10 WWE Tag Team Champions Less Worthy Than Nicholas

Boy Story 2

Spirit Squad Nicholas
WWE

Wrestling'll give you an existential crisis if you let it. Just engaging in the product requires a certain respect for many of its unwritten rules considering how recklessly it treats the basic formulas of storytelling and narrative.

The malfunctioning parts within WWE's creative machine are exposed by its own internal engine room - NXT operates with such success by seamlessly welding contemporary in-ring action with the oldest of old school storyline devices. Characters are carefully considered in all of their decisions, almost never acting outside of the rigid personality traits they've gained from their on-screen journey.

The main roster is another 'Universe' altogether. One Monday is often indistinguishable from the next - frustratingly so for those that grew up with WrestleMania main events planned a year in advance every year rather than just when The Rock was free to fit in a John Cena match between box office blockbusters. Undefeated streaks are ended to shock discerning fans rather than stock depleted rosters with newly-made stars. Hardly anybody even is a star anymore - WWE would rather the three initials sell the tickets rather than two main event icons because a brand won't leave you even if human beings do.

It's within this world that young fan (and referee John Cone's real-life son) Nicholas can be plucked from the crowd to become a tag team champion alongside the dominant Braun Strowman at WrestleMania 34. The decision was divisive, but the company has done far more deep-rooted damage to the doubles division in the past...

10. John Cena & The Miz

The Miz John Cena
WWE

'The Champ' will come in for quite a bit of flack here, but know that The Miz was just as guilty - if not more so - for callously disrespecting the belts as an excuse for some petty point-scoring over his upcoming WrestleMania foe.

Strange bedfellows because WWE, Cena and Miz dethroned p*ss-weak pairing Heath Slater and Justin Gabriel to win the tag titles on an edition of Monday Night Raw less than 24 hours after The Corre (sic) duo won them at February 2011's Elimination Chamber pay-per-view.

The point of making sacrificial lambs out of the new titleholders before they'd even left the pen? Main event shenanigans of course. Tag belts were there to be f*cked with if it meant Miz could get one over on John Cena. After Corre leader Wade Barrett ordered an immediate rematch, Miz snuck in with a Skull Crushing Finale on his teammate, gifting the belts right back.

The damage to both Slater and Gabriel AND the belts was long done by then of course. Fans cared about none of it, as was the case when the four men in question engaged in two separate heatless matches at the 'Show Of Shows' a month later.


9. Heath Slater & Justin Gabriel

Heath Slater Justin Gabriel
WWE

Champions in both The Nexus and The Corre without ever even remotely looking like winners, Heath Slater and Justin Gabriel had the unfortunate dishonour of being mammoth losers for both stables thanks to humbling treatments of the talent and titles.

Backdooring into an original tenure with the titles as part of The Nexus (more on that later), their second reign commenced in dignified enough fashion. It was quickly binned though thanks to their diminished position as extras during the aforementioned pre-WrestleMania drama between John Cena and The Miz. The entire angle devalued the the division to grim new lows. Swallowing much of the blame for all of the lame was Wade Barrett - a leader so sublimely feckless that he failed to dominate WWE with two huge groups in less than one calendar year.

That's not to pin all the blame on the tough-talking former Intercontinental Champion. Even in his absence, Nexus was a busted flush. New leader CM Punk couldn't reverse the curse, even when his obedient members took control of the tag team titles themselves...


8. David Otunga & Michael McGillicutty

David Otunga Michael McGillicutty
WWE.com

91 days.

David Otunga and Michael 'Curtis Axel' McGillicutty held WWE's only (at the time) Tag Team titles for just short of a hundred days. There's no more damning indictment on the state of the division at the time.

Don't believe me? Just ask WWE themselves!

Jerry Lawler was scripted to abuse the feckless friends for weeks just to build up a comedy match alongside Sheamus he actually won! The company have been thankfully toned down their intentional burials in recent years, but it was something of an epidemic back in the confused early part of the decade. Talent were arriving on the main roster woefully underprepared to perform upon it, and top-down bullying was somehow viewed as a shrewd tactical approach to helping them turn corners.

It was fatally flawed, of course. Virtually none of the half-drawn 'stars' that emerged from the period survived it, and those that did were forced to drastically overhaul themselves just to cling on to employment. Otunga and McGillicutty were two with the reverse midas touch, and their ugly bronze belts were reduced to an even lesser value in their ownership.


7. John Cena & David Otunga

John Cena David Otunga
WWE.com

Look at the f*cking face on John Cena in the above image. 'The Champ' isn't even there, let alone here for whatever David Otunga is trying to get him involved in.

The makeshift Nexus pairing concludes this 2010/11 square of sucktitude (yes, cribbed from Edge & Christian - the only credible duo to be mentioned in this entire list) not by being the last of the bunch from this big yellow mess but the dirt worst.

A hideous splinter story from the disparate 'John Cena joins The Nexus' angle, Otunga's partnership with 'The Champ' was enforced by Wade Barrett to humble his hated rival, but 'Big Match John' as usual overcame the obstacle with his incomparable competitive spirit or whatever they were calling it that week.

What made this worse than all the rest was how it buried both the titles, the young wrestlers involved and others in the division ordinarily exiled from the wretched tale. Champions Cody Rhodes and Drew McIntyre were beaten clean as a whistle, only for leader Barrett to eventually force Otunga to lay down for fellow stablemates Heath Slater and Justin Gabriel. This, despite the fact Wade had orchestrated the apparently foolproof plan to begin with.


6. Heidenreich

Animal Heidenreich Legion Of Doom
WWE.com

Far from just being disrespectful to the already-tarnished legacy of the Road Warriors, Heidenreich's substitute appearance alongside Animal in 2005 sucked the gimmick further into the gutter.

Brought into the company as a variety oddball, Heidenreich was useless both as a buffoon babyface and heinous heel. The last gasp push for Paul Heyman's former charge saw him don the famous spiked shoulder pads and somehow score a tag team title run alongside the legendary Legion Of Doom performer.

The company booking them to beat up-and-coming stars MNM was rancid in the extreme, despite the fact they'd drop the belts back in relatively short order. Heidenreich got no less useless than he'd ever been, whilst Animal understandably wore the physical strain of 20 years in the industry. His Hawk replacement looking so f*cking ridiculous in the role can't have boosted his mental strength either.

Though tricky to work out exactly what the facepaint was supposed to represent, it broadly resembled a skull in place of his wild-eyed face. For a tired retread with such little meat on the bone, it was rather appropriate.


5. Chief Morley

Lance Storm Chief Morley
WWE.com

Plugged in to a spot alongside Lance Storm after William Regal's encounter with a near-fatal viral infection in early-2003, the former Val Venis had a similar impact on the under-appreciated Raw brand titles by completely sh*tting the bed as a stand-in.

Morley's move away from cheesecake curiosa came thanks to a panicked promotion by Eric Bischoff. 'Easy E' needed to build a human wall between himself and the returning Stone Cold Steve Austin - with 'rock hard' on his resumé, the Chief seemed to fit the bill.

Exhibiting zero chemistry with Storm, the supposed workhorse was somehow blander than his partner - a man WWE considered so dull they once booked 'The Rattlesnake' to heckle his matches with snores from under a duvet.

The pair's switch-off appeal resulted in their WrestleMania 19 clash with Rob Van Dam and Kane suffering the indignity of late relegation from the main card in order to facilitate such time-sinks as a Limp Bizkit performance and a pillow fight pitting Stacy Keibler and Torrie Wilson. At least the prop bed probably served a purpose for those stuck watching the pre-show snoozer.


4. Deuce N Domino

Domino Cherry Deuce
WWE

A punchline pairing that somehow made shoddy use of one of wrestling's most prodigious funnymen, Deuce N Domino saw a lousy 1950s cartoon concept brought to life far more than the half-century out of date they already were in the mid-2000s.

Rather than being a case of too much too soon, the greasers' snatching of the tag team titles was just too stupid, full stop.

The pair had little goodwill with audiences as it was following an indifferent introduction and tepid follow-through, and didn't ingratiate themselves after being inexplicably chosen to end one of the longest streaks of the modern era. Brian Kendrick and Paul London were polar opposites to the unpopular pair, having carried a division on their relatively small frames for just under one full year before controversially losing the titles on an Milan SmackDown taping in April 2007.

Cliff 'Domino' Compton eventually earned cult status amongst wrestling fans following some side-splitting storytelling on Colt Cabana's 'Art Of Wrestling' podcast, but the doubles straps themselves were the only jokes in his WWE arsenal and few fans saw the funny side.


3. Crush

Crush wwe
WWE.com

Never the biggest guys in the room when that room was bursting with hyper-inflated late-80s stars, Demolition were probably initially on cloud number nine when they heard rumblings of a near-seven footer joining their ranks. Despite his mammoth frame though, Brian Adams didn't have a lick of the charisma exuded by the tongue-toting Ax and Smash.

He'd run to them in 1990 amidst the former's declining health, and though fans were finding it hard to believe, he was in heaven. Everything he did, he did it for them. The only problem was, he didn't do it very well. Demolition began utilising the 'Freebird' rule, gifting Crush his one and only stint with the tag titles despite never once scoring a win in a successful defence of the straps. It was all for love and all for one amongst the Legion Of Doom knock-offs, until the real thing finally arrived in WWE and made their SummerSlam 1990 loss to the Hart Foundation a night to remember.

Few wrestlers survived multiple stints in WWE without a name-change or two, but the Kona, Hawaii native somehow managed to keep his Demolition moniker despite a diverse range of repackages throughout the 1990s. Vince McMahon wasn't daft - it was the only thing that looked good on him.


2. The Spirit Squad

The Spirit Squad
WWE.com

The choreographed quintet don't deserve all the blame for the wretched state their lengthy 2006 reign left Raw's Tag Team Titles in, but KENNY, MIKEY, JOHNNY, NICKY AND MITCH had no clue how to swim with the sharks on the flagship whilst in possession of the allegedly prestigious prize.

Laughable as this notion later became, the straps landed on the crew to help heat them up in a resolute reversal of how the system is supposed to work. The Spirit Squad dethroned the dominant Big Show and Kane not because they were ready for the titles but because they needed to look like the were in time to spend all summer getting the sh*t kicked out of them.

As champions, they were destroyed on a weekly basis alongside the rest of Raw's heels by D-Generation-X working through their mid-life crisis on live television.

The state of the belts was left in disrepair by the notion that Shawn Michaels and Triple H didn't even want them as they effortlessly steamrolled over the cheerleader chumps, and the problem wasn't solved when then the youthful group eventually lost them to ancient (and ancient-looking) nostalgic nincompoops Ric Flair and Rowdy Roddy Piper.


1. Shawn Michaels

John Cena Shawn Michaels
WWE

Shawn Michaels might have a case for being the greatest all-round performer in WWE history, but his wanton disrespect for the tag team titles is fittingly heartbreaking. And that's ignoring DX's indefensible disrespect of the Spirit Squad.

'HBK' has picked his own interests over the prestigious doubles gold so often, it's quite astonishing the very idea of tag team wrestling didn't retire long before he did. After grafting his knackers off as a Rocker alongside Marty Jannetty throughout the 1980s and early-1990s, his first taste of tag gold went sour when he hurled the belt to the concrete following a breakdown in relations with partner Diesel in November 1994.

Less than a year later, he didn't put up much of a fight when President Gorilla Monsoon took his newly-won belt back on a technicality - certainly not as big as a one he did with Bret Hart backstage at a 1997 Raw taping that again saw him abandon his responsibilities to leave Stone Cold Steve Austin partner-less for weeks.

Even his hair follicles died harder than his old habits - Michaels was at it again in 2007. John Cena was his supposed ally this time, but the warring WrestleMania 23 main eventers lost their gold 24 hours removed from their 'Show Of Shows' showdown because 'The Showstopper' simply couldn't be a*sed with 'The Champ' any longer.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.