10 WWE Superstars Who Could Call Themselves "Mr Summerslam"

If Shawn Michaels is "Mr WrestleMania", who then is "Mr SummerSlam"?

WWE.comWWE.comIt€™s officially summertime! We are just short of one week into the summer of 2014, and things are definitely heating up. Kids are out of school, The World Cup continues, the weather is getting better and better, summer blockbusters are starting to roll into theatres, and of course the start of summer also signifies the beginning of the Road to Summerslam. You know, the road that the WWE doesn€™t pay quite as much attention to (they always seem to be making plans for that other road around February and March). Summerslam, while not Wrestlemania, is one of the WWE€™s premier annual special events. Summerslam takes place live from sunny California each year, it always comes right around the last couple weeks of the summer season, and it usually features the culmination of the WWE€™s hottest summer programs. It€™s a great way to celebrate summer coming to a close, and more often than not it delivers a quality show, with it€™s share of big moments. It€™s funny that an event with such a storied history doesn€™t have many superstars clamoring to make it their show. Obviously everybody wants to steal the show at Wrestlemania and become Mr. Wrestlemania, but owning Summerslam would be quite an accomplishment in its own right. This week, let€™s look at 10 Superstars who could claim the title of Mr. Summerslam. Like the Iron Throne of Westeros, many can stake a claim, but in the end there can only be one true Mr. Summerslam. As always your comments are welcome and greatly appreciated. Let us know who you think deserves the Mr. Summerslam moniker. Now let€™s Rock and Roll!

10. Bret €œThe Hitman€ Hart

WWE.comWWE.comAny list of the superstars who could conceivably call themselves Mr. Summerslam that didn€™t feature Bret €œThe Hitman€ Hart would simply be incomplete. The WWE Hall Of Famer has a stellar resume at the annual summer event including a great win loss record of 7-3. His claim to the name goes beyond his fantastic record. Bret competed at the first Summerslam in 1988, alongside his Hart Foundation tag team partner Jim €œThe Anvil€ Neidhart. The duo lost their tag team match to another iconic WWE tag team, Demolition. Those are two of the WWE€™s greatest tag teams of all time going toe to toe in what has become one of the WWE€™s biggest events, and while Bret and his partner didn€™t pick up the victory in 1988, in 1990 The Hart Foundation would defeat Demolition at Summerslam to capture the WWF Tag Team Titles. In the subsequent Summerslams, Bret would go on to capture the Intercontinental title by defeating Mr. Perfect in 1991, main event the summer extravaganza in 1992 defending the Intercontinental Title in a losing effort against the British Bulldog live from Wembley Stadium in London, defeating his brother Owen in a 32 minute cage match to retain the WWF Title in 1994, and defeating The Undertaker to capture the WWF Title in 1997. If that wasn€™t enough, he€™d make his Summerslam return thirteen years later in 2010 and help team WWE defeat The Nexus. Bret Hart has put on many a show at Summerslam and certainly belongs in the discussion for the moniker Mr. Summerslam.

9. Montel Vontavious Porter

WWE.comWWE.comThe only man on this list that can say that he is undefeated at Summerslam is MVP himself, Montel Vontavious Porter. Granted he€™s only had two matches at the event, but they were both against future World Champions. In 2008 MVP scored a pinfall victory over Jeff Hardy. This may not seem like a big deal, but the fact is that Jeff Hardy is a very accomplished WWE Superstar. Jeff has been World and WWE Champion, Intercontinental Champion, a multiple time Tag Team Champion, and I haven€™t even gotten into his reigns as Light Heavyweight and Hardcore Champion. Jeff Hardy has done just about everything there is to do in a WWE ring, and MVP beat him at one of the WWE€™s premier events. The very next year, MVP would defeat Jack Swagger, a future Mr. Money in the Bank and World Heavyweight Champion, in less than seven minutes. It was a dominating performance against a guy who would go on to be one of the top guys in the WWE (before falling back down the card upon losing the World Title). As it stands, MVP is undefeated at Summerslam and defeated World Champions in his two Summerslam bouts. While not the strongest case, he is without question in the conversation for Mr. Summerslam on record alone.

8. The Undertaker

WWE.comWWE.comWhile known most for his exemplary Wrestlemania Record of 21-1 (a record that was unblemished until this year€™s Showcase of the Immortals), The Undertaker has a pretty solid record at Summerslam as well. He has competed in 15 matches at the summer event, and has a record of 9-5-1. He made his Summerslam debut in 1992, and definitely made a name for himself in those early years. He won his first four Summerslam contests, defeating monsters like Kamala, Giant Gonzalez (in a Rest in Peace Match), The Undertaker (yes he took on himself, or at least a version of himself), and Kama (in a Casket Match). His first Summerslam loss came at the hands of Mankind in a Boiler Room Brawl. The Undertaker would follow up his first Summerslam loss with another one, this time losing the WWF Title to fellow Mr. Summerslam contender Bret Hart, and the following year he would lose yet again to Stone Cold Steve Austin. In 1999, he would get back on the winning track, teaming with Big Show to win the WWF Tag Team Titles from X-Pac and Kane. He would go in to win or draw in his next four Summerslam appearances. The Undertaker would fail to capture the WWE Title from JBL in 2004, losing to the €œWrestling God€, and 2005 The Undertaker was defeated by heated rival Randy Orton. After missing both the 2006 and 2007 Summerslams, The Undertaker would return to the event for a final time, defeating Edge inside of Hell In A Cell. Not only did he defeat Edge, he for all intents and purposes massacred him, putting him through two tables, sending him through one of the Cell€™s panels, hitting Edge with a con-chair-to, and Chokeslamming The Rated R Superstar off a ladder through the ring for good measure. Oh and then The Undertaker engulfed the hole in the canvas in flame. That€™s one way to commemorate your last Summerslam and stake your claim for the title of Mr. Summerslam.

7. Daniel Bryan

WWE.comWWE.comDaniel Bryan has only competed at four Summerslams, but some of the highest points in his career to date have come at the event. Daniel Bryan made his return to the WWE after his unceremonious firing for choking Justin Roberts with his tie during the Nexus Invasion angle, and was revealed as Team WWE€™s seventh member in their match against The Nexus. He was cheered loudly upon his return and his team was victorious. To that point, it was his greatest night in the WWE and was the start of something special that would manifest itself years down the line. His next two Summerslams would pale in comparison to his first. He would split the bouts (a loss to Wade Barrett in 2011 and a win over Kane in 2012), and move on to what would become a key moment in the Yes Movement in 2013. At Summerslam 2013 he would defeat John Cena clean to capture his first WWE Championship. Moments later he would be screwed out of the title by Triple H, losing it to Randy Orton who cashed in his Money In The Bank briefcase, but despite the negative outcome, that night launched Daniel Bryan into stardom. It was that night where he beat the Golden Boy clean in the middle of the ring. It was that night where he began feuding with The Authority, building to his eventual Wrestlemania triumph. Two of the greatest moments of his career happened at Summerslam, and the single greatest moment of his career happened as a result of the events that took place at Summerslam 2013. His record may be an unimpressive 3-2 on paper, but Summerslam has been very good to Daniel Bryan, and he for it. He€™s torn the roof off of Staples Center, and left everything in the ring as summer came to a close. He€™s certainly a contender for Mr. Summerslam.

6. Triple H

WWE.comWWE.comSince 1995, Triple H has only missed four Summerslam (1996, 2001, 2005, 2010). He has competed 13 times at the event posting a record of 8-5, at the summer extravaganza. Triple H is all but a staple at the WWE€™s annual summer show. Triple H made his Summerslam debut in 1995. He split his first two Summerslam bouts, winning in €™95 against Bob Holly and losing to Mankind in a cage in €™97. In 1998, he would defeat The Rock in a great Ladder Match for the Intercontinental Championship. That would be the last time Triple H would walk out of Summerslam victorious until 2003. He would go on a three match losing streak, failing to capture the WWF title in 1999 and 2000 (Mankind and The Rock would walk away with the belt those years at Summerslam), and in 2002 he would lose an Unsanctioned Street Fight with his former best friend Shawn Michaels, who came out of retirement just to face the Cerebral Assassin. 2003 would be the beginning of a winning trend for Triple H. He would go on a six match Summerslam winning streak starting with his victory in the Elimination Chamber at Summerslam €™03 (he defeated Goldberg, Chris Jericho, Randy Orton, Shawn Michaels and Kevin Nash in a pretty star-studded Chamber match). He would go on to beat Eugene, The McMahons (Vince and Shane) alongside his DX running mate Shawn Michaels, King Booker, The Great Khali (to retain the WWE Title), and Legacy (again as part of DX), in that order. In 2011 Triple H was the Special Guest Referee for the WWE Championship Unification Match between John Cena and CM Punk that CM Punk would go on to win, and in 2013 he was the Special Guest Referee for the WWE Championship Match that saw Daniel Bryan defeat John Cena to win his first WWE Title. Both times he refereed at Summerslam, John Cena lost and the Money In The Bank briefcase was cashed in on the guy that beat Cena, which is an interesting piece of trivia. In between dabbling in officiating matches, Triple H wrestled his last Summerslam match to date in 2012, losing to Brock Lesnar. Triple H has quite a lengthy and successful history at Summerslam, and certainly has some claim to the Mr. Summerslam designation.

5. Edge

WWE.comWWE.comIf you were to say that you thought Edge had the strongest claim to the nickname Mr. Summerslam, it would be very hard to refute. Not only has he competed in ten Summerslam bouts, he is 8-2 at the event, which is truly a spectacular record. It€™s made even more incredible when you consider the fact that he€™s only lost once in singles competition at Summerslam. He won his first Summerslam match teaming with Sable to defeat Marc Mero and Jacqueline. From there he would go on to win and retain the Tage Team, Intercontinental and WWE Championship in four out of his eight Summerslam wins. He€™s beaten names like Eddie Guerrero, Chris Jericho, Batista, Matt Hardy and John Cena at the WWE€™s summer celebration. One of his biggest victories at Summerslam was as a member of the tag team Edge and Christian. They went into the first ever Tables, Ladders & Chairs Match as champions facing off against two of the best tag teams of all time, The Hardy Boyz and The Dudley Boyz. Not only did they put TLC on the map, but they walked out with the titles. Edge is a big part of why the TLC Match has a whole PPV named after it. His biggest victory at Summerslam was probably when he beat John Cena in 2006 to retain the WWE Championship. That victory came two years before what would be his final singles match at Summerslam, losing to Undertaker in epic fashion. It€™s sad that he was forced into early retirement, but he definitely had one hell of a career, and his Summerslam record is emblematic of his career. He was a star, he improved every year of his career, and he definitely deserves to be considered as Mr. Summerslam.

4. The Rock

WWE.comWWE.comSummerslam is the celebration of the summer season. The summer season also happens to be when Hollywood likes to release their biggest blockbuster. So if you€™re talking about Mr. Summerslam, a box office draw like The Rock has to be in the running. Not only is the guy the single greatest wrestler turned actor of all time, but he is also the most electrifying man in sports and entertainment. Whether it€™s at the cinema, or in an arena on PPV, The Rock is a blockbuster performer, and virtually a license to print cash. The People€™s Champ has a very limited Summerslam history, but the fact is it€™s a very strong history. He€™s wrestled at five Summerslams, with a record of 3-2. He has competed with a championship on the line at 80% of his Summerslam matches, including a terrific Ladder Match for the Intercontinental Title with Triple H in 1998, a great Triple Threat WWF Title Match with Triple H and Kurt Angle in 2000, capturing the WCW Title from future WWE Hall Of Famer Booker T in 2001, and a torch passing effort against Brock Lesnar for the Undisputed Title in 2002. His only lackluster effort was against Billy Gunn in a Kiss My Ass Match in 1999, and that match was still second from the top of the card. The fact is that The Rock was nothing less than a primetime performer in every appearance he€™s made at Summerslam, he is one of the most bankable names in Hollywood and without question the most bankable name for the WWE right now. Everything about The Great One screams Blockbuster, and isn€™t that what summer and conversely Mr. Summerslam is all about?

3. CM Punk

WWE.comWWE.comCM Punk like The Rock, is a primetime Summerslam performer. He may not be a movie star like The Rock, but the guy has blockbuster talent. Also like The Rock, he shares an affinity for the summer season, lest we forget either of the Summer Of Punks. Whether it was in ROH or the WWE, CM Punk has had a tendency to own summers, and his Summerslam history is evidence of that. CM Punk has competed in every Summerslam since 2007 (with the exception of this year as things stand), has a record of 4-4, and in all but two of those bouts he was competing with a World Title on the line. In 2007 he lost to John Morrison with the ECW Title up for grabs, in 2008 he defeated JBL to retain his World Heavyweight Championship, he won a TLC match against Jeff Hardy to win the World Title in 2009, in 2011 he beat John Cena to become the Undisputed WWE Champion during the Summer of Punk (and subsequently lost the belt to Alberto Del Rio), and in 2012 he defeated Big Show and John Cena to retain the WWE Title en route to the longest WWE Title reign in the modern era. So what were those two matches he was in that didn€™t have titles on the line? Well in 2010 he and the Straight Edge Society lost to Big Show, which is as underwhelming as it seems, but in 2013 he only had what I consider one of the best matches of the year in a losing effort taking on Brock Lesnar. This guy shows out in the summertime and his Summerslam history only verifies that he might just be what he claims to be, and that is The Best In The World! The best might just have the greatest claim to the title of Mr. Summerslam.

2. Brock Lesnar

WWE.comWWE.comThe Beast Incarnate, the man who ended The Undertaker€™s undefeated streak at Wrestlemania, Brock Lesnar, not only is 3-1 at Summerslam, but he has never had anything less than a stellar match at the WWE€™s biggest party of the summer. He made his Summerslam debut in 2002 by defeating The Rock to capture and become for a time the youngest Undisputed WWE Champion of all time. Hell of a debut right? His next Summerslam match was a 2003 WWE title match against Kurt Angle, a spectacular match and his only Summerslam loss. He didn€™t compete again at Summerslam until 2012, but he returned and defeated Triple H and CM Punk in consecutive years in two very entertaining matches. What else is there to say about the guy? He€™s not flashy, he doesn€™t say much but his record speaks for itself. It€™s a small sample size, but the man has only competed against A+ competitors at Summerslam and he€™s only been defeated once at the event. He is a monster, he is a crusher of dreams who kicks all kinds of ass and takes whatever the hell he wants. Maybe he wants the title of Mr. Summerslam. If so, who€™s going to tell that guy no?

1. Randy Orton

WWE.comWWE.comNothing but respect to all the guys on the list, but if there is only one Mr. Summerslam, It€™s Randal Keith Orton. A lot of people think the guy is boring and that he has no sizzle, but the fact remains that he is one of the WWE€™s most talented superstars and has been performing at a very high level for them from a very young age. He went from the youngest member of Evolution in need of tutelage to one of the WWE€™s most reliable veterans inside the squared circle, and his history at Summerslam reflects that journey. His first ever Summerslam match was in 2003 (he€™s only missed the 2008 and 2012 Summerslams since) where he competed in the Elimination Chamber for the World Title, but ultimately lost, though his Evolution running mate Triple H was victorious. The next year he became the youngest World Heavyweight Champion of all time by defeating Chris Benoit at Summerlam. From there he went on to face The Undertaker, Hulk Hogan, John Cena twice, Sheamus, Christian and most recently Daniel Bryan. All but two of those matches were for the WWE or World Championship, and only two of those performers have beaten him on the Summerslam stage (Hogan and Cena). His record at Summerslam is 6-3, his quality of opponents has been very high (three absolute legends in the business in Hogan, Undertaker and Cena, 2/3 of which he beat), and he set a record that still stands to this day back in 2004. He€™s won 3 WWE/World Championships at Summerslam, he€™s never walked in as Champion and lost the title at the event and each passing year he just builds on his Summerslam legacy. The greatest moments and victories of Randy Orton€™s career arguably all came at Summerslam, and nobody else in the running for Mr. Summerslam can say that. Go back and watch the matches and you will see how he grew into the reliable professional that he is today, each passing year gaining more confidence and experience. Congratulations to the Mr. Summerslam, Randy Orton! The moniker is yours until someone else takes it.

Contributor
Contributor

Matthew J. Douglas is an emerging screenwriter born in Toronto. A lifelong fascination with what makes a compelling story and the Toni Morrison quote "If there's a book that you want to read, but it hasn't been written yet, then you must write it." led the often opinionated Matthew to the life of writer. Matthew is also a lifelong WWE fan, and a self diagnosed Reality TV Junkie.