11 Wrestlers TNA Completely Dropped The Ball With

Could these men (and women) have made a difference to the beleaguered company?

Okada TNA NJPW.jpg
impactwrestling.com/NJPW

When all is said and done and the final nail has been drilled into the coffin of TNA, the obituaries will make for interesting reading. 

No company in recent memory seems to have been subjected to such overwhelming negative press, and having watched Impact for a decade now I can't really argue with a lot of it.

Even so, for a short while at the end of the last decade TNA provided a genuine alternative to World Wrestling Entertainment when it came to North American wrestling. It had a fantastic roster, separate well-defined divisions and truly exciting in-ring action.

Unfortunately, the promotion also had a tendency to snap up released WWE talent and past superstars that were way beyond their best.

Throughout its tenure, TNA has had countless wrestlers on its hands that could have made a true difference. Either by committing to getting behind them or by treating them differently, a core roster could have emerged that would have continue TNA on its positive path, as opposed to the product we find today.

This didn't happen though, and TNA has become synonymous with all that is bad about professional wrestling. Still, for every Pacman Jones there has been a Matt Morgan, for every Val Venis an Alex Shelley. 

Here are 11 wrestlers TNA completely dropped the ball with.

11. Joey Ryan

Joey Ryan TNA
impactwrestling.com

Okay, so Joey Ryan was never going to be the man to lead TNA into a brave, new world, but he is a shining example of TNA coming across something good and then just having no idea what to do with it.

TNA's Gut Check Challenge made its return to TV in 2012, and numerous independent talents had tryouts in the hope of gaining a TNA contract. Only two such individuals stick out from this time, one of whom is Taeler Hendrix (obviously). The other is Joey Ryan.

In many ways the whole thing seemed to designed to bring Ryan into the company, and for a little while it worked. Ryan's attempts to hijack the show were great TV, and Ryan was building considerable traction as a performer.

He eventually got his contract, defeating Al Snow at Bound for Glory thanks to some help from Matt Morgan (more on him later).

From there on, Ryan seemingly ticked a couple of title shot boxes and was gone by summer 2013. A waste of a hot angle and a popular, diverse talent.


10. Alex Shelley

alex shelley tna
impactwrestling.com

It may just be me, but I'm utterly convinced that Alex Shelley could be one of the biggest singles wrestlers on the planet. He seems to have everything going for him, but he's never quite received the assistance from creative teams that he deserved.

This was especially true in TNA. They flirted with Shelley as the X-Division champion, having him win the belt in 2009 by defeating tag team partner Chris Sabin, only to lose it very quickly afterwards to Suicide.

Alex Shelley is a fantastic in-ring performer with the microphone and character skills to back it all up. Why he only got a cup of coffee X-Division reign is beyond me.

Shelley and Sabin experienced a decent amount of tag success, but here was a singles star waiting to explode.


9. Daffney

daffney TNA
impactwrestling.com

When TNA made its ill-fated move to Monday night programming in 2010, my then girlfriend found herself with little option but to watch TNA Impact Wrestling with me.

To her great surprise, she became rather enthralled by one character on the show in particular. No, it wasn't the Nasty Boys or Val Venis, but Daffney.

The reason was that there was just something about her, the intangible X-factor that made her stand out from the pack. Daffney had a different look to the rest of the knockouts, and carried a totally different aura.

She was more than capable in the ring too, the ex-girlfriend commenting that her attacks seemed more vicious because of her aesthetic.

I tend to agree, and TNA could have done a whole lot more with Daffney around this time. She was another option TNA had if they wanted to present a real alternative to WWE, to offer something different.

She was severely injured towards the end of 2010, and was given a whole lot of nothing to do on her return before being given the boot.


8. Okato

okato okada tna
impactwrestling.com

In New Japan Pro Wrestling today, Kazuchika Okada is arguably the biggest star in the company.

He has won the IWGP Heavyweight Championship on a number of occasions and been in the main event of the January 4 Tokyo Dome show for the last two years, which is essentially the WrestleMania of Japan. His star will continue to rise, however hard that is to imagine.

In TNA, Okada was presented as Okato. Well, he was Okada for a while, primarily losing in dark matches, but at the beginning of 2011 Kazuchika started dressing as Kato from The Green Hornet and was nonsensically involved in the awful Samoa Joe/D'Angelo Dinero feud.

Needless to say, NJPW were angry, and the relationship with TNA was soon ended.

A year after returning to New Japan, Okada defeated Hiroshi Tanahashi for his first IWGP Heavyweight Championship. Figures.


7. Mr. Anderson

mr anderson tna champion
ImpactWrestling.com

Whilst it might go against the entire point of the article to include a former TNA Champion and someone who was expected to get a rocket up the botty from WWE on the list, but I still think the point can be made.

Mr. Anderson was a strange talent, a marmite performer in professional wrestling to say the very least.

He was capable of producing fantastic matches, and when he was on his game on the microphone he was as good as anyone in the company. Anderson actually got two runs with the top title, but both lasted just a single month apiece.

Anderson was convincing and popular in the anti-authority role, but frequent turns and the nonsensical motives derailed him somewhat.

Anderson did a whole lot of nothing in his last couple of years with the company before leaving earlier this year, following a supposed failed drug test.


6. Matt Morgan

Matt Morgan
impactwrestling.com

Another former-WWE wrestler who really came into their own in TNA, Matt Morgan was seemingly continually on the cusp of greatness there.

He was an easy-moving big man who could give promos for days and had unreal strength, which frequently made one question why he got saddled with the ludicrous stuttering gimmick in WWE.

Despite teasing it on oh so many occasions, TNA just refused to pull the trigger on Morgan as a monster heel champion/high energy babyface champion.

In his six years with the company Morgan didn't win a single championship, and his story arc seemed stuck on 'team with other singles wrestler, split up, feud'.

Matt Morgan was a great talent that TNA just didn't believe in enough to get behind.


5. Desmond Wolfe

Desmond Wolfe
IMPACT Wrestling

Whenever Desmond Wolfe's name comes up in the same subject as ball-dropping, many are quick to jump and point at Wolfe's injury issues that eventually led to his release and retirement.

I would argue, however, that TNA had long since messed up what they had with the former (and current) Nigel McGuinness.

They seemed to do everything right to begin with. Wolfe went straight into a feud with none other than Kurt Angle, the two putting on some genuine classics in the process.

Wolfe then transitioned into a feud with 'The Pope' D'Angelo Dinero (more on him in a moment), but it seemed that whatever faith creative had in him had been lost.

This was all but confirmed when it was clear that Ric Flair was putting together a new Four Horsemen-esque group, and Wolfe was the only individual to fail to qualify to join the group.

Instead of leading to a hot feud against the newly formed heel faction, Wolfe started a team with Magnus. The team had promise, but Wolfe was forever tainted in TNA eyes.

Desmond Wolfe was also the unlucky recipient of TNA's unwillingness to listen to their fans. A Championship Ranking system was installed, allowing fans to vote on who would get TNA World Championship shots.

Ahead of such assumedly popular names as Kurt Angle, Jeff Hardy, AJ Styles and Sting, Wolfe led the poll from start to finish. His title shot came, but it was over in a flash.


4. D'Angelo Dinero

D'Angelo Dinero TNA
ImpactWrestling.com

At the same time as things started floundering for Desmond Wolfe, they started exploding for the former Elijah Burke, D'Angelo Dinero.

The Pope was on fire, seemingly transforming overnight from a heel feuding with Suicide to the most on-fire babyface on the entire roster. Pope's congregation was growing quicker than Pope could print money.

All of which led to a feud with AJ Styles over the TNA World Heavyweight Championship. Dinero defied the odds to get into the match, and everything seemed set for him to win the belt at Lockdown 2010. As it was, Styles won the match and that was that for Pope.

He would turn heel later in the year, going on to have ridiculous stories with Samoa Joe and Brother Devon. Another hot talent left by the wayside.


3. Jay Lethal

Ric Flair Jay lethal TNA
ImpactWrestling.com

The same as many other names on this list, TNA flirted with the idea of truly getting behind Jay Lethal but ended up being too afraid of truly pulling the trigger.

Lethal would go from big story to nothing to big story to nothing. He was stuck doing an impersonation gimmick for the most part, a state of affairs that he still managed to turn into gold.

If you wanted an example of a truly effective way to book a pro wrestler, look no further than Ring of Honor's treatment of Lethal over the last few years.

The company made a conscious decision early on to get behind Lethal and give him a sustained push, which led to him sitting proudly today as a dominant world champion and as one of the best wrestlers in the world.

I bet he still does a sweet Ric Flair impression though.


2. Generation Me

young bucks generation me tna
impactwrestling.com

You may know them as the Young Bucks, or simply put the best tag team on the planet today, but Matt and Nick Jackson also had a short tenure in TNA as Generation Me.

The brothers had a single tag feud, admittedly over the titles, with the Motor City Machine Guns before heading into singles competition.

TNA then decided it would be a good reason to split the brothers up and have them go at each other in singles competition. Needless to say, it didn't work, and the two were reunited only to be left with a whole lot of nothing.

The Bucks eventually left TNA in less than pleasant circumstances, with Matt stating that he almost quit pro wrestling altogether after the experience.

Even back in 2011, the Young Bucks were a true breath of fresh air in TNA's tag team division. They were ahead of the game in terms of high octane offence, and TNA really dropped the ball in not making them an integral part of the division.


1. Monty Brown

Monty Brown
ImpactWrestling.com

When the words 'TNA' and 'dropped the ball' are used in a discussion, the safe money is on Monty Brown's name coming up in the chat.

Brown was the first big organic star that TNA had on its hands, their own product who was really getting some momentum behind him with the crowd.

He had the look, the charisma, the promos and the finisher. He was more than acceptable between bells, but that was a little inconsequential. The crowd loved him.

Brown was unsuccessful in challenging for the top title in the company, but it seemed that his time would soon come. Well, anyone believing that needed to head back to the drawing board, as Monty Brown decided that the best way to deal with his lack of title shots was to cosy up to the champion, Jeff Jarrett.

Yeah, TNA did to Monty Brown what is truly does best; turned him heel for no reason, killing his momentum dead in the process.

Also, the irony of TNA dropping the ball when it comes to a former American Football player is not lost on me.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.