10 WWE Stars Who SERIOUSLY Need A New Look

Isn't it about time Sheamus stopped dressing like Brad Pitt's Snatch character?

Sheamus snatch
WWE

As French cultural theorist Roland Barthes once observed, wrestling is a spectacle of excess, sharing lineage with both Greek drama and bullfights.

Along with their excessive gestures and exaggerated explanations, every sign displayed by a wrestler is imbued with meaning that should be immediately obvious to the audience. This includes each detail of the wrestler's posture, manner of speaking, and what they wear. A wrestler's gear communicates a great deal to the audience about the role they play, who they are, and how they want you the viewer to feel as soon as you look at them.

As Barthes says, everything must be understood on the spot, and bad choices can leave the audience confused about what the performer is trying to portray. Personal style can be subjective, and sometimes a performer will not realize when their choices are not having the intended effect. Likewise, when a wrestler refuses to update their gear after everyone has seen it a hundred times, the audience may begin to take the performer for granted, like an old set of curtains, or the wallpaper in your granddad's den.

These men and women fall into the second category...

10. The Undertaker

The Undertaker
WWE

Yes, really.

The Undertaker has had final matches, retrospective documentaries, left his hat and gloves in the ring, had final farewells, and just about anything else you can think of that means "okay, this really is it for this character."

For now, at least.

Maybe.

However, with WWE's love of nostalgia and its frequent desperation to pop a rating, there's no doubt Mark Calaway will show up again soon. But if The Undertaker really is retired, maybe Mark should show up in the future without this particular gimmick.

From his first appearance in 1990 to his most recent farewell appearance 30 years later, Mark has remained loyal to the basic bones of his look, with the hat, coat, and different iterations of facial scruff. There have been deviations as well, including the more demonic Ministry of Darkness cloaks, and the American Badass biker gimmick, but the basic hat and coat have always returned. That's fine-- people love it. But if you're going to tell us a hundred times that it's gone for good, eventually Mark is going to have to decide that the next time he arrives, he's not going to be dressed like it's the 1800s.


9. The Miz

John Morrison The Miz
WWE.com

At best, The Miz is a solid performer in the ring and on the mic, but he has elevated himself beyond his midcard skillset by presenting himself as a big star with an almost satirical level of conviction.

Miz tells us he's awesome, that he's a huge star, and that his appearances are "must-see." His whole schtick is not that he's a star, but an annoying prat who thinks he's a huge celebrity. His gear follows this theme, and while his slick suits work with his "real big star" gimmick, his goofy entrance garb of oversized headbands and a wardrobe full of long robe-coats don't work anymore, especially when combined with his trademark twirl-and-point pose.

The problem is not with the ostentatiousness of his entrance gear, but the fact that he keeps wearing the same weird robe-coats and headbands, even though neither are remotely fashionable. It defies belief that anyone trying to present themselves as a celebrity would use these corny get-ups and poses. A key element of celebrity is keeping with current trends, and the longer The Miz keeps trotting out this same look, the more he approaches every celebrity's worst nightmare: nostalgia for past glory, and eventual irrelevance.


8. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Apollo Crews is an incredible athlete, and his physique is astonishing, so it's no surprise that he would want to show off his body by wearing minimal gear. And while he's playing to his strengths, pardon the pun, by wearing trunks that expose his muscular frame, the sameness of his approach is an apt metaphor for what has plagued his main roster run: that he too often appears as a one-note player.

When you're always presented the same, and you're always being booked the same way, it's hard for WWE's creative department to think of something bigger and better for you. Tweaking his look might be one way for Crews to change some opinions about how high he can go on the roster.

If Crews wants to break out of his current role, he could look no further than the Hurt Business. The Hurt Business has been a success thus far, and a big part of their rise is due to how cool they look, whether it's in their matching black and gold t-shirts or in their snappy business suits. They look fresh. And although one of Crews' biggest assets is his physique, he could look at the value Bobby Lashley has found in covering his muscles up in a suit: you just look so damn cool when you take the suit off.


7. Akira Tozawa

Akira Tozawa 24/7 Title
WWE

In the 1980s and 90s, there were two tropes the then-WWF loved: wrestlers having second careers, and tacky racial stereotypes. Vince McMahon packed his match cards with garbage men, accountants, and cowboys. And if you were a member of a visible minority, that meant your other job was based on a racial stereotype.

Akira Tozawa seems to have fallen into a WWE time machine set for 1988. In his current gimmick he is a ninja, and it looks as though his attempts to capture 24/7 Championship gold are wedged into his schedule between battling mutant turtles and infiltrating G.I Joe headquarters. Not only is the gimmick kinda racist, it's also tremendously dated, offering evidence that the creative team at Titan Towers stopped consuming non-wrestling media literally decades ago.

Tozawa has been assigned to the gimmick-heavy comedy end of the wrestling spectrum, and while he might be happy just getting on TV, it's not doing much good for his future. Once the joke has run its course, he'll have to be seriously rebuilt, or maybe leave WWE altogether to try and regain his credibility as a serious performer. The sooner he can get out of the ninja costume, the better.


6. Asuka

Asuka WWE
WWE

For the most part, Asuka has maintained a consistent look through her WWE run, with bright and motley ring gear that matches her bombastic personality.

It has been a perfect blend of style and substance. The most significant change to her aesthetic has been related to face-paint. When she Kairi Sane turned heel in the fall of 2019, Asuka switched from her familiar horizontal stripe to a more diabolical look, with green paint trickling from her eyes and mouth. This paint was paired with a new weapon as well, as Asuka began spraying "green mist" from her mouth into the faces of her opponents. Definitely evil stuff.

The problem is that after Asuka regained the Raw Women's Championship, she shifted away from heel tactics, and is now a solid babyface again. The green mist hasn't been seen in a long time, but the evil green face-paint has remained, and it seems out of place. It's understandable if she doesn't wanted to switch back to the tried-and-true horizontal stripe that she wore for so long, because that might appear regressive. But the slime-tears don't really fit with her current character, and the time has come for her to experiment with something new.


5. Tucker Knight

Tucker Ricochet
WWE.com

When WWE creative split up Heavy Machinery, Tucker had to know things weren't going to be great for him.

After all, there were no plans for what to do with the performers beyond the split, and Tucker had already been relegated to a supporting role behind Otis. Those two have continued on their diverging trajectories, with Otis taking part in significant storylines, while Tucker has fallen into the dreaded 24/7 Championship circle of hell.

A major obstacle that Tucker will have to overcome if he's going to climb back up the card is the fact that prior to breaking with Otis, the audience and the RAW creative team had only known him as part of Heavy Machinery. Now that he's dropped that gimmick, he needs to establish himself as an individual.

In order to stand out, he'll need to develop a look that is both striking and memorable. Tucker's first post-Machinery match on Raw, in which he was quickly squashed by Ricochet, saw him wearing black track pants as ring attire. Aesthetically speaking, it was local talent level stuff. He'll need to be a lot more creative if he wants to avoid drifting right off the bottom of the roster.


4. RETRIBUTION

Mustafa Ali RETRIBUTION
WWE

RETRIBUTION has a lot to overcome. They've been saddled with horrible ring names, stupid-looking masks, and have been made to lose nearly every time they step foot in the ring. They arrived on WWE TV claiming they were there to destroy the company, but there's a significant chance the only things that will be destroyed are the careers of these poor performers.

Even so, Mustafa Ali is a tremendous talent, and WWE keeps giving them TV time. But if the group is to dig themselves out of the hole WWE made for them, changes must be made. The first thing that will have to go are those idiotic masks. After all, getting over as a professional wrestler isn't easy at the best of times. Getting over when you're named Slapjack and you're wearing a hockey mask from the 1970s is impossible.

One mask is gone already, as Mia Yim, or "Reckoning," as she is called in Retribution, had her incredibly impractical mask knocked off during a loss to Dana Brooke. If she could keep the mask off in future appearances, it wouldn't be a surprise to see Slapjack, T-Bar, and Mace try to "accidentally" lose their masks as well.


3. Rhea Ripley

Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

Rhea Ripley is awesome. She rose to prominence in NXT playing a fearless, nasty badass, and her leather-and-spikes style worked perfectly for her. Rhea's aesthetic and demeanour combined to project an aura of being tough and mean, even as she shifted to a babyface role to take on NXT Women's Champion Shayna Baszler.

The problem came when she faced Charlotte Flair at WrestleMania 36. While the match was intended to elevate her, the promo work leading up to the event portrayed her as a wide-eyed youth, living her dream. That broke with Ripley's style of being hard and mean and fearless, and dropping her title to Flair didn't help much either.

Ripley took a brief hiatus after 'Mania, and upon returning she hasn't been able to recapture her momentum. She's bumped around the card, failed to recapture gold, and seems to be in a holding pattern, with a much less defined character than she had previous to her feud with Flair. She's still wearing the same gear that she wore as a fearless badass, but the aura is gone. A repackaging, with a new look and some clearer motivations, might her set her back on the right track.


2. Natalya

Natalya WWE
WWE

Natalya is a valuable member of the WWE roster, but let's be honest: while shiny black tights always look cool, her style could use an update.

The trouble with Natalya's current presentation is that it is so firmly rooted in the Hart family past. She has now spent a dozen years on WWE's main roster, which is plenty of time to establish her own legacy, and yet so many aspects of her aesthetic are references to The Hart Foundation of the 80s and 90s.

Her entrance music borrows directly from her uncle Bret "The Hitman" Hart's music, and her ring gear is nearly always black and pink, in tribute to The Hart Foundation of Uncle Bret and her late father Jim "The Anvil" Neidhart. She uses The Sharpshooter, Bret's signature move, as her finisher. Even little details like always wearing cat ears to the ring and giving them to a member of the audience seem like a direct callback to Bret always giving his mirrored shades to a kid in the front row.

It would be great to see her do something distinctively her own, even if it was something as simple as adopting a different color scheme.


1. Sheamus

Sheamus snatch
WWE

Sheamus appeared on Miz TV during a recent episode of RAW to explain that yes, he and WWE Champion Drew McIntyre really are actual, real-life, good friends.

Sorry dude, but if Drew really was your friend, he would never have let you go on television in front of a million-plus people wearing that hat.

Sheamus has had some iconic looks over the years, with some working better than others. The mohawk and mirrored shades he sported as a member of The Bar were definitely cooler than the phase when he had all that dangly crap hanging from his beard, but it's hard to tell exactly what he's going for during his current run. He's in amazing shape, but it's hard to aesthetically capitalize on your tremendous physique when you're dressed like an old-timey dock worker.

With some adjustments, it could work. The sleeveless undershirt, suspenders, and taped-up fists that he sported during his bar fight with Jeff Hardy made him look like a nails-tough brawler from the turn of the last century, but the effect is ruined when he walks out on RAW wearing a coat and hat that would be rejected by a charity shop donation bin. Maybe something similarly old-fashioned but a little more dapper would be effective, and make him look less like a bum. The important thing is to keep trying. Don't give up, Sheamus. We believe in you.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Sheamus
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Nolan Whyte hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.