
In the early '90s, Rick Rude reached the height of his career in WCW. As the centrepiece of the brilliant Dangerous Alliance faction, Rude became US Champion and had some of the best matches of his career. Rude would also go on to lift the 'Big Gold Belt' (then recognised as the WCW International World Heavyweight Championship), before retiring from in-ring activity due to injury.
By the time he returned to WCW in late 1997, Rude had been out of action for several years. Nevertheless, his debut was a big deal. Rude had left the WWF in disgust following the Montreal Screwjob, leading Rude to become the first man to appear on Nitro and Raw simultaneously.
Rude also became the first man to be part of both DX and the nWo, quickly reprising his managerial role next to long-time friend, Curt Hennig. Rude and Hennig became shackled to nWo mid-card feuds and were both off TV within a year.
Hennig would return at Starrcade, noticeably without Rude by his side. Rude himself was recovering from a nasty testicular cancer scare, that eventually turned out to be cysts. Despite rumours that he was training for an in-ring return, Rude left WCW in March '99 and died of heart failure a month later.
4. Ted DiBiase
In the WWF, Ted DiBiase had become a made man. A recurring fixture of the main events, a former (albeit dubious) WWF Champion, and one of the most memorable heels to ever grace the territory, 'The Million Dollar Man' was a household name in the early '90s.
Regrettably, the same can't be said for his tenure in WCW. Having retired from in-ring competition, DiBiase made his debut in style as the often-forgotten fourth member of the nWo. Just one month after the radical formation of the group, DiBiase was given a high profile spot as spokesman for Hogan and co.
Billed as 'Trillionaire Ted' - an obvious shot at WWF's childish 'Billionaire Ted' skits aimed at Ted Turner - DiBiase was portrayed as the financial backer of the New World Order, living up to his established WWF character as the wealthy villain.
Unfortunately for DiBiase, his role would soon become redundant, as Eric Bischoff himself became a member of the nWo, thus ousting DiBiase from his spot as the group's money man. DiBiase career languished in WCW after the unceremonious removal and his managerial days were numbered from that point on.
He went on to briefly manage The Steiners and Ray Traylor before leaving the company altogether in 1999.
3. British Bulldog
Despite having a pretty successful run with the company in 1993, Davey Boy Smith's return to WCW in 1998 was world's apart from the main events and title shots he became accustomed to five years earlier.
Smith was immediately entered into an uninspired mid-card feud with Steve McMichael. 'Mongo's limited in-ring ability made the assignment a tough task for Bulldog and his debut bout was far from his best work.
Bulldog quickly aligned himself with Jim Neidhart and the two became a recurring tag team. However, by the time September came around, Bulldog's spot on the card was much the same as it was when he entered eight months earlier. At Fall Brawl '98, Smith and Neidhart teamed against Disco Inferno and Alex Wright in a disastrous match that almost ended Smith's career.
During the match, Smith landed on the trap door set up beneath the canvas for The Warrior's mystical entrance later that night. The awkward fall would eventually lead to a spinal infection that saw Smith confined to a wheelchair in the aftermath.
The injury and near paralysis resulted in a morphine addiction that curtailed his career for 12 months, before he made his eventual return to the WWF in late '99.
2. Ultimate Warrior
After whirlwind success in the WWF in the early and mid '90s, WCW's signing of The Ultimate Warrior in 1998 was a huge coup for Eric Bischoff and co.
Still in phenomenal aesthetic shape and still very much a household name in wrestling circles, Jim Hellwig - now known simply as The Warrior - debuted in WCW by entering straight into a main event feud with Hulk Hogan.
Sadly, WCW weren't sure how to book the crazed former champion. Instead of presenting him as the high-octane madman that WWF had offered, he was displayed as a mystical figure with supernatural powers. Bizarre instances like appearing in a mirror that only Hogan (and the watching audience) could see and regularly exiting the ring in a cloud of smoke, became a common part of his act.
As a result of the strange booking, his tenure in WCW was relatively short and he only had three matches to his name by the time he left. Despite having one of the best win/loss records in WWF history, he won only one of his matches in WCW and did so by DQ.
His abysmal match with Hogan at Halloween Havoc was the nail in the coffin and Warrior retired from wrestling altogether shortly thereafter.
1. Bret Hart
Bret Hart is unquestionably one of the greatest wrestlers in WWE history. Sadly, his WCW run was a stark contrast to his time with Vince McMahon.
In the wake of the Montreal Screwjob, 'The Hitman' made his unspectacular debut as a special referee at Starrcade 1997. His in-ring debut came against Ric Flair at Souled Out in January '98, however, Hart wouldn't wrestle again until March.
With only three WCW matches under his belt, Hart inexplicably turned heel and became an "associate member" of the nWo. Labelled as yet another crony for Hogan, Hart became lost in the shuffle and was positioned firmly outside the WCW Title picture.
Despite main eventing World War 3 in November (a losing effort to DDP), he wouldn't appear on WCW PPV again until February '99. Hart's stop/start push continued until the big Goldberg/steel plate angle in Toronto. Sadly, this coincided with Hart needing surgery and his brother's tragic death in May. As a result, Hart didn't return to action until September.
Just when it looked like Hart had finally found his rhythm - capturing the WCW Championship - he suffered what would be a career ending injury in the main event of Starrcade '99.
Through bad luck, poor management and bad booking, what could have been WCW's franchise player was left to play second fiddle to Hulk Hogan's ego.