10 WWE Stars Who Have Defined SummerSlam

If Shawn Michaels is Mr WrestleMania, who is Mr SummerSlam?

After 26 annual instalments€”soon to become 27€”SummerSlam has firmly established itself as the second biggest showcase in professional wrestling. This has been achieved through a combination of epic rivalries, memorable storylines, blockbuster names and of course the most stellar of matches. Consequently, we see something of a virtuous cycle occur in that these stellar matches help motivate performers to continually up their game and exceed our rising expectations. It€™s a win-win situation. But of all these matches and all these superstars, who has delivered more than any other at the biggest party of the summer? Who has helped define the pay-per-view and elevate it to its current status? In short, who is the man most deserving of the moniker Mr. SummerSlam? It€™s a difficult question to answer, and a topic that will always be blighted by subjectivity€”but we can give it a go either way. This article considers a number of factors including records, appearances, wins, championship feats, the significance of these matches and€”most importantly€”the standard of the performances themselves. It€™s this final point that really separates the best from the rest, and the key reason why Shawn Michaels is universally known as Mr. WrestleMania. We begin with a man who made quite the impact at last year€™s event€

10. Randy Orton

Randy Orton is a man who wasted no time in making a name for himself at SummerSlam. In 2004€”just his second ever SummerSlam appearance€”the Viper became the youngest ever World Heavyweight Champion at the age of just 24. And remember that this was back when the big gold belt was the most prestigious strap in the company. To put it on Orton was a huge honour and symbol of recognition. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJfOwB82nlA Add to that a pair of classic championship feuds with John Cena in 2009 and Christian in 2011, his dastardly Money in the Bank cash-in at last year€™s event€”and the small matter of a victory over the Undertaker in 2005€”and Orton will be remembered as one of the most successful superstars in SummerSlam history. Despite all that success though, Orton wasn€™t necessarily the man to steal the show at the summer spectacle. Sure, he regularly made a striking impact, but he could rarely consider himself the standout performer of the entire night. For that reason, the third-generation superstar will have to settle for tenth place on this list.

9. Hulk Hogan

While Orton is a name associated with SummerSlam€™s more recent history, Hulk Hogan was a pioneering figure during the PPV€™s infancy. The Hulkster headlined the three of the first four shows with a variety of blockbuster tag matches. In 1988 he formed the Mega Powers with Randy €œMacho Man€ Savage, facing off against the team of André the Giant and Ted DiBiase, before teaming with Brutus Beefcake the following summer to face his fellow Hollywood star Zeus and former ally Savage. Tag action then became handicap action in 1991, when Hogan and the Ultimate Warrior faced the team of Sgt. Slaughter, Col. Mustafa (the Iron Sheik) and General Adnan as part of Slaughter€™s lengthy €œIraqi-sympathiser€ storyline. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wz8HBzLAYHs Then after a 14-year exile, further success in singles competition arrived€”most notably in 2005 when he beat Shawn Micheals in one of WWE€™s much loved €œfirst time ever€ matches. Ultimately, he finished his career with a 6-0 record at the August showcase. But it was his earlier success in main eventing the first couple of PPVs that made him something of a SummerSlam icon. It was a period of growth for the WWE and without Hogan€™s €œMega€ main events, who knows if SummerSlam would have achieved the success that it since has. Of course, much like Orton, Hogan€™s actual performances were rarely the most accomplished of the show. For that reason, it€™s difficult to place the legend much higher than ninth.

8. Ultimate Warrior

Much like Hogan, the Ultimate Warrior was also a key part of SummerSlam during the show€™s early years. Unlike the Hulkster though, Warrior can boast the honour of being the only man to emerge victorious in each of the first five summer PPVs. And more to the point, those victories were each highly valuable. The first saw Warrior defeat the Honky Tonk Man€”ending his record Intercontinental title reign in just 31 seconds€”in an appearance that is widely regarded as one of the most exciting in SummerSlam history. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzmWjqzOtfk He won the same belt again the following year, this time beating Rick Rude, before going one better and downing the very same opponent, this time with the WWE title on the line, inside a steel cage in 1990. 1991 saw Warrior turn to tag team action, forming the aforementioned alliance with Hogan to face Slaughter, Mustafa and Adnan. And finally, he scored a victory over WWE Champion Randy Savage in 1992€”however the DQ victory meant that the belt itself eluded him. The only blemish on Warrior€™s SummerSlam career was his alleged threat of no-showing the 1991 event. It remains a controversial issue, but isn€™t quite enough to overshadow five blockbuster matches that made Warrior arguably the top star of SummerSlam€™s early years.

7. Triple H

With an 8-5 record at SummerSlam€”bettered only by one man€”Triple H was always likely to feature on this list. His highlights include the classic Ladder match with the Rock in 1998, where the Game won the Intercontinental title and both combatants showed that they were ready to take the company by storm, and a couple of World title victories. In 2003 he captured the World Heavyweight Championship in the second-ever Elimination Chamber bout, outlasting the likes of Goldberg and Shawn Michaels, while in 2008 he beat the Great Khali to retain his WWE title. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xzv1wa_summerslam-1998-the-rock-vs-triple-h-ladder-match-for-the-wwf-intercontinental-championship_sport The Game also boasts victories as a part of DX in 2006 and 2009, but the flipside of his record is that he€™s also suffered plenty of defeats, including two Triple Threat matches for the WWE title in 1999 and 2000. And furthermore, even some of his victories have been a little underwhelming (his aforementioned clash with Khali in 2008 was anything but a classic). That may not necessarily be solely his fault, but either way it€™s a hindrance that makes it difficult to place the Cerebral Assassin above seventh place. As a huge fan of the Game I€™d love to feature him higher on this list, but I can€™t help but feel that they are others who are more deserving of the title Mr. SummerSlam.

6. Edge

And one of those men is Edge. Despite having his career cruelly cut short by injury, the Rated-R Superstar has a whole host of SummerSlam moments which helped reinforce his legacy. As impressive as his tally of eight wins is, it€™s the rivalries themselves that he€™s been involved in that have arguably overshadowed the numbers. His 2006 feud with Cena essentially defined his career, while his life-imitating-art showdown with Matt Hardy the previous year remains one of the most intense rivalries of all time. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sz64vQ7MZwE He also did battle with the Undertaker at SummerSlam 2009 inside Hell in a Cell. Although that particular contest ended in defeat for Edge, as Mick Foley and Triple H will tell you, being able to go with 'Taker inside a cell is enough to prove to the world that you're truly amongst the profession's elite. Perhaps the most significant match though came at SummerSlam 2000 appearance; the first ever TLC match. Along with Christian, the Dudleys and the Hardys, Edge not only stole the show but helped revolutionize a gimmick match that is now one of the most popular in the WWE today. There€™s even an entire PPV named after it€”now that is a legacy worth celebrating.

5. John Cena

This one may seem like I€™m going against an earlier point, but hear me out. John Cena has won four matches at SummerSlam, but like Triple H he€™s also tasted his fair share of defeats €“ losing on six occasions in total. But the difference here is that even in defeat, Cena€™s matches have been of a very high standard. He's often garnered criticism for his limited ring style, but at SummerSlam the posterboy of the company has proved that he's more than capable of putting on a top-quality match. As a fan, which would you deem to be more successful; Triple H vs. Khali from 2008, or Cena vs. Daniel Bryan from just last year? And what about his clash with CM Punk during their classic feud of 2011? Sometimes in pro wrestling, your legacy can be boosted more from a loss than it can from a win. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5DEJGl1DxEI Admittedly Bryan and Punk are better workers than Khali, but nonetheless Cena still played his part. Those matches and the performances within them will stick in fans€™ memories for far longer, and thus make the leader of the Cenation a more suitable candidate for Mr. SummerSlam than the aforementioned Triple H. Some of Cena€™s other highlights include WWE Championship victories over Chris Jericho and Randy Orton in 2005 and 2007 respectively.

4. Brock Lesnar

Brock Lesnar€™s inclusion on this list is perhaps somewhat questionable, given that he€™s only featured in four SummerSlam PPVs (winning three and losing one). But the sheer magnitude of these matches are enough to make Lesnar a very worthy entrant on any list charting the PPV€™s most successful performers. His first SummerSlam, in 2002, saw him defeat the Rock to become the youngest ever WWE champion after just five months in the company. And in the following year, though he tasted defeat in a submission match as part of his epic rivalry with Kurt Angle, Lesnar still put on a stellar display, impressing with his technical and physical prowess. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vUy1b3v7irY Since his return in 2012 though, he's reached an entirely new level, acting as the blockbuster draw of the past two events. First against Triple H in 2012 and then against CM Punk last year, Lesnar used his unique MMA-style to put on the type of match that few others can. He has truly mastered the art of suspending disbelief, making him as entertaining as anyone in the company right now. Not many superstars can boast such a high profile and ultimately successful SummerSlam resum途and it looks like it could get even better at this year€™s show.

3. The Undertaker

Undertaker almost makes this list on pure longevity alone. Over the years the Deadman has featured at SummerSlam a record 15 times, 14 of which were in successive years (this man knows how to put together a streak) and nine of which ended in victory€”yet another PPV record. It€™s certainly an odd couple€”a macabre, supernatural €œdead€ person and one of the warmer, more enjoyable month of the year€”but it€™s a pairing that we€™ve seen come together more than any other. €˜Taker€™s greatest SummerSlam moments include tag team glory in 1999 and 2002, three separate WWE Championship bouts, his memorable Hell in a Cell clash with Edge in 2008, as well as the bizarre honour of being the only man in the PPV€™s history to ever have a match with himself. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LAxImAAPNI The one thing that lets the Phenom down though is that a number of his matches were upper mid-card matches rather than absolute main events, such as his clashes with Test, A-Train and Kama. In many ways this is a testament to the professionalism that has defined the Undertaker€™s career; never reluctant to put anyone over, and as enduring and consistent as any other superstar before him. But nonetheless, his lack of show-stealing, headline matches mean that it€™s difficult to place the Undertaker any higher on this list€”particularly when one considers the following pair of usual suspects.

2. Shawn Michaels

He may be Mr. WrestleMania, but the Heartbreak Kid is not quite Mr. SummerSlam. Nonetheless, his career at the biggest show of the summer is amongst the most storied in company history. Looking back at his record, you can literally map Shawn Michaels€™ meteoric rise through the ranks in the WWE. His first few SummerSlam appearances were spent in tag matches alongside Marty Jannety or in mid-card feuds against the likes of Rick Martel. In 1993 though, he burst onto the Intercontinental scene, beating Mr. Perfect by countout before putting on what is widely regarded as one of the most ground-breaking ladder matches of all time with Razor Ramon in 1995. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XC6jPR4OyUw Further success followed the next year when HBK beat Vader for the WWE Championship, and in 1997 he found himself acting as guest referee in Bret Hart€™s victory over the Undertaker. That was all part of the Survivor Series build for that year, and we all know what happened there... On top of all that, he still came back for more. His epic unsanctioned match with Triple H in 2002 proved that he still had what it takes, while his defeat to Hogan in 2005 is still one of the most entertaining matches that I€™ve ever seen (though perhaps for unconventional reasons). It€™s quite the list of accomplishments, and most importantly a list that was put together with a series of show-stealing performances. For that reason Michaels€™ is placed above all others bar one familiar face...

1. Bret Hart

At SummerSlam, Bret €œthe Hitman€ Hart truly proved himself as the best there is, the best there was, and quite possibly the best there ever will be. Since his first appearance at the inaugural PPV, Hart has thrilled fans in each and every show he€™s been a part of. His early days wrestling at SummerSlam were spent in tag team action with Jim €œthe Anvil€œ Neidhart. Forming the legendary Hart Foundation, the duo put on some awesome matches with the likes of Demolition (twice) and the Brain Busters. The innovation and technique Hart displayed did much to bolster his Excellence of Execution moniker. In 1991 he defeated Mr. Perfect in an instant classic, and in the following year created one of the all-time great SummerSlam moments in his Match of the Year with the British Bulldog. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7LAM7mULJY Having amply proved his worth, Hart progressed to the WWE title picture, beating his brother Owen for the belt in 1994 and the Undertaker in 1997. The latter victory was a pivotal moment in a feud that would go on to create the most controversial moment in wrestling history just a few months later at Survivor Series 1997. He even staged a dramatic comeback at the 2010 PPV when he joined Team WWE in their quest to banish the Nexus. A litany of championships, some epic rivalries and most importantly a handful of the greatest performances of all time are reason enough to crown Bret €œthe Hitman€ Hart the true Mr. SummerSlam.

Contributor
Contributor

Elliott Binks hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.