10 WWE Superstars Who Had Shockingly Long Tenures
Who knew mediocrity could lead to such a lengthy career?
The WWE is a tough place to make a living in today's era. Wrestlers usually do not get multiple kicks at the can to make a name for themselves on the biggest stage. Every year the WWE cleans house and rids themselves of talent they no longer see a future for. Talented performers like Drew Galloway, Damien Sandow, and Kharma were all let go from the WWE despite still having significant upside in this business.
This kind of cut throat, one and done attitude was not always present, as in days past WWE's rosters of 'sports entertainers' were given much more leeway.
These are the WWE superstars who had lengthy, yet unspectacular careers. The names on this list are all remembered and at times even celebrated for quantity over quality. In many cases, these folks enjoyed long careers that rarely included main events, significant storylines, championship titles, or memorable moments.
Perhaps less really is more.
10. Crush
Brian Adams, better known as Crush, had several stints of varying success in the WWE (and WCW). Wrestling in the two federations from 1990-2001 inclusive, Crush spent 11 years in the upper mid card of the big two despite not being regarded as a great worker. While a large part of that was due to his size, another reason was his versatility, being able to take whatever someone from creative would give him, for better or worse... mostly worse.
The main highlights of Crush's career included tag team title reigns in WWE (as part of Demolition) and WCW (as part of Kronik), the only two major titles he won over the course of his career. In the mid '90s he had a relatively successful run as a mid-card babyface calling himself 'Kona Crush'. He followed that with a run as Japanese sympathiser Crush alongside Yokozuna. This gimmick would produce his best match, at Wrestlemania X against Randy Savage.
The lowlights of his career include going to jail for steroids and coming back with a jailbird gimmick where he led a wildly unsuccessful stable called the Disciples of Apocalypse. Crush would continue to rack up bad gimmicks later in life as a member of the nWo B squad, a brief stint as the KISS demon, and winning The Wrestling Oberver's worst worked match of the year with Kronik against the Brothers of Destruction in 2001.
In all likelihood Crush would have had another run in the WWE if not for his death, aged just 43 in 2007. He will be best remembered (at least by me) for his feud with Doink culminating in double Doinks at WrestleMania IX, and for dragging The Undertaker to a worst match of the year contender.
9. Big Daddy V
Many things come to mind when thinking of Big Daddy V, such as the sight of an enormous, ridiculously attired 500lb man coming down the aisle with fake contacts. What does not come to mind is a long and storied career in the WWE. However, the big man actually wrestled over eight years for the company.
Viscera's first run in the WWE was as Mabel, in a tag team with his friend Mo, called Men on a Mission. At this point, Mabel was less than one year into his career and not ready for prime time. Due to his size, Vince McMahon immediately thrust him into the spotlight. Mabel would go on to win the King of the Ring and then famously, or infamously, wrestle Diesel and The Undertaker in main event feuds. He proceeded to injure both of them.
A few years later Mabel returned, repackaged as Viscera. This mostly uneventful run included the big man winning the hardcore championship for about 15 seconds at WrestleMania 2000. This was Viscera's only WWE singles title. After this Viscera disappeared for four years, only returning to form a short lived, aptly named tag team with Val Venis called V Squared. Viscera was then repackaged again as Big Daddy V and sent to the ECW brand in 2007, where he competed in the epic 'Monster Mash Battle Royale'.
Eight years, three proper gimmicks, additional variants of those gimmicks and a lot of lower card matches sums up Big Daddy V's career in the WWE. Tragically, Big Daddy V would pass at the young age of 43 after a long and at times uneventful, at other times fun, but at all times ridiculous pro wrestling career.
8. Paul Roma
Paul Roma wrestled professionally for 11 years. Almost all of that time was spent in the WWE and WCW. While in WCW Roma would go on to have some success, his seven year WWE career was almost a complete throwaway.
Debuting in 1984 Paul Roma was used as enhancement talent for the first three years of his career. In 1987 Roma formed a team with Jim Powers as 'The Young Stallions'. They peaked winning the initial star studded Survivor Series tag team match in 1987 and wrestling The Islanders in the main event (seriously, the main event) of the Royal Rumble 1988. Sadly, after splitting the team in 1989 Roma was back to being singles enhancement talent. The WWE would give Roma one last crack at making it by putting him in a tag team with more established star Hercules, as the glory in 'Power and Glory'. They started off hot defeating the Rockers at SummerSlam 1990 but by the time WrestleMania VII came around they were getting destroyed by the Legion of Doom in a matter of minutes. Shortly thereafter Roma ended his run in the WWE, jumping ship to WCW in 1991.
Roma went on to have some success in WCW as everyone's favourite member of the Four Horseman and part of tag team "Pretty Wonderful" before flaming out in 1995 after refusing to make Alex Wright look good during a match at SuperBrawl V. For someone who wrestled in the WWE for seven years, Roma participated in just a handful of pay-per-views and won exactly zero titles. The fact he managed to last seven years in the WWE is a bit of a miracle as in less forgiving times, like today's PG era, Roma would likely have had a much shorter run.
7. Tito Santana
Arriba! Tito Santana had a hall of fame career in the WWE. For those of you confused by how this happened, this is a prime example of the WWE taking quantity over quality. Tito spent his WWE career jobbing to bigger stars on pay-per-view events.
Let's start with the quality portion of his career. Tito was a key player in the Intercontinental title scene early in his career defeating Don Muraco for the strap in 1984 and trading wins with Greg Valentine for the belt in 1985. Tito also won the tag team titles with Rick Martel (as Strike Force) from the Hart Foundation before dropping them to Demolition at WrestleMania IV. Afterwards, Tito feuded with Martel (a feud ending with no proper blow off...) and in one of his rare pay-per-view wins would be a sole survivor in a jobber Survivor Series 1990 match. After winning this match he would team with Hulk Hogan and the Ultimate Warrior in a kayfabe shattering faces vs heels Survivor Series survivors match. This would be his only pay-per-view main event. In that match he was pinned by Ted Dibiase in under two minutes.
Tito spent over 13 years in the WWE. His 11 consecutive year run was spent primarily as a mid-carder as he wrestled on almost every major pay-per-view from the first WrestleMania to WrestleMania IX. He would accumulate a 2-7 record on the grandest stage of them all winning his first match against the Executioner and his last, a dark match against Papa Shango. Other than jobbing on the big stage Tito will be forever remembered, at least by this writer, for his 'El Matador' persona, a bullfighter gimmick where he would dress in brightly coloured green spandex.
6. Billy Gunn
'Bad Ass' Billy Gunn is best known as part of a successful tag team with the Road Dogg Jesse James, known as the 'New Age Outlaws'. However, that peak period really only accounts for three of the 11 years from Billy Gunn's initial WWE run.
Billy Gunn debuted in the WWE in 1993 with his kayfabe brother Bart as part of the Smoking Gunns. They took the struggling tag division by storm, winning the titles three times, but then faded quickly and they were languishing at the bottom of the card in 1996 when Billy and Bart decided to go their separate ways. Billy's next gimmick would die a brief but painful death, as Honky Tonk Man's protégé 'Rockabilly'. For the next few years he would tag with the Road Dogg on and off winning the tag titles five times and then transitioning to failed singles star after winning King of the Ring 1999.
Billy spent his remaining four years in the WWE, with varying degrees of success as 'The One' Billy Gunn, Mr. Ass, and Billy of the team 'Billy and Chuck', a tag team that was heel because of their homosexual tension (this was somehow not a Russo idea). Though this did result in two more tag title reigns his final years were not nearly as memorable as his peak run during the WWE's hottest period, the Attitude Era.
Billy stood the test of time in the WWE. At the time of his departure in 2004 he had the 3rd longest tenure of anyone in the WWE behind only The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels. With 11 uninterrupted years in the WWE to go with his 11 tag team championships, Billy Gunn represented both quantity and occasionally quality in the WWE.
5. Mark Henry
Mark Henry has been wrestling in the WWE (and its developmental system) since 1996. For those scoring at home that is 20 years. The former powerlifting champion and Olympian has been a staple on WWE television with a career that has seen its ups and downs.
Henry started his career debuting against Lawler on pay per view at In Your House 2. Following this basic, pretty terrible match, Henry was taken off TV and given time to train. He returned with the entertaining Sexual Chocolate gimmick, where he hit on ladies on the roster like Chyna and Mae Young, resulting in the latter giving birth to a hand. As entertaining as all that was, Henry's in ring work was still sub par so he was sent back to developmental in 2000. It took him a few years but by the time 2005 rolled around Henry was ready to begin his ascent to the main event. Feuding with the likes of The Undertaker he would go on to win the ECW Heavyweight Championship and finally, the World Heavyweight Championship from Randy Orton during his fantastic Hall of Pain run.
Unlike a lot of modern stars Mark Henry was given the opportunity to fail in the WWE a few times before he succeeded. This has afforded him a 20 year career in the WWE including a lot of memorable moments, for better or worse. This also distinguishes him from the rest of this list as he was the only person on it who rose to main event status while maintaining his utility player status with the WWE. He's still kicking around today, providing us with another amazing moment recently by faking his retirement in order to turn on John Cena.
4. Koko B. Ware
Koko B. Ware was a fan favourite 'jobber to the stars' who had a lengthy WWE career resulting in a Hall of Fame induction in 2009. While never picking up any WWE titles or main event storylines, Koko was a staple of the WWE from his debut in 1986 to his departure in 1994 as a high energy (pun intended) worker.
He made his debut tagging with previous list member Paul Roma against the Hart Foundation in 1986 and spent the majority of his first few years feuding with Jimmy Hart's stable. Over the next eight years Koko appeared on most WWE pay-per-views in losing efforts to more established stars like the Big Bossman, The Mountie, Butch Reed, and Mr. Perfect. He capped off his initial run by teaming with 'The Rocket' Owen Hart as part of High Energy, a mid card baby face tag team before returning to singles competition and continuing to job to heels Jeff Jarrett and IRS.
Interestingly enough, for all his on screen losses Koko B. Ware had a lot of memorable moments in the WWE. He sang the 1987 hit 'Piledriver' on the album of the same name for the WWE, he was the first WWE wrestler to take the Undertaker's 'Tombstone Piledriver', and of course he played Owen Hart's body double as 'The Blue Blazer' in a hilarious angle in 1999.
Koko B. Ware, through his eight year career and Hall of Fame induction is proof that longevity is something the WWE takes seriously. Koko never held any titles or even rose to the mid card but managed to carve out a long WWE career through his interactions with the fans and ability to make others look good.
3. Hercules
Hercules, much like his aforementioned tag team partner Paul Roma, lasted seven straight years in the WWE. Unlike his tag team partner, Hercules found his way on to 20 straight pay-per-views from WrestleMania II to Royal Rumble 1992 inclusive. This is an impressive feat for someone, who much like a number of other folks on this list won and challenged for exactly zero WWE championships.
Hercules had a promising start to his WWE career competing in a losing effort against Ricky Steamboat at WrestleMania II, and competing in a winning effort against Billy Jack Haynes at WrestleMania III. He also holds the distinction of being the first wrestler to lose to the Ultimate Warrior on pay-per-view, in an awful match at WrestleMania IV. Hercules then put his career in neutral for a few years (despite appearing on all big shows) until teaming with Power and Glory where they would receive an initial push before being relegated to jobber status.
Hercules ended his WWE career unceremoniously by lasting less than a minute in the Royal Rumble 1992 and losing a match to Sid Justice at MSG which is famous for Hercules no selling all of Justice's offence including his signature powerbomb.
Post WWE Hercules appeared briefly in New Japan working in an awesomely named tag team with Scott Norton known as the 'Jurassic Powers', winning the IWGP tag team titles once. While he may not have been a household name, he lasted seven straight years in the WWE, managing to find his way on all of the pay-per-views in that time period. From that perspective Hercules career can be seen as a success. Tragically, Hercules would die in his sleep at the age of 47 in 2004.
2. Greg 'The Hammer' Valentine
Greg 'The Hammer' Valentine is a second generation wrestler who spent more than a decade wrestling in the WWE. He was rarely involved in any major story lines, producing just a handful of memorable moments in his WWE career.
Valentine came into the WWE in 1984 red hot following his feud with Roddy Piper in the NWA and their classic dog-collar match at Starrcade 1983. He began his career by defeating Tito Santana for the Intercontinental title, holding it for nearly a year. After this Valentine would form a championship winning tag team with Brutus Beefcake known as The Dream Team. Upset about having a role in 'The New Dream Team' with Dino Bravo, Valentine briefly resigned. When he returned months later he would fall down the card forming an entertaining comedy tag team called 'Rhythm N Blues' with the Honky Tonk Man. After years of playing a heel the WWE switched the Hammer face, and he was used as a jobber to Earthquake and IRS at WrestleMania VII and SummerSlam '91 respectively. He would fade into obscurity and eventually end his WWE run in 1994.
While Valentine had a long, Hall of Fame career, which includes many accolades and countless titles from his time in the territories from 1976 - 1984, his WWE run had a lot less fan fare. Gone were the days of him being the most hated man in wrestling (PWI voted him this in 1975, 1979 and 1983). His new role would include jobbing to mid carders, getting poked fun of by Jesse Ventura on commentary, and appearing under a hood as one of Shawn Michaels' knights at Survivor Series 1993. Today, he can be found making disparaging remarks about female athletes on podcasts.
1. Bob Holly
Bob Holly spent an unbelievable 15 consecutive years wrestling for the WWE. During that time he went through a few different incarnations, Thurman 'Sparky' Plugg, Bob 'Spark Plug' Holly, Bombastic Bob, and finally Hardcore Holly. The one thing all these personas had in common was that they never ascended beyond the mid card.
Holly's early career was spent primarily as a borderline enhancement talent where his main task was to make others look good. While wrestling under his NASCAR (Spark Plug and Sparky Plugg) gimmicks he was consistently seen on WWE Superstars putting over the mid card, with the exception of winning the tag team titles with the 1-2-3 Kid for a day. This point was accentuated by the fact that he was in a faction called the 'J.O.B. Squad' a group of wrestlers who jobbed. This gimmick was a transition to Holly's most successful persona, Hardcore Holly, where he went on to win the WWE Hardcore Championship six times. Holly would end his career after 15 active years in the WWE.
Though he never achieved great success, Bob Holly had a very long career in the WWE and was given multiple opportunities to establish himself. Holly owes his longevity to being a true utility player, taking on whatever role creative wanted him to with enthusiasm. He also, perhaps infamously, was known for being a locker room leader and true tough guy (something Vince McMahon loves) as evidenced by his stint as a trainer on Tough Enough and beating Daniel Puder silly during the 2005 Royal Rumble match. This kind of longevity as a full time worker is unheard of in today's day and age and is proof that there is a place in this business for those who toil on the undercard.